Nine Inch Nails - Leaving Hope

[beck8404]

Really touching.

[JamesBond0072727]

muy buena melodia

[pigrivit]

Wow what can I. Say

[axisvideo]

i thought it was pretty good, only things was a few of the edits were a little abrupt.

[blackbone88]

thanks for ruining the song and editing out the best part i didn't even want to watch your shitty little video. i hope trent reznor comes and abuses you for your butchery

[Urrarg]

It wasn't bad. My favorite part was the credits. I think the choice of song was perfect and I"m glad you went the instrumental over lyrics for it. All it really takes is those first 3 piano notes to give any NiN fan a jolt of pain that feels like being stabbed with a satin covered knife. I almost think it's worse with no lyrics, it lets you fill in the lyrics mental, which somehow makes it sadder to me.

It's also good to see NiN inspiring other people artistically:)

[MissGoth18]

i love ur video !

[TehScag]

The song is beautiful. Nine Inch Nials rocks. The video is beautiful too. But kinda ruins the moody feeling of this song.

[LordSixty]

Absolutely beautiful.

[mrwobbleheaddeluxe]

the epitome of what NIN rly is deep inside....beautiful

[gardini100]

looked real and i had to wipe a tear away :)so thanks

[EverSecluded]

One sentence came to my mind: We are but falling leaves.

[dreaminfinity]

Let me make a note since not many people are getting it. You are welcome to leave CONSTRUCTIVE criticism over this video that was shot over half a decade ago. But if it is not constructive and just plain rude and immature, your comment will be deleted, and your user name will be banned from this video. Thank you.

[avaporcelina]

@dreaminfinity It's beautiful, I can't find a single thing to criticize. It resonates deeply with me, and even if it did not in the manner that it has, I would still recognize it's beauty.

[ar15mmdelta]

Great video. True work of art.

[Boowey116]

i wasnt phased by it... i mean i wanted to accept the emotion that your video had, but i found it hard to understand. I mean your basically screaming the death of the husband at the end... but what did he die of? I think it would be better if you made it longer

[dreaminfinity]

@Boowey116 it is about the victim of the world trace center attack on 9/11/01.

[0breezy]

@dreaminfinity  trade center

[misterwobblehead]

@Boowey116 art is left up for interpretation, so interpret how you like it, and stop being so damned critical. Its a brilliant vid. It could be about a loved one lost in war, in a shooting, who cares..it could be about a break-up...point is, someone lived is lost....if you don't get that, then just stop watching and listening to Trent Reznor and NIN

[kross1488]

tepy chuj smierc mierszniu rac :P

[dreaminfinity]

@BlackrebelMC83 thank you for watching!

[tneper]

Brings a tear to my eye, honestly. This particular song has some meaning to me as well, in some of my darker memories. Very nicely put to video, thank you.

[dreaminfinity]

@tneper thank you for watching!

[uberryan]

chick is hot

[soupsmoke]

well done

[Mr123hotdogchampion]

my auntie passed away a month ago and i really needid someone to be there then i listend to this song and after it i found my girlfriend who i have been with for ages now thanks nin

[laughorgomad]

All you people are beautiful!!Your comments moved me. I love NIN fans :) This video really tugged on my heart strings too.Great job!!

[TheeMislolsmileyface]

wow intense

[madness3000]

jesus bays, listen to this music with a slight bit of hope and quit this touchy feely love bull shit

[helloofiree]

so nostalgic...depressing years

[superchristian102]

I remember when my doctor put me on Klonopin for my panic attacks. I ended up becoming suicidal, due to a side effect from the drug. While I was attempting suicide one night while extremely high off the drug, I found time to make a video of me slitting my wrists to this song. I find the song very...disturbing and bone chilling now.

But, hey, at least I'm off the drug xD

[aiden00]

wow...how r ur pain attacfks? u ok buddy? =[

[MissMeechaveli]

@superchristian102 I thought of taking medicine but i think maybe mines r not that bad like i've hyperventilated twice i feel very anxious most of the times but i'm afraid of taken meds exactly for that purpose i've tried to kill myself more times than years i am old so i guess i think the panic attacks aren't really that bad.

[LeviathanoftheDanube]

more power to you, we are among the few that survived - my sister died last year of an overdose - Klonopin was on of the many drugs she was on

miss you... @}---

[Demonact1337]

@superchristian102

eek that sounds spooky, glad to hear your better now

[StormyGoddess]

I've recently lost both my parents so this song has helped me get the tears out because while I'm with people, I have to be the strong one. I can listen to this song alone and just let the tears fall. It's theraputic.

[danielinraleigh]

Leaving Hope... it's a song that I swear is depression translated perfectly into musical form. Perfectly captures the feeling of wanting something that can never be.

[Cewyyy]

Yay, 100th rater :)

I really love this song.

[virgofemme5]

This song gives me goosebumps-in the best way, of course. So beautiful, but also quite sad.

[spammey]

my all time favourite band! cheers for this..

[pin37]

super sad song, reminds me of the past

[AssassinsExtraction]

One of my favorite, i usually smoke a cigarette when listening to this song. Calms the nerves, and frees the mind. Thanks for the upload, great video by the way

[reedjsupra]

Pretty good. I'm military, as is my wife. This is the type of thing I hope we never have to endure, and it's set to one of my favorite NIN songs. Sad, yet beautiful.

[StormyGoddess]

God bless you and your wife for your service.

[Wutzin]

really beautiful=) love it

[Phil2171]

Beautiful.

[dreaminfinity]

Thank you :)

[Phil2171]

Dont worry about it.

Really, this video is quite good. The camera work is amazing, and the girl is a really good actor.

[fuckitstrent]

i cant actually tell if your being sarcastic or not?

[Phil2171]

Im not, Im a Nin fan, but i never really like this particular song until i watched it with this video, then it kinda made sense to me.

[NINBrandonNIN]

This song makes me think of walking in a dead road with a lot of with fog (Mist), kinda like Silent Hill...

[Joeyal123]

thats cool in a erie kinda of way

[monochromatically]

Same here.

:]

NIN & Silent Hill go hand in hand, in my opinion.

[NINBrandonNIN]

Glad you agree, I just have so much of an imagination, that songs like this make me think of past experiences and also things that has the same feel as the songs, this song makes me strongly think of a foggy road walking endlessly, then I realise it is Silent Hill! lol

[lucider666]

Damn inspiring.

This is a song definitely worth listening to.

Great video chaps.

[pasha1877]

love this song , very touching :) i love the frail aswell alot , especially when trent plays it live on the NIN dvd from 2002. i wonder if NIN has anymore beautiful songs like this one or the frail ? or if anyone knows any other band that make songs like this :) tnx.

[Disturbedone1954]

Listen to 'La Mer' by them or 'Adrift and at Peace' or 'Gone, Still' another one is 'Another Version of the Truth' There are many songs that are slow and very warming like this, there is about one song like this per album (exeption of Broken), however not all are instrumental. A great album for you to buy if you enjoy his instrumental work is the album 'Ghosts I-IV' because it is over two hours of instrumental music.

[breathingworld]

wow, thanks!

[Excovon]

Listen to A Warm Place, Adrift and at Peach, La Mer, and The Great Below. The last two aren't instrumentals, but they do strike me as equally beautiful. :]

[Baxxter101]

There is no other.

[dagonX23]

dont start arguments, just listen, come up with your own story to the song, this song really hits home with me, im a corpsman in the navy, and a long time fan of nine inch nails, this song got me through some rough times. bravo trent, bravo.

[RezinAngel]

Nicely done and emotionally touching.

I cry when I hear this song by NIN, as it brings back nostalgic memories in my life that will be lost forever in time.

[ercaca]

That was absolutely beautiful, touching and so human...Love it

[dpstheband]

With the resources available I thought you did a nice job of conveying the core of the story.

[dreaminfinity]

thank you :)

[fuckAuserNAMEandfukU]

i love this video i love nine inch nails.. trent is a freakin genius i can relate to his music very much so. thank you for posting this song.

[Veekahr]

This video made me cry. :(

[jango2fett]

is that why everyone put you for thumbs down..you have bad taste in music if you think this is bad..

[xMaratjuhh]

great video and song

love it!

[thefinalkut]

...so touching.

:` (

[idiotbrothers]

I wish the song went slower.

[dreaminfinity]

There is nothing wrong with criticizing someone's work, however there is a difference between constructive criticism and non constructive one. Saying things like "it sucks" or "its retarded" is immature and non-constructive. Such comments like that will be removed, and blocked from the page. And please, if you are over 18 making such statements, please grow up.

[Murdexxx]

Just so you know I think it's a beautiful tragic video and I think you did a very good job on it. I think it tells a story if you pay attention to it. I've lost alot in the war too.

[dreaminfinity]

Thanks for your comments :)

[Marrothefirst]

awesome

[LitttleGirlPL]

so amazing and beautiful video. I love 'leaving hope'. Congratulations, very good job

[blackbutwhiteguy]

i agree with Suidakkra ya dick its a song called leaving hope not anything about 9/11 and even if it was it would be about the people loosing a loved one

[DSCKSR]

Great video. The victimes are more beautiful from this song.

[armywalaby]

Hmm...was ok until it was supposed to be a 9/11 tribute. We're not over this yet?

[dreaminfinity]

This video was made in July of 2002, which makes it not even a year since the attacks.

[Suidakkra]

How can someone be over something like that? Seriously man, fucking think!! If you lost someone close to you due to that, would you be such an asshole? Dick!

[xxtaxidermyxx]

it's been almost 8 years. a lot can change. we've squandered all the goodwill we earned in that attack.

[Zeketh88]

What do you mean by we're not over this yes "?". who said it was a tribute, and why should it matter even if it was relating to the towers collapsing? relating a song with a real life subject that captures it is making art, and thats what this video is.

[sophminx]

Really lliked that :)

[drcanoro]

I saw your video on the website but I lost track of it, I'm glad you decide it to upload it to YouTube. It's my favorite video (outside the official videos) using the song Leaving Hope.

[GarethW09]

Very nice movie. The music works perfectly. My only criticsm is that you could have used a pathetic falesy to strengthen the melancholy of the story, but thats kind of uncontrollable, so it's fine really. All in all, some beautiful shots. 5/5

[peoplethought]

Excuse me.

[GarethW09]

pathetic falesy is when the weather reflects the mood.

[peoplethought]

Pathetic fallacy

[GarethW09]

sorry, i'm not a great speller.

[Maszzmic]

Great video... I create short movies myself, and I think the music choise for this movie is absolutely perfect. I like the mood-setting in the beginning where you shot al those flowers, and that you don't really see in that flashback how the male person looks like. You only see his eyes, just enough to see it's a boy.

beautiful movie..