Lilly Scott - I Fall To Pieces (American Idol Season 9 - Top 8 Girls) 03/09/10

[TheTop20freak]

how funny is it, simon predicts she's going home 2:45 lol

[sheruelxpxp]

i love lilly she had a great voice... pathetic aericans...

[brianok01]

rlly kinda baad...

[hir0ismyher0]

anyone who hated this has no idea what music is. the fact that Miley Cyrus and Justin Bieber can be so praised and people like Lilly Scott can be insulted for originality, expression and soul just goes to show that most people don't appreciate great music... it's sad. so many people are missing out!

[irock9114]

this season sucked! big time!! :/

[9heisman]

What's with her face? (right when she says "pieces") It's SO funny!!!

[bendnotbreak18]

@9heisman It's called expression. It shows she's putting her heart and soul into the song. She has an unusual face so some expressions might look strange. But if you get used to it, you might like it. :) Some of the best things (and people) in life take time to grow on you.

[billy29211]

Did u hear her lullaby of birdland? SO GREAT!

[susan13027]

She butchered the song for one...and why does she make that stupid ass face when she is singing? She looks like a cat that is getting ready to attack!

[kroniclover]

omfg she totally ruined the song like fuck man she is sickin even my dog hated her singin

[YT102008]

Next to Crystal I liked Lilly and Lacey. Don't understand how both got voted off and some one like Paige Miles (who can't carry a tune, awful) remain. That's par for Idol and why I don't like it. Crystal is the only reason I'm watching Idol with my two teenie-weenies. I wish Lilly and Lacey were still on. My teenie-weenies agree with me for a change. They like that I'm hanging with them.

[Patsyclinefan1]

This chick sucks.

Patsy cline will be rolling over in her grave hearing her sing this song.

[micap20078]

patsy cline is very old fashioned lily made it currrent and i dont why people keep comparing lily to her cause thats so not the point noone else is being compared

[TheThinkingBiatch]

Even Kara said she made Patsy Cline feel current! PLS BOYCOTT AMERICAN IDOL! I'm sure if simon leave nxt season. BYEBYE AI!

[AngelicAnimeX]

The next one to go home should be Katie. I don't want to sound cold, but I feel as if the only reason shes getting votes is because shes 16, and she has her sappy little story, and she bats her eyelashes and says "I just want my grandmother to see me win before she forgets about me..." like, thats sad and all, but if her voice isn't what it SHOULD BE to WIN, then whats the point in voting? So she can give her grandmother a guilt-trip win? No. I dont want to sound mean but katie should go home.

[XXcme019XX]

i was shocked when she's voted off :(

fucking voters (those vote her ho vote her off!)

she rox

[JessicaMedhurst]

I hope she continues singing she will always be my favorite

silly americans voted her off :(

I WANT HER TO MAKE A CD!!

[cardante979]

after she went home I stopped watching AI9...

[rkent]

Mee too she is my American Idol..............

[LivingForTheSummer]

Dang, she went home?! WHY?! She was one of the best ones this year in my opinion. Sad to know she's gone. :l So unique. I was glad we'd finally gotten some originality out of all those sound-alikes. Dang...

[slogroove]

How sad we didn't get a chance to see this unique flower blossom. I guess Simon's words at the end were prophetic.

[micap20078]

how dare you stupid americans keep paige and vote off lily. americans are just too cheesy to undersand unique singers i think she would do better europe. i reakon they just kept paige to avoid the show being called racist

[izzyzdz]

I agree with you, Paige should of gone home she was so off key. Lilly was 100% better she was the best one I guess they didn't want Crystal to have competition! Americia had ear plugs in!

[spamarrows]

@micap20078 i agree... but i'm american and i love lily scott

[twnaj]

I want to know why only Americans are allowed to vote? If I were allowed, I would...but I guess it's because it's "American" Idol, so the rest of the world have no say in it, although we are good enough to buy American artists' cd's...maybe the rules should change so that we can vote via email as well...

[TGSchannel]

the wrong girls go home every week... Michelle delamor haeley vaughn ashley Rodriguez katlyn epperly.. and now MY FAVE LILLY... send lacy n paige home

[taurus2leo]

okay i think the reason why lilly and alex got voted off...and its the same reason why other AI contestants(can't name all of 'em but you can try) got booted off way too early...

it's because people ASSUME they will get thru. they think "well for sure she's gonna go thru, she's been doing so good all this time so i'm not gonna vote for her i'm gonna vote for somebody else who may need it..."

Ryan says it every every season..to VOTE VOTE VOTE if you wanna keep your idol in.

[akolangnamanito]

@taurus2leo i agree

[twnaj]

Lilly, you will always be my number One...I cried so much last night when you were voted off...but like you said - there's definitely an audience for you, and I'm one of them...keep it up - you don't need the show to achieve your dream. Just keep on following it...I'll be the first to get your cd when it's released...luvya

[butterlove81]

She so so so talented... why its so difficult to accept..... she is defferent and unique... that black girl should got off.... and alex should not going home, he got the best voice ever on american idol... how can andrew and tim got to the top 12.... the producer of american idol should done something.... make its top 14 this years... something defferent.....

[rkent]

I would have kept her in,she did soooooooooooo well.

[jt20042]

Insane she got booted off so soon. She is very talented and the only person from American Idol that I'd ever actually pay to hear live or on CD. Go get'em Lilly! You don't need the show. We'll all be waiting for the CD!

[irock9114]

wtf? she certainly deserve a place in da top 12!!!

[AceAssazin]

Lili Scott I think is the best of this batch why didn`t she got in to top12

[jeremyemilio]

She's out for the same reasons that Leonard Cohen, or Bob Dylan, or Johnny Cash, or Joan Baez, or KD Lang, or Patsy Cline herself would never make it to the top 12 on American Idol... 'cause when it comes right down to it, most people are stupid...

[atlast23]

She has talent. What a shame that she is not part of the show anymore. That's a mistake.

[JaYnEsAyZ]

i like her style but this wasn't good at all

[quebop]

Great song !!! Too bad Americans are such idiots !!!

[flyingryan12]

After tonight Idol is done for 2010. No way this girl should have been gone. No way Alex Lambert should have been gone. Idol has become a texting contest, last year proved that. No way no how can Chris Allen outsing Adam Lambert, I dont blame you for leaving Paula, or you Simon

[zacandtaylorrule]

A friend sent this to me. She did alright but I muh prefer the original Patsy Cline version. Noone can sing this like Patsy Cline and noone should try.

[annasyl12]

Well obviously, its a beautiful song. The point is she made it sound current it was brave. She did a great job. But America doesn't see that.

[kjerstie001]

That is just fucking terrible.

[TheflyingL]

What slop. She should be haunted.

[Ninjacombat1]

I love her I hope she makes it far

[Ninjacombat1]

I love her I hope she makes it far

[micap20078]

i would buy her album though i feel she can do better

[mattfrye1]

I guess good for any attempt at Patsy, but personally I dont like any Patsy Cline song without Patsy singing it.

[dpro123]

LOVE this and love her. I've always liked the original but what she did to it is really cool.

[kamikenaz]

It took me a bit to get into her way of singing and I really like it. I just wish she wouldn't squint like that or maybe it's her makeup or whatever.

[flyingryan12]

Being from Winchester, Va. the home of Patsy Cline, you made me proud. Sorry Simon, but it did have the WOW factor. I have last nights show on my DVR, and i watched Lilly sing this about 10 times so far. It was amazing.

[ForeverAnalog]

@flyingryan12 Are you joking? She is an insult. She is no Patsy Cline! I am from Virginia. too. Patsy should get out her grave and yodel her off the stage.

[flyingryan12]

I never said she was Patsy Cline, and she never claimed to be Patsy Cline. They ask the contestants to make the song their own, and Lilly did just that. And Patsy would'nt have had a bad word to say about her.

[ForeverAnalog]

okay. i was too hard on her before. Im just not thrilled with pop singers trying to cover patsy cline.

[njenret]

I agree with you on this one. Patsy is a legend and had such a unique voice. It's hard to sing one of her songs without taking away some of its greatness or being compared with her.

[sweetglory]

awesome song, awesome singer- I hear amy in there.....

[connorkimbro]

Not my favorite song choice, but i love this girl too. Interesting sound, very talented.

[XXcme019XX]

yep n she's hot

[ForeverAnalog]

@connorkimbro This is an excellent song sung beautifully by Patsy Cline. She just butchered it.