02. Piggy - "The Downward Spiral : Live" presented by ThisOneIsOnUs & The NIN Hotline

[jockner1]

god i really hope they tour again i havent got a chance to see them live):

[nimatek667]

love the decadence of TDS so much

[Mantooth901]

NOTHING CAN STOP ME NOW, NOTHING. CAN STOP. ME.

[Shapiro216]

Ilan Rubin absolutely butchered that drum solo. I have never hated a musician more for a single act in my entire life.

[tguipi]

Shame on me I discovered NIN way too late to see them live :(

[Deathcorpler]

@tguipi

me too...

all we can do is to hope trent reforms and lets hell upon us.

i would fucking give my liver or my kidney just to see him.

i think i'm getting obsessed with his music.

[mzprezisballin10]

@Deathcorpler you can't help but to get obsessed with nine inch nails. Trent's amazingly talented.

[Mantooth901]

@tguipi DUDE

me too. But its not my fault that he started to make music before I was even born

[whatthefucktheodore]

i love how the crowd screams "hey motherfucking pig"

[ac1dchr15t]

MANNNN......Perfect...fucking live album to EVER do.

[NanaPharcyde]

It's quite an achievement when a live version of a song has more atmosphere than it does on the album... and that's saying somthing!

[bradtwo]

Even though I know there is an entire DigiDesign/Avid Venue backend system going on behind it, I still love how stripped down it feels.

[DaTechnicalOne]

Wow thank you so much!

[savourelerouge]

J'adore!!!!

<3<3<3<3<3

[thepenguin55]

Great performance, though I'm not sure if I've ever seen a bad performance of this song. NIN always knocks this song out of the park. The only real difference between most performances of Piggy is how the drums are played at the end of the song. To this end, I'd say this drummer and Josh Freese did a much better job playing this song than either Chris Vrenna or Jerome Dillian.

[nexsolost]

Hey guys, the torrent of this concert live on 720p doesn't work. Can anybody give me a link for downloading this?

[pintozazz]

Man, sucks not to have been there.

I saw them at their last Wave Goodbye tour show in West Palm Beach.

Still got the ticket stub.

Amazing.

[Ervine4]

Just found this... too young to ever see them when they where touring... THANK YOU so much for uploading!

[ISuckAtSpanish]

omfgg thank you for postin this...its just INSANE

[Malin242]

guitar kills

[mortcasinomort]

wowie wow wowie wow...... wow !!!!

[nathanel1313]

I think this performance of Piggy is even better than one from AATCHB. Drummer + Robin = OMG!

[L2Ikar0]

increible

[Basisforstace]

Reminds me of the HammerJacks show in 94?? Trent Reznor is still the best artist i have ever seen live- Hi is the greatest songwriter to ever live...

[k1171502]

Fans should not be allowed to film in concerts. They should be charged high fees if they wish to do so.

[williammurderfacex3]

um, NIN wanted them to. webster hall wasnt going to allow NIN to record, so NIN allowed an open recording whatever its called.

this was entirely fans at the concert who met after the concert and compiled everything that was recorded.

enjoy it, douche.

[k1171502]

:I I 'm joking kermit the frog. Jesus loves your penis. So calm down.

[mogiczar]

@williammurderfacex3

Yup

You're my hero on this comment list =]

Go fuck yourself k1171502

The thing is...

NiN Puts fans over money any day, hence the free albumb =]

[lamalamacocowheats]

i sang this once in a kareoke bar in seoul. they interrupted us to serve us ice cream. :p gooood tiiiiimes

[PunkMartyr]

NOTHING

can

stop

ME

[lotoreo]

I love the way that throughout the song the crowd sings along

[xpalad1n]

Seeing this made me a fan of Ilan immediately. Nothing against Josh Freese, but Ilan absolutely *owned* the drum solo here.

[hatfisc]

Im just glad he stopped hitting himself over the head with the microphone. He used to rant on about politics after doing that in the past.

[KradProductions]

Trent on politics? Not at a show, I wouldn't think.

[mawhar]

I'm pretty sure Reznor has the best attitude now out of any musician. Performing a show like this, encouraging fans to record and make their own DVD, and we get THIS. Hell yes.

[manakerito]

Why did my comment get marked down? I was merely responding to someones elses comment on recording things at concerts, jesus some people.

[holehole123]

i got goosebumps during this song...and everyother song

[ReznorRules420]

1:25-1:40, so much emotion, such a sense of betrayal

[bullsfan93]

3:22 TO 4:51 FUCKING AMAZING!!!

[pablodonosoc]

I was searching for some videos of this EPIC concert and found this, right now i'm like HOLY SHIT!.

Thanks to all the people involved in this project, it's one of the greatest things that i've ever found on the internet.

I'm downloading the DVD right now.

Thanks AGAIN!

[lendude1]

WOW!! Ilan's solo is just so legendary, i ddnt even notice Robin's fucking bad-ass solo!! lol!

[GamerConor]

Holy Fuck Drums!!!!!!

[markiepoos]

Just WOW! :|

[ERASETHEFUTURENOW]

The Downward Spiral has got to be one of the best rock albums ever... getting a taste of what it is like live is fucking great. Thanks to all involved.

[kang568]

its actually rated one of the best albums by rolling stones magazine. I think between 30-40 on the top 100 albums of all time

[ReznorRules420]

dude, its rated number 200 out of 500, not the same, but still, hell of an honor

[hurly000]

Wow, Thanks to everyone who did this.

[h3r35j0nnY]

See, this is why I love the NIN community. And NIN in general. Ridiculously kick-ass editing and project... everything. Thanks.

[digitalwasabi2]

THAT IS AMAZING!!!!!!! Great work. VERY impressive.

[LCouto87]

A really big thanks to all the fans who contributed to this DVD =)

the rest of the world appreciates! =)

[bobinchainz]

question.....did the people who attended the show know it was going to be all downward spiral?

[ThisOneIsOnUs]

Nope. Nobody knew.

[TheNineinchsnails]

@ThisOneIsOnUs thats fucken awesome lol

[cmk61478]

No...but that was such a great album I don't think anyone cared.

[NCSamurai]

@bobinchainz Listen to Heresy, you hear a guy in the crowd yell: "Is he playing the whole album?!"

[eddeetoy]

This keeps getting better every time I watch. Per Scope: "Of all the fans out there, Nine Inch Nails fans may be, if not most, at least one of the most devoted." Here it is proved again!

[minkuce]

To guys who filmed/edited this whole thing: YOU FUCKING ROCK! Thank you!!! :)

[TrevortIn]

Drummer's a beast.

[gyrk111]

The dude drumming was aparently young as shit and had to learn 80 songs for the tour. he filled it in other words. Fuckin amazing that somebody could learn that much material and it be NINE INCH NAILS for fuck sake... GRATS drummer dude! /bow

[churchy99]

The drummer is called Ilan Rubin. My brother's a drummer and told me about him saying that he's extremely talented. Saw him in other bands and he is amazing, so when Trent announced he was joining NIN I knew the tour was going to be something special and that Trent still has a great eye for muscians. hes 21 I think and he rocks!

[churchy99]

From what I understand he performed at woodstock at the age of 11

[gctones]

So they did the whole cd in one set? like no other songs after this?

[brejo57]

No, they played another 10 songs I believe. Not 100 percent on the number, but I know they played more.

[mlkjhgfds]

ofcourse they played more. at Wave Goodbye shows between 25 and 38 each show

[brayshizzle]

pretty sure there was like 14/15 songs play, downward spiral the a few others afterwards. not sure of the number

[jrquilty]

yeah Redzombie Tool is fucking amazing, saw em back in 2002 with Meshuggah and they were a real good metal band from Sweden and I'm not that big of a metal fan their drummer Hakke "spelling" fucking amazing.

[1ertia]

HELL YEAH!

[switchdogdotorg]

HAIL TO ROBIN FINCK!!

[brainysod]

Fucking hell - Ilan was amazing!

[JordanTheBeast]

drums were fuckin amazing

[rensq]

awesome collection of vids and well cut and great audio. thats why bands should let fans record shows. only bands imo that deny recorders generally sound like suck live and therefore dont want others to see it. good bands have no problem with people recording stuff. metallica should learn a lesson from reznor. metallica always sound good, so let people record and share it. only helps them in the end...

[vjex14]

boo on the metallica.....one of those bands on a list like areosmith.... and the rolling stones.. that i am suprised they are not dead yet... and i hope michael jackson gets a few friends for xmas. lets count the "yeah"s from metallica... oh wait i dont think we have enough time in my life time to count them all. learn a new word... but yes i do agree on fans recording... but some bands fans are just so shitty or just shitting their pants, cough rolling stones.... that its not worth the effort.

[rensq]

whatever. isn't reznor is older than metallca? hahaha. i only used metallica as an example because they've been so outspoken about sharing.

[dk2853]

Metallica was around about 6 years before Reznor's first record

[Mitsukiu]

Priceless <3 thank you so much :D

[IIdolizeDavidCook]

THANK YOU THANK YOU !

[Subliminallll]

NIN raise the bar once again without having to be all glam and mainstream!

[mstngo]

Awesome work! I was there and this is a great way to relive my last nin concert.

[fbfiveohv3]

what's the band's line up? is that Robin Finck? or did that dude do his hair like Robin Finck?

[Toolnay]

the tags list the lineup!

[BFMBomb]

trent, of course, Robin Finck, Justin Meldal-Johnsen, and Ilan rubin

[fbfiveohv3]

thanks, man. having robin in there makes this 20% more bad ass. i'm so stoked about this project.

[SpookyDS]

This is fucking awesome, thank you

[natotsukino]

great! thanks again, and forever and ever!

:-D

[simonenicholas]

Loving this, can't wait for the whole thing!!

[xscrimshotx]

Very excellent job with this. Ilan's drumming is insane.

[ruttiger711]

Just wait till "the becoming" the released teaser was the highkight of the show for me

[voidnz]

Ilan Rubin. Nice one! Great video

[mtlns]

Amazing job! Congratulations!!!

[JackieMantle]

the GREAT Trent Reznor!!!!!!!!!!Trent reznor the GREAT!!!

[ThisOneIsOnUs]

As of right now : it is still processing. Shouldn't be too long.

[Rosstacular]

Thank you guys so much.

[StaticPallour]

I WISH I could have been there. Seriosuly. This is wonderful, ya'll rock.

[thekskill]

Loving these.... this was the best show I've ever been to and the videos are doing it justice!! Thanks again for all the work it took to put this together.

[Albarai]

I didn't thik I'd ever say this, but this is something that I can finally compare to the incredible AATCHB version... Hands down, the best fan project created so far.

[emmelineishot]

comeonee number threeee!!!aghhg nin monster!!

[shelterslullabies]

Video is still processing.

[plusvsminuscom]

dude it hasn't even out out for more than a day, youtube is most likely still processing all of that

[superfundeathhammer]

Pretty fucking impressive.

[dante666diaz]

Ah, cant wait for the torrent.

[monkgotgroove]

Thanks to everyone who filmed & put this together - what an amazing show - the dream set! So gald to be able to see it!

[rasqash]

Awesome Clip. I envy anyone who got to see this live

[dillonamburgey]

Wow nice!