Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (77)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Not a bad remake. I love Pia but this version took all of the soul out of the song. I understand she's trying to do her own thing with it. But some songs should never be coverd and this is one of them. Sorry she sounds Beautiful though.....

  • @lawrencewhitney1 What soul? This is a contrived song, and Whitney of brilliant voice couldn't find any emotional resonance to it, so she just sang it with a lot of flourish and style. Pia finds more heart in it than Whitney did and has nearly the voice. Give Pia credit.

  • Pia not only has a great voice but with a beautiful face too....

  • Depuis quand chante cette merveilleuse perle, ça c'est de la chanson. Mais quelle voix, mon dieu que c'est beau. Merci Pia

  • And she didn´t need to sing almost naked - like many others - to got famous.

    Great voice!

  • @jlvt she didn't have to, but im sure all of us guys wished she did

  • @jlvt

    kkkkk

  • she's even better than beyonshit. 

  • cant wait for her to get her album out properly over here in lOndon

  • all judge last american idol season 10 where all ur minds why pia not a winner she is so amazing

  • ur voice reminds so much of celine dion :) it's precious <3

  • pis is the best she should of won amercian idol

  • @picklejbsdesign I totally agree!!

  • Лирическая

  • Pia sings better than any previous winner in American Idol. She beats all of them. The stupid jury this years should have waited with their save until there was someone really to save.

  • @katzy43 Kelly Clarkson and Jordan Sparks are my favorites Pia's amazing but Kelly Clarkson is my favorite singer ever

  • she has such a Celine Dion tone to her. Shes amazing

  • She is amazing!

  • Merciless Pia just murdered Whitney Houston.. a horrible cover.. although this lady has got the talent ..

  • Merciless Pia just murdered Whitney Houston.. a horrible cover.. although this lady has the talent ..

  • yeah baby i do care and love you

  • What an amazing amazing voice!!! Has such a Disney soundtrack song sound to it... She is soooooooo going on to amazing things! x

  • Comment removed

  • 3:09 holy goosebumps

  • Pia gots the Talent and Voice! Loved her from the beginning and still do! Cant wait for her cds and tour :)

  • @jakewieben yeah.....her voice is just so amazing....

  • She's okay, but .... I feel like she's boring. Her songs sound all the same to me; And she does have the whole package, hot bod, big boobies, etc, etc.; but just missing "UMPH" to her lol; Just my opinions.

  • @onetwo000005 don't listen to studio versions listen to live :)

  • @onetwo000005 what else does she need to be the whole package then she can sing live and looks great have a nice presence about her that says it all for me!

  • @onetwo000005 We have to take into consideration that she's still new to this and wasn't a recording artist yet. All she could do was covering other people's song, and she had to use her talent to the best, and she was truly talented. Vocally, she have it all too. Her power notes, her falsetto, her lower register, everything is perfect, crystal clear and tender. She's the closest to the special 5% of vocalist out there like Whitney, Mariah and Caline Dion.

  • @onetwo000005 I kind of agree. I liked her a lot, but American Idol is a popularity contest, and even though she had "the whole package" she wasn't very popular like Hailey who sounded like a foghorn or Casey. I think if she sticks with it she'll get the "UMPH"

  • This is great :)

  • American idol is mental retarded for voting her off. Or just deaf. Cause she sounds like a fucking angel (: her voice is so soft yet so powerful and sends chills down my spin. She will be famous. With a voice like that, she'll go far(:

  • @BriannaaLovely Yeah, Those voters seems to prefer slutty girls or cute guys. 

  • she gives me goosebumps...

  • No doubt in my mind that she will out perform the two finalists of AI the best contestant ever on Idol can't believe she got the boot

  • I love Pia. She was my fav of the season and I can't believe she was voted off. I cried myself to sleep on Thursday after the show as I listened to each of her performances from my iPod. I'm so happy that she got the record deal and I can't wait to get her cd

  • absolutely gorgeous...class, talent, beauty, and elegance...but do not shed to many tears for her...she got her deal with interscope...but I'm done with idol now that she is off...amazing talent!

  • She has the most amazing voice I've ever heard. It's strong yet soft and American idol is stupid for voting her off. I agree with @janewockee5293 she'll become famous cause her voice is one in a million.

  • I won't be surprised if Idol's ratings go down after Pia got eliminated.

  • Jennifer Hudson and Chris Daughtry were also voted off...they were far off from winning...but look at them now, they are way better than previous american idol winners...they were both famous now....Pia will be like them,too...i'm sure of it....

    go PIA!!!....

  • Sexy and hot voice

  • She is Wonderful. Even that I am fron Santa Cruz. She gets my vote for the best EVER on American Idol!!!!!!!!

  • wow!!!!!!! she is BEAUTIFUL would love to see her in PLAYBOY

  • why do people keep refering to jennifer hudson? yeah i get it . she didnt win and look at her now.. for real for real Hudson doesnt have shit on this girl...

  • happy birthday Pia! you are the best!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! to bad you are off but look at jennifer hudson she was voted off and is a star. follow her foot steps

  • Your voice is so beautiful....it makes me cry a little :) So beautiful inside and out.

  • I'd still do her and again.

  • LOVE Pia's voice but the musicians butchered the song... she did the best with what she had to work with but it would've been better acapella than it is with the noise in the background...

  • i love Pia and Thia...my favorite!

  • @cutemensroom well sorry to say but Thia left. dont worry i liked her too!:)

  • @meawesome102 yeah i know...sad..at least Pia still there...

  • @cutemensroom well, was still here..... america didnt vote. i did tho

  • live version was so much better because there was still a killer ass beat but it wasn't overwhelming her voice... she's too good for the background to be that prevalent.

  • The thing that sounds like a bass drum is very distracting. It's too bad because her voice is so beautiful.

  • Absolutely ruined by that garbage music in the background. I hate the record company wrking with them this season. Trying to make them "Current" but so un current! She is GREAT though! :)

  • @dubilloh7

    I agree - they screwed up a beautiful song and a beautiful voice by trying to make it too "Current "- current sucks, and particualrly with this song .

  • PIA ALL THE WAY!!

  • pia is the best!!

  • she reminds me of Katharine Mcphee, she's good, but not quite my favorite.

  • @kandigurll89 She reminds me of Katharine too. Only better!!!

    

  • @meganmooresvideos My only hope is that she does better than Katharine when she leaves AI.

  • OHMYGOD! broken hearts go get fixed again, pia, because of you. your hot voice. hotness. :)

  • Thia's studio version is much better and Thia's voice is so much more beautiful recorded than Pia's.

  • I enjoyed that!!!!  But I like the on-air version better!!!! You get this RAWNESS when she sings live!!!

  • nice voice, but the "instruments" are way too synthesized and loud. they don't enhance and compliment her voice.

    the song would be much better without all that crap in the background. less is more. let her voice shine and carry the song.

  • nice..... but i think i prefer thia's studio version than this.... but still love her...

  • LOVED IT .. pure talent from a long time. Good recording voice all together.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more