Added: 4 years ago
From: jamesdpdrury
Views: 127,007
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (296)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • His voice makes me cry...

  • I'll do my best, what else can I do? Since I wasn't born perfect like Dad or you.

  • I agree, fabulous, and a lot of it is that orchestration is not trying to drown him out and you can hear every perfect note perfectly!

  • Clay can really make me cry. What a wonderful song and singer as well

  • SO AMAZING

  • his voice is amazing. I try to be the best singer I can be, and watching him just amazes me that people out there have voices like that.

  • Beautiful song!!! and perfect artist to perform it!

  • I've never really been a Clay fan, but this is a beautiful song. He does it quite well.

    He was originally cast to play Flynn in Rapunzel, but was replaced.. kind of hope he eventually lands the role. I think he'd fit the Disney cast perfectly.

  • i love the innocence he puts into this song by the way he shapes his phrases. Love his voice. I would kill to have a control like his !!!! 

  • his teeth are reeeeeeally white! Anyway, the song is really beautiful

  • John Barrowman sings it better.

  • @Claramata -shakes fist- BARROWMAAANNNN!!

  • Clay is so wonderful!!

  • my boy shared this link with me on facebook ... as if I wasn't proud enough! A beautiful song

  • This song lives on. Just came home from the stage version of Aladdin at the 5th Ave. Theater in Seattle. This song is by far the best in the show.

  • wish this version had been on the cd instead of alan menken's singing :S credit to him for an amazing soundtrack though. awesome composer

  • Clay needs to voice a Disney character ASAP. He would be perfect for it!

  • @trentmcjiivers You have a point. I think you're right. He'd make a perfect Disney character's singing voice.

  • @trentmcjiivers i agree with you :)

  • 6 women aren't proud of their boys.

  • HE SOUNDS GREAT LIVE AND ON CD HE SOUNDS THE EXACT SAME WAY ON CD AND LIVE NOW THAT IS A REAL AND GOOD SINGER

  • I LOVE HOW CLAY AIKEN SINGS IT IT IS THE BEST VERSION OF THIS SONG EVER!! I LOVE HIS VOICE TOO!!

  • Sing the last 4 notes of Proud of Your Boy and the last 4 notes of Part of Your World. Sound familiar? It's so Menken. But Damn, this song and Clay Aiken's voice are made for each other. Perfection.

  • @AsiaMs They are different notes though...but maybe you're thinking of "Somewhere that's green" and "part of your world" where Menken repeated himself?

    And yes Clay Aiken's voice is that of a completely natural singer, and while his voice sounds fantastic here I really prefer alan menkens demo of the song, purely from a song standpoint. To me it sounds like Clay is just smiling throughout, missing the feeling, the emotion and thus the intention of the song.

  • Happy Mother's Day

    \

  • Darren Criss NEEDS to do this song

  • I wish this was in the movie. But the story about how it isn't is quite sad. But I love it.

  • this song brings tears to my eyes. it makes me think back on my mistakes and think I may just be able to fix them....

  • beautiful voice

  • So passionate and beautiful.

  • My goodness, Clay Aiken is versatile. I stumble upon this video every once in a while and marvel at his abilities.

  • Beautiful song sung by an extraordinary singer! Love this!

  • I must say this beautiful song has to be in my top 5 when it comes to the disney songs. Reason: Wonderful lyrics, extraordinary back music, The perfect voice and the song sounds so passionate and you feel so sorry for this boy. Well this makes me hear it over and over more than most Disney songs. Its so sad they cut it out of the film, but I understand they changed the story.

  • I wish they could've made an extended version of the movie with this song in it, like they did with Beauty and the Beast and Pocahontas.

  • @teruel82 The story was changed after this song was written so it doesn't fit with the story anymore. I too would love to see it in the movie, but there's really no place to put it.

  • I just wish they did it a HAIR slower. Everything else is so fabulous!!! :O

  • Gorgeous song. I just can't stop listening to it.

  • They are preparing (1-11-11) to put Aladdin on the Broadway stage, and are talking about the casting. If they are going to include the mother plot (which was not done in the film) I think Clay Aiken should be seriously considered for the Aladdin part. His is the voice I now hear when I watch Aladdin. Perfect for his second Broadway hit.

  • @oldladybug Isn't he a bit old?

  • They are preparing (1-11-11) to put Aladdin on the Broadway stage, and are talking about the casting. If they are going to include the monther plot (which was not done in the film) I think Clay Aiken should be seriously considered for the Aladdin part. His is the voice I now hear when I watch Aladdin. Perfect for his second Broadway hit.

  • I'd like to hear brad kane sing this...

  • @emzie189 just imagine...if it sounds this great when clay aiken sings it...how it would sound if brad kane sang it!!! :O :D

  • that would be amazing..

  • Comment removed

  • D Major :) Awesome Key.

  • I wish music hadn't strayed so far from this; a singer with an amazing voice and a beautiful orchestra behind him. You can see him getting lost in the music; everything about this is beautiful.

  • Very very beautiful...

  • I sang this song and put it on my YouTube profile, please check it out and give it a listen --- IF you'd like, of course! Thanks in advance for any listens =)

  • I love Clay singing this song, I could listen to it over and over again :)

  • It's a shame they didn't use this beautiful song in the movie.

  • why dose he close his eyes

  • @DeathByChocolate1995

    because he's lost in the music. happens to musicians all the time. well, generally for less hip-hopish songs and usually slower songs like this.

  • Conleth Kane tried really hard to sing this, and he did ok, but he is simply not in Clay Aiken's league vocally. He needs more stage appeal too. Clay could sing for Disney all day long, and he did a great job in Phineus and Ferb too. That voice is just stellar.

  • makes the hairs on my arm stand up cos its just such a wonderful song and he sings it so beautifully...

  • wow love it :)

  • ..Part of yourrrrrrrrrrrr worrrrrrrrrld.

  • I did a cover of this song and would love to get some honest feedback on it! It's on my profile (also a video response here) if anyone is interested, please check it out.. thanks in advance =)

  • I freaking love this song. I think it should have been in the movie. It gives me goose bumps when I hear it. Clay Aiken does a good job at it but the original song is also amazing.

  • i wish brad kane will sing this song

  • OOOH! he has such a good voice for emotion!

    I hoep he can sing some songs for disney

  • he has such a great voice.

  • A beautiful, tragic tribute to Howard Ashman's memory. He died before he could complete his work on Aladdin's mother, and this song is a reflection of his passion for what he did.

  • This needs to be back in the movie. Now.

  • At 0.44 it sounds very auto-tunesish to me!

  • @spursfan000 Yeah, it does.... :/

  • @BeLoudBeProud how? all i hear is vibrato.

  • @jongeneza There's that. But there's one part at 0:44 where it just has a kind of auto-tunish sound to me. I could easily be wrong, though. And I hope I am.

  • se la disney avesse insegnato a tutti i bambini che ciò che conta è rendere i propri genitori fieri di loro... che bel mondo ci avrebbe aspettato domani

  • Why did they have to cut it from the movie?????

  • still <3<3<3

  • I haven't seen this performance in such a long time. What a treat! A collaboration between Alan Menken and Clay is so long overdue.

  • In my fantasy world, this song made it into the final cut of Aladdin, along with "Humiliate the Boy" Ashman and Menken are/were awesome.

  • I wish they kept Aladdin's mother in the movie. :\

  • GUY, PLEASE CHECK OUT MY TV AUDITION OF PROUD OF YOUR BOY...

    Just search 'Conleth Kane Audition' xxx

  • This song makes me happy, and I can listen to it 100 times and never get sick of it.

  • WOW! Amazing voice!!

  • oh. my. gosh. just..omg! This song is amazing it makes me want to be a boy soo bad just to perform this. Clay Aiken's voice in this is perfect!!!

  • This makes me obscenely happy.

  • I love this song. SO much.

  • I just watched this last night on the Aladdin DVD...it made me cry, it's a beautiful song :')

  • this song is beautiful

  • Simply one of the most beautiful things I have ever heard.

  • GOD DAMN! I am in no way a fan of his but holy shit is his voice perfect for this song!! Just WOW!!

  • Terrific!

  • Breath taking. Beautiful lyrics and so emotional. I wish Mr Ashman would have been able to hear the completed song. Clay Aiken's voice is perfect for this, he felt this song. Kudos to Mr Menken and the whole team.

  • Absolutely breath taking voice. There is NOTHING he cannot sing well, and I hope Disney gives him a call again.

  • they shouldn't have taken this out!

  • I love this song. :-D

  • he is good:D

  • Does anyone know what key this is in?

  • I LOVE THIS SONG :D

  • How did this guy not win American Idol? Obvious talent discrepancy between him and Rueben. What voice control!

  • who the heck is rueben lol

  • @bendsen1 ikr!!

  • I love revisiting this. I hope Decca has captured the beauty of his voice the way Disney did here. I can see why Decca chose to go the orchestral route - to showcase "the voice". I am sure we will be pleasantly surprised with Clay's new cd this summer!!! I can hardly wait!

  • I like his voice!

  • I love this song, and Aiken's voice works totally in it :D

  • Comment removed

  • Such a lovely song .. I love it .. Just wish it was longer!!

  • Clay Aiken is an INCREDIBLE singer. I never really paid much attention to him because I never got the chance to well now I do and OMFG HES GREAT. And of course Alan Menken and Howard Ashman-- I always knew how great they were, I'm not surprised. ALADDIN ROCKS.

  • After listening to John Barrowman doing this, I was reluctant to hear this. I must say I am impressed though. Clay Aiken has a beautiful voice and I loved some of the things he did with the song, but it doesn't seem to flow like it should in some places. But all in all it was a magnificent song.

  • I relate to this song so much that I cry every time I listen to it.

    Alan Menken and Howard Ashman are/were just simply amazing.

  • Pocos conocen esta bella cancion... cada vez k la escucho pienso en mi mama a la cual amo muchisisisisimo... hermosa cancion sin lugar a dudas muy conmovedora... TE KELLLO VIEJITA¡¡¡¡

  • This song.....and Clay's gorgeous voice, make me smile. ^_^

  • what a wonderful song...

    such a shame it wasn't put in the movie (though i know why), it's still a nice song... :)

  • I LOVE this song so much. I wish they'd gotten Brad Kane to sing it, as I never much like Clay Aiken, but I'm just glad *some*one recorded it. Now I can go buy it on iTunes ;)

  • clay has a lovely voice. very sweet. he looks cute too. i shall have to move from Ireland to America to meet him

  • This song is so sweet!! Beautiful <3

  • YAY!!! an actual singer finally redid it!!! :D

  • wo!

  • He's amazing

  • There is simply nothing btter than an accomplished singer backed by a full orchestra-beautiful

  • @LFD254 Amen!

  • i love this song, yet brings painful memories

  • This song makes me want to cry sometimes.

    It honestly does.

    Clay was never my favorite American Idol, but this song really shows of his strong voice.

    Aladdin is my favorite Disney movie ever, and this is my favorite song!

  • Beautiful voice! I love Clay Aiken!

  • Beautiful. It moves me every time. I love this song

  • this is amazing if they ever made another aladdin this song should be in it

  • Absolutely amazing. He has one hell of a voice and with such feeling. He could make you believe he was really Aladdin singing to his mother!! Love Love Love it.

  • i luv this song. i wish they hadnt cut it frm the movie!!! :) its so emotional and amazing!! i luv it, clays amazing. <3

  • On the VCR tape this song is featured so it should be on the DVD.

  • It is!!!

  • Wow, Clay can really sing!

  • alen menkin and howard ashman are soooo talented ! l

    Love it !!

  • God I love you Clay! You were amazing..thanks for the wonderful times!!! Wow, 2004 2005 what a good time..

  • a very emotional and good song. Clay sings it with so many feelings.

  • This music video is the origional aladdin dvd movie

  • Clay is awesome.

  • Does anyone know if this video is actually on the DVD, in the special features or something? I'm gonna buy it and I'd like to know cos I'm a big fan :D

  • I do not think it is it only has the original one but,I'm sure that this track is on a Disney mania CD.I wish I could tell you more.

  • Thank you so much, I think I might buy it anyway though. :D

  • it ison a disneymania cd but i dont know which one

  • It's on Disneymania vol. 3, you can even get it on iTunes, but then you have to buy the whole album.-_-" Damn Album Only rules.

  • they should have put that in the movie

  • As much talent as this man has, he really should do more. A wonderful voice.

  • I miss Clay. I wish he made more tv appearances or came out with a new cd. It's time for one.

  • They should've kept this in one of the aladdin's or in the credits.

  • this is such a beautiful piece of music

  • why cant all boys have voices like Clay Aiken,Josh Groban and Brian D'Arcy James??

  • BEAUTIFUL!! I love this!!

  • that was just beautiful. Perfectly sung and with so much emotion.

  • His voice mesmerises me, just amazing

  • this is a cry for help. Clay wants his dad to accept him

  • oh, yes, that's exactly why the lyrics go "i wasn't born perfect, like dad or you." obviously, the lyrics are out to the character's mother (remember, this was cut from Aladdin).

  • i wasnt referring to the movie, but to Clay Aiken in general. So i'd appreciate it if you didn't try to make me look like a dumbass when im just commenting on this vid.

  • What a stunning performance. I felt the beautiful voice and innocence. Clay Aiken should be on Broadway.

  • He is.

    He is in Monty Python's Spamalot as Sir.Lancealot (I think thats who he plays)

  • Sir. Robin, I believe?

  • i like this song xD

  • i dont like him but i like this song

  • I LUV THIS SONG SOO MUCH I ALWAYS PLAY IT BAK especially the part at 1:19 i play over and over

  • im not a fan of him but i like this song. its catchy

  • Amazing!

  • Spectaculous

  • Howard Ashman and Alan Menkin - LEGENDS!

  • Exemplary lyrics Mr Ashman. What an honour to have worked with you. A life-changing experience.

  • not a huge fan of clay aiken but this song actually gave me goosebumps while listening. very good song

  • Howard Ashman, there will be none like you. *RIP*

  • And the movie would have not turn out as great as the movie Aladdin we all know today :(

    This song always makes me think twice makes me love my mama ever more :) I've wasted time that's true I've been bad that's true and now I regret every moment I made you cry mama I'm sorry if you read this forgive me.sorry pple don't mean to disturb you at all.