Which One is Better? Eps 1: Jason Castro vs. David Archuleta

[Maartjee2412]

Jason! <3

[BrittluvsBSB]

Jason all the way

[brendamartinezs]

='( i just realized that Jason has that beautiful,peaceful voice..better than...David=( man. I was this super obsessed fan but then i met Jason a couple of days ago..and dang. i'm getin' obssessed. But I'll Alwayyzzz be an ARCHANGEL!!!=) I can't choosee!!

[brit4ever]

JASON!!!... Archie is fine too. Jason is super hot and Archie is cute.

[angelgirl585]

Jason<333

[davidlovechaxine]

jason is look a lyk of "BOB MARLEY" u know who he is?

[davidlovechaxine]

david archuleta 4 ever! he is lyk an angel!

[chubawoodz]

see all the little girls thet are like 12

like faggot ass fake ass bitch ass david.

jasons older and like women not little girls.

im a dude and jason is better then that little boy david

[omigoshamberr]

jasons oh so sexy and has a great voice.

but david is super sexy and has an AMAZING voice.

soo obviously..

david wins by 982374982374 miles.

[xocutie54]

both but archie a.k.a david

[jelliebeen321]

i like them both but...ARCHIE!

[CMOUAROX]

JASON.

[linnahmoon]

JASON!!!duh

[ArchCaRxXX]

Definitely David, but I love the both of them. But David really feels the song and has a very amazing voice. GO David And Jason!

[sazeedoll]

Definitly Jason

[davidlover2]

DAVID ARCHULETA!! DUHHHHHH U PEOPLE WHO SAY JASON MUST BE DEF........AND BLIND!! hahahaha

[MissMaria10]

Archie, of course. Love Jason, but come on...Archuleta is #1. They appear to be close friends.

[ElectrikkPaperClipxx]

what kind of question is this? archie.

[princesscrj]

archie!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!! yay!!!!!!!!!!!

[brit4ever]

LOVE JASONNN! He's unique and what a gorgeous guy! Did Archie's voice crack at 3:34?

[r0r0r0cks]

archie! i like jason , but ARCHIE!!! :]

[ddaannii23]

ddaavviidd aaarrrrchhhullleeetttaa!!!!

[vip2zip]

definitely jason!!!!! no question about it!!!

[crushh11]

archie!

[MissJackieOlsen]

OK- I love them both...I'm a big fan of both...But if I have to pick one than I pick Jason. I'm DH first.

DH# 2537 (Mousy)

Rock on JC!

[idolchic14]

jason!!!

[dancegirlbabys15]

daivd arcchuleta duhh archie yeah go archie he was in top 2

[adawinan]

No offence but @ 6:01 Jason Looked Weird!!

[crushh11]

Archie! definitely...go archie!

[charweb1992]

Certainly Archie in every sense of the word - voice, tone, soulfulness, looks, hygiene.

[sugahstarrgal]

DAVID!!

[nally184]

DEFINATELY DAVID!! jason isnt that great of a singer

[kitkat0011n]

David Archuleta!! luv him!

[DavidArchuleta94]

I like Jason but love David ! It doesn't matter because they're both my favorites and both are awesome =)

[idolchic14]

JASON! DUH

[adawinan]

DAVID ARCH!!!!!!!! DAHHH!

[v59LA]

DA sing pretty good but now I'm too scare of hight tone,(got cley stuff in the ear can't get it out yet) need to listen to the mellow voice more....??? pretty boy David.Q.Q.Q

[maealo22]

I love david archuleta.. I like jason castro!

[princess4lyf07]

DAVIDDD!!

[arbereshe22]

32 for jason, 24 for david, and 3 for both.

whoo hooo! go jason! =]

[arbereshe22]

JASON CASTROOO!!!! Deffinately!

everyone thought daiv was so cute and young, but now that the show is over people are liking jason a lot more! and listen to both songs with your eyes closed, jasons voice is so peacefull, i could listen to that song all day! then when it got to david i had to turn it off after 30 seconds of him singing! his voice is soo nauseating, and he sounds like his throat is clogged and nassely!

and jason is much cuter!!!! =D

[arbereshe22]

*david

haha srry, my computer went all weird and i spelled daiv

[pistonDewa]

agreed..jason is way better. david has no variation. jason sings from heart, david from mouth..lol

[NextToNothing]

Definitely Jason.

[DavidAisYUMMY]

DAVID!! JASON!! ♥♥♥'s to Archie!

-Sheree R.

[xRadxxRiotX]

i think David is a bit better.

But i still like both.

[mollyloumelon]

i love them both too much to compare

[Cameronlover2007]

david. I mean, are you kidding me?! Jason can't sing worth crap!!!

[AnonymousWhatever]

Jason Castro!!!

[jodonrooneyxox]

DAVID!!! duhh!!!!

[rockkelle]

haha can these two even be compared to eachother? hm let's see..jason..the original, interesting guy who plays guitar...or the boring, unoriginal, powerless-voiced david archuleta? um...JASON!? yeah pretty much.

[balletdancer1993]

haha i totally agree

[InLoveWithCastro]

JASON!!

david is to boring.

[JaymeStephens84]

JASON!!! David is incredibly talented, but Jason is more my style, and MUCH better looking... and taller...lol

[amplifystryder]

wow, the comments seem to be pretty even down there...huh? Let me add my opinion.

...Either Archuleta or Cook, Michael Johns shouldn't have been voted off so soon either. I despise Castro, i didn't think i could sing.

[cookieglow]

JC!

[PheonixDown2003]

DAVID!!!!!!!

[ilov3spongebob4life]

david dah hes cute

[xxNightingalexx]

Jason Castro!

[kellysagastume]

David Archuleta!

[JBFAN01994EVER]

i cant stand jason i love david archuleta!

[shan789mudge]

JASON CASTRO 100%

i <3 him!

[mfmDancer4ever]

i loveee davidd ! (: <3

[redjfmsox]

DAVID!! >:[ Jason C. sucks xD

[Ecr605]

Jason :) <3

[keynamdc]

Jason es lo mejor de todo! no pasa nada con david archuleta!! lo adoro!! i love him!!

[pwincessMaz]

I like both of them but i like David.a 1% more :D:D lol

My sister is going to kill me since shes obsessed with jason castro :p

[Kristiluv224]

Definetly Jason!!!!!!

[savajess]

Jason, Jason, Jason!

[AbbyLuvsU101]

ummmm.... i think that david is cuter than jason, but jason's voice is unique. i really don't know. i'll have 2 go with: David Archuleta.

[ny11764]

man its hard 2 pic i like them both

[davidluver56]

DAVID ARCHULETA!

[thatchicem16]

um?! david Archulta!!

[wheresthexl0ve]

jason castro sucks

[rhcpluver25SEJR]

ARE YOU SEROUSLY ASKING ME THAT??? GOSH. JASON CASTRO x10000000000000000000000000000­00000000000000000000

[itsnancyer]

They both have their own unique voice and style.  I enjoy listening to both. I was agreeing with most out there that the finale was going to be between the 2 Davids until today. I think it is going to be between David A and Jason. For one they both have such a huge fan base. Two they are both very talented and when they sing they dig deep into a person's soul.

[InLoveWithCastro]

Jason, definately.  he is so AMAZING!

[OonElsa]

Jason! <3

[134134id]

both?

[kristom1234]

David archuleta.. <3

[natylore]

DAVID!!!! i love his voice

[e2daRica]

JASON CASTRO! AHHHHHH love that boy!

[jasoncastrofan1]

JASON!!!

[soccersara122]

DAVID

[tx4more]

Jason is better, no question about it! GO JASON!!!

[hawkette18]

Definitely Jason Castro. He has the most unique voice. Archuleta sounds the same each week. The only reason he is still there is because all the 12 year olds vote for him.

[balletdancer1993]

lol i agree hawkette18

[Alba025]

OF COURSE DAVID!!

[TRAKY16]

love both of them!! if i have to choose one it will DAVID!! love him so much! but jason is great too!

[banananito]

david!!but i love jason too!

[supastarrJonas]

DAvid Archuleta!!

[Kateeex21]

jassonn ways cuterr.(;

[nzgirl89]

I think in the first songs Jason is definately better- David sounds kinda breathy and a bit out of key. The second songs they are both amazing. :)

[balletdancer1993]

i agree :)

[fiipas]

David!!! :D

[carolann1218]

Definitely Jason!!!!

[jasoncastrofan1]

JASON!!!!

[PogoMcTiny]

OMG you know it's Jason! this is both of us (Lexi and Demi(pinkrox606)) bye! i think that u knew that answer!!

[balletdancer1993]

haha! jason is my fav!:)

[itsnancyer]

If Jason is your fav, then why the icon of David A?

[balletdancer1993]

i just left it as what youtube made it...i didnt feel like changing it

[rhcpluver25SEJR]

i feel terrible. i wanna marry jason. :( lol.

[danigirl789]

JASON!

Woot Woot!

[swimforever1]

JASON ALL THE WAY!!!! haha. awesome.