fight science- boxing,muay thai,tae kwan doe,and karate

[aquinomariloulim]

0:25 asshole!

[scootfd3s]

I have a technique that would defeat them all. it's called 44 Magnum

[HunK800]

its obvious that the force generated is totally based how power a man could be, not based on his fight style.

[brucekirk89]

They are not taking to concederation the diffrant size of all they guys also

[Ascenscion123]

This is bs ,TKD has no jab that punch wasnt even in tkd its just a jab thrusted forward.

[MrAlchemist009]

boxing owns all...nuff sed



[syaoranpies]

AFRO NINJA

[Metalgearsolid1992]

A SLEDGEHAMMER TO THE FACE?? IM GOOD

[504omni]

Yeah, the science part is pretty crappy (no control or uniformity), but the fighting is cool,

[ksjb85]

lol...

that black karate guy in the red gee is the same dude "bruce leeroy"...

he's the one who tried that famous backflip and ate it on camera.

then tried to do some numchuck move and fell back down..he just cut his fro.

[Karascool]

Ok I get the fact that different styles have different punches some more effective than others. The 90lb Chinese guy is never going to out punch a 200lb boxer. Then again you could attribute their muscle mass to their training styles as well. A boxer packs on big muscle where a kung fu fighter might go for more lean arobic muscle.

[cwmike08]

thats not even fair lol

[skate4life890]

this testing is stupid. all the guys are different sizes... and im pretty sure a taekwondo fighter with the same stature as a karate fighter CANNOT punch as hard.

[nippleripper]

Kung Fu punch?!!? thats not Jeet Kune Do punch, which has been previously proven the superior punch... and mass and weight does affect it... imagine if it was such a trained fighter such as Bruce who would have had the strongest punch easily... science may have the book smarts, but the common sense is no where to be found!

[lordhriley]

I do not like the punching test because it is not accurate. All those guys are different sizes. This affects the punching force. Reason we have eight classes.

[chiconspiracy]

@PattyCarnage91

So..his legs will be magically hardened against kicks vs a scrub boxer? Lowkicks will end you if you don't know how to deal with them, and everything a boxer learns has nothing to do with that.

[hugoloves2spooge]

Isn't a punch only as hard as the weight and speed transfered by the puncher? Hence, weight classes?

[johnsoncardarius]

at 2:20 tha guy said were gonna detrimine if 1 style can beat them all tha only way we can detrmine dat is if they fight

[songokukingdomhearts]

Muai thai is the best, a muai thai fighter could kick the shit out of a boxer

[aaronISyoda]

lol steve petramale "undefeated boxer"

Light Middleweight (154 lbs)

won 3 (KO 1) + lost 0 (KO 0) + drawn 1

via boxrec.com

[XxPhillipXxx]

the reason the boxer won cause he was fuckin huge

[RuVe2]

@XxPhillipXxx its technique, not size that matters

[StrangerKXH]

@RuVe2 mass does factor into the power of a punch because of the amount of energy need to move the arm is greater, which translates into more energy transferred into dummy.

[wwwaaarr]

scientific method requires a control or constant in order to be valid. there where different guys doing different martial arts, and unless you have a robot that can do all the styles within the same physical limitations then all this proves is that the boxer was stronger and maybe had better form.

[jerodt9]

@PattyCarnage91 dude jus type in boxing vs muay thai ....boxer gets lowkiked in all the vids and falls..its funny

[AAEffectsgeek]

They forgot something here, there are people up in mountains trying in these combat sports that no one knows about, but can probably KO every one of these guys. They based it on world champions the real champions don't fight for fame, they train and they never stop, just saying. But these guys are amazing

[GuardianAngel5150]

@CHRISTIANSOLDIER101 I think a boxer taking a real Knee too from a professional Muay Thai fighter like Menchor too would be devastating. Boxing has its place in combat sports, but it's really a limited combat system.

And as we see from teh "Scientific" standpoint? Most dangerous is the THai Boxer.

[EARTHza323]

Most of them are not asian lol

[mastermax911helpme]

I would just like to say one thing about low kcik and boxers, if boxers don't work on indurance with kicks to strengthn their legs then a low kick would be a HUGE supprise and do more damadge then one would think....... nice video i rank it with a pie :-)

[2020182]

@CHRISTIANSOLDIER101 actually no because us boxers have very strong legs, you could try though.

[ronnytravisbarker22]

boxing is something good to learn but you got to know more then just boxing

[SOADfan1825]

u gotta also notice boxing and tae kwan doe artists use 12 oz. gloves which dose alot more

[bympy]

this is fucking awesome thanks for uploading!!

[lileezyejr]

@bympy u welcume

[korasaku]

The karate-kia was not trained to use his body and pivot in his punch, karate is supposed to be one hit, one kill.

[tezopapa]

some style require more strenght but like one person say let one of them do all of their tricks. if u gonna compare kung fu skinny guy on a punch wiht a boxer 5 times his weight well haha he got fast arm and alot of weight so is gonna be obvious. but let boxer try a punch like a kung fu style or mua thay. btw i like muay thai. and i got this video on my laptop srry 4 my bad english.

[TheSonnetPrince]

hey people, i get your points, just watch the dang vid

[maninthewoods01]

Do some of you guys think that boxers are oblivious to other arts? Many of us were well versed in street fighting, and got into boxing later. We know that people will throw kicks, grapple us, and do joint locks. And many of us know how to avoid them, or use them. We just prefer boxing because it is what we are versed at. Same as karate, jujitsu, kung-fu,etc. I've seen muay-thai guys get beat by street brawlers, and karate black belts get whooped by golden-gloves champs. It's the fighter...

[lileezyejr]

watch my other vids guys subscribe rate and comment

[ajax9502]

the boxer needs to SHIFT if he shifted he would of put up to 1500 pounds of force

[MuayBoranWarrior]

Muay Thai's punch?

[godfist1]

No style is better than another, it depends on the fighter.

[MuayBoranWarrior]

That's a reductionist Ideology. Somebody using techniques based on poorly developed, impractical theories is less likely to win/survive than someone using practical, realistic techniques.

[godfist1]

Thats not true. Each style has its own strength and weaknesses. No one style is better than another.

[DonMack279]

@godfist1 If that were true you'd see more styles being used in Mixed Martial Arts. All styles are not created equal.

[MrLAKIWETPU]

stupid scientist. the kung fu guy is the smallest while the boxer is the biggest.

[MuayBoranWarrior]

Scientifically, that does have a lot to do with it. Shameful. "Experts say _____". LOL

[Nk00037]

@MrLAKIWETPU yup what they should have done is let one of them do all the moves  they used on the dummie

[bmon1010]

Boxing will break any one jaw.

[longrob]

@vincent8er You see, you promised to not get into spamming or responding to my post, but you did.....................that's why I owned your ass, dummy!

[longrob]

@vincent8er I didn't have to own your goofy ass. Everyone here can read how ignorant your post are. No need to own you, you own yourself. Now, scurry away and stop making yourself look like a short school bus rider.

[longrob]

@vincent8er How many times do I have to make you look like a 15 year old turd before you scurry away. Everyone here can see how ignorant your anaolgies truly are. I own you!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[longrob]

@vincent8er That was a great comeback sweetheart! Did your husband think that one up for you? You got gay on the brain!

[longrob]

@vincent8er You lil queer. Start from the outside with an elbow, and I'll be in the showers while you're getting smelling salts. fag

[longrob]

@vincent8er An elbow? Have you ever trained in your life? That's nonsensical? Come in with an elbow and then kick? Damn! OK, I don't wanna argue either..............never mind!

[longrob]

@CHRISTIANSOLDIER101 Only if you don't take the 5 minutes that it takes to learn to check a leg kick.lol

[longrob]

@vincent8er You don't have to close the distance. A smart fighter will wait on an opportunity. That opportunity is usually to eat a leg kick to throw your straight right. Lesnar did it to perfection to drop Mir in their first fight.

[k1bagami]

Shouldn't have all the people been at that same weight? Don't like this test.

[chevygearhead454]

@k1bagami thats wat i was thinking of course the heavyweight boxer is gonna hit hard then the 120 lbs kung fu guy

[lileezyejr]

@CHRISTIANSOLDIER101 I know

[karatergb]

good old fashin boxing...lol love it!

[MuayBoranWarrior]

That technique that the so called ninjutsu martial artist used is well known in the martial arts world called a heart break shot. It's no secret super ninja move. All you gotta do is use a long straight or a punch with your lead fist when your upper body is turning from a twisted position, like lets say after a slip, a long straight/hook/overhand/uppercu­t, back to a regular position while targeting the center of the chest.

[ClubGirlPower]

Never box a boxer!!!!!

Not a good idea lol. :)

[famousbro1]

hey whats ninjitsu all about?

[KTPax]

Why don't you two love birds exchange numbers and shit talk that way? It's ALOT more effective.

[ripper102596]

not to e rude r interfere r whatever but i do boxing and its a lot of fun im 14 while while bro is 20 and he does jensu yet i can still beat him but not by a long shot its pretty much over once im put in a submission move because they r deadly if used correctly and thats 1 thing karate has better then boxing but if i hit him he will have server damage ive been it karate 4 almost 6 yrs and hes been in jensu 4 only 3 but still considered around an even match.

hope that helps the situation:))

[ripper102596]

hey? sup ?

[sshwapoler]

hey how are ya?

[Willettes1]

boxing sucks its not hard to beat them

[sz42781]

In a life or death situation I wanna know how to kick! In setteling an argument on whos right or wrong or who's the badder dude all you should know how to do is box or wrestle. Kicking is something an animal would do.

[pezilla123]

i wish i could do a backflip -.-

[sz42781]

if it was just fisticufs cro cop would be all fucked up.

[sz42781]

LOL! I think that tai boxing shits kinda badass! But say a guy like Brock Lesner steps in the ring with James Toney lesnars gonna be lights out. Let lesner throw kicks (LOL) and toneys gonna get a charlie horse, then put Toney in a full nelson. Heres the new rule! "No kicks above the ankle"

[sz42781]

nothing like beating the shit out of someone with your fists! are you ok man?

[sz42781]

Leg kicks are below the belt!

[sz42781]

Well theres rules for a reason

[sz42781]

Well no one should have been kicking.

[sz42781]

Men dont kick cause men have nuts. if your kicking down there you could hit them, witch would not be respected not to mention gay. Also who whats to KO by charlie horse. Stand in front slip bob and weave KO punches.

[sz42781]

KUNG FU = fail

[sz42781]

The problem is, real men dont kick

[lileezyejr]

Thats not neccesarily true

[Kuraud0]

they shouldve let the tkd dude kick his style specializes in kicking but they made him punch....wtf?

[5ghter]

funny sound 1:47

[wwechamp7]

Kickboxing and Muay Thai are the best stand up

[jayvichy]

all those guys are different strengths....they didnt even announce that- pissed me off

[ikcjjtt]

this show isnt meant to be taken seriously.Its not real science or real statistics, its just for fun

[pawinful]

Muay Thai Are The best !!!

[GhostOkon]

@pawinful yea



[Feilanna]

DUDE THAT RED KARATE GUY IS AFRO NINJA!

[ShadowGKCP]

he doesn't even need a black costume

[Feilanna]

Because he's awesome like that. :D

[cleve101]

Muay thai round house is definitely the most powerful.

[neil248]

muay thai all the way... the best stand up art... by far...

[corvogio]

end jkd?

[reporter]

its Tae kwon do Theres no E at end Lolll your trying to teach someone how to spell BUt you just spell it wrong yourself

[TaekWonGee]

lol "Tae Twon Do" not "Tae Kwan Doe"

[lileezyejr]

Dang I seriously never noticed how many views this got if u guys want more I will post

[nadagain]

Yeah can you post the rest of this? I'm curious behind the explanation of a KO.

[ivo0312]

hahaha this is some stupid shit. the punch does not depends about a syle of fighting ..it depends about person ..

person who trains tkd ( kicking only with legs) had stronger kick than karate and kung fu kicker .. yeah right

[TheLtMajor]

i no huh?

[LingEntityNoobi]

and what is even more stupid is the fact that they are different weights lol.......

[neil248]

each style has a different techinque so yes the style can make a difference so can the individual....

[KirkJerky]

these tests arent accurate.(im asian btw) but honestly that asian dude cant punch as hard as a black dude. It varies from person to person

[filipinoguy101]

wouldnt the weight of the fighter make a difference?

[dragonfist25]

Exactly.

[lileezyejr]

Exactley what?

[AusEngPhil]

do not forget this prooves nothing with a sample of 1....

[Aydee2020]

1:15 F-Train!

[TheLostDrifterVan]

and people don't underestimate a boxer's leg's because we work them over double there just hard as are fist

[mrxxxoriginality]

and some say that first comes the brain signal then the move but i don't totally agree with that cuz before the signals the muscles prepare for the movement....it's about high speed reactions that the brain hasn't the enough time to calculate....and as for the boxer's leg thing the atack it's launched at the most boxers on the ankle because the ankle supports the most body wheight....if the ankle collapses the victim falls in a matters of seconds...but are some boxers that are higly train:)

[kamen25]

i still don't think this test was done correctly...each have different masses so of course their readings are going to be skewed

[defaultuserDDD]

The shouryuken is the mightiest!

[frost310]

Boxing would be superior to Muay Thai??

ur insane. someone explain this logic..

i dont see that being possible....put an olympic boxer with a level 3 or above experienced Nak Muay and it's nighty night for the boxer...

not because i dont like boxing, but because thats the way it is.

[lileezyejr]

muaythai is superior to boxing get your facts straight

[frost310]

thats what i just stated...duh.

[absalom0412]

@lileezyejr

I think that's what frost meant. He's in agreement to u.

[mrxxxoriginality]

to beat a boxer is simple but you need guts..the trick of a boxer is the front leg..if you saw the stance of the boxer in the video you will know what i mean..the front leg is used to lift the center of gravity from back to front....if you cut the link is over...to be more precise if you low kick him in the front leg while he delivers a punch he will end up down...but you must have your guard ready because if he delivers the punch and you are open you will end up down...or in a hospital bed:))

[TheLostDrifterVan]

as a boxer i applaud you for your since of fighting but you also should the in-fighter and out-boxer are the most dangereous to martial artist the boxer's secret is to close the gap and end the match fast but when it comes down to it it's the fighter and his brain that's wins the match

[mrxxxoriginality]

yes that should be apply to all the martial arts fighters...the guard and atack should be temperate and then you can use the brain to take the enemy down...to use the brain you first use the body, prepare the body to be much easier to control and to react....a good shape of your body permits your brain to develop more action with the exact calculated precision...in a battle you can't have one without the other:)

[blabla409]

I think the best combination would be muay thai and BJJ Im allready doing muay thai and its really awesome for kick,punching,elbow and knie techniques in my opinion ists the best fighting art and BJJ would be great for grappling techniques

[obsidiansdawn]

DAMN! After watching this I felt like I just got my ass kicked by these guys! I mean, shit, these guys could put you in the damn hospital, or worse! All that power! Wow!

[bobolandi]

O my fuck god it was just my fucking oppinion -.-

[bobolandi]

In my opinion Boxing is better than Muay because muay thai fighters do not train their punch properly , they train elbows , kicks and knees most and the boxer only train his punches , so if a MT fighter trade kicks with an boxer he would win but in matter of punches , boxe wins

[nwqwerty17]

muay thay is way much faster , you are just talking bullshit

[lileezyejr]

thank you

[bobolandi]

Thats your opinion...

[lileezyejr]

my opion is better

[vjoroa19]

don't mind him, bobolandi's probably one of those internet tough guys or video junkies.

[seaFoodSifu]

Styles aren't faster. Fighters make themselves faster. Wow...

[seaFoodSifu]

No shit? In a battle of kicking for boxing and Tae Kwon Do, the Tae Kwon Do guy wins.

What kind of obvious shit are you talking about? hahaha

[sombs]

I do muay that and we do a heck of a lot of boxing

[deathuandme]

just stop the bullshit. no fightin style makes u fast u make your self faster a fighting style may make u hit harder but u can even make ur self hit way harder by trainin for that style in my opinion any style that fights a boxer just boxeing rules would lose thats something if you do not agree on then am sorry you do not know fighting 1 punch from boxein is like hittin u with a sledge hammer but boxeing is the best puncher because they train so much for punches but they also need a lot of stam

[sombs]

Yeah a boxer would kill a muay thai fighter if it was just boxing, I don't deny that. I was just replying to bobolandi who said muay thai practitioners don't train their punch properly. We do train it properly, just not to the extent of a boxer, because we spend time doing a lot of other stuff. Boxing is an amazing form, don't get me wrong.

[vjoroa19]

O_o

[Kenshuho]

Best thing is that the guys training taekwondo isn't the most ideal type of takewondoka. Also the karateka hits like street thug. it's mostly from the type of person. I know many guys in karate that are better wrestlers than avarage karateka. I also know guys who can hit harder than usual, but their legs don't work as good. It depens of the person.

[twilightdumbass]

yeah i know that's why i said sport or a real fight, as in self defense.

[twilightdumbass]

ahhh good old fashion boxing, no doubt it's worth a knockout if all you do is work on the fist. not that i think the other martial arts aren't devastating too. it just makes too much sence that boxing gets those results.

[lileezyejr]

muay thai would kill a boxer not literilly

[twilightdumbass]

well of course muay uses more then just the fist.

however even though boxing isn't as graceful as other marital art, it's one that's effective in sport and in a real fight. of course i like muay thai as well and it looks amasing but i've never seen muay thai done in a real fight only in sport so it's hard for me to say it's an effective fighting style, which it could be. you can debate if you wish but i'm only giving my opinion. i favor both fighting styles, but have witnessed boxing.

[lileezyejr]

for one thing you cant use boxing in a real fight beacuse you will go to jail unless its for self defence and streetfightning is whats that called

[oliverg94]

everyone thinks that muay thai is just about kicks and elbows and knees one of the most important if not the most important is punching... the original art of muay boran is the ancient art and they were more concentrated on deadly kicks and knees and elbows. However what muay thai has turned into today as a ring sport it focuses MUCH MUCH more on punching. You people who are saying "OMG A BOXER WOULD KILL MUAY THAI" or other way around are just ignorant because it depends on the person.

[oliverg94]

I have trained boxing for 6 years and have trained muay thai for about 2 years. I have incorporated my punching and weaving style into muay thai and that is my preferred style. I think Muay Thai would be the closest to the most mixed martial art standup wise without actually going into MMA, which i also train on a regular basis.

[Evolutionrunbackward]

Yea all the knockout artists in the MMA have Muay Thai or Boxing background. Like GSP or Silva. Boxing give you the perfect punching technique which you can adapt into any fight style. And muay thai checking and striking is so effective.

[TSxUCEHADOUKEN]

it all depends on the person really! they didnt even have the pros in here!...that what get results not amateurs

[lileezyejr]

yeah they did dumbass watch the video

[TSxUCEHADOUKEN]

you know what! i type that b4 i watched the video! so yeah! my bad!

[lileezyejr]

it siahgt rbo we all make mistakes

[redbull90]

tae kwan doe? ...you idiot...start actually knowing anything

[lileezyejr]

shut up you dumb bitch you start knowing something