that last section, the balance needs a little work. tenors need to come out a little more at around minute four, and females tend to be louder than the males. other than that, great job
We're just beginning to learn this piece, in my school choir. I think you guys have done a great job! I'll be happy if we sound anywhere near as good as you. :)
As a choir-director I know that this piece is not easy to sing in german for an american choir. Nonetheless my compliments for pronunciation of the text. If you should do some more excersize in pronouncing "streiten" (consonant) I think this performance would be excellent! I enjoy this piece everytime I hear it. Compliments to all of you!
We are working on this piece now and I haven't seen any "doloroso" (right spelling) in the sheet music. Understanding German, one would know that there's nothing painful about text or music.
Dynamics might be somewhat stronger, but that's director's choice.
Piano: No need for an organ, just because it is religious! And wasn't this written for strings? The piece is not easy on the piano player and the one here did a great job, methinks!
We are working on this piece now and I haven't seen any "doloroso" (right spelling) in the sheet music. Understanding German, one would know that there's nothing painful about text or music.
Dynamics might be somewhat stronger, but that's director's choice.
Piano: No need for an organ, just because it is religious! And wasn't this written for strings? The piece is not easy on the piano player and the one here did a great job, methinks!
I don't think that ement's comment is too harsh really, a performance in a foreign language is harder than one in native tongue but proper pronunciation of consonant sounds is vital to a german piece. Direction was very good but i think as a performance the expression needed work as in parts some members were grinning like cheshire cats whilst others were sombre and "dollorosso" as the notation suggests. The singing wasn't of bad quality and the tuning had no major issues.
ernent, maybe you are being a little bit harsh on a school choir that consists of teenagers from the ages 13-18. I think it is pretty good for an extra curricular group.
Is it really possible that you approach such a great piece of music without the very basic knowledge of how to correctly pronoune a syllable in German that begins with "st" ("streiten" in this case) ?
This is most unprofessional and significantly diminishes the impact of a good performance.
I think this song is so beautiful. Its annoying to sing it and be a soprano because you have to wait sooo long! I have to sing it for a festival in Washington D.C. You guys are so amazing!!!!
This is a wonderful performance - it is hard to believe that German is not your first language the accent is perfect. But the singing is even better - lovely texture, beautiful phrasing. Keep up the good work.
Thank you! I enjoyed the Treble Choir very much as well. If I'm not mistaken...you had the conductor from Georgia Southern that had you perform the Cultural pieces right?
we were supposed to have a different one, but she was sick.
lol he taught us some things that i still do today- for example, feeling to song with out bodies... i still do it, and my voice teacher gets annoyed because i end up doing it when i perform :P
We did this piece for the districts choir that I was in this year. We rocked, altos forever! :D
biblegal10 4 hours ago
This is fantastic, gave me the chills.
brodypaul 1 month ago
Thank God for existence, music and Love.
JosephHuntington 3 months ago 3
that last section, the balance needs a little work. tenors need to come out a little more at around minute four, and females tend to be louder than the males. other than that, great job
sammascreel 10 months ago
Comment removed
sammascreel 10 months ago
We're just beginning to learn this piece, in my school choir. I think you guys have done a great job! I'll be happy if we sound anywhere near as good as you. :)
amberleykate 1 year ago
I find it lovely how they pronounce the word "streiten" though it is "wrong" (as you would say).
But the music carries above that, that´s my oppinion, the feeling comes through which is what counts.
WaKaSaWaKaSaa 1 year ago
Prison guards never sounded good to me, but this IS impressive.
JosephDillon57 1 year ago 4
Wow, incredibly good performance, my compliments!
Goliath131 1 year ago
As a choir-director I know that this piece is not easy to sing in german for an american choir. Nonetheless my compliments for pronunciation of the text. If you should do some more excersize in pronouncing "streiten" (consonant) I think this performance would be excellent! I enjoy this piece everytime I hear it. Compliments to all of you!
sandy140672 1 year ago
@sandy140672
American Choir???? this choir is from New Zealand (Auckland).....but thanks for your compliments and advice....
pja2pja2pja2 1 year ago
We are working on this piece now and I haven't seen any "doloroso" (right spelling) in the sheet music. Understanding German, one would know that there's nothing painful about text or music.
Dynamics might be somewhat stronger, but that's director's choice.
Piano: No need for an organ, just because it is religious! And wasn't this written for strings? The piece is not easy on the piano player and the one here did a great job, methinks!
No excuses needed: Compliments to all!
vhjmvn 1 year ago
We are working on this piece now and I haven't seen any "doloroso" (right spelling) in the sheet music. Understanding German, one would know that there's nothing painful about text or music.
Dynamics might be somewhat stronger, but that's director's choice.
Piano: No need for an organ, just because it is religious! And wasn't this written for strings? The piece is not easy on the piano player and the one here did a great job, methinks!
So, as far as I am concerned: Compliments to all!
vhjmvn 1 year ago
This is a great performance. I love it and it touches me.
andi1712weber 1 year ago
I don't think that ement's comment is too harsh really, a performance in a foreign language is harder than one in native tongue but proper pronunciation of consonant sounds is vital to a german piece. Direction was very good but i think as a performance the expression needed work as in parts some members were grinning like cheshire cats whilst others were sombre and "dollorosso" as the notation suggests. The singing wasn't of bad quality and the tuning had no major issues.
netgare 1 year ago
ernent, maybe you are being a little bit harsh on a school choir that consists of teenagers from the ages 13-18. I think it is pretty good for an extra curricular group.
panamuib 1 year ago
tee hee hee 1:40
onceigoblack 2 years ago 4
Is it really possible that you approach such a great piece of music without the very basic knowledge of how to correctly pronoune a syllable in German that begins with "st" ("streiten" in this case) ?
This is most unprofessional and significantly diminishes the impact of a good performance.
ernent 2 years ago
@ernent sorry. most of us were asian so cant speak good english... german so hard.
jollajolyo 1 year ago
i love this song. i song it at spivey hall.
olushoga 2 years ago
tenors sounded great, lovely performance.
thedict 2 years ago
i sang this in carnegie hall....one of my favorite songs
cbdd18 2 years ago
We Did this Piece in both New England Music Festival, and Vermont's Allstate, Allstate was far superior, but this piece is done beautifully here.
eddiec802 2 years ago
Comment removed
BigWhita01 2 years ago
I sang this song at the Vermont Allstate in 2009
BigWhita01 2 years ago
me too! I loved that director... he was amazing
sdrawrofkniht 2 years ago
IM from Sydney University Choral Society and we did this piece...thanks for the upload it was a great practice for a bass such as myself...
you guys are realy good..... they shold have honour'd you guys by having a Organ company it not a piano...pitty
YokaiTetsuiga 2 years ago
*love*
musicnerd96 2 years ago
I think this song is so beautiful. Its annoying to sing it and be a soprano because you have to wait sooo long! I have to sing it for a festival in Washington D.C. You guys are so amazing!!!!
insanexandxcrazy 3 years ago
Well sung but horrible pronunciation!
donartist 3 years ago
Yes, awesome sound! I think the pronunciation is okay, except for the word "streiten" which should be pronounced ['ʃtʀaɪ̯tn̩].
1218cl 2 years ago
This is a wonderful performance - it is hard to believe that German is not your first language the accent is perfect. But the singing is even better - lovely texture, beautiful phrasing. Keep up the good work.
careerdetection 3 years ago
You guys are sooo good! It's an outrage they didn't have an organ accompanying you. An outrage.
crazymavericksfan 3 years ago
Ooh! I was in Georgia All-State, too! Go 9/10 Mixed...we so rocked. :D
Windysmoke 3 years ago
i love this song and you all preformed it amazingly!!!!! GOOD JOB
likethoseboobies 3 years ago
Yea YAY!!!! CHORALATION WAT!!!!!! :D ima miss all you 7th formers nxt year :( dats straight up Westlake Represent right there!!!!!
StraightUpChony 3 years ago
Das war gut aber so oede haha. Sie sehen ein bisschen toet aus. Sehr schoen singen.
domin8d 3 years ago
very nice piece. I had to perform this in the Georgia All-State choir earlier this year. Great job singing within the texture!
tgipson30238 3 years ago
I was there at GA all state!
i was in intermediate treble choir!
didnt mixed do this?
musicnerd96 2 years ago
Yes. The 9/10th performed this song. I absolutely loved working with Dr.McCoy on this piece. He's a genius!
tgipson30238 2 years ago
you guys were so good at it!
musicnerd96 2 years ago
Thank you! I enjoyed the Treble Choir very much as well. If I'm not mistaken...you had the conductor from Georgia Southern that had you perform the Cultural pieces right?
tgipson30238 2 years ago
Cultural pieces?
i really liked our conductor!
we were supposed to have a different one, but she was sick.
lol he taught us some things that i still do today- for example, feeling to song with out bodies... i still do it, and my voice teacher gets annoyed because i end up doing it when i perform :P
musicnerd96 2 years ago
hahaha. Thats the great thing about all-state. We all can take what we've learned from the experience and apply it to our lives.
tgipson30238 2 years ago
so true!
musicnerd96 2 years ago