Added: 3 years ago
From: Astrotama
Views: 107,411
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (484)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • My very favorite Rush song and you did it wonderfully. Excellent work.

  • Friggin amazing!!! Huge RUSH fan!!! Rock on!!! My Fav Rush song.

  • Friggin amazing!!! Huge RUSH fan!!! Rock on!!!

  • did neil breathe on you?

  • you are frickn amazing you need to send these vids to rush so if something happens to neil like he breaks something or god for bid he passes you are his stunt double

  • nice 2112 shirt.... one of my fav albums... Temples of syrinx,discovery, (I think)

  • Good stuff/

  • Nice job. I'm not a big rush fan but I like this song a lot.

    Can you record Gates of Delerium by Yes?

    ...

  • awesome.. i wanna play drum like you play rush but i can't hehehe...

  • That was cool. That song has something for every musician. All the parts are classic.

  • DAMN GOOD JOB!!!! I could only do this air drumming in my younger day. I could never afford the gear to make it happen. To you I bid a five star! Thank you so much for fo-filling my dream.

  • Excellent!!You are very thorough on this cover,the best i have seen play it.

  • Great cover man!!!!!! do you have the full Neil Peart set? Looks like it :p Rock on man!!!!

  • Two questions. 1.- does your house have a security system and what hours of the day do you work? just wondering...

  • Great energy and dynamics.Have you listened to Carl Palmer(ELP),Bruford(Yes,King Crimson,UK),or early 70s Genisis? I know along with Buddy Rich Pert was into those guys.

  • That was awesome.

  • Absolutely amazing!! can't believe 9 ppl disliked this! congrats bro! keep it up! send me the link to your rush tribute band, plz!

  • Great job man!!!!

  • I like the power behind the sticks..

  • 9 dislikes are you kidding me ?? , this dude jams !!

  • I just watched a few of your videos. It brought back lots of great memories. Even though I am a guitarist, I always listened to Rush from a drum perspective. WIthout question, Moving Pictures was the soundtrack to my youth.

    Thank you.

  • hey astro, your my age an i think your the best rush drum cover player out here.... keep up the good work... a long time rush fan from the john rutsey era.. heres an " atta-boy" for ya...

  • Has Neal ever responded to your talents? I am amazed. Fantastic!!

  • wow..just incredible..good job

  • YOU ROCK! My question is that although I was a huge fan of Rush and Neil Pert in the 80's, wouldn't you have been less than 10? Did you follow or learn of him because of drums? I know other drummers who appreciated him. What's great is to know of musicians who appreciate all of them, while I seemed to have to defend my interest.

    :)

  • @girohead1 Euh, I'm much older than you think.... I started playing the drums several years before I ever heard of Rush and Neil but when I did, it changed a lot of things for me (as for many, many drummers). Neil's approach to the drumset is total: it's totally integrated within the music yet it's complex and powerful. His drumming makes you think and it's the kind of things I like... ;)

  • You are truly amazing, keep it up man, you could go big eventually!

  • That's pretty impressive pal!

  • awesome...

  • Excellent work and timing man

  • Seriously good job. Long, long time Rush fan.

  • great job. you might wanna relax a little though. u seemed kinda rushed. no pun intended. watch neil on r30. most relaxed drummer ever.

  • So fun to look. Love it, you are great :)

  • You are Neil Pert.

  • @RCdrummy You mean the shampoo? ;) No, I'm not even in the same Universe as Neil. I'm just a bum.

  • Sir, you are very great.

  • dude keep it up sound just like pert

  • You kick ass dude!!

  • how the hell do you afford that beast of a set

    mad skills as well

  • This my friend, is incredible. I can definatly say that Neil Peart is in for a big surprise. Also Neil, Geddy and Alex are all very very nice people. I have had the absolute pleasure of meeting them all, Neil smiles quite alot!

  • @Joeoliver123 Thank you!

  • Well done!

  • You are absolutely amazing! No one on YouTube can play Rush like you!

  • @rocknrolldude3212 Thanks!

  • You rip!

  • Dude, you are awesome! Keep up the hard work!

  • I've been a drummer and huge Rush fan for 30 years and this is one of the best fan performances I've ever seen. You play a lot of the bass drum and triplet nuances that most other drummers miss, and the feel and timing of your fills is fantastic.

  • Bloody-ell...most fun I've had on the internet in a long time....from one Rush fan (36 years and counting) to another....well met good sir!

  • @stagehand38detroit Thank you!

  • YOU RULES MAN............

  • Watch out, cuz tonight i am going to your house to steal that sexy kit!!!!

  • Watch out cuz today i am coming to your house to steal that beautiful kit!!!!

  • i've been combing youtube for drum videos for this song. yours is so far the best i've seen. i'm trying to learn the intro fills. i've got the first half. but that longer one right before the riff kicks in, i just can't figure out.  can you explain how to do it?

  • Another fine performance, keep up the good work! Thanks for the post :)

  • DUDE DIGITAL MAN WOULD BE AWESOME i know its a little too regae but every time I hear that song with the beggining fill it pumps me up.

  • Your the best I have heard! All your vids are great! Subscribed!

  • Good Lord, man! This is a sweet kit. You are really, really, good!

  • Makes me wanna bang a drum....Literally. Great work man.

  • cant wait till cleveland april 15th!!

  • great job man....... Kansas' number one RUSH FAN

  • i think you're missing some cymbals haha

  • Just wanna say that this is awesome man! mad props

  • Very well done ! keep up the good work.

  • You are THE MAN!!!!

  • very good :)

  • Just plain awesome!

  • Awesome love how you ride that cymbal.....perfect.

  • Another awesome cover dude, freaking awesome!!!!!!

  • ......CHINGON!

  • Have you ever met Neil in person? Just curious cause your a big fan. AMAZING job also :)

  • @Morningstardrummer

    not many people actually have met him.

    he doesn't like to meet his fans.

  • Biutiful man, Biutiful.. you got my foot a stompin' to your drumming. Respect

  • And my friend says Tama sucks! You just showed him! I never heard a drum cover like that of that song that that has perfect timing and a drummer that precise!

  • As a long time drummer, playing with many respected musicians and bands over the years, I have to say... I'M IMPRESSED! You do a great job, you have Neil's part down to a T! And It's NOTeasy ... keep up the good work, beautiful kit, too!

  • Well done! And only ONE kick, too!

  • The intro is challenging, and you did it! AMAZING, you're a Neil Peart copy

    lol.

  • Have you done "Analog Kid" yet?

  • You always do such a marvelous job on any Rush song. Did you already do Loosing it by them? I searched but cannot seem to find it and if you haven't you should. It is simply one of the best Rush songs ever and they never play it anymore. Sad Really! :)

  • u should give drum lessons!!!!

  • Belle Performance man, t'as du talent! Rush c'est Rush, classique, épique. Je suis dans la région de Montréal et y'a pas grand drummer qui sont capable de bien maitriser toutes les fills comme toi! Continue!

  • 3:16 Neil Peart fill engage haha. Great job, after two years of this video being up, I find myself still watching it again and again. Really admire your drumming, I'm also going to see RUSH in April, just bought my tickets today. It'll be my first RUSH concert so needless to say I'm just a little excited! Thanks again for all the great RUSH covers.

  • @Sn4keD0kkt0r @the KFC YUM! Center?

  • super...suis fan de rush aussi,,tes dur a battre....bravo,,,j,aime bcp

  • nice drum set!! and awesome drumming of course!

  • you are very talented as a drummer...this videos are living proof ...

  • well done

  • brilliant. pleasure to watch

  • and i thought my set was hard enough to move that set would be a NIGHTMARE

  • awsome i doubt i'll ever be that good, nice drummin'

  • @mulletpower2009 Aim to be better.... I'm just a bum!

  • @Astrotama DUDE...C'MON! YOU ARE NO BUM! You've actually helped me figure out which drums & cymbals get hit corresponding to the notes on my bass during the fast intro riff and after alex's solo so I'm playing along with you playing along to RUSH! :-) Thx! Never stop playing!

  • Howdy! Big fan. Would LOVE to see you do 'Digital Man' from Signals. I've always enjoyed the mashing together of different rhythmic textures in that song and am very curious how you would approach it. Besides, it's just a great song. Keep up the great work!

  • @shivoron Interesting request. You might be surprised to learn that I have mixed feelings for that song, though. To me, Rush went too far in their reggae/The Police experiment with that song. I know the drums is great but it's never been a favorite... until the S&A tour! The new version rocks really hard and I surprise myself playing along with it from time to time during practice. So, we never know...........

  • @Astrotama I understand. While I'm not a huge reggae guy, the opening bars of that song always get me fired up, but you're right that they went pretty deep into the island beat and if you're not a fan that can be off-putting. Anyway, I appreciate the consideration and will surely keep watching no matter what. I really enjoy all your work, and take a lot of inspiration away from your approach. Cheers!!

  • Hey great stuff, my first set was a set of Tama Swing Star Red 7 piece. Brings back great memories. Vous etes dans la Province ou Ville du Quebec?

  • @lg123xyz J'habite en Arizona maintenant. J'ai grandi en Gaspesie mais j'ai etudie a Quebec.

  • If i were Neil Peart, and I saw this, i would absolutely invite you to a show and let you play ANY song in front of the crowd. Just for kicks. IF that were to happen, what song would you choose??

  • @mrtransam666 Thank you! Good question... It will never happen, of course, but I think I'd play "Subdivisions".

  • @Astrotama What can I say but thanks again...

  • @Astrotama you could never be to sure, good drummin' by the way

  • @mrtransam666 The way he plays he has a good chance to meet Neil Peart. Just research the bands management and keep sending emails and letters. I'm a smallcraft pilot and got ahold of American Airlines owner and he responded to me in less than 36 hours via email. Nothings impossible my friends.

  • @mrtransam666 It's a nice thought, but I don't see it happening. Tight bands like Rush just don't do stuff like that. The only time I can remember this happening is back in the 60s when Keith Moon passed out drunk at a gig and a fan filled in for the rest of the show (footage is on youtube somewhere).

  • C WHEAT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Try not hitting the high hat with the blunt part of the drum stick and more of the tip. you will get a crisper sound. When there is a crash repeated on every beat, try to use the other hand on another cymbal, it makes it easier for the flow of the song.

    Otherwise one of the harder songs by RUSH.

  • I like the Camera Eye playing much better. I found this one sluggish. Sorry to be critical man, I used to play all these songs when I was little kid.

  • Congrats again!!! What Hi hat and ride cymbals you have in your set?

  • @jedibosch All Sabian Paragons.

  • @Astrotama Great.. like Neil's set. Good luck!

  • Hey . Congratulations! Very good performance.. Im a drummer too and I fuckin love RUSH!.too. I'm from Santiago, Chile and this year will be the first time that they come here to play a concert . October 17 2010!.. It will be a unforgetable day to all the Rush Fans here.. and we are a lot.

    As Drummer a little advice, be careful with your tempo, in some parts of the songs i feel like you are hurry a little, It happens to me too when i play this songs But you're an amazing Drmmer! Congrats again

  • You tube censors eat dog shit

  • You are a very very good drummer and you should be making money in a band I hope. How long does it take you to learn a song like this one?

  • man so good right on

  • marry me!!! :P

  • good fuckn job bro

  • Dude, are you, like, in a Rush tribute band, or something?

  • cool

  • goog job! I'm not even sure I could even play it..

  • Also, do you play in a band/teach drum lessons? I always see videos of amazing players and think "that guy better be in a band or I will visit him personally and slap the stupid out of him"

  • Hey, you are awesome. Not just the fact that you play this song, but the fact that you play it with the X-Factor: aggression, energy, real feeling. How long have you been playing drums? And LOL at the 5000 comment. This is gotta be much more expensive than that.

  • Dude.... your skills blew my mind... great job!

  • You have a kick-ass set, I want this set. But it looks like 5000 dollars so I can only dream.

  • @halo4life1234 Well, sorry, but 5000 bucks does not even buy the electronic set on that kit... :(

  • @Astrotama Damn.

  • @Astrotama Damn. Werd did you get the cowbell set?

  • @Astrotama doesn't even buy teh cymbals

  • @halo4life1234 more like 20000

  • Dude,LOVE your mic-setup!! Your drums sound AWESOME with that (and yes,LOVE the "true" sound of the cymbals too!!) Great job!

  • you have youe set up just like Neil!

    Love it :P

  • your ride is really fuckin loud.

    to loud even.

    awesome cover though.

  • holy shit did i just mangasm i think so

  • this is guy is kicking some major ass

  • good stuff ... this is very challenging to play and I'd say you are 98% dead on, which is about 98% better than anyone else could pull off (including me) ... of course, other than the guy who came up with all this stuff in the first place, Mr. Peart

  • Outstanding

  • WOW!!! As a drummer, listening to that makes me want to first weep for joy, then throw my sticks away and give up!!

    Truly fantastic performance. Well done son!!!

  • Incredible playing. That a boy!!!!

  • made my day. rock on

  • Dude, you got mad skillz!! Kudos!

  • CHeck out my vids! and fantastic job, i love this rush song!

  • That's awesome, and you play it very well, one hard at my opinion but when you get it's fun for sure. ^^

  • Dude....Str8 up...GR8 job!!!

  • F****** AWESOME !!!

  • Dude, your amazing!

  • i'm almost 49 .. been a Rush fan since 1975 ... watched all your videos .. i agree with staffsmole " Brilliant" .. wished I could do that after work everyday

  • Another brilliant rendition!

  • cool

  • rock on man. you rule so does neal.

  • really enjoy the video. I am a huge Rush fan

  • DUDE!! thats amazing. your great.... i like the shirt to

  • F'n awesome, enjoyed it. CRASH Cymbals!

  • tu toca pra cacete mano!!! you play a LOTT!

  • Great job. Check out our version at 2112tribute

    com

  • Very good! He made a lick you missed, Neal buddy :) lol sorry i couldn't resist!

  • Have to say, pretty good work.

  • Awesome! 5 Stars.

  • Stupid Youtube let this guy post more videos he is incredible and a master at what he does the whole world wants to see this guys talent but you stop him from sharing it? Fuck sorry for my language but I love all your vids and it is upsetting to see youtube from stopping you from posting vids.

  • How come the cymbals sound so tinny compared to the actual recording?

  • I'll try an answer... My recording setting if very simple. My camcorder mike cannot capture all the subtleties of the cymbals. But more important I think: Old versions of these videos were made before YT offered higher quality. They used to compress the audio to death so you lost a lot in the cymbals sound. They sound much different than on the original versions I have on my computer. Check the videos on my web site (address on my channel); they are the originals, not as compressed.

  • Thanks Astro. I think compression is the answer! Great drumming, btw :)

  • @Astrotama check out martin periard, and my drum teacher, mike michalkow.

  • Absolutely Killed it!!!!!!

  • im learning this and i sound nothing like that you rock!

  • Is that a Kiss t-shirt you are wearing?

    Ha! Ha!

    Brilliant skill...

    Please do a HD version, big man!

  • Euh, no, it's a Rush 2112 shirt! ;)

  • Dude, I've looked everywhere for a 2112 shirt but nobody stocks them any more :(

  • Dimlow! I was being ironic!!!!

  • @staffsmole lol, it's a rush t-shirt xD

  • @staffsmole wow you must have never even heard of RUSH if u confused 2112 with kiss

  • nicely done !

  • GREAT JOB my friend!! I watched very intently and I most say that was right on. I'd like some info on your set though. Tell us what you're using.

    Again, GREAT JOB!!!!

  • Bravo!!! Bravo!!! HEre Have Some Water Looks like your ready to pass out

  • man...I could watch this dude play all day...i think i will.

  • I'd love to see the video of you meeting Neil Peart when it happens.

  • Really nice job! Your kit looks kick ass as well. Rock on! Rush for life.

  • Nice job-pretty darn accurate.

  • Awesome job man!

    Come check out my cover of this song and tell me what you think!

  • That. Was. Amazing.

  • Way to go Astro! Awesome Job!

  • fantastic!

  • neil's replacement no doubt, he cant play forever lol

  • excellent....no doubt. great job.

  • Another perfect job! Did you learn these just from listening? or from the live dvds? tab books? teacher? Just memorizing 1 Rush song on drums seems hard enough lol.

  • very good playing. better than neal on his video.