1999 Caroline Benson 37-Carly and Robin Finally Come to A head!

[CAM8689]

glad robin told time to break up the CarSason nonsense that has ruined GH

[sonyab1974]

Great scene! The look on Carly's face at the end there. Yeah Carly you better be afraid! :)

[MrAquar1us]

Sarah Brown needs to come back as Carly. I miss the one and true Carly!

[Len0371]

Carly always says things in a nice dramatic fashion that she can get people to believe what she says is the truth. Well there is no colorful word that can hide what a liar she is. She may at time tell Jason the truth like she says but that is to lower him to hide some of her bigger lies. AJ and Jason never got the chance to be brother largely because of Carly and her 100 percent lies. And the trashy, conniving woman is still doing it today.

[peace2speak]

Too bad the bed hopping loser and the brother taking his brother's kid weren't woman or man enough to be honest in the first place. Jason lost me with always telling Robin that they would tell when Micheal, a kid, would be ready. That show destroying character would have been just fine. Stupidest thing on daytime. I do think that if the Robin actress had stayed the writers would have fixed this situation.

[TheOnly1tonid]

I love how they swear Carly lies all the time, but it's funny because I'd call it more like 60% truth/40% lies. Because sometimes what she says is 100% truth, like in this scene. Only because it's not what ppl want to hear or believe, mean old evil Carly is lying. When she's being completely truthful, her logic is undeniable, except to everyone who doesn't want to hear it. That's why ppl believe her lies... b/c it's exactly what they want to hear. She just did that to Lulu recently. I luv Carly!

[jasoncarly]

@TheOnly1tonid I like how you put things lol

[TheOnly1tonid]

@jasoncarly Thanks! I LOVE your channel b/c I've always been a fan of SJB's Carly & Jarly 1.0. It was Carly & Jason that got me hooked on GH in the first place. Your channel is the best!! I used to be a psych major & the depth of character Carly has was built incredibly by SJB. So being able to go back to these episode gives me greater appreciation for the character. Besides Carly is so relatable. Jarly is one of the best relationships on TV. Jason & Carly are two of the best characters. Thanks!

[Muirmaiden]

I love this speech from Carly to Robin - of course, the latter had to blab to AJ - but in doing so, she destroyed what she and Jason had. Jason and Robin were never the same after this and they were never romantically involved again. Jason has remained close to Carly (despite some intervals where they didn't speak), but no so Robin.

[TheOnly1tonid]

@Muirmaiden Nobody ever calls Robin out, except Carly. Most everybody else lets St. Robin off the hook. It's disgusting & discriminatory. She was not perfect, nor was she all sweetness & light. She could be devious & manipulative & controlling and when Carly would call her on it I would stand up & cheer. The funny thing is Carly's POV may be off sometimes, but she reads ppl very well. SO when she'd say something about someone's character she wasn't often wrong. Although sometimes exaggerated.

[Muirmaiden]

@TheOnly1tonid, so true! Robin is far from perfect or a saint. I could never stand her, although now on the show I can tolerate her much better. But she's so judgmental, people say Liz is bad, but I think Robin is far worse in that regard. Liz at least, acknowledges that she is flawed (as does Carly) but how often has Robin taken a good long look at herself? I think Carly did a good job of throwing it in Robin's face here, although it's obvious she didn't take it to heart. She should have.

[TheOnly1tonid]

@Muirmaiden I know! I've always called the Liason hookup J&R 2.0 because their relationship was just as flimsy as J&R's. The only difference is that Liz had no compunction about having sex w/ Jason b/c she didn't have HIV or something like it. I know why Robin & Liz are so close; it's b/c they're so much alike. I've never seen Jason have chemistry with any1 like he did & has always had w/ Carly. If Jason woke up 2morrow & asked Carly for a 2nd chance, she'd leave treadmarks on Jax 2 get 2 Jason.

[jasoncarly]

@TheOnly1tonid I totally agree with ya there!LOL

[sorcerer1975]

@TheOnly1tonid but that would only work if sarah brown came back to portray carly ...

[LG541]

This i one of my favorite parts. But Carly probably shouldn't have talked to Robin the way she did, cuz that pissed Robin off and that made her go tell AJ. Thanks!

[jasoncarly]

@LG541 Yep. That's why I put these up because people seem to think Robin just did it out of spite or because Jason and she broke up but, really it was the argument with Carly that set her off I don't think she had any intention on telling AJ at all but of course Carly can bring out the worst in people! Even Robin! LOL When this first aired I really did think that is why she did it and I hated Carly for talking to her that way and her lives but SJB played her so well when she left I missed her!

[LG541]

@jasoncarly yes..agreed! totally loved to hate Carly. Sarah was so good at making you feel bad for Carly even though she was such a bitch. She pissed Robin off and it bit her in the ass for sure! Ahhhh.. i miss sarah as carly soooo much..

[jasoncarly]

@LG541 I mean her lies not lives! LOL anyway I missed SJB playing Carly and watched her from the beginning and I know noone can play her better so I decided that I would dedicate my channel to her! I really loved to hate her you know? LOL only SJB can make me have those feelings with her brilliant acting. I looove LW especially from her days on loving as Ally and she is doing a wonderful job as Carly but SJB made her and NO ONE played her better IMO LOL

[LG541]

@jasoncarly love sjb! : )

[LG541]

@jasoncarly love sjb!

[TheOnly1tonid]

@jasoncarly I disagree... I think this was a set up... If not conciously, then subconciously. Robin had been singing the "Tell AJ" song from day 1. When she fell in love w/ Carly's family, she added the full custody & joint custody garbage in the mix. But all along this is what she wanted, but she was too much of a cowardto own up to her true motives. So she hid behind righteous indignation, and came to Carly's knowing she'd get the fuel she needed to follow thru. She just underestimated Jarly!

[jasoncarly]

@TheOnly1tonid You know looking at this again, I see what you mean now lol. Maybe she was looking for an excuse to tell AJ because yeah, why would she go see Carly right after breaking up with Jason it made no sense she knew they would fight so it does look like a set up lol

[sonyab1974]

@jasoncarly I love LW on her days on loving too! :)

[jasoncarly]

@sonyab1974 ;-)

[sonyab1974]

@sonyab1974 :---)

[jasoncarly]

@sonyab1974 Girl I can watch 1999 over and over lol. And I am finally almost done with 2000 and I can do 2001 and be done with miss Caroline Benson (Sarah Brown)lol. I cant wait to put my Jagger and Karen up afterwards and if nobody watches welll... that's ok lol

[sonyab1974]

@jasoncarly Yeah the 1999 stuff is awesome! :) Hey don't worry I will watch the Jagger and Karen stuff! I love Jagger and Karen! :) We can have some fun! :)

[jasoncarly]

@sonyab1974 Cool! LOL

[sonyab1974]

@jasoncarly Hahaha! What year of Jagger and Karen are you going to put up?

[jasoncarly]

@sonyab1974 I am going to put their whole storyline up from 1992-1994 when they got married and left

[sonyab1974]

@jasoncarly Oh great! :) I'm glad you are going to put it up! :)