@MusiicRoolz She said "keep your thing in your pants, your heart on your sleeve" where Kelly Clarkson says "keep your hand on my hand, your heart on your sleeve" ha ha!! :)
@Anonymus91233 I don't because every time Kelly sings like high, or doing a swipe(does that make sense?) well,just when she sings it more difficult..katy is just singing like on the same note..
This is a dramatically different version from what I was used to, which was Kelly's. But I do like this one as well, which is a first for me to like one of Katy's songs. She does it very well, but I still love Kelly!
@pennaki4ever "Hook Up" means having sexual intercourse with a person. So in the song she's saying she won't just hook up she wants an actual relationship. Isn't that what every girls' looking for?
why didn't this make the album?? her second album has maybe two good songs on it, what happened to demos like this and the actually good songs on her debut? thinking of you, lost, fingerprints, et c...
She says "keep your thing in your pants" instead of "keep your hand in my hand"
And is just overall less bland and more quirky
No offense to Kelly, she's one of my favorite singers too, but in this case Katy's more suited to the song. Makes sense, since Katy wrote it. There are some songs Kelly can sing well that Katy couldn't too.
@na18oux Uhm Katy Perry actuall co wrote this with Kara Dioguardi and Greg Wells. She also recorded this way before Kelly Clarkson with a way smaller budget and it was never actually released. Then later on she worked with Kelly Clarkson to rewrite the song for Kelly to record. So before you comment on something you might want to inform yourself so that you dont put a bunch of incorrect bullshit and make yourself look like an ignorant ass.
LOLLL! Still doesn't change the fact that Katy is, and always will be vocally inferior to Kelly Clarkson. This song being posted is, in fact, embarrassing to anyone who knows anything about music theory.
@na18oux Hmm that's funny because I know a hell of a lot of music theory. Katy Perry is indeed vocally inferior to Kelly Clarkson; Did I say that she was a better singer than Kelly? No. I like both versions of the song because they both have different elements to them. This version is more rough, raw, and unpolished and the other is more polished. Kelly Clarkson has a wider range and a more powerful polished voice so different notes are used because she can actually hit them.
1) This song was co-written by Katy Perry back in 2004 with Kara Dioguardi and Greg Wells.
2) This version was recorded on a much tighter budget than Kelly's, and therefore couldn't be as mastered and edited as Kelly's.
3) This album was canceled, and the song was never officially released by Katy.
On a side note, I think Katy's version (recording and original lyrics) has more heart and grunge to it, and I believe it suits the song better. But maybe that's just me.
As far as I know, Katy sang it first. I heard her version first, and in my mind, it's the only good one. I don't like Kelly. I just don't care for her style, and she's too much of a good girl for these lyrics to suit her.
kelly's voice is much more refined than katy's when katy recorded it (her voice evolved a lot since then). but the lyrics fit katy much much better. kelly seems to just sing them and nothing more. with katy you KNOW it's her through and through. it's just a matter of what you prefer when it comes down to whose version is better.
@kirstixo212 Actually this song was written by DioGuardi, Greg Wells, AND Katy Perry. Katy Perry has either written or co-written every song she has released.
OK first of all when Katy was asked about this song she said she did it a completely different way to Kelly so I'm wondering why everything is the same sept for 4 words? So I really don't think this was sung by her.
This song is sooooo Katy. Yeah, Kelly's voice sounds better, but Katy wrote this song and it's the original. In my opinion, nothing beats the original.
This song suits Katy's personality better with that sort of goofy fun feel. also, Katy's diction is about 1000x better, so I actually understood the line "the harder i'll fight to say goodnight"
she looks better without all the make up and the thing in ur pants part is lolz!!! worthy! i dont know who's i like better. im leanin toward katy but idk
Wow I love both Kelly and Katy, I think Katy really should have refined it a bit and put it on One of the Boys and had Kelly cover it (and Long Shot) but I love how both of them sang it both so different and yet the same
it looks like she changed the lyrics from "keep your head in my hand, your heart on your sleeve" to "keep your thing in my pants, your heart on your sleeve".
I have to go Kelly on this one if it's open for debate...Although I full heartedly admit I love them both equally and that Kelly probably couldn't do Katy's stuff.
It's not bad :)
Did she just say 'keep your thing in my pants' hahaha xD
I love both singers though ^^ <3
MusiicRoolz 1 week ago
@MusiicRoolz She said "keep your thing in your pants, your heart on your sleeve" where Kelly Clarkson says "keep your hand on my hand, your heart on your sleeve" ha ha!! :)
puppydog401 1 week ago
@lorettaluvsblac idc about relationships and im a girl.i good with just sex
cookmusic10 1 month ago
@cookmusic10 ya just sex and no grammar or anything :P haha jk
beatlesbabe27 3 weeks ago
Oh my God, wow! This sounds really great! I love Kelly Clarkson's version too, but Katy Perry should have this on One of The Boys.
MrWtfWhyTheFace 3 months ago
Listened to the lyrics, they're actually really similar to If You Can Afford Me
countach27 4 months ago 3
This is obviously a Katy Perry song, it would fit perfectly in One of the Boys.
countach27 4 months ago 4
seriously, i think i like kely clarkson version better, like katy perry does not match katy perrys way of singing.
yourmylifeXD 5 months ago 8
katy perry FTW! :3
SianyWorld 5 months ago
katy perry's version all the way!!!!
montagezz2000 5 months ago
It's keep your thing in "your" pants not in my pants
caitylovesbsb95 6 months ago 3
Kelly rocks in this song...katy made it horrible
BeingYuva 7 months ago
@BeingYuva It was Katy's first?
BarbiexStudios 6 months ago
@BeingYuva it was katy's song originally and it only seems horrible because you probably listened to kellys first before katy's like me.
crazyballoongirl 5 months ago 4
@crazyballoongirl yep..bt still its horrible..it doesnt matter who wrote it kelly sang it much betr..katy's nt geting credit for this..
BeingYuva 5 months ago
No matter what she says.... she actually does want to.
Russell Brand is the luckiest man on the planet
farrand93 7 months ago
So theres "I do not hook up" and "Wakin up in vegas" in the end but youtube recognized it as "Hot N cold" WTF?
TotalDramaKiller 7 months ago
Kelly has the quality in her voice, not saying Katy's is terrible but her voice isn't really a match for Kelly
NickelBackFTW96 7 months ago
I like Kelly more,this sound shit.
Parii27 7 months ago
Kelly's version is better. :)
ye5442 7 months ago
Kelly. way better. def....lol
pwermann5000 8 months ago
LOL EWWW! KELLY FTW!
BluexMuffinx 8 months ago
Neither Katy's or Kelly's is preferred by me- but Brian Fallon's? YES. ;D
TheLimo64 8 months ago
katy's is a little more vulgar, and i heard it LONG before kelly's got popular, so i think im gonna have to go with this version.
superfishy4 9 months ago 2
Kelly's version is so much better
TheBethPark 9 months ago
How about listening to Brian fallons version of this song? for another different angle on the song.
TheMusiccfan 10 months ago
I love kellys waaaaaaaaayy beter. Sorry katy, but new is better then original. (plus 0:00- 0:52 is just.... wierd. /: )
1charliebrownisweet 11 months ago
I like this better than Kelly's...
j00marie 11 months ago
@giristotesawesome katy's biography
TheGossipgirl911 11 months ago
@giristotesawesome no,this is katy's originally,just look at iTunes katy's biology,u'll see
TheGossipgirl911 11 months ago
@Anonymus91233 you only like it better because of the line that Katy used and don't play dumb
trenthunt 1 year ago
love both Kelly better
trenthunt 1 year ago
I had no idea that katy gave kelly this andddd long shot. i love both verisons of both songs. on that note, i love both artists too :)
justamber09 1 year ago
sorries Katy but I'm sticking with Kelly's version.....It fits her voice SOOOO much better
InuKagndWolfsRaingrl 1 year ago
@InuKagndWolfsRaingrl but katy wrote it
TheGossipgirl911 11 months ago
@TheGossipgirl911 yes and the lyrics are AWESOME but i like Kelly's version of it more...
InuKagndWolfsRaingrl 11 months ago
I don't think this fits her voice well :/
RHCPlover2 1 year ago
she does it better.
she has the attitude kelly clarkson lack
ZamirPeanut 1 year ago
enfim.
TheInesMariana1 1 year ago
I love both Katy and Kelly <3
I like this one better than Kelly's but I like long shot when Kelly sings it.
So everyone is a winner! :)
Happy days.
Twist136 1 year ago
I prefer Kelly's version. I like Katy's songs, but these is better for Kelly.
Clevleen1 1 year ago
i like kelly's wayyyyyyyyy better! this one is too slow and boring...
QueenOfBeauty22 1 year ago 5
this version is much more sing-able than kelly's, since kelly's voice is like way up there...in the skies....
mgcustado06 1 year ago
Comment removed
mgcustado06 1 year ago
just realised she said "Thing in your pants" instead of "Hand on your heart"
siddique20 1 year ago 4
im sorrry katy but your voice doesnt sound the greatest it can here. it sounds a little bad. :l
montse166 1 year ago 3
I normally do not say anything neg. on youtube--but this is terrible! OMG--
cingirpar 1 year ago
@Anonymus91233 I don't because every time Kelly sings like high, or doing a swipe(does that make sense?) well,just when she sings it more difficult..katy is just singing like on the same note..
annehartje 1 year ago
kelly's version!
blackforest 1 year ago
Her voice is wrong for this song.
Lucyshortybb 1 year ago 3
i like kelly's version better. maybe cuz i used to her singing the song. but i still like katy perry. :D
loveismysuperpower 1 year ago
I like Kelly's version better cause she screamed xD Sorry katy <3 <3
cooldude123fuhku 1 year ago 6
ick = P
loserbaby45 1 year ago
This is a dramatically different version from what I was used to, which was Kelly's. But I do like this one as well, which is a first for me to like one of Katy's songs. She does it very well, but I still love Kelly!
shuppet88 1 year ago
Kellys better. -_-
witchykit 1 year ago 7
i like kellys better
countryrulz411 1 year ago 8
great song... (:
i like both of the versions kelly's and katy's...
Could somebody tell me what exactly means "hook up"?
thankss ;)
pennaki4ever 1 year ago 28
@pennaki4ever "Hook Up" means having sexual intercourse with a person. So in the song she's saying she won't just hook up she wants an actual relationship. Isn't that what every girls' looking for?
lorettaluvsblac 1 year ago 54
@lorettaluvsblac
thanks soo much for the translation.. :)
yeap..you're right...that's what every girl wants...but unfortunately it's not that easy :/
pennaki4ever 1 year ago
@pennaki4ever You just wanted someone to say it,you already knew what it meant xP
DarkDespair14 2 weeks ago
why didn't this make the album?? her second album has maybe two good songs on it, what happened to demos like this and the actually good songs on her debut? thinking of you, lost, fingerprints, et c...
exheartoh08 1 year ago
kellys version wayyyyyyyyyyyyy better
pinecone1999 1 year ago
I like Katy Perry but she sounds kinda hungover singing this... or it could be I just prefer Kelly's version
thaaeroprincess87 1 year ago 5
Katy wrote it, it's even in the album credits for Kelly's "AIEW" CD.
antonia0728 1 year ago
she sounds like a dude no offence
MrAwsome248 1 year ago
kellys is a million times better
jessfoolingaround 1 year ago
sabe eu gosto da kety mais prefiro nessa musica a kelly
iara921 1 year ago
I didn't know that Katy sings this song... I like more Kelly's version
Mr68Fireman 1 year ago
i like Kellys better....
HaraJukeybarbee 1 year ago
i think kellys is soo much better plus she was probely the who wrote it!!
michellisforever 1 year ago
@michellisforever katy actually wrote the song...
alczyn182 1 year ago
I love kelly Clarkson's version BETTER! did katy perry copy kelly or kelly copyed this song? I'm confused who was the one that made this song?
wajenny13 1 year ago
Katy's version is better.
She says "keep your thing in your pants" instead of "keep your hand in my hand"
And is just overall less bland and more quirky
No offense to Kelly, she's one of my favorite singers too, but in this case Katy's more suited to the song. Makes sense, since Katy wrote it. There are some songs Kelly can sing well that Katy couldn't too.
Keshira 1 year ago
katy wrote this song she wasn't trying to "take on" kelly's song
itsmybirthday100 1 year ago
what would possess her to think she could EVER take on a Kelly Clarkson song?
If there were any doubt before that she cannot sing, this just eliminated it.
Why would she sing this in a lower key, and on top of that, not even hit the big note of the song? I'm embarrassed for her.
na18oux 1 year ago
@na18oux Uhm Katy Perry actuall co wrote this with Kara Dioguardi and Greg Wells. She also recorded this way before Kelly Clarkson with a way smaller budget and it was never actually released. Then later on she worked with Kelly Clarkson to rewrite the song for Kelly to record. So before you comment on something you might want to inform yourself so that you dont put a bunch of incorrect bullshit and make yourself look like an ignorant ass.
qwerty05101 1 year ago
@qwerty05101
LOLLL! Still doesn't change the fact that Katy is, and always will be vocally inferior to Kelly Clarkson. This song being posted is, in fact, embarrassing to anyone who knows anything about music theory.
na18oux 1 year ago
@na18oux Hmm that's funny because I know a hell of a lot of music theory. Katy Perry is indeed vocally inferior to Kelly Clarkson; Did I say that she was a better singer than Kelly? No. I like both versions of the song because they both have different elements to them. This version is more rough, raw, and unpolished and the other is more polished. Kelly Clarkson has a wider range and a more powerful polished voice so different notes are used because she can actually hit them.
qwerty05101 1 year ago
@qwerty05101
hmm, well perhaps it's a matter of taste. or lack thereof. ;)
na18oux 1 year ago
@na18oux Katy Perry wrote it and gave Kelly Clarkson permission to sing it. No one took on anyone's song.
Please do a bit more research next time. :)
TheRandomamp 1 year ago
I like both Katy's and Kelly's version.
megansgotstyle9893 1 year ago
I think Kelly's version better, but I still love Katy
Bratzgirl100 1 year ago
Look here's the deal:
1) This song was co-written by Katy Perry back in 2004 with Kara Dioguardi and Greg Wells.
2) This version was recorded on a much tighter budget than Kelly's, and therefore couldn't be as mastered and edited as Kelly's.
3) This album was canceled, and the song was never officially released by Katy.
On a side note, I think Katy's version (recording and original lyrics) has more heart and grunge to it, and I believe it suits the song better. But maybe that's just me.
becauseiplaythepiano 1 year ago 2
I like kellys version of this song better
anndroma 1 year ago
sooooo much better than kelly clarksons
Fancy16 1 year ago
i like katy, but kellys version is WAAAAAAAAAY better.!
GeeBee868 1 year ago
That song is just not Katy's style.
PauLina1493 1 year ago
I love Katy Perry, but I like Kelly's version better.
MizzezCuty 1 year ago
i like the lyrics to this one more but kelly puts more emotion into this song than katy.
IL0VESL0THS 1 year ago
Kelly's better because she has a stronger and louder voice
tontozoo986 1 year ago
As far as I know, Katy sang it first. I heard her version first, and in my mind, it's the only good one. I don't like Kelly. I just don't care for her style, and she's too much of a good girl for these lyrics to suit her.
immabandit 1 year ago 3
@immabandit katy wrote it first then helped kelly rewrite it
Fancy16 1 year ago
Like Katy, but Kelly's is better in my opinion.
WellxHelloxCorie 1 year ago 3
Kelly's one is waay better. I still love you though Katy :D xxxxxxx
Kelly can sing this song better, and is a better singer in general, I think. But yeah ... :P Love you both xD
EmmiJ82 1 year ago
kelly's is much better
TheGod20006 1 year ago
i like kelly's better idk why, still love katy perry though
Wierdgirl5834 1 year ago
kelly's voice is much more refined than katy's when katy recorded it (her voice evolved a lot since then). but the lyrics fit katy much much better. kelly seems to just sing them and nothing more. with katy you KNOW it's her through and through. it's just a matter of what you prefer when it comes down to whose version is better.
blackama 1 year ago 4
i prefer katy perrys lyrics, but kelly clarkson's singing. i still love katy perry more though
katattackmeow 1 year ago
every song that katy wrote and gave to kelly, kelly was muchhhhhhhh better. why? beacuse kelly has more talent, isnt a barbie, and can ACTUALLY SING.
TheMissML 1 year ago
Kelly's voice sounds much better.
HanniKelly 1 year ago
actually this isong is written by Kara Dioguardi for Katy katy didnt want it and then she gave it to Kelly
kirstixo212 2 years ago
@kirstixo212 Actually this song was written by DioGuardi, Greg Wells, AND Katy Perry. Katy Perry has either written or co-written every song she has released.
becauseiplaythepiano 1 year ago
i love kellys song better
browndoglover333 2 years ago
Kellys version is better : ) Sorry Katy I still love you!!
112bubble 2 years ago 91
@112bubble urs sooo rite!!=)
SweetHeart2756 1 year ago
@112bubble but this song is written by katy
TheGossipgirl911 11 months ago
this is kelly's song. katy wrote it. kelly then asked for it, so katy gave it to her.
MrBrightside772 2 years ago 6
I prefer Kelly !
IVH93 2 years ago 3
kellys better.
MeMarkyyMoo 2 years ago 5
i l0ve katy...like kelly...
but i like kelly's ver m0re...
s0r, katy
=[
MuSic520100 2 years ago 3
Whos song was this originaly ?
w3stham09 2 years ago
OK first of all when Katy was asked about this song she said she did it a completely different way to Kelly so I'm wondering why everything is the same sept for 4 words? So I really don't think this was sung by her.
Nasa1991 2 years ago
well the image of the song changes with those 4 words,
dreamdate 2 years ago
I like Kelly and Katy. They are both GREAT! Where do you get Katy's version because it is not on iTunes????
Lieyara 2 years ago 4
it's leaked I guess, you have to download it 'illegaly' if you want I think
dreamdate 2 years ago
i think it's "keep your thing in your pants"...
Revoluscon90 2 years ago
Kelly is way better Katy sounds like shes drunk.
Punkiztah271 2 years ago 3
katy wrote it and she sings it better...no question about it.
Katy is wayyy better
alberterrror 2 years ago
kellys better, she sounds like a drunk seal at the beginning
kimico98 2 years ago
fuckk noo!
Katty Perry is so muchh better!
XxCherryPerezxX 2 years ago
This song is sooooo Katy. Yeah, Kelly's voice sounds better, but Katy wrote this song and it's the original. In my opinion, nothing beats the original.
eBear07 2 years ago 4
Kelly vocal much better!
ZacGladiator 2 years ago
the only difference is katy perry didnt sing those higher notes, she didnt sing it very strong and she says thing in your pants xDDDDDDD
famouskphantom 2 years ago
Kelly clarkson is soo mutch better
GUMMYxBEARR 2 years ago
kelly clarksons virsion is a billion trillion times better
jonasbroluver1996 2 years ago 2
this. sounds. terrible. kelly clarkson is sooooo much better.
Meredithclare 2 years ago
This song suits Katy's personality better with that sort of goofy fun feel. also, Katy's diction is about 1000x better, so I actually understood the line "the harder i'll fight to say goodnight"
UveBeenLuPwned123094 2 years ago
she looks better without all the make up and the thing in ur pants part is lolz!!! worthy! i dont know who's i like better. im leanin toward katy but idk
boruken 2 years ago
I think Katy owns the cheekiness of the song better but I think Kelly's voice works better for it.
spiffehrottenegg 2 years ago 3
kelly 100%
sugarrrushxx 2 years ago
I prefer Kelly's version !
BecomingJane1010 2 years ago 2
ew ew ew ew .
this version suuuuuuuuucks !
kelly clarksons the way to go foools ; ) !
nancyandcharlie 2 years ago
Katy wrote the song, so Kelly wouldn't be singing it if it weren't for her :P
strtthshw 2 years ago
this version is perty good. i like it!
*~ashley~*
iloveme5895 2 years ago
Wow I love both Kelly and Katy, I think Katy really should have refined it a bit and put it on One of the Boys and had Kelly cover it (and Long Shot) but I love how both of them sang it both so different and yet the same
MsMusicDancer 2 years ago
just saying, most singers are pretty bad live, kelly is one of the few who isn't because she got famous singing live in the first place.
i give katy credit for writing the song and realizing that her own voice just wasn't right for it.
remember that this isn't a FINISHED version, either.
emmylee617 2 years ago 2
@emmylee617 wish a lot of people took the same considerations you have for this demo.
Joshorty 2 years ago
leona lewis, Carrie underwood, Taylor swift, Demi lovato, Michael buble, Susan boyle, Celine dion, Alicia keys
even shakira can sing well live now.
kelly isn't the only one.
and katy can sing live sometimes
but then again katy is no leona lewis who belts out songs... because katys songs are totally different view... so i don't really see the big deal
rustydevilll 2 years ago
She kinda looks like Zooey Deschanel
GilmoreGirlsRD 2 years ago
I LIKE KATY PERRY BETTER
but
she doesnt sound so good here
she still wrote it though
mrsfreak2you 2 years ago
it looks like she changed the lyrics from "keep your head in my hand, your heart on your sleeve" to "keep your thing in my pants, your heart on your sleeve".
doubleDdog09 2 years ago
Lol, I think it's "keep your thing in your pants." And yeah, I wonder why they changed it.
strtthshw 2 years ago
they probably changed it so it would sound less dirty.
doubleDdog09 2 years ago
i like dhis version BETTER !
its awesome ' err .
jamm11457 2 years ago
dont like katys version. its a lil paru.
pixienz 2 years ago
this is more of a katy song, you know she wrote it though right?
FlavoredxBleach 2 years ago 3
I have to go Kelly on this one if it's open for debate...Although I full heartedly admit I love them both equally and that Kelly probably couldn't do Katy's stuff.
12tlinkel 2 years ago 3
ummm...KELLY!!!<3333
kaitie can kinda sing..but not pop.....she has more of a rokker like voice....
kinda like p!nk...P!nk CANT sing pop! lol
JustinBieberGirl04 2 years ago
this is really good but i admit kellys version is better
cutiepop240 2 years ago
kelly's is 987435092873592735982735098273590873259074325987435987349302847520938745098324x better.
sorry :)
partootie 2 years ago
@partootie yea but katy has a funnier voice... i love them both
xXx96Bambola96xXx 2 years ago
KELLY ALL THE WAY, SHES SO MUCH BETTER
SugarSugar091 2 years ago
Kelly's version is wayyy better
Sunshine10708 2 years ago
its Katy's song. I love Katy, but I prefer Kelly's version
PanchiFurtado 2 years ago
NO! This is origannly KATYS SONG! Katy didnt liek it so she gave it to Kelly.
TheGroovyMovies 2 years ago 6
wow, this must be a live version, Kelly usually sounds much better!
Nucdesigner1 2 years ago
i think she culda signed this better :|
mafucas 2 years ago
i like thid version better for soem reason :o more rocker ish i suppose btu i guess im alone on this 1 o3o
Cassiecakes28 2 years ago
I like kellys better SORRY!
ChickSuperior 2 years ago 3
"keep ur thing in ur pants"
lol
Katy is gr8, but i must say kelly did a better jobbb!!
xoxo729 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This sucks she acts like shes gay from singing i kissed a girl and with all the fricken girls in it
TheGirlNextDoor111 2 years ago
katy's the original ??? or kelly's?
dianisAKO 2 years ago
Katy wrote it.
BroadwayMusicalFreak 2 years ago 2
i love this!
MR1happy1jason 2 years ago 2
eww im sorry but kellys is waaay better, although i still like katy
sarahdrew111 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
kelly clarkson ripped katy a new asshole with her version of this song.
greenwak 2 years ago
Comment removed
greenwak 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this sucks
INJJED 2 years ago
Kelly Clarkson the best!! ¬¬
kekeltho 2 years ago 2
wow what happened??this isnt good at all
mollopollo1 2 years ago
this sounds terrible to kellys version!!!
xxlolly91 2 years ago 4
Kelly's poos all over this version.
randomtom99 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I like tis more than Kelly's!
NaturelyPlaceOfPeace 2 years ago