are you experienced? Its nice , shes ok ....a little mononotanous & orchestrated but what kids these days aren't ..... was this for some talent show ? Kudos to the magnificient writer , Peter Gabriel blow your horn !!!!!!!!!
@pmerendi No. That's not auto tune. It's just her voice. Pretty sure someone like Sara Bereilles doesn't need or use autotune... live or in the studio.
I've been a mad Peter Gabriel fan for quite some years now and have really liked Sara for a while as well. It happens for me so rarely that two things I love in music come together and in such a brilliant way. I played it five times in a row before I could tare myself away. I’d like to see Sara do some Suzanne Vega as well.
I think almost everyone who does a cover to this song does a GREAT job....Sarah, Aaron Lewis (Exxxcellent!), Courtney Love, and actually Fred Durst did a great job too. Obviously nothing beats Peter Gabriel though. 5 Stars, 2 Thumbs Up, Standing Ovation, ROCK ON!!!
takes all the soul away. no peter gabriel doesnt have the great technical voice but he had conviction when he sang. plus all the african inspired music is way better than this
Sara Bareilles! She rocks! I love her. Wished she would share her story and allow people to connect their dots to her on Pocodot - (pocodot dot com) - she rocks. I hear Pocodot is the Facebook killer….
Sara Bareilles! She rocks! I love her. Wished she would share her story and allow people to connect their dots to her on Pocodot - (pocodot dot com) - she rocks. I hear Pocodot is the Facebook killer….
@sweetphenom6642 Because three-part structures are inherently more satisfying dramatically than two-part ones, i.e. she sings the verse melody three times, altering it each time and building to a climax that didn't really exist in Gabriel's original.
Truly amazing. For me, nothing can touch the original by Peter Gabriel. That having been said, there is NO DOUBT this version by Sara is breathtaking. She is, I think, one of the few truly talented female singer/songwriters out there today. At least in terms of mainstream music.
I don't think you guys understand with this song is about. I'm being serious. Not quite "there yet" what does that mean. This a great song. I don't undertand why it isn't there yet like what the heck!
boneheads. Wake up and stop comparing. You're probably the type of people who's constantly comparing themselves with other people. This song is fucking amazing-PG or this chick. Amen.
this makes it sound like a 'love-song' version. that's nice, but the PG version expands the lyrics beyond. especially the intro and outro he does in the live versions. its pure zen.
maybe im just used to peter gabriel doing his song...i prefer him...But, she has her own style and mixing it with Peter's song just doesnt do it for me..but this is my opinion so dont send hate comments..just being honest..
you can't really compare sara bareilles and peter gabriel, especially in regard to their voices. they simply prefer different styles of singing. anyway, i like this version and it's nice to hear a PG song from a modern "pop star".
p.s.: she has fewer problems with the high notes, or am i wrong ;)?
Well, I think THE most underrated female singer/songwriter in this country is Beth Neilsen Chapman.
BirdyinBOI 1 month ago
She sings this song as if it were written 4 her...
frost0813 3 months ago 2
Cool version and well done, She is good, and what a great Gabriel tune to do!!!!!!!
mymanbotis 3 months ago
are you experienced? Its nice , shes ok ....a little mononotanous & orchestrated but what kids these days aren't ..... was this for some talent show ? Kudos to the magnificient writer , Peter Gabriel blow your horn !!!!!!!!!
Treadlightlyful 3 months ago
i wish there wasn't any autotune on her voice. i think it kills some of the magic of a live performance, at least in this setting.
pmerendi 4 months ago
@pmerendi Pretty sure there isn't any auto tune here. Just her wonderful voice.
airbender0203 1 month ago
@airbender0203 start at 0:35; when she says "away," I'm pretty sure it's auto tuned. :/
pmerendi 1 month ago
@pmerendi No. That's not auto tune. It's just her voice. Pretty sure someone like Sara Bereilles doesn't need or use autotune... live or in the studio.
airbender0203 1 month ago
does anyone know if versions of this are available to purchse on i tunes?
jordannasierra 7 months ago
@jordannasierra I think there's an itunes live session w/her that features this song available.
askysoblue 6 months ago
I've been a mad Peter Gabriel fan for quite some years now and have really liked Sara for a while as well. It happens for me so rarely that two things I love in music come together and in such a brilliant way. I played it five times in a row before I could tare myself away. I’d like to see Sara do some Suzanne Vega as well.
Unitopia117 8 months ago
I think almost everyone who does a cover to this song does a GREAT job....Sarah, Aaron Lewis (Exxxcellent!), Courtney Love, and actually Fred Durst did a great job too. Obviously nothing beats Peter Gabriel though. 5 Stars, 2 Thumbs Up, Standing Ovation, ROCK ON!!!
patriots2185 8 months ago
God, how I love this girl! Her voice, her piano technique, her eyes, her mouth her evocative phrasing... I could listen forever.
nioc00 8 months ago in playlist 0 - Sara Bareilles - 0 3
takes all the soul away. no peter gabriel doesnt have the great technical voice but he had conviction when he sang. plus all the african inspired music is way better than this
joemoe23 1 year ago
not bad;))
kurvanoha666 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
to plain and... to simple... arrangement, vocals and keys. I don't get it. give her 10 or 20 or 30 years... maybe by then she will "get it"
bathetcnow 1 year ago
@bathetcnow I wonder if she understands the difference between "to" and "too" ? I bet she does "get that."
therealcommissioner 1 year ago 3
@bathetcnow Obviously, YOU don't get it. I give you 10 or 20 or 30 years, and maybe then you'll get it...
The "simplicity" is precisely what makes it so HAUNTING, and she uses it to build to a climax that, emotionally, surpasses Gabriel's original.
mysticsmb 10 months ago 4
@mysticsmb Agree completely. Good way of putting it. Some people need to open up their ears.
whatmusicsfor 9 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Sara Bareilles! She rocks! I love her. Wished she would share her story and allow people to connect their dots to her on Pocodot - (pocodot dot com) - she rocks. I hear Pocodot is the Facebook killer….
premarahman 1 year ago
Sara Bareilles! She rocks! I love her. Wished she would share her story and allow people to connect their dots to her on Pocodot - (pocodot dot com) - she rocks. I hear Pocodot is the Facebook killer….
premarahman 1 year ago
I dont understand why she repeats the first verse twice.
sweetphenom6642 1 year ago
Comment removed
mysticsmb 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@sweetphenom6642 Because three-part structures are inherently more satisfying dramatically than two-part ones, i.e. she sings the verse melody three times, altering it each time and building to a climax that didn't really exist in Gabriel's original.
mysticsmb 10 months ago
Truly amazing. For me, nothing can touch the original by Peter Gabriel. That having been said, there is NO DOUBT this version by Sara is breathtaking. She is, I think, one of the few truly talented female singer/songwriters out there today. At least in terms of mainstream music.
arbitrarynonsense 1 year ago 21
@arbitrarynonsense In that regard, check out Imogen Heap. She's the real deal.
TheColininla 5 months ago
have loved this version of this song ever since I bought her cd.
3rivergal 1 year ago
Amazing!
AlyssaInWonderland18 1 year ago
Such a haunting and beautiful song. I have heard so many cover this and Sara just blows me away with her voice. I so can't wait for the new album.
Rockzilla67 1 year ago
like her singing, but the rest of instrumental parts don't seem right.
tylerdurden1681 1 year ago
Marry me?
TruthSeeker10119 1 year ago 2
I don't understand whay you guys don't like this song. It's a great song. How come it isn't "there" yet. What's there? Like seriously...
1232TRK 1 year ago
I don't think you guys understand with this song is about. I'm being serious. Not quite "there yet" what does that mean. This a great song. I don't undertand why it isn't there yet like what the heck!
1232TRK 1 year ago
Not bad, I guess. It has potential, but not quite "there" yet.
PhantomOfTheMall 1 year ago
This is a great cover ...amazing....love her voice!!
Coquenao07 2 years ago
Great cover, and a great show for giving us these performances. Thanks for posting this!!!! Wow...it's a a great, faithful, but fresh song!
paxpaul 2 years ago
Amazing! Love her!
bullynation1 2 years ago
Great song!! What an amazing voice!
nanoc22 2 years ago
I think this is a pretty good song.
This version is kind of like a song in its 'own rights' as it has little resemblace to the original by Peter Gabriel. But I like it.
123ThisIsMe 2 years ago
nice job Sara!
I like where it picks up around 2:00, fun.
ben909ben 2 years ago
just thought I'd mention it...the percussion instrument the guy at the left of Sara is playing is a Peruvian "Cajon"...viva el Peru CARAJO!!!
Phletcher100 2 years ago
It is an amazing song. It all starts with the song. So got to give Peter Gabriel credit. Did he write this song?
tsanur 2 years ago
Yes he did. I like this "unplugged"-version too. but of course one one can reach the mood and deepness of this song like PG himself...
timonraphael 2 years ago
Cool!
korabon6362 2 years ago
bravo +7
deineiges 2 years ago
very nice version. She is definitely talented!
nicogi 2 years ago
boneheads. Wake up and stop comparing. You're probably the type of people who's constantly comparing themselves with other people. This song is fucking amazing-PG or this chick. Amen.
wordchief 2 years ago
this makes it sound like a 'love-song' version. that's nice, but the PG version expands the lyrics beyond. especially the intro and outro he does in the live versions. its pure zen.
mattability 2 years ago
I think this is a lot better than Gabriel's version. Sara's an amazing singer/pianist. She covers really well too.
ownmeucannot 2 years ago
LOL are you serious? This is okay but Gabriel's version is light years ahead of this
ViciousAlienKlown 2 years ago 4
zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
markjb1162 2 years ago
hmm I'm not in love with this. she's better on her own stuff.
caligirl2191 2 years ago
There's a depth to her voice, full of soul. Her range is impressive. I like it!
Rickerbyrd7 2 years ago 34
This comment has received too many negative votes show
peter gabriel's is better but this isn't as bad as i thought it would be.
jranner 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Jeffrey Gains version is best by far imo
fluttaby32 2 years ago
beautiful love you sara, hommage to peter and genesis...
amirhamra 2 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
oh no. i don't get it at all. she's taking away from the spirit of the song by dragging it this way.
td100 2 years ago
it gets good about 2 mins into it...
HBA215 3 years ago 2
does ANY1 have sheet music for THIS song!! the SARA version
missanime12 3 years ago 2
I like both versions. SB has her own style and it does sound beautiful and soulful here as well. Lovely.
Jenndeve 3 years ago
I agree
volamihary0623 2 years ago
peter gabriel. all the way.
ToniAqua 3 years ago
maybe im just used to peter gabriel doing his song...i prefer him...But, she has her own style and mixing it with Peter's song just doesnt do it for me..but this is my opinion so dont send hate comments..just being honest..
txiceprincess 3 years ago
i like this song......
123shania1234 3 years ago
this version looks So Sad = S, supposed to be a hAppy SonG
Ihsaahc 3 years ago 2
mm sad no, i think very personal and unique, i dont know her but she have a beauty voice.
morrosound 3 years ago
you can't really compare sara bareilles and peter gabriel, especially in regard to their voices. they simply prefer different styles of singing. anyway, i like this version and it's nice to hear a PG song from a modern "pop star".
p.s.: she has fewer problems with the high notes, or am i wrong ;)?
littledaved 3 years ago
I really like Sara Bareilles, but I think her voice doesnt really suit this song. There isn't enough emotion.
Awesomeosaurus91 3 years ago 2
I really like this version, but that's probably because i love her voice.
AnitatJ 3 years ago
its a cover...she can do whatever she wants with it...so why does it really matter...if you dont' like it there really is not need to comment on it
gino0224 3 years ago 2
I disagree with the comments. I find this very good.
bufangel 3 years ago
The instrumental part is very strong, But the vocal parts, annoy me especially at the end.
Peter gabriel wrote this very Out of the box
and this is to much in the box.
Compliments on how she looks, we can use some normallooking people in today's television.
Heuwmeuw 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
exactly, she is too controlled. I like her other stuff. But this is horrible...horrible
stolenminds 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wrong lyrics lady....
andreacasale 3 years ago
In her rendition she skips a line or two but the lyrics are correct.
TubeAddicts 3 years ago 8