Added: 3 years ago
From: harvtron
Views: 15,881
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (65)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Great video, the end if from buenos aires at 2005 in Ferro, now they will come back on november, i hope they add a second one, because i cant go that day! But the best black ever is the one in buenos aires, argentina on the first concert. I give you I like!! THANKSS!!

    Pearl Jam En ARGENTINA 13/11/2011 Estadio único de La Plata.

  • Thanks for this-I just loved it!

  • Thank god for mixers & the confederacy

  • dreams are made.... dreams are made... dreams are made.... to fall apart... dreams are made... dreams aaare made..... to fall apart.... but sometimes... sometimes.... sometimes... becomes......... true.... we belong, we belong, together together.... we belong together together together.... you're so beautiful..

  • i prefer this one, because two reasons

    my best part (I know someday you'll have a beautiful life, I know you'll be a star... ) has better audio than the other

    and the great ending here in Argentina where im from is amazing

    thanks for including it

  • One of their best... which is hard because everything is good.

  • very cool

  • THANK U SO MUCH, this song means so much to me, I will be 40 in oct, im so blessed that i grew up during the EVOLUTION of the worlds greatest band ( tear running down my face)

  • thank you very much.. is beautiful, magic!

  • Well done,

    only 1 mistake: You already pasted the "sun can drop away" in the first part of the song, as it is only in the second part.. so you pasted two times.. but still nice job :)

  • @cloarot Hi, first off I'm glad you enjoyed the movie. Second I do know that I had that line in too early, I did that on purpose, I felt that, since Eddie tends to switch the lines around every once in a while, either because he is drunk or forgets or just feels like it, I could too. Besides that live performance of black on MTV's unplugged Eddie said "How quick the sun can drop away" twice.I think he shakes his head knowing he switched it. Idk I liked his facial expression there so I kept it.

  • Argentina 2005, I was there both nights! =D

    Now this is truly an evolved band. How they managed to get better and better through all these years is a mystery to me. But it is such a pride to be a jammer girl!

  • I love this video.. Thanks !

  • Thank you very much!!

  • This video is only topped by my daughter singing (with my wife singing along with her).

    Thanks.

  • lol wow cool, thank you very much!! Check out my other version of this same idea. Its called "The Evolution of black (part 2)" tell me what you think,m which is better! Thanks again :)

  • Here I am once again caught on the spell of this video. =)

    It doesn't matter if I'm feeling happy/sad because the emotion brought with this song is unique.

    Life makes much more sense when u're a Jammer.

    Great job Steve. ;)

  • Amazing trip Steve- Thank YOU......This song is EPIC.........means SO much to me....One of the greatest rock ballads of all time!

  • THANK YOU! This is my favorite song ever, and I am hoping to put up a new version of this I am working on. So keep on the look out It should be up within the next month.

  • You're welcome man....I'm seeing them play live in 5 days in Auckland, New Zealand (feb 27th).....I'm hopin they play BLACK....CANT wait!! Anton

  • I was meant to say November 27th!!

    No band has come close to Pearl Jam in the past 18 years.....

  • completely agree

  • I'm just getting more and more mesmerized by this video. If I had to choose the best video from the millions on utube, this would be the one!!!

    I lack for words to describe what I feel while hearing this song, thanks to u I can close my eyes and just feel the passion/vibe/intensity in this song colliding with my heart.

    Thank YOU, Steve!!!!! (and Eddie too) :D

  • Thank YOU!!

    I am happy that you and everyone have enjoyed this video. I also agree there is just something about this song that just captures what the band is all about.

    Thanks again for your comments!!

  • see how taste in drummer loses power until reaching actual 0 level ;)

  • Pearl Jam no Brasillll

  • `i just called vedder to tell him about this video .. he said is great job ...

  • lol thanks im glad he liked it!

  • Great job!!!!!

  • Awesome well done thank you for this Love Pearl Jam love Eddie Vedder .

  • Fuckin great man... 5/5

    This song makes me cry :(

  • AAAAAA that's great.. sorry for my english.. i speack spanish.. the 1 video its history.. do you have it?? upload it here or in a page to dowloand it. in spanish if you understand... Muy buen video disculpa por mi ingles es que no lo hablo.. el primer video es historia.. lo tienes? subelo aqui o en una pagina para descargarlo.. saludos

  • First in english: Thank you for your comments! Do you mean the opening show I used? if so its on YouTube just look for "Pearl Jam live at Tower records 1991" I am not to sure on what ells you said, Sorry!! ¡Gracias por sus comentarios! Usted habla del primer video. ¡Significa usted que apertura muestra utilizó? si ése es el caso su en YouTube busca justo "Pearl Jam live at Tower Records1991" soy no a seguro en qué medidas de longitud inglesa que usted dijo, Arrepentido!!

  • WOW!!! What a great video...that was awesome!!

  • Thank you so much!!!

  • well done! Thanks!

  • Great video harv!!! 5 stars.

  • Thank you so much!!!! Love your YouTube page by the way!!!

  • wow 3000 views thanks so much guys!!!

  • This is awesome.  Thank you!

  • Your very Welcome!!!

  • you did a great job...i'm impressed!!!your mix is realy nice done...i add the video to my playlist...home made pearl jam vids...thanks!!!!

  • Hey thanks alot!!! Check out my Do The Evolution Video too. Soon I hope to make a Even Flow fan Music Video as well.

  • Impressive!

    I also love the Berlin 06 tag:"Time heals the wounds, no one can see, but my memories won't let me be"

  • GREAT VIDEOO!!

    but theres one that eddie said

    " I didnt need you for make my dreams come true "

    In Santiago Chile First Night !

    Great Band, Awsome song

  • nice harv. great band

  • Excellent. Thanks

  • Great job dude. Amazing song, amazing band.

  • wow.... thats. good job man.. that was great

  • excelente trabajo. no se cuanto tardaste en hacerlo pero creeme que valio muchisimo la pena.. es de lo mejor que he visto en youtube.. de lo mejor... Leonardo de Argentina

  • Absolutely an amazing job. You rock man.

  • thanks man!!!!

  • Thank you everyone for your comments. It means alot to me!!!!!! :)

  • Nice video, thank you for making it! Eddie's beard is apparently growing longer and longer and Mike's and stone's hair is getting shorter and shorter:D

  • Wonderful idea!!! Fantastic!

    Very good moment! Delighted

    thank you

  • Wow, this is almost as good as my Jeff Ament filmstrip! :D

    This was incredible and so much fun to watch, thank you! Ever think of doing one with Alive??

  • oh my god.....really really awesome job..!!...LONG LIFE PEARL JAM....!!!!

  • BEST video on youtube. By far.

  • awesome video. Great job matching up the timings and everything else.  Plus its just cool to watch how one of my favorite bands has changed throughout the years.

  • fallait vraiment y penser et c'est trés bien fait, une belle video que je reverrai souvent merci harvtron....

  • Whoooooooo this is great.

  • This is just incredible,captured everything that is,was and always will be great about this band in one video.Quite the achievement,well done.

  • Thank you very much!!!

  • Im speechless

  • WOOOW!!!

    Absolutely AMAZING!!! :-O

    And especially accurate. Great linking between the different events. A HUGE THANK for this beauty!

    One of the best I've ever seen up here! :)

  • Awesome video, great song. Thank you so much for doing it :)

    PS: The Chilean show was in 2005 (although I wish it was in 2006 and in 2007 and 2008 for that matter :)

  • thank you very much :)

  • nice work dude :) couple things tho...the Brazil footage is from 12/3/05 and what program did you use to put all these together??

    Thanks, keep up the good work!

  • Thanks I will fix that, and I used Sony Vagas 7 to make this video. Thank you for your comment!! :)

  • Above it all, really really great video, just perfect. My fav. song in the world!!

  • Thank you for your kind words!!! I agree that it is awesome when Eddie says "I Didn't need you to make my dreams come true". But I feel that when he says stuff like "We belong together" and anything else that shows his emotions of how sad he is that he and who ever are no longer together, it goes back to the roots of this song. But, like I tried to show through this video the song has changed a bit over the past 18 years and perhaps the meaning of this song to Eddie has changed too!!Tahnks :)

  • I don't know if u had listened to a couple of different versions for the ending of the song on youtube, I like them a lot.

    Corel Centre - Ottawa, Canada - 16 Sept. 2005

    vienna - 25. of September 06

    There are also amazing versions played in Spain and Portugal (specially the one played in Oeiras Alive in 2007). I think I've listened a number between 70-80, or even more live performances of this song.

  • Let me tell u Steven...this is the best video on youtube!!

    If I've to vote for the best video on youtube, for sure this would be the 1.

    I lost the count of the number of times I've seen this video...specially the last few footages, I've seen before the versions of Black in Chile and they were great.

    The version played in the other day with Eddie saying "Didn't need u to make my dreams come true, was awesome too.

  • the second vid is from 1991 :P

    Mural Amphitheater, Seattle

  • cool I'll Fix that then.

  • Great job, man! Awesome editing.

    Black is one of those songs you wish there was no end to. Too good to be true, really. No song better captures the power of what was early-day pearl jam. Rock on!

  • really cool idea. great job editing. thanks for posting

  • Thank you for commenting!!!

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more