it has been some time sinse i listented to this, I was raised listening to the great baritones of the past, Bonelli Thomas, Rufffo, Stracciari and of course Lawrence Tibbett, but the more I listen to this man the more I am compelled to include him among the great baritones of all time
Почему-то у меня создалось такое впечатление, что он просто открывает рот под запись. В определенных местах его артикуляция не совпадает с произносимыми словами, или запаздывает.
Absolutely outstanding! He is not a young man in this video but the voice sounds wonderful. These videos are so valuable because they give us a clue how these great singers negotiated their entire ranges. The 'oooo' sound on the A flat is amazing and done with a small open mouth. How native Russian speakers can vocalize so strongly on the 'oooo' is astounding.
im am usually unimpressed by many singers who are concidered outstanding by many listeners, critics etc. but without hesitation, i call this man great.
Who was the author of this terrible Russian translation, I wonder? Why translating operas into Russian in general takes so little effort to the people in charge?! Russian is my mother tongue, but I can't recall a single aria worth the name of a "translation". That's sad.
I completely disagree. 1. Translations in general aren't the same as the originals, and I, for one, have a lot of complaints about translations *from* Russian (eg check out English "Mozart and Salieri" on YouTube - yikes!) 2. This particular translation is quite good: don't forget that the text wasn't exactly a masterpiece of poetry in Italian, either) 3. Whatever your opinion about the style and grammar might be, nothing gets in the way of the beautiful interpretation by Lisitsian.
Well, the matter that the original was not a masterpiece of poetry is exactly the reason for calling this translation an unsuccessful one:)Because the translator tried intentionally to make a masterpiece of his/her translation, and was sadly awkward at it. The transaltion must be adequate to the original, that is, produce the same effect by means of similar techniques...
...But here we have an intentionally naive, simple-hearted, and thus very sincere original text (it is not a even a verse - just the words a poor uneducated street actor could utter) - and an unbearably high-flown, cold, I would say, abstract oration-translation.
Darn--I always felt Warren owned this aria. Now I'm leaning towards Lisitsian. Never heard him before. What a voice, technique, mastery of phrasing!. More Pavel!!
When I first heard hun in a aria from Nero, I was stunned . Where had this voice been? Unfortunately behing the Iron Curtain. Fortunately I own a Cd where is the only artist.
An incredible artist. The "rapid" vibrato is FREEDOM! He is singing on the breath, which gives his voice ping, carrying power and beauty.
vpo2g2 1 month ago
He sounds almost tenor. The highs aren't as dramatic as Warren but definitely has an amazing voice.
gallantentry 6 months ago
it has been some time sinse i listented to this, I was raised listening to the great baritones of the past, Bonelli Thomas, Rufffo, Stracciari and of course Lawrence Tibbett, but the more I listen to this man the more I am compelled to include him among the great baritones of all time
operalament 9 months ago
Лисициан просто потрясающий!
Почему-то у меня создалось такое впечатление, что он просто открывает рот под запись. В определенных местах его артикуляция не совпадает с произносимыми словами, или запаздывает.
germonbast 1 year ago
Great Armenian baritone. i miss you.
joejoe4812 1 year ago
@joejoe4812 Russian barytone )
moguchiy 1 year ago
@moguchiy He's Armenian by birth.
joejoe4812 1 year ago
One of my favorites!
TheVerdiBaritone 1 year ago
Is it a playback thing or do all of these russian singers have such rapid vibratti? See Koslovski or Lemeshev for other examples.
mdgaultney 1 year ago
great voice! Bravo
DMGIT 1 year ago
The most beautiful baritone voice.
Herur22 1 year ago
Can somebody share this libretto in Russian... or at least this aria's one?
gomongio 1 year ago
Absolutely outstanding! He is not a young man in this video but the voice sounds wonderful. These videos are so valuable because they give us a clue how these great singers negotiated their entire ranges. The 'oooo' sound on the A flat is amazing and done with a small open mouth. How native Russian speakers can vocalize so strongly on the 'oooo' is astounding.
lemeshev 1 year ago
beautiful voice....certanly deserves more recognition
aliceSAURUS1 1 year ago
The best Russian-Armenian baritone of all time
DiverdiMusic 2 years ago
What language is this being performed in?
TheLOLrus12 2 years ago
Russian
Onegin65 2 years ago
@TheLOLrus12 Russian.
MyNatalie31 3 months ago
Sensational inded! Bravo maestro! T Y.
paulostroff99 2 years ago 2
G-R-E-A-T !
THANK YOU!
CurzonRoad 2 years ago 2
O my god, he's such a gorgeous artist. What a delicious voice. So viscerally and emotionally satisfying. Unmistakable timbre.
Thanks a lot.
vstasov 2 years ago 6
im am usually unimpressed by many singers who are concidered outstanding by many listeners, critics etc. but without hesitation, i call this man great.
operalament 2 years ago 4
Wauw what a great singer, the warmth in his voice!!
wauw, i am big tenor fan, but wauw
kfalahi 2 years ago 2
He's got a very similar timbre to Bjorling...as if he's a baritone version of him.
leadoffeohippus 2 years ago 2
@leadoffeohippus I was going to write the exact same thing then I saw your comment.
Gille2416 1 year ago
bravo, bravo!!!
coreTenore 2 years ago
The singing of Pavel Lisitsian is so effortless and exquisite that it is a marvel.
He is also singing with heart and passion and a magnificent warmth.
He is in many senses unsurpassed.
klokheten 2 years ago
thank onegin for posting this great artist..
alber6161 3 years ago 2
It was an answer for bulbataras)
JulietteDruet 3 years ago
Fantastic singing. But according to my pitch pipe, the recording is about a half-tone high.
CarlJFehlandt 3 years ago 2
Здорово!!!
Karamelyshka 3 years ago
Who was the author of this terrible Russian translation, I wonder? Why translating operas into Russian in general takes so little effort to the people in charge?! Russian is my mother tongue, but I can't recall a single aria worth the name of a "translation". That's sad.
JulietteDruet 3 years ago
I completely disagree. 1. Translations in general aren't the same as the originals, and I, for one, have a lot of complaints about translations *from* Russian (eg check out English "Mozart and Salieri" on YouTube - yikes!) 2. This particular translation is quite good: don't forget that the text wasn't exactly a masterpiece of poetry in Italian, either) 3. Whatever your opinion about the style and grammar might be, nothing gets in the way of the beautiful interpretation by Lisitsian.
bulbataras 3 years ago
Well, the matter that the original was not a masterpiece of poetry is exactly the reason for calling this translation an unsuccessful one:)Because the translator tried intentionally to make a masterpiece of his/her translation, and was sadly awkward at it. The transaltion must be adequate to the original, that is, produce the same effect by means of similar techniques...
JulietteDruet 3 years ago
...But here we have an intentionally naive, simple-hearted, and thus very sincere original text (it is not a even a verse - just the words a poor uneducated street actor could utter) - and an unbearably high-flown, cold, I would say, abstract oration-translation.
JulietteDruet 3 years ago
Élégance et noblesse au service du vérisme;
extraordinaire, il me rapelle le grand Carlo Tagliabue.
jacquesurlus 3 years ago
And what a voice for a 63 year old.
kgus123 3 years ago
I had completely forgotten about this great singer -- haven't herad him in over twenty years. Thank you.
kgus123 3 years ago
Perfect singing, but why did he have to sing it in Russian?
Moffolover 4 years ago
Why not, Moffolover?
canzonettasullaria 3 years ago
Well, why not, as it's technically perfect. :)
Moffolover 2 years ago
Darn--I always felt Warren owned this aria. Now I'm leaning towards Lisitsian. Never heard him before. What a voice, technique, mastery of phrasing!. More Pavel!!
greenstboy 4 years ago
Have a look at Gobbi too. There's a couple of his versions of this on here. Both fantastic singers.
rm946 3 years ago
And don't forget the superb recordings of the aria by Battistini and Amato.
meltzerboy 2 years ago
When I first heard hun in a aria from Nero, I was stunned . Where had this voice been? Unfortunately behing the Iron Curtain. Fortunately I own a Cd where is the only artist.
63Attila 4 years ago
A great voice, fabulous technique, elegant phrasing -- an artist.
vpo2g2 4 years ago 2
What a powerhouse!
hufarted 4 years ago
it is not surprising that many people rate him as the finest baritone ever
clewis2666 4 years ago 2
Великолепно!!! Браво!
kerri78 4 years ago
wspaniały głos wspaniała technika i wspaniały człowiek
kordian13 4 years ago
Wow, gobsmacked!
Glenmed 4 years ago
Unbelievable!
paulostroff99 4 years ago
Such a gorgeous voice which I've admired for a long time. He's much better suited for Silvio than Tonio, but always a treat to hear him.
izar1234 4 years ago
More Lisitsian! Specifically his Ja vas ljublju!
DragTas 4 years ago