A Guy Challenged Dr Zakir Naik on HUMANITY vs ISLAM

[glower125]

"ON BEHALF OF HUMANITY.." PLEASE DON'T SPEAK FOR ME

[jasonthedragon73]

Respect to the dude in the spotlight.It would be hard to argue with Dr.Naik in front of all those people!

[64av54an44cak]

Allah does need a few lessons in humanity.

[dieAmuslim]

@SAIFUALI786 just to correct you on that issue, the fact is majoriy of scholars in islam say that Shia are not considered to be Muslims and the reason for that is that they have rejected the companions of the prophet saws and also given the 12 imams some of gods attributes.

[dieAmuslim]

Dr zakir is an open minded man who has studied many religions to seek the truth and discovered that the Quran and the teaching of the prophet Mohamed saws along with his companions is the path to salvation.

[h8ryj]

Islam doesn't accept GAYS, end off!

[servercabinet]

But I do agree that dr zakir naiks tactics in speaking and debating is sometimes too aggressive. Maybe thats because he learnt bad traits from his late teacher ahmed didat, who i do respect but was way too aggressive and inconsidorate when debating.

No one is perfect if we look into everyone, we all have some small kind of bad habit.

[servercabinet]

The kid has a hippy mentality with no real knowledge trying to debate rather ask a quedtion, with a person that has studied long and hard with very good knowledge.

It seemed more of an insult.

Its like those chinese karate films where the student at start thiks he knows more than the sensei, until he is slowly shown the right path.

[servercabinet]

Dr Zakir wasnt calm, because he Could sense the kid came with an arrogant persona that is hiddenly trying to attack rather than ask a question.

[madhuva]

The guy was really screwed up zakir. Zakir lost his temper. The guy was calm and focussed . Zakir is trying to force people to accept his views.mad Zakir naik. Zakit naik has gone MAD

[spdeshwal]

I am sorry Dr. Nayak, you were least convincing and very poor temprament!

[tathagatsom]

Who is this Motherfucker zakir nayak ?

[infinity2012starseed]

dr naik is not a spiritual man. prove me wrong. he may have the knowledge of all religious books, and the quickness to stomp opposer's and to re-inforce believers by quoted things from these books. there is no spiritually, i see but a robot, a man who has been programmed. the only flicker of intelligence i see in him is the ability to co-ordinate the quotes and knowledge. but looking at the bigger picture. religion, no matter which one, ruins spirituality and a true relationship with the source.

[infinity2012starseed]

being a human being is not being muslim, hindu, an american or a jew, nor is being a human being someone who is dumb, a sinner, or someone who does not know life. being a TRUE human being is to be divine without religion, without books, without science. being a TRUE human being is to be with nature, to be with inner awareness, to be spiritually intelligent, to have god that exist within to shine through and express. to be a TRUE human being is to be god. religion completely ruins spirituality

[Dambis0]

@bhasinuscuscable Yes, education is the key to destroying Islam. Force is only a temporary solution. The mediaeval Europeans tried it and they only held Islam back. What we need is for people to be enlightened about the true nature of Islam. Once they know the truth, Muslims will start to renounce their faith thinking it's a legitimate religion. We don't even have to do propaganda. Just let people read the Quran, Sunna and Sira and Islam's rotten core will be exposed.

[Dambis0]

Dear Dr. Zakir Naik, please go to Gulf countries and preach islam there. You are not invited here.You are a TRAITOR in India and all Indians including Indian Muslims hate you. You may have bookish knowledge- but you have you iota of WISDOM in you—Learn the path of BUDDHA or rot in hell with OSAMA..

Zakir Naik is just a salesperson marketing the ideologies of MUHAMMAD- THE PEDOPHILE--> A MAN OF MORE THAN FIFTY YEARS HAVE SEXUAL INTERCOURSE WITH A GIRL OF ONLY 9.

[108Wake]

where there is hate, intolerance and barbaric punishments, sadly, it is a cult- a crime against islam. is islam not hateful of other religions? is islam not painfully intolerant? is islam not barbaric in its punishment? did prophet mohammed not kill many? truth hurts. wake up and love allah discarding the koran the source of ignorance.

[TheMansoorMJ]

Is You Are Against Dr. Zakir Naik That Means You Are Against The Whole Islam.

[TheMansoorMJ]

actually dr. zakir sir got angry but he never liked someone interruptin while answerin....wch i support him tooo....i jst luv him.

[AikidoEnth]

Hahaha yes because there's nothing in the Quran that goes against humanity.

Yeah right. Hilarious.

[31MegaMike]

@AikidoEnth can you point one without quoting it out of context?...

[AikidoEnth]

@31MegaMike Of course. Mohammed was a pedofile. It doesn't matter which context you put that it, it will never be right.

[31MegaMike]

@AikidoEnth lol is that ur best?

[ZTahir07]

Zakir is nalike

[kuttus007in]

he is not allowing to open the mouth of that little boy ....poor boy... he was shouting ....was that humanity?

[futbalgopal]

@kuttus007in this is not a debate this is a question and answer session he asks he answers and if he has any doubts line up again and then ask again he is willing to answer him because he know he is spreading the truth may Allah bless you with truth soon......

[kuttus007in]

@futbalgopal The truth can be spread politely, also some times I feel like he is insulting the questioners. I don't want to listen Zakir bcz of the way he talk, it is my personal view. I believe GOD is one,you call him Allah,I call him Yahova.Some one else Vishnu,but all are same. All religions says the same thing.There are good and bad with all religion, take the good in it.I already have the blessing to understand we are all one and we are all loved by one GOD. May Lord Bless you the same way!

[kuttus007in]

@futbalgopal I have been heard he was discussing whether Jesus is god or Why muslim religion is the best etc.According to me the first thing he must teach to others is about islam and how good it is. Nabi has told many good things, but people criticizing his words,especially the words during the war time. Zakir should teach why it has been told and when it needs to be followed. So Zakir please help us to understand Islam more and let us decide what is best.

[sharmaa27]

HUMANITY:THIS GUY SAYS IN HIS DEBATES THAT IT IS WRITTEN IN QURAN THAT JEWS ARE ENEMIES OF ISLAM...............SO ACCORDING TO HIM PAK QURAN TEACHES ENMITY.......IS THAT CALLED TEACHING HUMANITY/PEACE

[msaqibc]

the young chap should learn manners... he is very disrespectful... in humanitarian HINDI language... a Battamaiz...

[senengg1]

why the hell he was shouting and making scared, poor young boy

[sharmaa27]

@senengg1 REASON WHY IS HE SHOUTING ......................... HE ISN'T A PEACEFUL MAN HIMSELF. i HAVE LISTEN TO A LOT OF HIS SPEECHES AND DEBATES ON YOUTUBE AND MR NAIK'S STATEMENTS CONTRADICTS HIMSELF.EVEN A LOT OF MUSLIM PREACHERS SAYS THAT HE TALKS RUBBISH.

[draslrus]

Masha Allah, the perfect answer as always!

[salimnazer]

I would like to know how a person going out of Islam dealt with a death Penalty could be justified on the base of humanity. Does it send him straight to heaven or give him another chance to change his mistake ??

[uroojrahman]

@onlypeacenoreligion........u hv no ryt to use abusive wrds fr any1....

if u wnt peace tou its better fr u to speak politely .....

[yogsmith1]

GOD is ONE, people pray in many different ways. All kinds of people exist in this world irrespective of their religion/faith, this is the basic thing everyone forget, including Zakir Naik.

[alkdaruzi]

The best answer among answer... I proud to be muslim.

[onlypeacenoreligion]

i get angry hearing this bastard(zakir) What nonsense he is talking about.

[MrAzman75]

@onlypeacenoreligion meaning that brother, you're not listening..try to open your heart and mind if you want people to listen to your opinion then you should learn how to listen to others as well..

[onlypeacenoreligion]

@MrAzman75 just tell me why islam is better(more than humanity as zakir said),without comparing any other religion.Answer me logically not like the way he does,,out of context,out of the world.

[MrAzman75]

@onlypeacenoreligion Becoz' if you learn the Quran (read and understand the content) you'll find that Islam has given us the way of life. Meaning, Islam is the one and only kitab that give you how to live your life as human being, islamic law (individually,family,comunity,­globally), science and lots more. Tell me brother, i'm not judging you, but how do know what's good and what's not for you, family and comunity?? Islam provides you with the answer brother. Thank you for sharing with me.

[lamay]

According to Pascal, a great scientist:

If there is God n u believe in it.. Its a winning situation.

But if there is no GOD n u still believe in it. Atleast u'll not be in Loss!!

But if there is GOD n u did not believe in it.. CONFIRM LOSS..

so better pray for urselves my dear NON BELIEVERS that one day u should be given this chance to believe... otherwise it will be too late... all muslim brothers please pray for them...thanx!! :)

[truemsgtou]

masha allah

[kasun34411]

If there a mighty God,he or she or it must be the most disgraceful person or thing in the universe.

[abhilashcdc]

big shame on MR Naik you are losing tempo....you have to show more maturity

[sanhakhan]

gr8888

[Dillak47]

hope that answered his q

[sanhakhan]

an execellent answer by doc naik hats off

[iFloRite]

Zakir needs a little bit more work in terms of dealing with youth who obviously have a lower intellect... he's a little too aggressive as well. I'm a muslim and I agree with his views, but I think he can be better! 100K people were live there, he should not have criticized him as much personally, he's a youth.

[daspinguru]

@iFloRite I think he just got a little annoyed. He rarely acts this way, and personally I'm glad he didn't take the soft approach this time because the guy was clearly arrogant and ill-informed.

[amiraqram]

@daspinguru nope. actually i think it is the best way to answer a silly question like that arrogant brother, sheikh ahmad deedat also did a same thing when he get a situation like this. sometimes straight is better

[nicename2011]

How many Lies Zakit told in this Q&A? Could any one count??

[TechKErala]

The supreme religion Never Say to "Believe in this religion" "This is ORIGINAL" "All other are Duplicate " !!!!!!! actually may the religion is not saying this the foolish people ... wort less ... Up stare wakened .. foolish fellows are Saying this ..

[TechKErala]

in my knowledge all religions commonly say One this ... Give food n care to poor people ,,,,also Love all People !! (All living Thing ). Never hurt any one ... This is better than that , that is better than this ... why this????? what we need? our needs are common .. so we need some basic thing to follow to live GOOD .. in my knowledge all religions are saying one in this basic Needs ... Only One this is true Love .... Love is God ... Try to understand ...and stop discussing this kind of SHIT

[TechKErala]

religions religions religions all are humans ,,,,,,,,,,,, so he have right to pray god ... and know one thing ! Everything is GOD ! (our soul is god) even a DOG is breathing ,,, because of god !!! Dog have no religion ... but God Give Him Air to breath !!!!....

Why we need a particular religion ? itz need to live the life in Good manner ... helping other people ... giving food to poor people e.t.c and All people are consider as sun of good ,,,, so every one help each other n live in peacefully .

[RazaAli33]

very good answer for dr zakir naik, a prefect slap on aragont bastard

[Keratoplastik]

@RazaAli33 I disagree. The young guy might have started with youthful exaggerated pathos. Zakir Naik hovewer clearly avoids answering the question by reason (as he claims to) but tries to intimidate the questioner and resorts to authoritarian flagwaiving "I am an MD" "I studied all major religions, you didn´t". This is just argument by authority, hence no real argument at all. The question posed remains valid. The majority (!) worldwide follows the religion of their family.

[Sukoi49]

@RazaAli33 LOL a perfect Slap

[Martinrubhan]

@RazaAli33 why u use bad words.............?

[gpstoor]

this guy, zakir, lives in his own world, totally ignorant abt what goest around. Only an ignorant person can agree with him.

[gpstoor]

this guy, zakir, is a con man.

[baristha]

I want to be blasphemous and if at all I am to be killed, That I want to be done by nature let the nature do omnipotent allah's JOB ....

why Humans?..Because there is no allah ...He never talked..Muhammad made him up to absolve Himself of His own misconducts and nobody dared to speak against what was supposedly the will of Allah.

what a Trick ..Great...But i'm too smart to fall in to that trap..

[nirmaljot]

I can tell a lot of quotations in kuran against humanity.............Humanity ...is a religions .when u understand the feeling of every person.

[baristha]

Islam an imperialist urge masked in religious phraseology.

because according to ISLAM "torturing/subjugating Muslims" means building a church or temple In any Islamic country...wow ..see I told you, their basic definitions don't match with ours.

they are like:

It's absolutely alright to kill infidels..because they are trying to subjugate ISLAM they build churches here..We therefore declare it is a war and it's lawful to kill INFIDELS/ pagans/ atheists/ pagans/ all of them (who are not MUSLIMS).

[sicker57]

@baristha can u quote the verse which says kill infidels ..and if possible read lines above and below so that u and i get clear picture ..

[baristha]

Jihad historically has been a perpetual war against infidels (Buddhists, Hindus, Deists, Pagans, Atheists, Skeptics, Jews, Christians, etc).

Beside The 5 pillars (obligations) of Islam: Shahadah,

Salat, Zakat, Sawm, and Hajj.

As a practical fact JIHAD narrowly missed becoming a ‘declared’ PILLAR of Islam(so as not to alert others by revealing intents to potential adversaries).

Amongst a majority of Muslims Jihad enjoys at least reverence and support.

Considered Highly HOLY..They are martyrs!

[baristha]

Lebanon proves it takes just a handful of Islamic anarchists to ruin a society, albeit most citizens want progress & prosperity.

Jehad' is an Arabic word that literally means 'endeavour'.In the literal historical context, this Islamic doctrine clearly implies physically fighting for the ‘Allah’ to establish ISLAM'S supremacy over NON-MUSLIMS, until they give up their OWN faith & become Muslims or acknowledge their subordination by paying the ‘Jaziya’ (or Jizya) humiliation tax.

IS THIS PEACE??

[baristha]

The Tag "religion of peace" is clearly a misnomer according to Our understanding of PEACE.

Islam was not a TORCH, as is claimed, but an EXTINGUISHER.

Conceived in a barbarous brain for the use of a barbarous group of people,

it was/still is - incapable of adapting itself to civilization.

Wherever it has been dominant, it has broken the impulse towards progress and curtailed the evolution,advancement of society.

This Book koran has myriads of subversive presumption, proclamation and assertions..

[baristha]

Isn't that a Tad ARROGANT TO ASK A COMPLETE STRANGER to convert t Islam almost directly..

This is the vileness confined in ISLAM..And this is endorsed by that channel namely peaceTv...wow..the core reason for terrorism hosted by the channel called peaceTv what could More ironical and misleading than this?

Ha ha ha !!

NOW FOR ALL WHO THINK ISLAM IS BEST...Google "Geert wilders' view on ISLAM" and visit Faithfreedom(.)org, WikiIslam(.)net...you'll yourself witness the truth.ISLAM IS PROFANITY..

[nycinuk]

@baristha instead of reading all those websites, why not go direct to the source. Grab the Quran (or online quran[.]com), read through it, and find all the 'evil' things yourself and then decide if the Quran glorifies terrorism :) incase u didnt know, 1 cannot b a muslim if does not believe in Jesus (pbuh) and all his miracles, including his birth without a male intervention. that he is the messiah. and he is sure to come again :)

[baristha]

@nycinuk U think I didn't do it already?

I found myriads of philosophical VOIDS ..it mostly deals with profane & obscene things & full of falsities; not a Single verse that talks about CONCEPT OF Humanity, forgiveness & just iterative indirect praising of Lecher prophet in a clearly unjust way.

It's the principal cause of the decadence so visible today in the Muslim world..

its social & political proclivities are in my opinion highly atrocious ..rather a progress in relation to paganism itself..

[sateesh752]

GOD- What is the meaning of GOD? Probably I feel that god a 'creator' and 'decider' of every thing(both good and bad). My doubt is why he created many religions and why he decided to put controversy among them?

Zakir Naik is keep on trying to show his potential, he is in the race every day to prove that Islam is the best. Is Quran told somewhere "spread the Islam" and challenge all other religions? If that is not there in Quran then he is not a 100% implementer of Islamic protocol.

[rakibsll]

fuck you motherfucker u are a nut ball crushed bitch.........gain knowledge then u wil know

[SarveshwarThakur]

To my own comment on Gita, I said Gita is not for a particular religion. Any one can follow Gita without even converting/reverting. Why he'd stressing so much on REVERTING to Islam? Just to increase number of people? What do you say to that? Does a person really needs to convert to Islam to be lovale to Allah or to be eligible for Jannat? It only proves his crippled ideology. He's a big FAKE.

[SarveshwarThakur]

And before accepting this man's claims, please forget that you're of any religion. See how he's trying to impose his dicey thoughts on poor people. I really suspect he's read all the religions's book or he's a detailed knowledge of all the religions. Islam may be good. I dont oppose that but HE HAS NO RIGHT TO BERATE OTHER RELIGIONS. That is unaceptable and I condemn him for that. He's not a true human being, thus, HE'S NOT A TRUE MUSLIM.

[TheGlueFace]

@SarveshwarThakur

he didnt berate no religion, the question islam and he questions there religions, 1=1 simple logic

[SarveshwarThakur]

One thing. This man is propagating hatred in some or the other way. THIS MAN MUST BE CHECKED. He is really in such a support of Islam because he was a Muslim by birth no matter what he claims. He's a fraud. And his followers are confused. I said his followers - not followers of ISLAM. I respect all religions and we all should. People like him only cause riots between different religions. SHAME ON HIM. His ideas and he himself are so fake.

[kareena88888888]

@SarveshwarThakur I sow agree with you. My believe is that there is a creator that we all call him by different names and he is the one and only. Names of religions does not matter. The way we worship him does not matter. What matters is that we all follow humanity which is in every religion. After all religions are to guide us to the right way and that is why they all basically teach us the same thing. We should not find differences between us because the name of the religion.

[sandyr734]

5. My request to Dr. Naik is please work on some common teachings of all the religions he knows and show people some message of oneness, harmony, peace and love. Show true intention of all the great religions. To the best of my knowledge Dr. Naik can do this job better than any other pandit I know with his vast knowledge. After all I like this man very much, may God bless you.

[getrock1438]

@sandyr734 - I appreciate ur comments and convey my good wishes to u n ur throught process. At my work We have few don'ts and do's and we have to follow them or leave the job (Every organisation in this world) and starve or get into bad co. Similarly Dr.Zakir Naik field is Comparative religion study and he quote reference from different faiths and that is his job. Pork is not allowed in Islam and other major religions - if somebody wants he can on his risk for health n do the don't of God.

[getrock1438]

@sandyr734 I appreciate ur comments and convey my good wishes to u n ur throught process. At my work We have few don'ts and do's and we have to follow them or leave the job (Every organisation in this world) and starve or get into bad co. Similarly Dr.Zakir Naik field is Comparative religion study and he quote reference from different faiths and that is his job. Pork is not allowed in Islam and other major religions - if somebody wants he can on his risk for health n do the don't of God.

[sandyr734]

4. To me life is very simple, I will not have time to go through all the scriptures in this life time. It is even scientifically proven today we all are from the same souce - does not matter, Hindu, Buddish, Christian, Muslim or whatever God loves us all. As long we are pleasant within ourselves with love and peace and promote same to everyone else around God is happy enough with this type of thinking. I don't even see any need for any compitition or reason for defending my point of view.

[mad4tune]

@sandyr734 bro, this is not a sphere competition. dr naik's lectures like, ''...ISLAM is the only true way to survive..'' is not 4 to compete with u, but to spread the truth, which is the duty of every muslim.

u r not a student of theology and u r saying, ''...God is happy enough with this type of thinking...''-just sounds like a joker.

[Keratoplastik]

@mad4tune What makes you so sure that Islam is the only truth? Billions of humans on this earth believe a different truth. And there doesn´t exist an objective standard to which all these people could resort to validate the truth of their beliefs and falsify the ones of others. Everybody of these people might be tempted to raise his holy book or belief system to take this role. But deciding by argument from the Quran/Bible/BookXYZ that Islam/Christianity/Faith XYZ is true is circular argument.

[sandyr734]

3. Anything which may go against peace - is it not anti Islam in a way? With all respect lets say for example Muslim people are not allowed to eat pork, that's fine, but for others pork is just a food. If some other people are happy eating pork why should any Muslim have any problem with that person, why that person should be said give up eating pork and accept Islam, instead is it not better to live in harmony loving and accepting each other for a better world.

[mad4tune]

@sandyr734 bro, yr comments r just silly. for example a man's drunk a bottle of alcohol n unfortunately yr mom or anyone's mom come in front of him, now if he commit rape, then who should u blame. remember, u said, ''...pork is just a food...''-similarly alcohol is just a drink. hilarious.

sorry bro, i didn't try to make u hurt. remember, what is bad, that is bad 4 all human being. n ISLAM is 4 all n the true way 2 survive.

[sandyr734]

2. Such a Pandit like Dr. Naik with such a vast knowledge can do a great job by promoting harmonious living with each other. He should have little more open mind to accept other religion and talk more on harmony. He already have enough knowledge to do it. This sort of divisive argument no matter how wise it is, chances are it will put people into war in the end instead of peace.

[mad4tune]

@sandyr734 ''Such a Pandit like Dr. Naik with such a vast knowledge can do a great job...''-that is what he doing. in yr first comment u've agreed yr-self that dr. naik is far better in knowledge than u. n in yr 2nd comment u wrote ''He should have little more open mind to accept other religion...'', again, it isn't he but u who should have little more open mind to accept the truth. 4 u the most remarkable statement is ''only humanity has no level''-try 2 realize. not yr so called harmony.

[sandyr734]

1. Dr. Naik is a pandit. There is no doubt about it. He understands everything and capable of learning any unknown. I have only one problem with Dr. Naik - in my limited knowledge it looks like he is always determined to come to the same conclusion as if the tree is always his whatever the judgement/argument is. Why does he always has to say that Islam is far better than any other religion? Where does this divisive/comparing thoughts come from? Is it the teaching of his holy book?

[mad4tune]

@sandyr734 does this statement-''Islam is far better than any other religion'' hurt u? bro, make your heart open.

embrace the truth with a free heart. u've said, ''I have only one problem with Dr. Naik - in my limited knowledge.....'' again brother, the problem is with u. like the man of this video, my advise to u is enlarge your knowledge first. then u'll b able to understand yourself that ''Where does this divisive/comparing thoughts come from?'' and yes this is the teaching of his holy book.

[asmashr209]

He could have explained more about humanity in islam with examples,, a very simple example when the prophet pbuh was sitting and a car slept on his pullover,, so when he wanted to stand up he cuted the pullover so he don't disturb the cat,, wat more humanity than that!

[mrpious1972]

everyone want to listen a foolish statement All Religions are same without studying even about their own religion .

[SarveshwarThakur]

@mrpious1972 I have read Bhagwad Gita throughout and let me tell you that it has nothing against any other religion and it also does not claim that non-hindus are not lovable to God. Hell, Gita is a way of life and it is not even concentrated to Hinduism (it never even mentions/references the word/religion). Its just KARMA - what you do in your life - to urself and others. Good deeds yield good results and bad into bad results. I CHALLENGE YOU (& NAIK) TO POINT OUT A FAULT IN GITA. You can not.

[adkajang]

@SarveshwarThakur then what u r waiting for u must go and debate with him. we also want to know the truth either geeta have any fault or not. please go on

[salimnazer]

@mrpious1972 its never all the same other than they all preach for peace & humanity. Theres too much of senseless human fantasies mixed into most of the religions. Not talking about the unicorns or winged creatures but we humans are all good artists & story tellers who had even mixed our imagination into the Gods itself. If i was God, I would never be so proud about my creations kneeling down before every piece of shit they find on the way. Call it ego clash of someone with supreme authority. :D

[BangBangKillMusic]

@mrpious1972 essentially they are the same. They all give a false sense of purpose and meaning to life.

[kuttus007in]

@mrpious1972 Sir 1000% Agree with you

[jadoublet1]

this guy shut him up....didnt even give him the right answer

[getrock1438]

@jadoublet1 - This Guy (Mr. Shiraz or what ever his name) deserved that answer - The Kid want to do a healthy discussion on Humanity and was arrogant from start. Was awarded with freedom of expression and then when Mr. Naik start to reply he want to poke in Mr. Zakir naik answer and want to put words in Mr. Naik's mouth. If u want to measure Humanity u need a Scale. Humanity in other parts of World (Eg. Teenage Girls sells Kisses and send the money for charity n that is Humanity for them).

[getrock1438]

@jadoublet1 - Al Hamduliallah Allah shows the best form of Humanity through Islam and Muhammed (PBUH)