Thank you for recognizing HOTRS as the best of the season! I recently spent a lot of time making a list myself, it was top 25, but I'll just put down the top 10. 1. House of the Rising Sun 2. Paint It Black 3. Jealous Guy 4. A Change is Gonna Come 5. Give Me One Reason 6. Wicked Game 7. Me and Bobby McGee 8. Treat Her Like a Lady 9. The Scientist 10. Long as I Can See the Light
"Rhiannon" is my #16, but "Play With Fire" just barely missed out. For me Crystal and Siobhan dominated Season 9 and if I had limited their performances to 5 each or something she would have been in.
I put "Rhiannon" in the 17th spot, but "Play With Fire" just barely missed out. For me Siobhan and Crystal were season 9 and if I had limited their number of performances then she would have made it in.
@coolsims1234 I agree. Hallelujah is such a pre-made moment song on Idol. It was mediocre, and it would power the performance if he just left out the choir and kept it tender. But DeWyze was way too pitchy all the way through his Idol run. Crystal should have won. Too bad Siobhan last her steam towards the end (she deserved top 3 for being bold and brave though). =(
shukigkato 1 year ago
@shukigkato what does HOTRS stand for
i agree about crystal and siobyhan but is didi in your top 25
coolsims1234 1 year ago
@coolsims1234 "House of the Rising Sun" ;)
"Rhiannon" is my #16, but "Play With Fire" just barely missed out. For me Crystal and Siobhan dominated Season 9 and if I had limited their performances to 5 each or something she would have been in.
shukigkato 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@coolsims1234 "House of the Rising Sun" ;)
I put "Rhiannon" in the 17th spot, but "Play With Fire" just barely missed out. For me Siobhan and Crystal were season 9 and if I had limited their number of performances then she would have made it in.
shukigkato 1 year ago
Dewyze singing Hallauljah is not even on your list? By far the most memorable of the whole season.
sonofmabarker 1 year ago
@sonofmabarker didnt think that was a major performance i thought simple man was more of a moment for him that night.
coolsims1234 1 year ago
@coolsims1234 I agree. Hallelujah is such a pre-made moment song on Idol. It was mediocre, and it would power the performance if he just left out the choir and kept it tender. But DeWyze was way too pitchy all the way through his Idol run. Crystal should have won. Too bad Siobhan last her steam towards the end (she deserved top 3 for being bold and brave though). =(
Ikurun 1 year ago