Oh god I barely noticed It said "Litte" (I know I'm not the first to notice It don't think I'm trying to be 'FIRST') And this has been out for a long time.
I clicked the link on the Bronyville google dock to here while the song was still playing in the podcast and when this video started playing I didn't notice the transition XD, awesome work.
I just read the lyrics and really you people can't tell the difference between a cello and a bass...someone needs to remake this badly... And cut off last time apocalyptica is awesome look them up ( there not screamo or anything there classic rock played with 4 cellos only!)
Damn, I just fell blow away this is my favorite Beatles song and I hate how it's being ripped off but at the same time it speaks to the soul the same way the original did it did have some better lyrics I have to say take out pony and add people back and change the name from octivia to something more catchy and seriously needed "wall of sound" effect needed here not some obvious bacround music well someones singing sounds cheep and I can say better than the original. And added and random... I th
The sad thing is that in the original song, it implies that Eleanor Rigby kill herself so this song kinda implies that Octavia is depressed and is suicidal
It's actually quite difficult to tell whether it's a bass or a cello. It is too big to be a cello, because well, ponies aren't that short, but it has tuning pegs like a cello, and not a double bass.
Ya know what? I wouldn't call myself a tried and true Beatles fan. I know most of their more popular songs, but I'm not a huge fan. However, I am a Brony to the core, so this got my attention, and my god, it's amazing. I've since listened to most of your other bronybeatles songs, and they're very good, some more than others. but for some reason, I keep coming back to this one. Can't say why, but I love it. Keep at it Brony! *brohoof*
@FlutterDashie i wouldn't say that it is a parody. it doesn't sound like it was made to satire the original song, but more of a re-dub version of it to make it ponyfied.
i like hearing this and other of your songs, and watching my little pony.
cheers me up and make sme happy lol idk y but i just love it lol
usually in a bad day of school or just negative thinking that "'ugh, another day of school tomorrow...." i watch and or listen to this and i feel in a good mood lol
She had so little screen time and now she has a name, tons of fanart, fics and now an awesome song. There just isn't one single pony who doesn't get some love from the fandom, is there?
As of now, the fandom can no longer grow 20% cooler... because it has just passed infinity +1% Anything more and the universe will vaporize from over-awesomeness.
Um... is it weird that this is actually BETTER than the original Eleanor Rigby song? I mean, im serious here. I love the Beatles, but i think this honestly sounds better. And the lyrics work better too actually.
Alright, youve beaten the Beatles. Apparently you are now the Grand-High King of Sound.
Great song! I'm a bassist myself, and the size difference is pretty drastic between bass and cello. The drawing style might just leave out the details in difference between the two. It's most likely a bass. :3
@BeatleBrony Finally, another person who believes me. I also find it weird that she plays the bass, and her cutie mark is a Treble Cleff @HealyHQ Ponies aren't the tallest beings, but the instrument is taller than her, and cellos aren't that big.
@smallgiraffe42 they probably used a treble clef because it's much more well known. Show someone a treble and they'll recognize what it is, show them a bass clef and they'll likely wonder wtf it is. Only time I ever saw a bass clef was in my trombone music. Her having a treble clef cutie mark is probably also why most people think she plays a cello rather than a double bass.
I've never seen a double bass or cello in person, so I'm not sure what the size difference is between them.
@aztecsword12 Ah, I'm a band geek, and a bassist. Well, there's quite a considerable size difference between a cello and a double bass(or stand up, or contrabass, many different names). A double bass is about 6 feet tall, and a cello is about 3-4 feet. Mucho difference. How she has a treble clef and mistaking it as a cello is also another mistake, I haven't known since recently, since we're doing transposing for the orchestra pieces, cellos play in the bass clef aswell.
@smallgiraffe42I'm a cellist and I have had to play in treble before. It's actually a tuning thing, you read treble but play at a much lower octave. And yes I can tell she obviously has a cello and not a bass. Bass tuning pegs are mechanical and either brass or stainless steel (steel for VERY high dollar current models). Plus on a bass the area under the c bout is usually much wider than the top whereas a cello is more proportional.
Take a look at the tuning pegs. Then look at Double Bass tuning machines and Cello Tuning pegs. I'm an orchestral bassist and I can tell you she plays the Cello, no doubt! :)
@BeatleBrony It's a tough call. Size-wise, it's taller than her, implying a contrabass (though cellos can occasionally be taller than the performer, too).
Based on the music (if I recall correctly from the episode), though, the notes being played by a string instrument are a bit high for a contrabass, yet are much more comfortable on cello. Not to mention that another pony is playing a sousaphone; in most ensembles that size, more than one bass instrument is redundant and overpowering.
The two best things in the world combined. Well done, sir.
Theultimategeeks101 3 days ago
Could you please do She's Leaving Home?
lordantonio101 1 week ago
@BeatleBrony This track is being promoted on the Music section of Vanacus.com - Congrats! :D
OfficialVanacus 2 weeks ago in playlist VanaBeat Radio
Oh god I barely noticed It said "Litte" (I know I'm not the first to notice It don't think I'm trying to be 'FIRST') And this has been out for a long time.
oclictis1 3 weeks ago
just noticed it said "Litte Octavia"
JKawasawa 1 month ago
I heard bass and I said "YEEAAH!" Really loud lol
LunarDragon 1 month ago
I love the fanfic "Black and White" and this song.
highelves01 1 month ago
This is just. Oh my god. :glommmmp: LOVE.
justbuythecookies 1 month ago
Octavia is my favorite pony. :D
ilovetangled2010 1 month ago
4 people thought the dislike button was the download button.
kickiwi 2 months ago 6
I'm proud of you guys
Vecetti33 2 months ago
That last verse brought me to my knees in tears. Well, I was sitting, but I was brought to tears.
Goderich1942 2 months ago
I'm sorry to say that I do not find your singing to be as good as I would like from any adaptation of a Beatles song. The lyrics look nice though.
alexfotland 2 months ago
just realized that ponies never need to buy strings for their bows
Divinelighte 3 months ago 5
@Divinelighte Bwahahahahahaha!
deathtoad88 2 months ago
Comment removed
kickiwi 3 months ago
This song just got 20% cooler
SnellingFilms 3 months ago
I clicked the link on the Bronyville google dock to here while the song was still playing in the podcast and when this video started playing I didn't notice the transition XD, awesome work.
lawnmowerdude 3 months ago
One of my favorite Beatles songs ever.. Even better Bronified!
Thanks guys!!
Shanawolfo1 3 months ago
I thought he said, "Fucking her strings" …
gamefreek41795 3 months ago
'owdey beatlebrony ah'm a fan of the beatles and mlp so i think these songs of yours are epic
gloomymetalhead 3 months ago
Everything is better with Ponies. Even the Beatles.
Hydorior 3 months ago 42
@Hydorior 10 minutes ago, I wouldn't have said the Beatles could've improved, even with Ponies.
Now I wish I could go back in time and smack myself.
MegamanSora1 3 months ago
@Hydorior Is that even possible? Can you be awesome TWICE???
gamefreek41795 3 months ago
Listened to "PonE-Sharp - Trixie: A Star No More" by Coltsuke before...
Couldn't match better...
Benden01 3 months ago
I just read the lyrics and really you people can't tell the difference between a cello and a bass...someone needs to remake this badly... And cut off last time apocalyptica is awesome look them up ( there not screamo or anything there classic rock played with 4 cellos only!)
THExDESERTxFOX 3 months ago
Damn, I just fell blow away this is my favorite Beatles song and I hate how it's being ripped off but at the same time it speaks to the soul the same way the original did it did have some better lyrics I have to say take out pony and add people back and change the name from octivia to something more catchy and seriously needed "wall of sound" effect needed here not some obvious bacround music well someones singing sounds cheep and I can say better than the original. And added and random... I th
THExDESERTxFOX 3 months ago
Oh dear sweet Celestia this is amazing.
shikitokaproto 4 months ago
Simpley amazing. Good show.
AxleWolfKeyblades 4 months ago
The sad thing is that in the original song, it implies that Eleanor Rigby kill herself so this song kinda implies that Octavia is depressed and is suicidal
BronyForEvar 4 months ago
@BronyForEvar Sometimes, to paint a pretty picture, you have to start out with some pretty dark colors...
LucanVaris 4 months ago 37
This songis very soothing.
Turturro98 4 months ago
Loved the fiction, loved this.
Can't wait for the re-mastered version!
EonEvolution197 4 months ago
I never thought a song would inspire me to read a pony fanfic...then again a few months ago I never would have thought I'd be reading pony fanfics.
Tvidify 4 months ago
I'm not a huge fan of Octavia, but this video has left an impression. And earned you a subscription.
hamsterdoom360 4 months ago
DEAR GOD HOW DID I MISS THIS CHANNEL
Screw homework, I've got a channel to peruse
tuackanxu 4 months ago 2
My favorite background pony mixed with what may be my favorite Beatles song. I now officially love you all.
PerryPlanet 4 months ago
One of my favorite Beatle songs mixed with the best show ever? All of my money, TAKE IT!
gage64 4 months ago
I wonder whos the gift for?Vinyl Scratch? Nah....
loltroll12341 4 months ago
x@ my favorite song
traductor babel fish o google:
HISIERON ESTA CANCION MIER**!!!! X@ LOS ODIOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!
MissKeyle 5 months ago
animators, make a video of octavia playing this. NOW
bearVshark100 5 months ago
The Beatles+My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic= Fucking awesome.
BratzSlipknotGrl3004 5 months ago
It's actually quite difficult to tell whether it's a bass or a cello. It is too big to be a cello, because well, ponies aren't that short, but it has tuning pegs like a cello, and not a double bass.
smallgiraffe42 5 months ago
Ya know what? I wouldn't call myself a tried and true Beatles fan. I know most of their more popular songs, but I'm not a huge fan. However, I am a Brony to the core, so this got my attention, and my god, it's amazing. I've since listened to most of your other bronybeatles songs, and they're very good, some more than others. but for some reason, I keep coming back to this one. Can't say why, but I love it. Keep at it Brony! *brohoof*
BDbiogamer 5 months ago
epic
myoomoo5 5 months ago
im SO glad that you realized that it was a Bass and not a cello.
zeldapikachu64 5 months ago
My favorite song, re-done with my favorite TV show. Subscribed. 8,D
ConnorMTracy 5 months ago
I really love this song. Im glad that you know she plays a double bass.
Bronywatcher1 5 months ago
Good god these songs are AMAZING!! I can't even describe just HOW awesome I think they are!
JordanRynes 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Must. Watch ALL THE VIDEOS!
FightingJEDI 5 months ago in playlist More videos from BeatleBrony
everyday im listening..
lolke12 5 months ago
Thank you so fucking much for actually knowing that Octavia plays bass and not cello.
TheSynthExperience 5 months ago
This almost brought me to tears.
Knightmaren11 5 months ago
Good to know people know to replace 'people' with 'ponies' in accordance with 'some/every/nopony' :j
thps48 5 months ago
How is this genre called?
SilentNinjja 6 months ago
@SilentNinjja Welcome to classic rock, my friend.
OMGITSME918 5 months ago
@OMGITSME918 I was with it all the time. But this is not classic rock. I made some research and found out that this genre is called Barocco-pop.
SilentNinjja 5 months ago
TOO GOOD
TrueBloodTimeLord 6 months ago
Amazing parody. :'D
FlutterDashie 6 months ago
@FlutterDashie i wouldn't say that it is a parody. it doesn't sound like it was made to satire the original song, but more of a re-dub version of it to make it ponyfied.
zeldapikachu64 5 months ago
This is absolutely epic.
RTDragonCommando 6 months ago
Sir I would like to give you a few of my Internets.
Ellrocthor 6 months ago
Why can't i thumb up this twice?!?!?!
AmstradExin 6 months ago 3
@AmstradExin its funny that you got exactly 2 thumbs up
CMSpartanz 5 months ago
i like hearing this and other of your songs, and watching my little pony.
cheers me up and make sme happy lol idk y but i just love it lol
usually in a bad day of school or just negative thinking that "'ugh, another day of school tomorrow...." i watch and or listen to this and i feel in a good mood lol
demonfox879 6 months ago
She had so little screen time and now she has a name, tons of fanart, fics and now an awesome song. There just isn't one single pony who doesn't get some love from the fandom, is there?
Sonetodecirene 6 months ago
As of now, the fandom can no longer grow 20% cooler... because it has just passed infinity +1% Anything more and the universe will vaporize from over-awesomeness.
Alondro77 6 months ago
Um... is it weird that this is actually BETTER than the original Eleanor Rigby song? I mean, im serious here. I love the Beatles, but i think this honestly sounds better. And the lyrics work better too actually.
Alright, youve beaten the Beatles. Apparently you are now the Grand-High King of Sound.
TheVampireCabbit 6 months ago
Beatles + MLP=HNNNNNNG
mysterioso2006 6 months ago
Ok, I now wish I had never read Black and White, because now I'm sad dammit and I need Octavia to get a happy ending.
succundo 6 months ago
mmpretty good.
SyntheticEarth 6 months ago
Black and White made me cry :,(
now Octavia is my favorite background pony.
Atlittle104 6 months ago in playlist Luna theme 2
You should do Mrs. Robinson next. :)
watsonwolffang 6 months ago in playlist PonyMusic
@watsonwolffang That's Simon & Garfunkel, not the Beatles.
leeshajoi 6 months ago
@leeshajoi And that means they still can't do it? Amirite?
Just because they are called BeatleBrony doesn't mean they can only do Beatle music. :P
watsonwolffang 6 months ago
Have you thought of submitting your songs to be played on Celestia Radio?
I hope you say you will, cause I think everyone needs to hear your wonderful work!
LazureusFalcone 6 months ago
@LazureusFalcone link is ponify.me
LazureusFalcone 6 months ago
It's definitely a Cello.
Look at the Wikipedia pages for both the Double Bass and the Cello.
The Cello is a skinnier build and is more rounded like in the drawing itself.
KeisukeDarkefaux 6 months ago
Great song! I'm a bassist myself, and the size difference is pretty drastic between bass and cello. The drawing style might just leave out the details in difference between the two. It's most likely a bass. :3
Hailkit 6 months ago
The song was for DJ Pon-3
DrIvoRobotnick 6 months ago
I know its a bass, I just like cellos more...
KrassMcWriter 6 months ago
This honestly brought a tear to my eye.
Confound these ponies, they drive people to be absolutely amazing.
CedricBale 6 months ago 37
You sir, have made my week.
Supersheep64 6 months ago
Wait whats black and white never heard o dat
oclictis1 6 months ago
@oclictis1 ~ It says on the image itself. It is a fanfiction.
Ahem, anyway, I absolutely love this, not sure if I commented on this already though...
(my mind is a little derpified at the moment)
KeisukeDarkefaux 6 months ago
This is so good! Really good singing!
Brightgalrs 6 months ago
Way to combine one of my favorite songs with one of my favorite passions. Excellent work!
calimantis 6 months ago
I love it
I love it
I love it
I love it
I love it
I love it
I love it
I love it
OCTAVIA <33333
paperluigi232 6 months ago
This is some intense badassery.
AaronFeitelberg 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Wow, those vocals sound almost identical to McCartney's original vocals. This is awesome! Can you guys do a pony parody of Help or Hard days night?
Drumada 6 months ago
Comment removed
Drumada 6 months ago
Wait, there's no MP3 for this yet? Oh good GOD. What am I going to do? Seriously, this was pretty gorgeous.
BronyMike 6 months ago
There is so much awesome in here. I'm surprised one Youtube URL can contain it.
DracoReincarnated 6 months ago
you earned a sub
FlCl3000 6 months ago
MP3 download please? ♥
Ekevoo 6 months ago 14
@Ekevoo Your wish has been granted!
BeatleBrony 6 months ago 8
@BeatleBrony Amen
GiromCalica 6 months ago
since no one pointed it out yet, i'll say it: it says "litte" instead of "little" on that picture.
anyway, great song! my favorite one of all from this channel.
suizidschraube 6 months ago 14
@suizidschraube Omg, it does... *facehoof*
BeatleBrony 6 months ago 18
@BeatleBrony We love you anyway!
DaUziel 4 months ago
I wish I had an awesome voice like yours... :(
TheDashingHero 6 months ago
But she doesn't play the bass...she plays the cello. :/
HealyHQ 6 months ago 11
@HealyHQ A common misconception, but she does indeed play the Double Bass. (But I think in the fic it's a cello, I'm not sure).
BeatleBrony 6 months ago 14
@BeatleBrony Finally, another person who believes me. I also find it weird that she plays the bass, and her cutie mark is a Treble Cleff @HealyHQ Ponies aren't the tallest beings, but the instrument is taller than her, and cellos aren't that big.
smallgiraffe42 6 months ago
@smallgiraffe42 they probably used a treble clef because it's much more well known. Show someone a treble and they'll recognize what it is, show them a bass clef and they'll likely wonder wtf it is. Only time I ever saw a bass clef was in my trombone music. Her having a treble clef cutie mark is probably also why most people think she plays a cello rather than a double bass.
I've never seen a double bass or cello in person, so I'm not sure what the size difference is between them.
aztecsword12 6 months ago
@aztecsword12 Ah, I'm a band geek, and a bassist. Well, there's quite a considerable size difference between a cello and a double bass(or stand up, or contrabass, many different names). A double bass is about 6 feet tall, and a cello is about 3-4 feet. Mucho difference. How she has a treble clef and mistaking it as a cello is also another mistake, I haven't known since recently, since we're doing transposing for the orchestra pieces, cellos play in the bass clef aswell.
smallgiraffe42 6 months ago
@smallgiraffe42I'm a cellist and I have had to play in treble before. It's actually a tuning thing, you read treble but play at a much lower octave. And yes I can tell she obviously has a cello and not a bass. Bass tuning pegs are mechanical and either brass or stainless steel (steel for VERY high dollar current models). Plus on a bass the area under the c bout is usually much wider than the top whereas a cello is more proportional.
BIPICY 6 months ago
@BeatleBrony
Take a look at the tuning pegs. Then look at Double Bass tuning machines and Cello Tuning pegs. I'm an orchestral bassist and I can tell you she plays the Cello, no doubt! :)
HandyTheXxxX 6 months ago
@BeatleBrony It actually IS a cello. Trust me, I play bass. ;3
Infalle 6 months ago
@Infalle
And I play cello. There is no way that is one. Far too large. You don't need to stand to play the cello :/
servbotno33 6 months ago
@servbotno33 Hello?.. Whe're talking ponies here... Wher we sit they HAVE to stan and where we stand... I don't know, maybe some chair under them?..
Plusle843 1 month ago
@BeatleBrony It's a tough call. Size-wise, it's taller than her, implying a contrabass (though cellos can occasionally be taller than the performer, too).
Based on the music (if I recall correctly from the episode), though, the notes being played by a string instrument are a bit high for a contrabass, yet are much more comfortable on cello. Not to mention that another pony is playing a sousaphone; in most ensembles that size, more than one bass instrument is redundant and overpowering.
northrupthebandgeek 5 months ago
@BeatleBrony hey can i have the one without the vocals? your a great singer but its just that i like these kind of songs with out vocals
floodboy55 4 months ago
@HealyHQ What's to say she's not multi-talented?
TheDoomAlpha 6 months ago
I love this, so so so much
smallgiraffe42 6 months ago
This is FANTASTIC! :O
serenosaur 6 months ago
Holy shit, best pony has SONG
kite10122 6 months ago
Everypony thinks my mind is hazy
I don't mind, I think they're crazy
Things are not as bad as they may seem
And I'm ok, life's a dream (life's a dream)
Please don't blame me,
No don't shame me
there's nothing wrong with my eyes
I'm only Derpy
wolfdemexico 6 months ago 62
@wolfdemexico YES YES YES!
beatlegirl99 6 months ago
I think it is wonderful you got inspired by a fanfic to do a song.
I know the author irl and I shared the video with him. I think he very much liked it ^^
<3
Pinkiederp
kittycupcakekun 6 months ago
@kittycupcakekun Awesome! It's great to hear he liked it! Thank You!
BeatleBrony 6 months ago
That was amazing. <3
Goodwrench12345 6 months ago