Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (809)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I love Her!!

  • Beautifuly done AMY =D

  • danny elfman is a genious. amy lee is amazing w/this rendition.( fiona apple not so much

  • it is nightmare before christmas

  • wow who wrote that song? its pretty amazing. sounds like nightmare before christmas a little bit though. if amy wrote that song i think my heart would melt.

  • lol Danny Elfman wrote it and it is from Nightmare before christmas. Its called "Sally's song" because the character named Sally sang it in the movie.

  • loveeeeeee it

  • Awesome!!

  • supreme.

  • amy lee is awesome <3

  • beautiful,simply beautiful

  • I would go gay for amy lee...for sure

  • I love Amy Lee, she's one of my favorite singers :)

  • i love this song! she sings it so beautifully! i got to watch the nightmear before christmas now :P

  • she's so frekin badass.

    5/5

  • if this is the new amy lee i think i like this alot more. she did a little tori amos mic switch-a-roo  there nice! it great to see her play harp!

  • Oh gods. She really pwns. Big time.

  • i love how she smiles at the end of the song. shes beautiful and very talented.

  • Is She Bold OMG, luv the new song though

  • does that look like shes bold? its a fucking feather..

  • She sings really good live this time! And for starting playing harp not so long ago, she played beautifuly <3

  • This is amazing... Amy Lee isn't usually that good live but this is incredible

  • The thing is she's usually total crap at the hard, fast songs live, and that's because she's moving around and head banging with her whole body and trying to sing at the same time like an idiot (NOBODY can sing while doing that), but she's amazing when she's just sitting down at the piano doing the slow, pretty songs live.

  • this pwns. She's so freaking talented!!! =D

  • Oh man that was awesome!

    I never knew she should play the harp X.x

    Simply Amazing.

  • wow

    her sallys song is even better live

  • OHH MY GOD

    awesome.

  • when the crap was this on?

  • She sings and plays the piano and harp! God, she's awesome. I love her!

  • And she occasionally makes her own clothes too. Does she not rock? <3!

  • lol, for a minute i thought she was going off britney spears crazy becoming bold, with that feather....but hey, its amy lee!!!

  • for a second there, i thought she shaved her head or something haha

    great song amy i love you!

    ^_^

  • I love her. She's amazing! That song and the peformance was beautiful.

  • Неповторимо, нежно, грустно!

  • oh i get it. sorry people on myspace said they did. i got confused

  • is that Lisbeth scott doing backing vocals?

  • shes beautiful and so is her voice!!! but did evanescnece brake up? its been almost 4 years since the open door.

  • Even though they haven't made an alblum in awhile that doesn't mean that they broke up. Some times a group would take some time off before they make another one.

  • Beautiful.

  • i love amy

  • It's a hair clip

  • Oh my god, I thought she shaved some of her hair haha. A gorgeous performance <3

  • Amy just got an incredible talent. every random pop singer can run away when she sings. such an amazing and touching voice. :)

  • Simply amazing...

    What more can you really say? She's brilliant.

  • I want that feather thing on her hair.

    I love AMY!! She's amazingg! EV ROCKS!!

  • Amy Lee is so fantabulous. It really makes me smile when a musician is grinning that hard when playing.

  • Amy's amazing...

    Sha has the perfect voice for teh song

  • shes gorgeous but who cares what she looks like or what she does her hair like, its all about the music, i got chills when she grabbed the harp and blew everyones mind, its hard not to love her though so i can see why we all care, guess im a hypocrite.

  • Lmao, I'm so glad you put the bubble saying it was a feather. I was freaking out at first!

  • Everyone was confused! I'm not sure if it's just dyed or a feather but it's definitely not a head wound :)

  • what thing in her hair?

  • l2read much.

  • I love this song, and the film, I think Amy owns this song. She's awesome and an incredibly talkented woman!

  • Amy's a dream. but the harp needed its own closer mic - the lowest chords cant be heard enough

  • best singer for me:)

  • " the thing in her hair is a feather i promise" XDD lmao i thought she was bald at first but thanks for that

  • she took the song half a step lower it's beautiful

  • ah that's cause ''hollywood'' likes stupid blond skeletoney chicks with no talent and double D cleavage which is also fake like they're whole lives

  • Awesome live performance! I'm stunned, she can play harp! o.O

    Yeah weird hairstyle, but if y'all say it's feather, I'll take your word for it.

  • well, i'mnot one for amy lee

    at all

    but this is fantastic!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • i belive u it loks like a feather

  • Wooow from the background vocals , scene, her voice and choice of the song..feel beautifully weak.. <3

  • Her voice is perfect for the song!

  • The dark, weepy backing vocals sound so awesome with Amy singing.

  • well, don't worry about me ripping the video. no idea how.

  • she is good....real real good hehehehe.

  • and she enjoys what she is doing at the same time...now i`m just a little jealous

  • his great song!

    <3

    cOver... of perfect amy lee!

    fionna apple is bad!

    amy lee is god

  • Well I think the POINT was to make it beautiful. If she made you think it was beautiful, then it wasn't pointless. Derrr. Negative points for you!

  • *-* ermosa

  • GOD I LOVE HER

  • this song is so powerful <3

  • Beautiful performance but I think the last part when she turns around to the harp was out of key and a little off-beat BUT it was still amazing! :D

  • love it so she made the song better its deep and hits :]

  • support Amy !!!!

    sally's song is so awesome!

  • <3 this video. I don't really know why, but this just might be my favorite performance of hers (Well, maybe aside from the Cartoon network Song)

  • Love her!

  • Whats wrong with her hair?? Whats that redish smooth part behind her ear??

  • It's a feather

  • Omg! I LOVE this song! She is the perfect person to sing it!

    I <3 Amy Lee/Evanescence! XD

  • La amo...!! No solamente porque su voz es la de u angel... si no tambien porque es una de la INTERPRETES mas grandiosas de este mundo... y digo interprete y no cantante porque no solo canta las canciones, si no que las interpreta, les da un sentido, un color, un sentimiento, ademas de tener en cuenta todos los instrumentos que sabe tocar... simplemente la mejor...

  • she didnt leave Evanescence she has a possiblity of working on movie songs but she also said shes working on new material

  • Amy Lee é maravilhosa.

    Cantora lírica que sabe produzir excelentes espetáculos.

  • perfect!

  • I love this version of the song!

    PS. Amy cut her hair! it is rlly short, i have a picture of it as my bg.

  • this song is really beautiful but also very sad

  • woa no sabia ke ella la cantaba...solo por que mi nenan me dijo :O!! que genial!! me gusta *w*

  • what happened to her hair :O

  • It's A Feather :)

  • good

  • LOVE U DEAR AMY!!CUTE!!

  • she's one of the most talented woman in pop music today. she did wonderful on this song.

  • harp? omg?

    awesome!

    And singing too

    difficult, but beatiful

  • Wow the harp is beautiful

  • beautiful voice

  • I think that was the intention when they called Amy Lee to record this song...

  • haha i thought it was shaved too. but she just has it pinned back with something.

  • she can play the harp too? what else????

    and what's wrong with her hair?

  • omg she is awesome *sigh*

  • I didn't know she played harp?

  • 5/5

  • Her version does more justice to the song. The original was way too quiet and restrained.

  • agreed, she adds so much....agony?

  • I disagree. While this is certainly a "kick ass" version of the song, it would have thrown off the balance of the movie. So the version from the film is perfect for the film

  • That's true. It would've been too long and dramatic for the movie. But it's still more satifying to listen to.

  • Danny Elfman is so great.

  • evanescene first record was great, their second sucked. amy's better off solo, shes amazing.

  • wait wait wait i take back my comment she didnt shave her head, notice the area of the "shaved" region is red? wtf

  • it looks like her hair is just painted there. Like pasted back and then painted red. Not shaved.

  • its not shaved! she just died tht part a little red, i know i freaked out the first time i saw it too!

  • It a feather thats interwined with her hair

  • yar, tell them tht X(

  • first of all amy, you nailed the song here, Congrats then the hair i think its awesome tht she shaved her hair a bit, it can be very irritating if its too long.... anyone knows when she will perform again? :(

  • she shaved her hair?!!!

  • first i love u amy lee u have really good music..and sceond what the heck did u do u hair on here

  • i am addicted to this song, its strange hehe :D

  • she totally kills the song tooo good ! i could listen to this all day !

  • she rocked the heck outta dat song!!!especially at the end with that harp thing lol i dunno wat its called but..if she is over with evanescence den im sure she is going to something better and we will all still be hearing alot of new and good things from her...i wish her the best!!

  • I want to know why she quit performing with evenesence. And if she is goin to have a solo ablum when does it come out?

  • Wait what?? She quit Evanescence?? WHEN =O I thought she and Terry were still playing together and that knew Tim guy or she'd found a a group of other guy band members, did she really leave Evanescence? :(

  • she didn't quit, danny elfman just asked her to do this song.

  • Amy Lee u r gorgeous i hope to be sand that u walking over it to see you wheresoever you go

    Amy Lee i love u to death

    Amy Lee i'm one of the tormentors in life cause i submerged in your love

    maybe u'll think me crazy but that's true

    that's my feeling & i'm not interested in any one making fun of me

    ............................

    LOVE U TO DEATH

    .

    .

    Note : about her hair it's normaly you are really enlarge the subject !!

  • is this on the new edition of the dvd?

  • amy lee is so hot and she has a beautiful voice

  • nooooooooo her hair

  • She is wearing a hair bobble type thing...

  • yeah , what did happen to her hair ????....it looks bald...in one spot ...I dont mean it in a bad way , I love amy lee

  • it's a feather.

  • her hair!

    What happened to her gorgeous hair? OH MY GOD!

  • musica muito legal!!! gosto muito dessa musica!!!

  • She's gorgeous! I'm so thankful that she was born and that every step in her life led her to this moment so that I could admire her *__*

    Amy I love you!

  • wooow!!!

    she just keeps surprisin me with what shes capable of..the harp?!!

    Amy ur the most rockin singer in my book

    cheers for an angel of talent ppl

  • i was wondering why the harp was there for most of the video .. didn't know she could play that :P

  • I stayed up till like 1am to watch this O_O and it was WORTH IT! Amy Lee is like an angel

  • OMG ! she can sing so angelic, play the piano AND the harp! shes is officially my rolemodel and im completely jealous!

  • My god she's amazing. I like the Fiona Apple version too, but the harp in the end of this one gives it such an ethereal touch. I love it.

  • fuck! how can she sing so well and play the piano fucking awesome at the same time??? just love her voice

  • she has the best voice ive ever heard she sings every note perfectly.

  • i actually liked this live version of her, a lot of her singing live doesn't sound right

  • yeah i agree,

    its cz she jumps around alot!

    but without jumping around her voice is beautiful and he performances are gr8.

  • I really liked the Fiona Apple version but I like this one even more!

  • she is amazing. evanescence is amazing. this song is amazing.and that was a cool harp

  • beyond her child-scarring hairdo...

    She has an awesome vioce.

  • i like her hair. it's cool and weird.

  • something deeper to say

    haha joking

  • It's a feather...jeesh. I thought we already discussed this a while back?

  • A very talented girl hayssss shes awesome my big idol....

  • Amy Lee's voice is so enchanting and lovely, yet haunting at the same time.

  • love it! i love amy shes awesome :)

  • perfect *-*

  • I love how she smiles at the end of the song.

  • OMG!!!!!!!!

    How could she be so perfect?

    Love her voice, and all is this woman

    soo cutee she playing harpa at the end *_*

  • Happy Birthday Amy!!

  • Yeah Amy x10000 it's so beautiful

  • Her voice sound very sweet

    i really like it

  • Damn shes talented,i never expected to see her switch to the harp at the end! Awesome!

    Fuck off with the pop ups too! You got your logo the whole time in the middle,thats enough,

  • that was awesome! XD

  • :OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO whoa they shoudlve had this song on the nightmare before christmas go amy

  • she is fucking amazing that voice (wow) and a hottie too!!!!

  • I LOVE AMY!!! :)

    But i'm not a lesbian ;)

  • You are my Muse Amy!

     Love you...

  • yup me too.a 10

  • One of the few singers that sound the same live AND recorded! Great rendition of the song, I give her a 10!

  • she got the lyrics wrong one time :D

  • when?

  • wow... I watched the whole video again but I couldn't find the part I meant o.O must have misheard something, sorry

  • hah, that could've happened to me too. ^-^

  • she continues to amaze me

  • Beautiful song

  • Figures that an angel would know how to play a harp.

    ;)

  • Awesome voice...

    Love Amy Lee...

  • incredible voice

    I love Amy lEe!!!!!