Pink Floyd's Comfortably Numb ( ??? ) Jam.

[PearlProject8D]

ITS DREAM THEATER

[kircof19]

Is Tool...

[kircof19]

Is Tool...

[nfgmusic]

it's not Eddie Vedder at all!

[giga0524]

@nfgmusic you can say that again. Question is 'who is it'?

[sicva67]

i think this is roger waters solo

[THeBEEtleNAMEdGEORGe]

@sicva67 no its pearl jam read the title.

[Seiyanashi]

It may not have the magic of Pink Floyd behind it, but I really don't mind this version of the song. It's actually pretty good; better than most covers I've seen, anyway.

Dammit, I can't wait to see Waters at Scotiabank Place this coming October!

[Jorrit1992]

This is most certainly not Eddie Vedder (lead singer Pearl Jam)

[DizzeBR]

pink floyd not pj

[lightfall]

I love the solo. I loved the original solo on The Wall, and McCready's take was faithful to Gilmour's original, and even built on it by adding some great runs. I love this version.

[machinefuckinghead86]

its pearljam you clueless tit

[triangle910]

we new it all along. but  just to make it misteriuos so that people will keep on commenting.

[magickjac]

@machinefuckinghead86

Okay...this is not Pearl Jam...nor does anything about it even sound close to Pearl Jam. What it is, however, is somebody got a backing track to Comfortably Numb and is singing over it and playing the guitar solo. Trust me, there's a whole website that has these backing tracks with backup vocals and everything.

[AnotherLife101]

@magickjac

Lol, nice story. Im afraid you're still completely wrong. This isnt just some backin track, this version is played all over classic radio, and IS pearl jam, regardless of what your obviously very UN musical ear may be telling you. Learn your facts in future boy.

[magickjac]

@AnotherLife101

Okay dude, you're obviously...

a) a pathological liar OR

b) a douche bag

This is not played on "classic" radio...IS ABSOLUTELY, NO DOUBT, NOT PEARL JAM...

First of all...OPEN your fucking ears and listen to the singer. He has NOWHERE near the baritone that Eddie Vedder has. Second of all, I used to train people in Music Theory and have a fairly trained ear, thank you. Learn respectable grammar and pull your head out of your ass, you pathologically lying douche bag...

[AnotherLife101]

Okay sad little cunt, you're obviously..

a) an extremely hormonal little girl OR

b) a teenage boy whose still waitin for his balls to drop.

Dont try the grammar card with me either, one of the points of things like youtube is that you can be lazy with it. Also dont use lame yankee insults like douchebag on me as it does nothing but make burst out laughing

If you used to train people in music theory i feel desperately sorry for your students.

Lookin forward to your next girly reply mary.

[magickjac]

@AnotherLife101

Haha...Man, it sucks to be wrong, doesn't it? Now all you can do is resort to childish fallacies. BTW, I don't think I saw anything in the YouTube "terms and conditions" that said you can be an idiot when it comes to grammar...so, if you did then I'm sorry. Haha!

Stick to the facts, moron. You were wrong about this being Pearl Jam and then you tried to lie about it and say that you heard it on the radio.

You are pathetic, a liar, and an internet troll.

Enjoy mediocrity.

[AnotherLife101]

@magickjac

LMAO.

What really sucks is that I know with 100% certainly I'm considerably more intelligent than a condescending imbecil like you. I also know that my grammar is perfectly good if I want it to be....This being the reason your woeful attepmts to use it as an insult are nothing short of hilarious.

I'll stick to the facts. I've had as much fun as I'm going to making you pointlessly argue your point but I'm bored of you now.

This may be trollish (unlike me) but you're an idiot so...

[magickjac]

@AnotherLife101

Wow...MORE fallacies.

FYI, if you're going to try to insult somebody's intelligence by calling them a name like "imbecile" you should at least hit spell-check because it only proves your arrogant ignorance. You started with the condescending attitude- I just finished you off like the bitch you are. Haha, you KNOW your grammar is perfectly "good". Haha...Well, I guess they say, "ignorance is bliss" and it looks like you definitely enjoy wallowing in your own.

[AnotherLife101]

@magickjac

Finished me off??!! ROFLMAO....and you say I enjoy wallowing in my own ignorance. Lol.....Speaking of which, accidentally missing the "e" at the end of a word in no way proves "arrogant ignorance" and making that comment actually does nothing but highlight your own.

I also really don't understand what you find funny about me saying "I know my grammar is perfectly good IF I WANT IT TO BE"

Finished me off haha. Your so entertaining, I think I'm starting to like you LOL!!

[magickjac]

@AnotherLife101

You're really sad. Again, I feel bad for you. The best thing though is that everyone who comes here can read your comments and validify your idiocy for themselves. Please get a life.

Soo...WITHOUT you resorting to fallacies. Did you not lie about hearing this on "classic" radio? Did you not lie about knowing this was IN FACT Pearl Jam? Did you not attack me first? So...from the jump I had you pegged for what you are: a pathologically lying douche bag.

Cheers!

[AnotherLife101]

@magickjac

Get a life? Haha. That's a first class lesson in hypocricy my friend, not that I would expect anything else from someone like you.

The fact is, anyone with even a modicum of intelligence will not be looking at this and thinking of me as an idiot but I don't expect you to see why.

Don't worry, I've had you pegged from the beginning as well and the more this goes on, the more sure I am. So please, keep commenting! LOL

[magickjac]

@AnotherLife101

All you use to argue with are fallacies...you never answered any of the aforementioned questions. Instead, you try to dissuade the conversation into baby banter. You lost this one a long time ago...

Your defense-mechanisms are showing quite clearly. I recommend you take my original advice and "get a life".

Liar.

[Arrowman7827]

This is absolutely not David Gilmour or Pink Floyd. Listen carefully, I only say it once.

[triangle910]

arrowman u are right. anybody, find out who's the performer if its not PF or PJ who are they.

[BobTheTwit]

does it matter? this recording is GREAT!

it is also Tool, BTO, Cat Stevens, Jewl, Sting, Pearl Jam, Pink floyd

[b1u3z]

this is pink floyd not pearl jam

[GenniLombarda]

When I say that the solo is too static, I'm not criticizing the great McCready. The solo is clearly a tribute to the great Gilmour.

[hxcmetalhead]

this isn't pearl jam. it's pink floyd. you assfucks.

[GenniLombarda]

First, the lead singer sings everything, including the theme ('Hello, hello, hello, is there anybody in there?), which Gilmour NEVER does.

Second, I can't hear Gilmour's Cambridge accent.

Third, the solo is too static. In all the Floyd's version I have, there's more improvisation.

Fourth, can't you hear Vedder talking with the audience at the end of the track?

Conclusion: it's PEARL JAM

And, BTW, a bit more of courtesy makes the world a better place, mate.

[pipparogers]

Hi monkeybrains. Trust me, that vocal is not Dave Gilmour or Roger Waters. And I should know. As for the guitar solo, Gilmour pisses all over this version. So, less of your lip or I shall come over and sew your upper lip to your chin.

[icirum]

i prefer this version of it to the floyd but thats just me.

decent vid i suppose too though it doesnt really make any sence, but ya shoulda showed a wild wipe out where some one got messed where he says: just a little pin prick there'll be no more ahhhhhhhhhhhh.

hahaha woulda been funny as hell

[psychedelicfloyd]

good viddeoo exelent 5/5 good good good

master buddy and the music is perfect with the video congratulations...

[triangle910]

thanks. we just love pink floyd

[inkpixie]

this is mental, a legend covering a legend.

[triangle910]

pink floyd is idolise by pearl jam