Added: 5 years ago
From: chokapika
Views: 693,392
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (569)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • mariah, the worst lyp syncher ever!!

  • i really love how she can change the notes smoothly

  • @catsmartie, it's ok for her to lip. at least she is doing a great lipsynch with her great voice of all time.

  • Que Hermoza Esta en este video

    How beautiful is in this video!

  • Na minha modesta opnião ela cantou com playback sou fã dela mais isso eu tenho que admitir ao vivo alii só os backing vocals . Pode pegar a versão em studio e comparar!

  • 素敵な唄ですね☆

  • Essaa musika eeh lindaa ^^

  • quiero!

  • realmente fantaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaastica  . linda linda

  • Mariah Carey simplesmente um anjo cantando !!! l

  • ah, esqueci de mencionar que as backing vocals cantaram em cima, de verdade! os músicos, não! tenho quase todos os cd's e esse foi o mais "sussurrado" da carreira dela, que felizmente deu a volta por cima e sua voz está mais "viva" nos últimos álbuns.. hoje ela não faz performances 100% ao vivo, mas li que ela já teve problemas com calos nas cordas vocais.. isso tudo não a afeta, nem diminúi a artista que é. Ela nunca deixa de ser referência para outras cantoras, inlusive famosas.

  • Comment removed

  • You realize this video was 5 years ago right? So she looked like a cheap hooker back then too.

  • she looks like a cow in this dress i'm sorry, she should cover up a little bit and focus more on SINGING than trying to look hot -smh-

  • this is not a live im sorry

  • Charice= No1

  • @emilio58ful who is that unknown flop?

  • I love that Mariah makes it obvious when she lyp syncing not like others who do it and try to full us, there is way less emotion when its lipped that how you know! If a performance doesnt move you then its not live Mariah live >>>>

  • Comment removed

  • @sxcjojo2env2222 watch her video Mariah Carey in the Studio Touch My Body 

  • Canta muuuito! Mariah no Brasil, queroo! :)

  • Everybody's always so fast to point out Mariah's bad performances, but they never reconize her good performances. People are so fast to point out flaws in people and not the good.!

  • its a lipsync.... period :)

  • @prophet0116 right ur an expert

  • duh? its too obvious... its not a lipsing... if u know the real copy of this song.. the first voice is with OHHHHH ,, but this video doesn't have.. and the first stanza in real copy of this song is WHEN YOU KEEP CRYING OUT.. but in this video.. ITS DEFFIRENT! so its obvious that ITS HER REAS VOICE>>>.. MARIAH IS AN ANGEL! she has ANGELIC VOICE! yeaaahhh

  • @nheilneruka29 she's lip syncing in this video... it's not about the album version... She recorded this song prior to the show... if she'll sing this live, I don't think she'll sing it perfectly like that in the album version.. :) peace out!

  • Beautiful voice!

  • Its so obvious when mariah sings live vs lipping. She needs to practice her lip acting skills a bit better. When she sings live, she makes a lot of facial expressions like she is constipated. When she looks more relaxed then she is faking it.

  • She's sh!t now. I can't believe this fat common tart with no class or talent was the legend of the ninties and only person who comes close to whitney.

  • She's used the same live recording of this song too much -_-

  • ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥­♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥

  • she is not live

  • Lipping or not, she is the BEST.

    By the way, Who recorded this song, from who is that voice?

    Lovee you Mimi. ~♥

  • Comment removed

  • shes lipping doesnt matter for me, she has done spectaculare in live so doesnt care!

  • Please make sense. If someone records a song and then several weeks or months later sings the same song live and every run, breath, pause, note, emotion, tone and word is exactly the same then it’s lip-synching. Get over it. It is not a personal insult to you (or to her for that matter) to say she is lip-synching. Get over it. She even admits that she does it in interviews. Get over it.

  • Please make sense everyone, if she is lipping, she does not need to hire backup singers. 

  • If you really listen she's not lip singing! :)

  • she said this song its hard for her to sing so she has just sing it live once, but by the way she needs to rest her voice...and what if its lipsynched all the singers do it!!

  • another lip synch of mariah again!

    lol!

  • why do ppl hate on mariah carey?!

    shes amazing

  • Hehehe.. Just the true.. :P

  • go Mariah Carey

  • One tit, one mile, another tit.

  • @guigo1986 HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHHH MY FAVORITE COMMENT ON YOUTUBE EVER! Her surgeon should have did them better.

  • @guigo1986 lmao.......

  • @kelvinpyaeko Hi Kelvin- People don't really hate Mariah or anyone else who has perfected their craft and trusted God and Believed in themselves. Stepping out on faith takes more courage that lip service can EVER required. For those who master courage on daily basis in front of the world to see-They become a mirror reflecting the possiblilties of Who* What* Where anyone of us could be if we simply applied good energy toward a different future for ourselves.

  • @MinisterLynne uhm? i don't get it. but i am a MC fan, so i am not hating on her. i just laughed that comment above

  • Bad choice of dress

  • Love this. Just feel bad that she didn't TRY to sing.

  • Totally lip-synched. This is a thoroughly punched-in vocal recorded in a studio. Not even Whitney in her prime could hit every riff perfectly like this, and Mariah never could, live.

    An easy way to tell if a vocal is live is whether the sound drops off when the singer turns her head from the mic. It doesn't here, so you know it's pre-recorded.

    I'm not hating on the lady. She's a big talent. But let's be real.

  • Too much back up..

  • Comment removed

  • WOW, This was the 1st song I sang in front a large crowd,.. It was such a inspiration to me, I had to sing it...... I just luv thjis song & MAke-IT HAPPEN... two of MC best inspirational songs for me...

  • this is live. like how could u lip especially the high note toward the end of the bridge & there's no way she could had lipped that...

  • where can i find a live version of this where she actually sings???? :/

  • i love you and Mariah Carey is fa number une

  • I Love Mariah and, Through the Rain

  • Go get Mariah Carey's new Album "Merry Christmas II You"! Mariah's back better then ever her voice and music has returned to the perfection of the 90's!

  • Comment removed

  • wooow :)

  • this song is perfect everytime i watch the video i cry :) love you mariah forever and always!!!!!!

  • wow....didn't know Melonie Daniels sang backup for Mariah.

  • @johnds123 Yup since back in the day. She's been doing vocal arrangments with her since about 93. Very recently they linked up again to do some work for MCIIU.

  • @johnds123 she was already the back up singer of Mariah even before Music Box came. i wished that she should had stayed with Mariah till today but unfortunatelt she left just before The Emancipication Of Mimi arrived.

  • Owntt meu Deus

    eu me lembro que tinha gravado essa música em uma fita VHS

    kkkkkkkkkk

    não saí da frente da TV pra poder gravar ella cantando :)

    

  • she sounds like an angel :)

  • Divahhhhhh

  • those were the days..char.. hehe

  • pena q foi playback a unica coisa ao vivo foram as back vocal q foram magnificas

  • pena q foi playback 

  • sometimes I think if human beings can sing so artistically perfect.. how does GOD sing? :')

  • Giọng của cô ta thật đáng nể :((

  • all those tacky ass butterflies!!!!!

  • ok, don't get me wrong, she's a beautiful singer. BUT, this was definitely a lip sync. If you know the original version then you know that this was the version from the album. she never sounds exactly like she does on the album live, unless she lip syncs.

  • @glknblk23 you wrong, she sometimes do sound like the album version, although in this song she sounds different than the album version. but she certainly lipped this performance. it's pretty obvious also.

  • this is not live!!!!

  • She's not fit anymore. But she's still Beautiful ! Babyface x)

    Anyway I don't know, But I get this feeling that this is a lip sync?

  • Fora ela, que back maravilhoso, né?

  • i love Mariah but this was lipped.

    understandable though, she was going through a lot of vocal healing at the beginning of her Charmbracelet era.

  • Bem romantica

  • what year is this? people say she cant sing anymore :/

  • @Jessikia527 - obviously you haven't been to a recent concert. She can still sing beautifully

  • @calleridcallerid i know she can! im just saying, people think she cant. thats why i wanna know what year this is, so i can prove them wrong.

  • @Jessikia527 - This has to be from either 2003 or 2004

  • joss stone better by far

  • AMAZING SONG

  • 27 DEAF people disliked this video

  • Mariah is the best

  • now this is what you call a singer go mariah love you 4ever all those 27 haters just get lost if you hate then don't watch it

  • Wow, yet again another gorgeous dress that shows off Mariah's gorgeous body.

  • me encantas Mariah

  • she's just IT..the best..i wish i could sing like her..too sad i can only do as much as play the guitar and back up vocals for her..haha!..best team up ever with luther vandross in endless love..cool cool song..

  • It's not LIVE! NOT A LIVE PERFORMANCE! You must be STUPID or DEAF to think she's singing LIVE! IDIOTS! LOL

  • Beautiful,, your my GOD,, Perfect song,, perfect singer,, i love you mariah carey !!! <3

  • this is not live

  • lipping.. she looked too relaxed lol... shes not usually like tht when singing.

    lippin'

  • check out charice singing this!!

  • live or not i LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOVE this performance!

  • it is not live cuz...if it is live she do the whistle

  • Who Care if she lipping.. she always get called on it but everyone body else get an escuse pass!!

  • @mariahpowerful just because she never did it at the beginning of her career. who cares. we all know she isnt lipping because she can't sing. she can do whatever she wants at this point.

    love you mc!

  • is she lippin it?...

  • shes the best singer i know wit a voice of an angel!!!

  • ok she's lip singing so what.... i mean she has already proven by being a legend that she has a magnificent voice, i mean we all kno she can sing so its nt realli a big deal if she's faking it she knows as well as we; that she kould sing this live if she wants 2 bt she chooses nt 2, y u ask?? idk bt who r we 2 sit here an judge n critque a LEGEND 1 of the greatest voices of our tyme c'mon nw..... she's lipping so wut she 1 of the best so she gottit like dat.... CHILL OUTT

  • @BMEZY i agree wit u 100%....Mariah is da best!!

  • this song makes me think about my life and how i can overcome anything . I LOVE MARIAH WITH ALL MY HEART SHE IS A TRUE INSPIRATION!!!!!!!!

  • she looks pretty in this clip

  • Responder a este vídeo...

  • this is live !! 100%!!

  • este video teve duas gravações não teve? porque se vcs repararem no cabelo dela, hora estão pra trás e hora estão na frente dos ombros...

    acredito que fizeram duas gravações desta música..

  • holy crap!!!!!!!!!!! that is lip sing not a live performance. .

  • @DavidParkson

    you obviously do not knau what a live performance is.

    she is so sinqinq live

  • lipping or not, she's great

  • U can tell by her her face and gestures that she is lipping. By that time she was never that calmed at high notes. but still mariah is a great singer

  • @raul7193 u don't know WTH youre saying..She clearly not lipping!

  • @cersus sorry I have to agree with raul7193.. she is lipping =)

  • @Mndjj I don't think she's lipping.I think she's just singing to a backing track along with her own vocals..

  • SATELITLGTVUSA VSATV WEBTV GSMTV USA

  • mariah carey and to our better world .. keep it up

  • É D +++++++++++++++++++!!!!!

  • No tiene desperdicio!. Muy buena version!

  • Everytime I heard this song my tears drop by.

    Nice song and she gets to sing this one. She has a softly voice.

    Nice job Mariah.

  • ta cantando em playback,mas adoro ela,nao sei pq fez isso,ela nao costuma cantar em play

  • q ano foi?

  • great... but she isnt singing live :(

  • mariah,,volta ao brasil,,WE LOVE YOU,

    sssssss222222222222

  • lipped !

  • canta muito ::)

  • i love this song

  • Linda

    amo esta mina ai

    muitão

  • lllliiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii­iiiiiiinnnnnnnnnnnddoooo!!!!!!­!!!!!!!!!

  • Just perfect!! I love that woman :) wonderful!

  • bravo,bravissimo

  • Perfect!

  • she looks great and her voice is awesome

  • I think that it was not lipync, but, if she does, she does the perfect way, like nobody else. anyway, she is an ANGEL, I venerate it, since the first time that listen it and I saw it

  • my god bad bad bad dress

  • Em, She was the singer that can perform as well as same in the original tracks.. Don't believe this? Pls listen,

    1. FLY LIKE A BIRD GRAMMY AWARDS

    2. WE BELONG TOGETHER LIVE ADVENTURES OF MIMI 2006

    3. I WANNA KNOW WHAT LOVE IS LIVE TODAY SHOW

    4. WE BELONG TOGETHER LIVE 05 MTV AWARDS

    5. MY SAVING GRACE SOUL TRAIN AWARDS 2003

    6. FLY LIKE A BIRD AMERICAN IDOL

    It was almost identical with the original one..

  • And also, it was NOT a LIP SYNC..

  • Thank Youuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu. It is identical. Not almost.

  • amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!

  • This is lipped - when it's live her eyebrows arch and her nostrils flare and she really concentrates.

  • I love her :)

  • what a beautiful song....and wonderful voice....

  • beautifull,my god is perfect...voice the angel

    i`love you mariah carey!!!!!!!!!!!

  • amo ela d+

  • muito boa ela é uma grande cantora

  • Why u keep on telling that she's lip sync?

    She would very happy when to sing

    Not to lip sync..

  • Ok.. But, why do u think that she needs to lip..

  • I will be completly honest with you : In studio her voice always sound awesome and perfect and has so much range cause the engineers raise up the key of Mariah's voice, I think she is doing that since Glitter and it is possible to do that (I work in studio,the singer sing some notes lower and they raise up the key).That's why she never really belt those notes live,and when she is it is from the CD track (Charmbracelet is when she did that the most).

  • She was probably so frustrated after her voice lost so much range between Daydream and Butterfly.

    You might agree or not but I could spend hours showing you the performances and telling you when she is doing that and bla bla bla.LOL I have nothing against her,I'm a fan, but Mariah is NOT perfect and I don't like the fact she is cheating the audience.

  • Her voice definitely loss range between Daydream and Butterfly but that is only the whistle register, she still has a tight chest voice. I do not agree however that she is cheating the audience. No artist is perfect.

  • LOL, that's exactly the opposite my friend :)

    Her chest voice register has diminished so much,, but Mariah hide that by lipping the high belts since Butterfly-Rainbow era.

    But it's not perfect so any personn with some ear can hear the trick.

    Her whistle register is STILL AMAZING.

  • I do not agree with that because I have heard her live in concert on tour twice and her chest voice sounds amazing, she still sings the older songs the way that she used to. I am a professional singer technically and I definitely have an ear so I can tell you that the whistle register was airy from Butterfly through Charmbracelet. Her whistle register is back to being amazing but it was not in between those years, the minute that she left her husband you can hear the difference in her whistle.

  • Also, she is just more nervous when she performs live at award shows. That is why she does not always sound the same, but on tour she sounds flawless normally. I disagree about the chest voice so we will just have to disagree.

  • but be honest that she can fool the audience PERFECTLY...^_^.

  • she's so Wonder !!

    i love her!!

  • la mejor te quiere una gaditana(cadiz) spain. muxos besos

  • Nice lip syncing.

  • this girl voice is very blessed!!She must be very happy to have that voice!!!

  • Perfect Singer, perfect song, perfect setting!