So tired of hearing about the "old shit" and "new shit" and "selling out". Isaac changed a lot, and so has MM's music. The band is clearly in a different place right now and enjoying success, which is a part of doing the whole damn thing, and that has brought a bunch of people who might have felt alone together, and otherwise not heard of MM here. Feel what you want but if you're so vapid to assume ALL the 'new shit' is bad then you never deserved to listen to Modest Mouse in the first place.
@AtHomePregnancyTest haha, where did you see a comment about someone disliking their new shit. I agree with you but i just feel like you're debating against yourself.
whoa! no way. 5:36 -Jeremiah Green was also in Red Stars Theory? i read about them on Pandora. their stuff isnt bad. and in the 'similar artists' list are names of bands that i'v never heard of heh
@ElWeasle Oh you're right i had him confused with someone else. but yeah, people think they might have been self inflicted stab wounds, in other words, an hero.
That Calvin Johnson guy is a smug douche. He never made any good albums either with beat Happening (dire voice, lacking melody) or solo. It's ironic cuz MM would not only release two of their best albums but also get huge.
@MrTrinklied i don't think that's fair. many people will tell you that those lacking melodies and offbeat singing, chanting sounds are what makes beat happening really beautiful. i would be a sad thing if he never made those albums, for example. it isn't for everyone, obviously. anyway i don't know why the name calling was appropriate.
I have no idea where you got leukemia from..but he officially died of two stabs to the chest. It wasn't really decided whether it was suicide or not, but he was often depressed and whatnot..
@Randazzo1234 hey its not actually concluded. they found defensive wounds on his arms, and the stab wounds are inconsistent with self infliction. Plus his then girlfriend claims she locked herself in the bathroom when he was stabbed, heard a scream, then came out and found him with a knife in his chest. sooo yeah its actually not confirmed a homicide or suicide....
@musicforchewfaygs I asked one question douchebag not multiple questions. Fuckin moron I highly doubt you can walk into a music store and still be able to find LCW
totally. he talks to all these awesome musicians and asks them all the same stupid question. watch everyone of their faces drop when says "how would you compare your still of music making with theirs?" what a dbag. no good musician or artist wants to answer that question
The interviewer asks a question, the person answers it, and then he creepily leaves the camera on them, for like a solid 2 minutes of awkward silence.
Sounds like it, but the interviewer didn't give him much of a chance to sound interesting. It was an awkward conversation for sure. But Calvin can play some music. Check out Beat Happening if you haven't before.
Elliott Smith was in the band Heatmiser, but after that he started making his own music as an indie-rock kinda guy. He was nominated for an academy award for his song "Miss Misery." His music has changed my life and the lives of many others, but not many people can appreciate it. You should check him out, he's really good.
yeah not quite sure, its really hard to hear, if only the internet had its own eq... but i think he said "it's a bad thing, sometime, sometime, thats all im askin for from you is a cigarette... and when they do tell em to tell me, cuz then i'll know to buy some." i'm not sure who "they" are, probably the store he pointed at.
I'm tired of hearing about "sellouts". What does that even mean? That they arent' teenagers anymore? That they aren't driving around in an old van playing small venues? Success does not equal selling out. If they had traded their values for money, they would have sold out. If they hadn't gone for the money when they had the chance, they'd be flipping burgers by now. Enough with the sellout talk.
when used right the term sellout has nothing to do with success. in regards to modest mouse it is used when comparing the realness of there earlier recordings, emotional intensity of the lyrics/music, and the basic recording style, to the new modest mouse sound which is more processed, lacking the realness and originality of the early recording (moon and antartica and before) now they try to make hits and get radio play and sound too produced. if thats ur thing then I guess they're not sell outs
@Crackhouts People are forgetting true meanings of words and phrases now. They just don't know the meaning of "sell out" any more. Kind of sad really when you think about it.
elliot says he likes them, etc. & his deferential response isn't that surprising. calvin's is more interesting to me-he's producing their latest record (at the time) & pretty much says they are boring & to seek out isaac's early tapes.
People who bitch about them "selling out" because their music is on tv...YOU ARE FUCKING RETARDED. Sony music basically owns the music they record and can distribute however they want. Modest Mouse probably didn't even have a say in wether or not their music was being used. YOU PEOPLE ARE JOKES!
that's like saying Minor Threat couldn't write a good album sober . . . I think that it's just the way they've changed I mean same with Clapton, you get older your tastes change you lose your ability to jump around on stage and go nuts, especially if you were a junky or a drunk or any of the such . . . people put too much importance on drugs in the creative drugs . . . there are great musicians that used drugs and there are great musicians that didn't . . . the mind can be unlocked other ways
the Minor Threat example isn't exactly the same, Mackaye writes in a completely different style and mindset from modest mouse. Isaac wrote a lot of the older material drunk or high. He mixed moon and antarctica strung out on pain killers. I don't think drugs are important creatively for ALL musicians, but it seems like Isaac in particular got a lot of material and perspectives from his drug habits. I don't think his sobriety is the only factor, but the new album is really mediocre.
what I'm trying to say is that the after effects of the drugs may have made his sober music less attractive but it isn't the fault of his not being on drugs it's probably more the fault of the drugs in the first place . . . it's just that it sounded to me like you were trying to say his music was created by the drugs and not him which is common . . . I just wanted to clarify . . . it's sad cuz people think they hafta use to be good musicians when people say stuff like that
oh yeah, there's no question he's a great musician, drugs or not, but but drugs did have a big hold on him when he wrote the earlier stuff and I think you can easily see that reflected in the earlier work. Its not black or white, I just think drugs affected his music in a big way, and I happened to like that music. I think of it kind of in the same way as R. Crumb. He was a great technical artist before he took acid, but his work afterwards is phenomenal and it's what he's remembered for.
the whole acid thing is kinda tricky though cuz I mean it more breaks down barriers of thinking rather than influences music I mean that's kinda what I had in mind when I said there are other ways to unlock your mind it's just acid is easier for people I guess
but the fact still remains that you ARE right abouth selling the rights and that sucking . . . but it doesn't mean he doesn't make good music . . . I don't like their later stuff as much just like I don't like Clapton as much as I like Cream but it's all still quality work by hard working passionate artists
I don't see what is so terrible about Modest Mouse now. To tell you the truth I think they may not even care whether anyone thinks Modest Mouse are sellouts anyway. They make the music and either we like it or do not. I just so happen to love it.
Are you insane?!! Pull your stubborn mind out of your ass. I love their music through and through and to tell you the truth I find some songs from their later albums to be more deep and emotional than their earlier ones, lyrics wise.
does anyone know where to find isaac's solo music or whatever before modmouse? I can't find it anywhere, whether it be digital or tapes or cd I fucking want it
sweet, elliot smith thinks he's better than modest mouse, you can tell, At this point he is a more mature musician, but LCW in my opinion tops any smith album
i like how the guy at 3:45 totally proves to the interviewer how lame of a journalist he is by using reverse psychology
Garrettfilms 1 week ago
i think we can all agree that elliott smith is way better than modest mouse.
cheeseyfosheezy 3 weeks ago
So tired of hearing about the "old shit" and "new shit" and "selling out". Isaac changed a lot, and so has MM's music. The band is clearly in a different place right now and enjoying success, which is a part of doing the whole damn thing, and that has brought a bunch of people who might have felt alone together, and otherwise not heard of MM here. Feel what you want but if you're so vapid to assume ALL the 'new shit' is bad then you never deserved to listen to Modest Mouse in the first place.
AtHomePregnancyTest 1 month ago
@AtHomePregnancyTest haha, where did you see a comment about someone disliking their new shit. I agree with you but i just feel like you're debating against yourself.
redstripe19 1 month ago
So many indie rock legends in this clip. The Pacific Northwest music scene in the late 80s-90s was second to none.
modestlyneutral 2 months ago
I laughed so hard when he gets the matches, Isaac tells the clerk, it's kinda hard to smoke beer without em'... love that
JcGrubbsFilms 2 months ago 2
Beat Happening Rules!
jesuscat29 3 months ago
Comment removed
hockeytofu101 4 months ago
I would love to hangout with Elliot and Isaac haha. Im not into coke so i would probably be left out of their partying
rightbrigade92 5 months ago
Comment removed
DiscoDancinNeighbors 5 months ago
oh, elliott :);;
daiellis 6 months ago
Early tapes? somebody fill me in.
thincotex 6 months ago
@thincotex tube fruit all smiles and chocolate. and uncle bunnyfaces.
thefearedESK 1 week ago
calvin johnson is one of the only peoples whose opinion didn't sound corny as fuck lol
tracksuitjim 6 months ago
he asks the same question in every interview
biscuthead123 6 months ago
god i love calvin.....
looshkin66 6 months ago
damn. i wish beer was 1.07 here...
denfigueroa 6 months ago in playlist Modest Mouse
ahh :( elliot smith looks so sad. r.i.p.
jahcksawn 6 months ago
2:23 Halo Benders.
ShadowJunkieMusic 7 months ago
I only watched Elliotts interview. . that motherfucker is infectious.
thewombatsshred 7 months ago
whoa! no way. 5:36 -Jeremiah Green was also in Red Stars Theory? i read about them on Pandora. their stuff isnt bad. and in the 'similar artists' list are names of bands that i'v never heard of heh
92soothsayer 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
SIMPLY,.:COPY`;:&:`'PASTE;;'
WWW.WATCHFULLMOVIE.TK
SIMPLY.:.COPY,,;&';,PASTE.:,
YongHurt 8 months ago
I love how over the top awkward this interviewer makes things.
Like @ 4:57 shoving that camera up into his face in an already awkward interview. Hahahah
cKunke2 8 months ago
soon the chain reaction started in the parking lot
NathaNRiveraMelo 8 months ago
I came here to watch a modest mouse documentary, now i'm back to being obsessed with Elliott. Shit.
Telecasterpunk 9 months ago 7
3:06 -is that the band themselves write there in that room? Judy, Brock and Green?
92soothsayer 9 months ago
@92soothsayer No...just Brock.
ericmsandoval 7 months ago
ELLIOTT FUCKING SMITH GODDAMN
CyborgDeer 9 months ago 6
Elliott fucking Smith! what a hero!
alex93metallica 11 months ago 19
@alex93metallica i think you mean "an hero"
OfficerMcGroist 5 months ago
@OfficerMcGroist nahh, i think he means "a hero"
jackslasho 5 months ago
@jackslasho elliot smith became an hero
OfficerMcGroist 5 months ago
@OfficerMcGroist dont you use "an" when the next word starts with a vowel (in most cases at least)
jackslasho 5 months ago
@jackslasho i know dude... look up "become an hero" it means you killed yourself
OfficerMcGroist 5 months ago
@OfficerMcGroist ahk, well cheers, learn somethin new everyday
jackslasho 5 months ago
@OfficerMcGroist What, when he didn't kill himself? That's not how it works.
ElWeasle 4 months ago
@ElWeasle he died of a drug overdose, same thing bro. he became an hero.
OfficerMcGroist 4 months ago
@OfficerMcGroist What part of 'stabbed twice in the heart' is a drug overdose? Psssht.
ElWeasle 4 months ago
@ElWeasle Oh you're right i had him confused with someone else. but yeah, people think they might have been self inflicted stab wounds, in other words, an hero.
OfficerMcGroist 4 months ago
he even left a suicide note for chrissakes.
OfficerMcGroist 4 months ago
That Calvin Johnson guy is a smug douche. He never made any good albums either with beat Happening (dire voice, lacking melody) or solo. It's ironic cuz MM would not only release two of their best albums but also get huge.
MrTrinklied 11 months ago
@MrTrinklied i don't think that's fair. many people will tell you that those lacking melodies and offbeat singing, chanting sounds are what makes beat happening really beautiful. i would be a sad thing if he never made those albums, for example. it isn't for everyone, obviously. anyway i don't know why the name calling was appropriate.
erinearthling 8 months ago
ooh..i heart calvin so hard.
heidiguinn 1 year ago
LOL @ Calvin Johnson's beanie, all pointed up
murdoc562 1 year ago
rip elliot
rebelfpf59 1 year ago
I was eating a sandwich when Isaac Brock was eating a sandwich.
ccrraazzyypoop 1 year ago 19
@ccrraazzyypoop You must be the next Isaac.
SCSubert 2 weeks ago
@ccrraazzyypoop
HIS BLOOD RUNS INSIDE YOU
TAKE UP YOUR THRONE AS THE NEXT ISAAC BROCK
RottenSpaplem 1 week ago
Comment removed
setusupthebomb 1 year ago
@ ~ 5:55 i agree, early tapes are my favs as well. like he says very exciting and spontaneous stuff.
finalchores 1 year ago
First saw this back before I knew much about Elliott Smith. I now enjoy the part with him in it sooo much more.
TheSpoonRooster 1 year ago
i need subtitles for this haha
rabbitsuit18 1 year ago 4
at 5:49
did he say i think everyone should die?
AberhamA 1 year ago
@AberhamA No, he said " I feel like everyone should uh.... try to find the earlier tapes..."
KillingOptions 1 year ago
Everyone smoked back then , ha.
muzikman182 1 year ago
Shucks,
RIP Elliott Smith
Randazzo1234 1 year ago 2
4:00 calvin johnson is an awesome dude
smcosci 1 year ago
Calvin Johnson is a fucking LEGEND
redeigrezzi 1 year ago
13 years ago...nutter butters were 49 cents
Specket22 1 year ago 2
at 7:40 do those people even know who their walkin around with in a store
mike4200ify 1 year ago
elliot died of leukemia </3
andimhisfriendjesus 1 year ago
@andimhisfriendjesus Nah that fool stabbed himself
RusselMuttly 1 year ago
@andimhisfriendjesus and @RusselMuttly.
I have no idea where you got leukemia from..but he officially died of two stabs to the chest. It wasn't really decided whether it was suicide or not, but he was often depressed and whatnot..
but he was a fantastic musician. RIP man <33
soufHYWRD94544 1 year ago
@soufHYWRD94544 sorry yeah, confusing him with someone else Isaac associated with
andimhisfriendjesus 1 year ago
@andimhisfriendjesus
Elliott Smith?
No, he stabbed himself two times in the chest
Randazzo1234 1 year ago
@Randazzo1234 hey its not actually concluded. they found defensive wounds on his arms, and the stab wounds are inconsistent with self infliction. Plus his then girlfriend claims she locked herself in the bathroom when he was stabbed, heard a scream, then came out and found him with a knife in his chest. sooo yeah its actually not confirmed a homicide or suicide....
sleepytimetrio 1 year ago
i bet they new they were going to hit it BIG wit that album
Skate4TheLove210 1 year ago
calvin johnson really just seems like hes being a dick to the camera guy
SeanSeanSeanCanada 1 year ago
The guy at 8:25 was probably stoked when he found out he gave isaac brock a cigarette before he and modest mouse went big haha
imjohnandyouare 1 year ago 2
she was goin' with a cinematographer, never knew that he was really a pornographer...
musicforchewfaygs 1 year ago 2
Can I have some matches? It's hard to smoke beer without em. HAHAHA funny shit.
scoobyfan2009 1 year ago
Comment removed
imjohnandyouare 1 year ago
It's called "Lounge".
monkeysnail 1 year ago
dude, buy some of their records and stop asking questions.
musicforchewfaygs 1 year ago
@musicforchewfaygs I asked one question douchebag not multiple questions. Fuckin moron I highly doubt you can walk into a music store and still be able to find LCW
imjohnandyouare 1 year ago
haha, "do you have matches? cant smoke beer without 'em"
bluetinkerfox 1 year ago
1997 was a camera shy year
1nate8 2 years ago 2
elliott looked so gone. poor thing must have been so scared.
redserendipity 2 years ago
Calvin is pretty damn wierd
acoosam93 2 years ago 4
Comment removed
ianradics27 2 years ago
Most likely he's referring to the Parasite Sessions Isaac did in '93/'94.
aboutime9 2 years ago
HALO BENDERS POSTER! listen to them...calvin and doug martsch
nydude6009 2 years ago
horrible interviewer. the awkwardness kills me
ElvisDelvisPelvis 2 years ago 6
totally. he talks to all these awesome musicians and asks them all the same stupid question. watch everyone of their faces drop when says "how would you compare your still of music making with theirs?" what a dbag. no good musician or artist wants to answer that question
jdupree13 2 years ago 5
The interviewer asks a question, the person answers it, and then he creepily leaves the camera on them, for like a solid 2 minutes of awkward silence.
mikejackson4ever 2 years ago 6
hahaha.... "..It's hard to smoke beer without em'"
Eviland 2 years ago
When Calvin's talking about Isaac's old recordings, is that those 30 second songs on Sad Sappy Sucker?
fubsie2 2 years ago
Yup!
GravityRides 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
there is so much disdain and jealousy on the faces of the people being interviewed.. especially calvin and elliot
mywaterdig 2 years ago
I wish this interviewer would ask different questions once in a while.
simulator79 2 years ago
@simulator79 What? The whole point of a documentary is to explore and compare different peoples views on the same topic.
summercool3 1 year ago
R.I.P Elliot Smith
miim333 2 years ago 2
these interviews are so awesome! its great to finally see how the guys act when not performing and when they were young!
JakRipp 2 years ago
Intervewer needs to understand interviews better
roosterchains 2 years ago
All these interviews don't really go anywhere.
Do you like modest mouse?
Yeah it's cool.
What did you think of the last tour?
It was alright.
lambizzee 2 years ago
elliot smith was just pissed about that question...
mrjackolantern4 2 years ago
awe elliott so looks uncomfortable!!
Obiwannabe 2 years ago
that elliot clip is creepy. :D
mushroomleg 2 years ago 2
this was very insightful, they're all so young..
GNOMECREATURE 2 years ago
I wonder what Elliott was looking at.
N1ckSc0tt 2 years ago
probably a big red balloon
supersibbers 2 years ago
"if they stick with it, they could go somewhere"
andr123w 2 years ago
I dig the Halo Benders poster at 2:29.
tylerjamesstephens 2 years ago
Tis. I think that it is the "Don't Tell Me Now" album cover. That's my favorite Halo Bender's album.
Lilbalot223 2 years ago
Calvin is a dickface.
Zeplygimus 2 years ago 2
Sounds like it, but the interviewer didn't give him much of a chance to sound interesting. It was an awkward conversation for sure. But Calvin can play some music. Check out Beat Happening if you haven't before.
Lilbalot223 2 years ago
Bah R.I.P Elliott. (this whole documentary is gold)
bungie091 2 years ago 3
It's interesting to watch back when isaac had to borrow money to buy a 40oz...I doubt he has that problem anymore.
Caribou4 2 years ago 2
40oz? i'm, pretty sure that's a 22oz
sr18dummyretarted 2 years ago
Is that really the issue?
Reisgar42 2 years ago
haha
ch4p2 2 years ago
or maybe he was milking the guy?
jrcenina85 2 years ago
Pinochio dove of the cliff and swam away
cheschestofootlocker 2 years ago
8:10 Can have some matches. Its hard to smoke beer without them. Hahaha.... :) Isaac is fucking halarious.
Discokid715 2 years ago 3
I would love to hear those early Isaac Brock tapes!!
Lilbalot223 2 years ago 3
Part of it is the last half of Sad Sappy Sucker, if you're interested.
Reisgar42 2 years ago
calvin seems like a wiseman of a movie or something, loved his stuff with beat happening, and the halo benders, and dub narcotic.......
Ayeetbolz 2 years ago 4
can i get some matches....its hard to smoke a beer without them. haha.
nowhereman1124 2 years ago 26
Calvin Johnson rules
pompadourssuck 2 years ago 5
calvin johnson´s bit is so hilarious
albafro 3 years ago 12
6:25 the old Deschutes Brewery beer sixer. Which one is that?
atripa645 3 years ago 2
I wish elliott were still around.
jonnygreeny111 3 years ago 3
me too.
xtigermilk 3 years ago
me too....
rip elliot
cspring08 3 years ago
alot of people i know don't like his music unless its a certain time...i don't find it depressing at all, any time is good, it's beautiful.
onlymodestmouse 2 years ago 3
This guy Calvin Johnson seems like an annoying dickhead to me. maybe he's just trying to be funny, but he comes off as a dick.
hankinsrl 3 years ago
Elliott Smith, sweet.
ertwyu 3 years ago 4
What bands has he been in?
roosterchains 3 years ago
Elliott Smith was in the band Heatmiser, but after that he started making his own music as an indie-rock kinda guy. He was nominated for an academy award for his song "Miss Misery." His music has changed my life and the lives of many others, but not many people can appreciate it. You should check him out, he's really good.
ertwyu 3 years ago 3
its hard to smoke beer without em...
robloco16 3 years ago 2
"if they stick with it, they're gonna go somewhere"
moltasonti 3 years ago 3
anyone know what he said when he bumped that cig off that old guy?
nemo1823 3 years ago
yeah not quite sure, its really hard to hear, if only the internet had its own eq... but i think he said "it's a bad thing, sometime, sometime, thats all im askin for from you is a cigarette... and when they do tell em to tell me, cuz then i'll know to buy some." i'm not sure who "they" are, probably the store he pointed at.
anulhyf34 3 years ago
boy i sure do like me some modest mouse
newranchchewties 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
rape rock?????
northwestrider12 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
oh shit elliott smith! somebody get me a knife! also, are modest mouse "rape rock?"
transmit13 3 years ago
I'm tired of hearing about "sellouts". What does that even mean? That they arent' teenagers anymore? That they aren't driving around in an old van playing small venues? Success does not equal selling out. If they had traded their values for money, they would have sold out. If they hadn't gone for the money when they had the chance, they'd be flipping burgers by now. Enough with the sellout talk.
Crackhouts 3 years ago 47
when used right the term sellout has nothing to do with success. in regards to modest mouse it is used when comparing the realness of there earlier recordings, emotional intensity of the lyrics/music, and the basic recording style, to the new modest mouse sound which is more processed, lacking the realness and originality of the early recording (moon and antartica and before) now they try to make hits and get radio play and sound too produced. if thats ur thing then I guess they're not sell outs
andrewcramer13 2 years ago
@Crackhouts Holy FUCK YOU BLEW MY MIND.
TheXxGreatxXOne 1 year ago
@Crackhouts People are forgetting true meanings of words and phrases now. They just don't know the meaning of "sell out" any more. Kind of sad really when you think about it.
AimersSB 1 year ago
elliot says he likes them, etc. & his deferential response isn't that surprising. calvin's is more interesting to me-he's producing their latest record (at the time) & pretty much says they are boring & to seek out isaac's early tapes.
i like that...
spunkchug 3 years ago
They're still very much the same band, to me.
Love these guys.
ILIB77 3 years ago
UMM i DON'T KNOW WHO WENT ON MY YOUTUBE BUT I DIDN'T WRITE THAT COMMENT OK I DON'T EVEN LIKE THIS BAND OK..??
mnmloveslac 3 years ago
lol
ILIB77 3 years ago
haha i love this
modest mouse is the greatest
although i must say, poor beer selection
lazulitooth 3 years ago
cheers
Fran100 3 years ago
Lounge (Closing Time) and it is off "The Lonesome Crowded West"
EgyptinMagicin21 3 years ago
will someone please tell me what mm song it is they play at 3:15?
Fran100 3 years ago
R.I.P. elliot
merrisunny56man 3 years ago 2
that calvin johnson guy seems kinda like a weird ass. What is he looking at
thtsritesun1212 3 years ago 2
eat shit.
forgettingxoctober 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
eat shit and die
Soniclife91 3 years ago
Yeah he's freaky.
Panicumbrella 3 years ago
lol at isaac eating a sandwich
foreeverhope 3 years ago 15
Yes Isaac. It is hard to smoke beer without matches. He's crazy, but we all love him. Can't wait to see them live. Wooooo!!!!
MadcapLindsay 3 years ago
my name is elliott smith music i play... music.
bigbabyjesusicantwai 3 years ago 5
haha so funny when elliott is singing right before the interview.
ve1vetundergrnd 3 years ago
damn. footage of isaac in the beer isle!!!
classic. Thanks for the tips isaac. Im a gonna go get me a mickeys right now.
serfur007 3 years ago
People who bitch about them "selling out" because their music is on tv...YOU ARE FUCKING RETARDED. Sony music basically owns the music they record and can distribute however they want. Modest Mouse probably didn't even have a say in wether or not their music was being used. YOU PEOPLE ARE JOKES!
YouPrayMyPhoneRings 3 years ago
as soon as they signed a contract to give other people control of their music, they signed away their integritry.
itchyweasel62 3 years ago
integrity rather
itchyweasel62 3 years ago
isaac will always have integrity
elancares 3 years ago 6
possibly, but he sure can't write a good album sober.
itchyweasel62 3 years ago
just like hemmingway couldnt write a good book sober, just like clapton cant write good music without cocaine. whats your point?
elancares 3 years ago
healthy for them, drag for us, haha
itchyweasel62 3 years ago
that's like saying Minor Threat couldn't write a good album sober . . . I think that it's just the way they've changed I mean same with Clapton, you get older your tastes change you lose your ability to jump around on stage and go nuts, especially if you were a junky or a drunk or any of the such . . . people put too much importance on drugs in the creative drugs . . . there are great musicians that used drugs and there are great musicians that didn't . . . the mind can be unlocked other ways
findingusernamesucks 3 years ago
the Minor Threat example isn't exactly the same, Mackaye writes in a completely different style and mindset from modest mouse. Isaac wrote a lot of the older material drunk or high. He mixed moon and antarctica strung out on pain killers. I don't think drugs are important creatively for ALL musicians, but it seems like Isaac in particular got a lot of material and perspectives from his drug habits. I don't think his sobriety is the only factor, but the new album is really mediocre.
itchyweasel62 3 years ago 4
what I'm trying to say is that the after effects of the drugs may have made his sober music less attractive but it isn't the fault of his not being on drugs it's probably more the fault of the drugs in the first place . . . it's just that it sounded to me like you were trying to say his music was created by the drugs and not him which is common . . . I just wanted to clarify . . . it's sad cuz people think they hafta use to be good musicians when people say stuff like that
findingusernamesucks 3 years ago
oh yeah, there's no question he's a great musician, drugs or not, but but drugs did have a big hold on him when he wrote the earlier stuff and I think you can easily see that reflected in the earlier work. Its not black or white, I just think drugs affected his music in a big way, and I happened to like that music. I think of it kind of in the same way as R. Crumb. He was a great technical artist before he took acid, but his work afterwards is phenomenal and it's what he's remembered for.
itchyweasel62 3 years ago
the whole acid thing is kinda tricky though cuz I mean it more breaks down barriers of thinking rather than influences music I mean that's kinda what I had in mind when I said there are other ways to unlock your mind it's just acid is easier for people I guess
findingusernamesucks 3 years ago
but the fact still remains that you ARE right abouth selling the rights and that sucking . . . but it doesn't mean he doesn't make good music . . . I don't like their later stuff as much just like I don't like Clapton as much as I like Cream but it's all still quality work by hard working passionate artists
findingusernamesucks 3 years ago
I don't see what is so terrible about Modest Mouse now. To tell you the truth I think they may not even care whether anyone thinks Modest Mouse are sellouts anyway. They make the music and either we like it or do not. I just so happen to love it.
ILIB77 3 years ago 3
Are you insane?!! Pull your stubborn mind out of your ass. I love their music through and through and to tell you the truth I find some songs from their later albums to be more deep and emotional than their earlier ones, lyrics wise.
mnmloveslac 3 years ago 3
okay. that's your opinion, and I have my opinion. Just Because they're not the same doesn't mean I'm stubborn or insane.
I'm not trying to change anyone's mind. I'm stating my opinion of a band I respect and am interested in.
itchyweasel62 3 years ago
does anyone know where to find isaac's solo music or whatever before modmouse? I can't find it anywhere, whether it be digital or tapes or cd I fucking want it
Bruce0Smith 3 years ago
Sad Sappy Sucker is what he's refering to. It's Modest Mouse, just less organized and way funnier.
fivewerehigh 3 years ago 4
sweet, elliot smith thinks he's better than modest mouse, you can tell, At this point he is a more mature musician, but LCW in my opinion tops any smith album
Bruce0Smith 3 years ago
calvin johnson is so awkward.haha. love him.
wegotmarriedinafever 3 years ago
calvin's saying they sold out in 97, and itnt it ironic. youre having the same argument here.
orlyfan 3 years ago