i find it quite funny how when Paula was on Idol she was criticized for being too "nice" and now its all about a gentle Idol.. i think its just not fair :/
You know what! I don't think Steven Tyler is a sellout. I think American Idol is. For ruining ppl's dreams and the music industry is a pure example. BTW the judges are fine. Steven is good. JLo needs to say no.
i couldnt stop laughing the whole show steven tyler rocks so much . thought the show would suck without simon but guess what didnt miss him at all, no more of that "snobe vibe" going on, steven tyler and j.lo are fresh and fun. its about time american idol! bring it on
These young black girls have no history in their voices they only listen to the most basic pop. It's amazing to me that these people say they are so pasionater about music yet they don't know anything about real singers and only listen to the worst kind of shit. You kids are so simple minded about music. Record companies intetionally produce crap becuase they know it's the only thing you dummies will understand.
Paula was great but even though simon worked sometimes on my nerves I actually just realised that American Idol would not be the same without him givin some bullshit no with some comments :D
I miss Saula... I'm heartbroken to see them gone, but we need to give the new judges a chance! I wish Kara was here though.. I actually started liking her last season.
@willycosme Amen! This season could have the most talented group ever and people arent giving it a chance....just watch the show first. It would be foolish to quit watching because of Simon not being there, especially if the contestants are great.
though just to be fair, but to be honest I'm not really impressed with any of it. =/ I'm more excited for the American X Factor and hope it'll be just as good as the British one.
To be honest the lack of artist theme nights and going back to 3 judges are all I like so far about this season. =P Don't get me wrong, I LOVE 4 judges on the X Factor, just doesn't work on AI with the chattery judges though. ;P XDDD I do hope we'll get some good talent this year though and the pretty face won't win.
I don't agree with the majority of the commentors here saying "Steven Tyler and J Lo are awesome!" "season ___ is the best!" or "Kara and Ellen suck!!111!!" or even "I miss Paula and Simon!", but I do agree it just won't be as good. I liked Simon, so I am kind of sad to see him go. Hate me all you want but I could care less about Paula. And I actually didn't mind Ellen or Kara, especially compared to J Lo. >>; But, this season just looks like it won't be too good to me. I will give it a shot
Why are people complaining about which judges are and aren't there? Its called AMERICAN idol, not judges idol. It SHOULD be about the contestants. I am excited about this new season!
@imarunner89 Don't be wrong, I do agree with you and you have a great point -- this isn't the X Factor where the judges actually mentor the singers. But, on American Idol, to be able to "fully" enjoy it I believe you should at least have judges you like/love, or at the very least DON'T MIND; because otherwise about 1/2 of the show is through the window with you. =P
oh, please. best season of American Idol -- Season 7! that was the last season where the original judges were still complete. Ever since season 8 I THINK American Idol lost it's appeal to the people.
@analogheart2913 Season Four all the way. And ever since Kara got on as a judge and Paula left it's just gone down hill... Kara's a beautiful singer, dont get me wrong, but she's a bad bad bad combo with Paula+Randy+Simon. R.I.P to the old american idol.
i really can't wait 'til season 10 comes but it won't be as good as season 8.season 8 will always be the best season ever! nobody can replace season 8.i hope season 13 is the last season of american idol not season 10 because i want to audition in that season.
@whitemenaresexy His high notes, uniqueness, keeping it fresh every week... The bar that he set for other contestants will never be met. Adam Lambert will always be the best on idol. No disrespect to the others they are great as well but he is my type and after seeing him on idol none of the other can top him for me.
@ParavatiShallow I said he was the type of music I listen to. And I mostly meant male artists. She's good as well, but for my preference he is the BEST!
Now I ask you, is losing Simon and / or Paula worse than not hearing these wonderful voices emerge for another Season?. I myself am looking forward to the fresh approach that J-Lo and Steven will bring. Now even more so after seeing this....................Season 10? Bring it on!!!!!!!.
@martellexox me too,i'm gonna miss simon's mean comments and i already miss paula 'cause it's been almost a year since she's been gone and i'm soo glad that kara got fired,i didn't like her,she was annoying and ellen was okay.
@klewis9995 Yeah. I've missed Paula ever since she left. And same... I hate hate hate Kara she's rude and abnoxious and so very full of herself. Simon's gonna be missed. I dont even think I'll be watching this season.
@martellexox I didn't like Kara either but she is gone this season so that's good. I don't care about the judges really. I dvr idol and fast forward through the judges anyway.
@martellexox I didn't like Kara either but she is gone this season so that's good. I don't care about the judges really. I dvr idol and fast forward through the judges anyway.
omg... Idol died after season 8... new judges are completely strange... simon once said smth like "it was supposed to be a serious competition"... now it is... it isn't funny at all... my opinion =))
@COOLDNNR96M I know! Which is kind of sad, actually. :( To be honest I don't think I'll watch it this year, unless either it is just REALLY REALLY GOOD or Steven Tyler/J Lo turn out to be not as bad as I think...
none of them even made past hollywood I think
halabrdave 4 months ago
i find it quite funny how when Paula was on Idol she was criticized for being too "nice" and now its all about a gentle Idol.. i think its just not fair :/
101ros 6 months ago
i miss simon and kara
villzam 1 year ago
i miss simon. he is the best judge
villzam 1 year ago
Check out American Idol Judges review - Are they good enough? on our official Duchess Radio Channel [officialchriscourtis]
officialchriscourtis 1 year ago
You know what! I don't think Steven Tyler is a sellout. I think American Idol is. For ruining ppl's dreams and the music industry is a pure example. BTW the judges are fine. Steven is good. JLo needs to say no.
dandyfireable 1 year ago
I think the show is ok. I guess. I'm not The Simon Cowell obessed type.
dandyfireable 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i couldnt stop laughing the whole show steven tyler rocks so much . thought the show would suck without simon but guess what didnt miss him at all, no more of that "snobe vibe" going on, steven tyler and j.lo are fresh and fun. its about time american idol! bring it on
Chicley 1 year ago
American Idol without Simon's comments? ohh noo!
etebulinele 1 year ago
I miss Simon.
RoseyDanes 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Season 10, Episode 1, @ 7 minutes and 28 seconds ,Steven Tyler says; "Well hell fire save matches, phuck a duck and see what hatches..."
after a brief short of a C&W singer, singing..
LOL.... Season 10 might be good...
UTubePied 1 year ago
Season 10, Episode 1 on, @ 7 minutes and 28 seconds ,Steven Tyler says; "Well hell fire save matches, phuck a duck and see what hatches..."
after a brief short of a C&W singer, singing..
LOL.... Season 10 might be good...
UTubePied 1 year ago 5
Season 10, Episode on, @ 7 minutes and 28 seconds ,Steven Tyler says; "Well hell fire save matches, phuck a duck and see what hatches..."
after a brief short of a C&W singer, singing..
LOL.... Season 10 might be good...
UTubePied 1 year ago
These young black girls have no history in their voices they only listen to the most basic pop. It's amazing to me that these people say they are so pasionater about music yet they don't know anything about real singers and only listen to the worst kind of shit. You kids are so simple minded about music. Record companies intetionally produce crap becuase they know it's the only thing you dummies will understand.
bigsleep32 1 year ago
@bigsleep32 who are the real singers?
lk0micho 1 year ago
WE WANT SIMON,PAULA,AND KARA BACK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
denizucurum 1 year ago
@denizucurum No we don't.
imarunner89 1 year ago
@imarunner89 YOU DON'T!! BUT THE REST DO WANT THEM BACK!!!
denizucurum 1 year ago
Paula was great but even though simon worked sometimes on my nerves I actually just realised that American Idol would not be the same without him givin some bullshit no with some comments :D
NJMoviemaker 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I'm sorry but I love my mom dearly and had to post this
Ur mum will pass away
But post this into 10 vids and she wont
whithneyade 1 year ago
I miss Saula... I'm heartbroken to see them gone, but we need to give the new judges a chance! I wish Kara was here though.. I actually started liking her last season.
CarrieUnderwdfan 1 year ago
The last girl was pretty good...
TrillLibra93 1 year ago
never watched american idol before. I'll watch it for the first time on january 19th because steve tyler's gonna be there ;) give it a chance, I am.
Nonvivant 1 year ago
@Nonvivant good master yoda
VogueMraz 1 year ago
@VogueMraz Lol. I didn't mean "giving it a chance, I am". I meant "YOU should give it a chance, because I am"
Nonvivant 1 year ago
Jennifer sounds exaaaaactly like Paula
FuzzehPeach 1 year ago
Guys seriously the season haven't even started so can you guys stop with the negative comments and give the new judges a chance?
willycosme 1 year ago
@willycosme Amen! This season could have the most talented group ever and people arent giving it a chance....just watch the show first. It would be foolish to quit watching because of Simon not being there, especially if the contestants are great.
imarunner89 1 year ago
I'm looking forward for this season! :)
liveasong 1 year ago
i miss paula and simon cat fighting :( :(
noactiontalkingonly 1 year ago 4
though just to be fair, but to be honest I'm not really impressed with any of it. =/ I'm more excited for the American X Factor and hope it'll be just as good as the British one.
To be honest the lack of artist theme nights and going back to 3 judges are all I like so far about this season. =P Don't get me wrong, I LOVE 4 judges on the X Factor, just doesn't work on AI with the chattery judges though. ;P XDDD I do hope we'll get some good talent this year though and the pretty face won't win.
1dbad 1 year ago
I don't agree with the majority of the commentors here saying "Steven Tyler and J Lo are awesome!" "season ___ is the best!" or "Kara and Ellen suck!!111!!" or even "I miss Paula and Simon!", but I do agree it just won't be as good. I liked Simon, so I am kind of sad to see him go. Hate me all you want but I could care less about Paula. And I actually didn't mind Ellen or Kara, especially compared to J Lo. >>; But, this season just looks like it won't be too good to me. I will give it a shot
1dbad 1 year ago 2
Why are people complaining about which judges are and aren't there? Its called AMERICAN idol, not judges idol. It SHOULD be about the contestants. I am excited about this new season!
imarunner89 1 year ago 6
@imarunner89 Don't be wrong, I do agree with you and you have a great point -- this isn't the X Factor where the judges actually mentor the singers. But, on American Idol, to be able to "fully" enjoy it I believe you should at least have judges you like/love, or at the very least DON'T MIND; because otherwise about 1/2 of the show is through the window with you. =P
1dbad 1 year ago
i miss paula & simon but im happy that J.Lo is one of the judges now :)
xoxoGirlzxoxo 1 year ago 6
Comment removed
tjhazukiv1 1 year ago
oh, please. best season of American Idol -- Season 7! that was the last season where the original judges were still complete. Ever since season 8 I THINK American Idol lost it's appeal to the people.
analogheart2913 1 year ago
@analogheart2913 Season Four all the way. And ever since Kara got on as a judge and Paula left it's just gone down hill... Kara's a beautiful singer, dont get me wrong, but she's a bad bad bad combo with Paula+Randy+Simon. R.I.P to the old american idol.
martellexox 1 year ago
cool
GFABTHEKING 1 year ago
it feels so empty without paula and simon... :( im not a fan but of kara but at least shes lively
ShadowWolfey 1 year ago
@ :38 J-lo has no lips :D
reziboy100 1 year ago
i really can't wait 'til season 10 comes but it won't be as good as season 8.season 8 will always be the best season ever! nobody can replace season 8.i hope season 13 is the last season of american idol not season 10 because i want to audition in that season.
klewis9995 1 year ago
@LittleMak1 Hi! I know this because RYAN said it once upon a time. AND I tried out for Idol 3 times.. I listen to what goes on around me. :)
mizskayla91 1 year ago
nnnoooooooooooooooo not sure about jlo!! steve tyler is a legend if he can incorporate his passion for music into this i might not miss simon
whitemenaresexy 1 year ago
the last one was really good
shamil222 1 year ago
Jennifer Lopez looks so orange and oily. Lay off the bronzer and get some oil strips, girlfriend!
feffany 1 year ago
wow its gona b hard this season
lostinmyregrets94 1 year ago
i think the first girl is going to go very far.
tjhazukiv1 1 year ago 3
I say no. The magic is gone.
midtownjohn 1 year ago 2
Adam Lambert season 8 changed everything.... American Idol will never be the same.
Tannazification 1 year ago 3
@Tannazification why did he change everything?
whitemenaresexy 1 year ago
@whitemenaresexy His high notes, uniqueness, keeping it fresh every week... The bar that he set for other contestants will never be met. Adam Lambert will always be the best on idol. No disrespect to the others they are great as well but he is my type and after seeing him on idol none of the other can top him for me.
Tannazification 1 year ago
@Tannazification Oh Pah-lease...have you watched season 1? Kelly Clarkson hello??
theres the one example you needed of someone who tops Adam Lambert.
you're welcome
ParavatiShallow 1 year ago 3
@ParavatiShallow I said he was the type of music I listen to. And I mostly meant male artists. She's good as well, but for my preference he is the BEST!
Tannazification 1 year ago
Now I ask you, is losing Simon and / or Paula worse than not hearing these wonderful voices emerge for another Season?. I myself am looking forward to the fresh approach that J-Lo and Steven will bring. Now even more so after seeing this....................Season 10? Bring it on!!!!!!!.
MidAgeAllisonFan 1 year ago
i miss paula & simon ... its not the same!
martellexox 1 year ago 31
@martellexox me too,i'm gonna miss simon's mean comments and i already miss paula 'cause it's been almost a year since she's been gone and i'm soo glad that kara got fired,i didn't like her,she was annoying and ellen was okay.
klewis9995 1 year ago
@klewis9995 Yeah. I've missed Paula ever since she left. And same... I hate hate hate Kara she's rude and abnoxious and so very full of herself. Simon's gonna be missed. I dont even think I'll be watching this season.
martellexox 1 year ago
@martellexox i'm gonna watch season 10 even though it won't be the same with simon and paula because i wanna see how good the contestants are.
klewis9995 1 year ago
@martellexox I didn't like Kara either but she is gone this season so that's good. I don't care about the judges really. I dvr idol and fast forward through the judges anyway.
Spideymrw 1 year ago
@martellexox I didn't like Kara either but she is gone this season so that's good. I don't care about the judges really. I dvr idol and fast forward through the judges anyway.
Spideymrw 1 year ago
@martellexox wtf Simon is gone? hahaha i guess ive missed a lot, Without simon is no American Idol.
mythicaljuls 1 year ago
@martellexox me too, but i love the new judges! lol
iLoveLeahRemini 6 months ago
omg... Idol died after season 8... new judges are completely strange... simon once said smth like "it was supposed to be a serious competition"... now it is... it isn't funny at all... my opinion =))
Anhety 1 year ago 3
at 0:22 looks like shane's brother :P
PinkGhost1 1 year ago
@PinkGhost1 HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!!!!!!!!
1foottall 1 year ago
Huh....
MissPatatee 1 year ago
Wow
shazenmaire 1 year ago
the only thing good about this season is Randy's "Dawg" and Ryan's "This......IS AMERICAN IDOL"....
COOLDNNR96M 1 year ago 32
@COOLDNNR96M I know! Which is kind of sad, actually. :( To be honest I don't think I'll watch it this year, unless either it is just REALLY REALLY GOOD or Steven Tyler/J Lo turn out to be not as bad as I think...
1dbad 1 year ago
!!!!!!<3!!!!!!!
niqwalici0us 1 year ago
american idol gonna dieeeeeeeeeeeeeee
eeeeeeeeeeee
-eeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
strenghting 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
WHAT A BUNCH OF SHIT
InformedScotsman 1 year ago
ehhh I don't think this seasons gonna be good...Idol died after season 8 :P SEASON 8 FTW! :) Kris, Adam, Allison and Matt! <3
krisallenisawesome 1 year ago 6
@krisallenisawesome Yeah seriously!
Tannazification 1 year ago
this will suck, i hope its the last season. its been bad since this past season
LittleMak1 1 year ago
@LittleMak1 they have one more year after this! =/
mizskayla91 1 year ago
@mizskayla91 how you know? this season didnt' even start yet
LittleMak1 1 year ago
this is gonna be the worst season since ellen came to the show
Tdiarocks123 1 year ago
I thought Ryan Seacrest was dead until you raised money for HIV? Hmmm? I think this is cheating! ;)
EricSes 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Good singers, it should be a good show next season. Check out my covers on my channel and let me know if you like my voice. :)
CrystalMurphyMusic 1 year ago
no simon.....this isnt even right....its wrong
AlexysTexas97 1 year ago 3
Comment removed
snowbear15 1 year ago
Comment removed
snowbear15 1 year ago
The best is yet to come
JEMCO2008 1 year ago
This season of Idol should be a great one.
ThePopPrincessXoxo 1 year ago
I say no!!!! hehe =)
claudia1515 1 year ago
FIRST COMMENT
bellaandedward1610 1 year ago