All those scores are absolutely amazing, when I first heard of the nominees I was happy and sad at the same time, because one great winner also means four composers who would have deserved the Oscar just as well!
Okay so I recently take saw Avatar and I take back what I just said. It really deserves the nomination. The music for Avatar is awesome, but Up has the best themes.
I remember watching the performance of the scores, and I sat there nodding as I recognized each one... until Avatar. The music to that movie was just completely unmemorable. Mr Fox, Hurt Locker, Sherlock and Up all had beautiful, instantly recognizable music. Avatar's was just really bland. Star Trek should have been nominated instead.
How was Avatar nominated for this?? I don't remember a single song from the movie and I saw it twice. Star Trek or Terminator Salvation should've been nominated instead.
strange... all my friends say that a movie sucks because of its story.... i don't exactly cara about the stupid story of a movie.. i just want to enjoy watching it god damn it... people says avatar sucks because its a cliche story.... WHO THE FUCKS CARES!! ITS A MOVIE.. IT WAS SUPPOSE TO BE FUN...
the best scores ever written; ben hur, et, star wars 2 theclone wars, dance with wolves, spartacus, titanic. [rosza,willams,barry,north,horner] no comparison.
i wanted Sherlock holmes to win, im so pissed that they didnt win anything. i loved that movie and the soundtrack and art direction gave it more of that crazy,artsy,old-time london aptmosphere
I hope Michael Giacchino gets it for Up because that montage of Carl's and Ellie's life was basicly supported by the music and when the mood changed the music went with it so well.
All those scores are absolutely amazing, when I first heard of the nominees I was happy and sad at the same time, because one great winner also means four composers who would have deserved the Oscar just as well!
CarpeNoctem410 1 year ago
Okay so I recently take saw Avatar and I take back what I just said. It really deserves the nomination. The music for Avatar is awesome, but Up has the best themes.
CoolFiddler94 1 year ago
I remember watching the performance of the scores, and I sat there nodding as I recognized each one... until Avatar. The music to that movie was just completely unmemorable. Mr Fox, Hurt Locker, Sherlock and Up all had beautiful, instantly recognizable music. Avatar's was just really bland. Star Trek should have been nominated instead.
militiagung64 1 year ago
How was Avatar nominated for this?? I don't remember a single song from the movie and I saw it twice. Star Trek or Terminator Salvation should've been nominated instead.
Up definitely deserved this award.
CoolFiddler94 1 year ago
@CoolFiddler94
funny you should say 'Star Trek', as the winner, Michael Giacchino, composed both for Up and Star Trek
cazia9 1 year ago
Giacchino deserved it.
CkvMntr 1 year ago
Sherlock Holmes..... :)
I like Up! also, and Fantastic Mr. Fox.
Each score was very well composed.
williammoseleyfan101 1 year ago
strange... all my friends say that a movie sucks because of its story.... i don't exactly cara about the stupid story of a movie.. i just want to enjoy watching it god damn it... people says avatar sucks because its a cliche story.... WHO THE FUCKS CARES!! ITS A MOVIE.. IT WAS SUPPOSE TO BE FUN...
dfghj241 1 year ago
Fuck yeah you're right :P
metafixi 1 year ago
Avatar really should've won.
17Paperclips 1 year ago
he he its WHIP IT guy!
Panditha666 1 year ago
These comments are a little bit unqualified to be honest.
He does not even call one of the composers by name. And whay did not the composers thereselves give comments on their scores?
inspi1212 1 year ago
the best disney score is undoubtley The Lion King
WtfSimpleplan 1 year ago 3
yay UP!
This was the one Oscar that I was really excited for, haha...
oldmoviemusic 1 year ago 3
Up has a great soundtrack ;)
Gliskor 1 year ago 8
Avatar should have won this!
kobretti888 1 year ago
the best scores ever written; ben hur, et, star wars 2 theclone wars, dance with wolves, spartacus, titanic. [rosza,willams,barry,north,horner] no comparison.
ldaccardi 1 year ago
Seen this movie yesterday it was very good!!but best Movie of the Year???
SmokieNLD 1 year ago
US propaganda of Iraq war.......
nicolasshang 1 year ago
How? Politics were never mentioned in the movie.
It's about men, not motives.
WillKillForName 1 year ago
yes you right
slaughter908 1 year ago
I'm so happy that Up won. It's just so magical. :)
tru3s 1 year ago 5
Yes man, give it to Up!
SquareBooth29 1 year ago
check out my latest video for "vintage glamour hollywood oscars 2010" xx
leilalondon 1 year ago
@ Drummerheadboy0
It went to "Up"
ThatsGoodTellivision 1 year ago
dammit up won, I like the score for up, but Avatar is way better
WtfSimpleplan 1 year ago
@WtfSimpleplan yeah but it sounds like titantic part 2 set to native drums
harlow86 1 year ago 2
i wanted Sherlock holmes to win, im so pissed that they didnt win anything. i loved that movie and the soundtrack and art direction gave it more of that crazy,artsy,old-time london aptmosphere
smashboxLIVE 1 year ago 2
i know what you mean. i LOVED the sherlock holmes art direction!!!!
uptownxgirlx 1 year ago 2
This guy looks a lot like the up Old man.
LolmansEntertainment 1 year ago
i think Michael Giacchino will win! anyway good luck for the nominees.
XavifromSeville 1 year ago
This actually a rather shitty collection of scores I thought.
levanyzzuf 1 year ago
I think Cloudy With a Chance of Meatballs should have been nominated.....
spudess 1 year ago
I can't believe A. R. Rahman won best score last year, what a joke.
guitars2112 1 year ago
I agree
MandelbudetReturns 1 year ago
I hope Michael Giacchino gets it for Up because that montage of Carl's and Ellie's life was basicly supported by the music and when the mood changed the music went with it so well.
kingofthemooners09 1 year ago
Mark Mothersbaugh should get a bloody Oscar.
sanspoint 1 year ago
Going with Giacchino for Up
clutchcityrockets 1 year ago
I hope avatar wins for best picture, its got a great message that should speak to everyone
imflyinn 1 year ago
I think John Williams should win for Titanic.
FanzReviews 1 year ago
John Williams did not compose the music in Titanic. James Horner did, and he won the Oscar.
MandelbudetReturns 1 year ago
@RafikiSource I agree. It's an outstanding film.
skydark 1 year ago
James Horner!! He deserves the oscar! :D
Aquamarina13 1 year ago
what exactly does perfect score mean?
Chelsimay 1 year ago
Too bad Dorian Grey isn't nominated..
Great movie!!
Aww,well..if it depended on me I would have wished Sherlock Holmes to receive an oscar but i suppose Avatar would get away with all the trophies,aye:D
Jinny9898 1 year ago
I completely agree!!!!
perfectajo 1 year ago
Sherlock Holmes should win. The weird things he did in that score work so perfectly.
SharpWMusic 1 year ago 3
as WALL-E SHOULD
muxaxete 1 year ago
What about "A single man" soundtrack?! Abel Korzeniowski's an artist.
VamptasticVamp 1 year ago
I hope Michael Giacchino will win this year.
MandelbudetReturns 1 year ago 5
I really like what was shown of Hurt Locker's score: it served the movie without drawing attention to the score itself.
However, that unforgettable unspoken montage may seal the win for Up. Which is fine since Pixar can never have too many Oscars.
AmadeusKing 1 year ago 3
Avatar or Up HAVE to win this, if not then it's a massive joke.
and come on, Hurt Locker gets nominated for best sore?! come on, it's a brilliant film, but best score? that's a load of crap.
Hughezy 1 year ago
Agreed, Michael Giacchino is this generation's John Williams I think.
spugesdu 1 year ago
@ spugesdu
John Williams is still around!!!! Wait till he's gone, and then you'll be right.
ThatsGoodTellivision 1 year ago
I thought Avatars soundtrack was more memorable, but it's not gonna win I guess...
Jellyfish60 1 year ago
No Fantastic Mr Fox Must WIN!!!!
YJCY 1 year ago
I second Up FTW
Blademaster865 1 year ago
Hurt locker is a fantastic movie, and if avatar wins, i've lost hope in the movies!
MrTuckerFord 1 year ago 3
i'm with u ;)
SukarMadrid 1 year ago
I can't see how Up WON'T win. A second would be Sherlock Holmes, but even then, it doesn't come anywhere near Up's music. Giacchinno needs to win.
ThroneofEden 1 year ago
I think UP will win the oscar but i really want avatar to win it!
calahoon22 1 year ago
ae comr on ^^ avatar is not oscarworthy. maybe for the cgi an effects oscar. its a computer effects demoreel with an average story
happosai27 1 year ago
Michael Giacchino FTW!
vdork 1 year ago
Agreed.
1moe7 1 year ago
No, the Oscar goes to Avatar, the soundtrack was the best.
17Paperclips 1 year ago
Avatar :D
marimba101 1 year ago