I love the way all these critics are on here putting there penny's worth in..... please also upload yr rendition to be pulled apart by the wannabe critics up on here.... hey I think if you havent got anything nice to say ... then don't say anything at all....
The line ascending like curlining incense the the high B at 3:10 is so hypnotic. I remember hearing Gruberova for the first time doing this and it still knocks me out how she stretches up to the B and just floats. It may be cheating vocally, but so so beautiful.
@gustopheles to get techincal, she is sliding up to the high note, without vibrato. If she sang the interval up to the high note with vibrato that would have been a true portamento. OK, so its a minor point. The effect is still beautiful, but she slims down the high note by singing it "off" the breath and that is a kind of cheat. Minor quibble, and part of Gruberova's charm is she has her very own style and that tiny whistle tone is one of her calling cards.
Je suis assez stupéfait de sa bonne diction française malgré l'incompréhension du début du 2ème couplet : "Oû va la jeune indue" ou peut-être dit elle : "Oû va la jeune fille"! Dans le 1er couplet elle vocalise lié comme Callas! Ce qu'elle fait est assez brillant bien que le contre-mi final ne soit pas juste!!!
@ioSonoCallas "...et brave leur foureur!" Grubi inverse systématiquement le "u" et le "ou". Charmante curiosité.
Le mi conclusif est juste en queue de note (le portamento l'induit) . Votre comparaison avec Callas est étrange.
car Si la soprano slovaque est en "terre d'élection" (clarté, hauteur d'émission, aisance technique, style) la Divine est en difficulté" surtout en "live" (premier mi escamoté, piqués aproximatifs et vocalisation contrainte). Son art était ailleur je crois.
I love love LOVE how she approaches her E at the end!!! XDDD Not to fond about that vibrato on it though..But still! That E makes Natalie Dessay's sound so weak! Bravo Gruberova!! XD
Beloved Gruberova. For me one of the best Ou va la jeune Indoue I heard. She truly is the absolute and superior master of her voice. Everytime I hear and see hear singing tears come into my eyes.
the great gruberova.....I get seriously shocked everytime i hear her singing that final note xD she truly is worth of the name "the Geat Gruberova" *****
por qué siempre se desliza sobre una nota incorrecta para llegar a la nota correcta?
sachmetixchel 5 months ago
Her staccatos are just perfect! Pure resonance no pushing at all....She's a such a queen of technique!
rrgallo 7 months ago
Her staccatos are just perfect!
rrgallo 7 months ago
I love the way all these critics are on here putting there penny's worth in..... please also upload yr rendition to be pulled apart by the wannabe critics up on here.... hey I think if you havent got anything nice to say ... then don't say anything at all....
Great piece.... great upload .... Thankyou.....
nathalyone 7 months ago
PERFEITA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!11111
Marcelosopro 8 months ago
Perfection is the only word that can describe what Gruberova made in this video.
pedrofribeiro 8 months ago
The line ascending like curlining incense the the high B at 3:10 is so hypnotic. I remember hearing Gruberova for the first time doing this and it still knocks me out how she stretches up to the B and just floats. It may be cheating vocally, but so so beautiful.
tenorbear60 10 months ago 4
@tenorbear60 cheating because the portamento isn't written?
gustopheles 6 months ago
@gustopheles to get techincal, she is sliding up to the high note, without vibrato. If she sang the interval up to the high note with vibrato that would have been a true portamento. OK, so its a minor point. The effect is still beautiful, but she slims down the high note by singing it "off" the breath and that is a kind of cheat. Minor quibble, and part of Gruberova's charm is she has her very own style and that tiny whistle tone is one of her calling cards.
tenorbear60 6 months ago
@tenorbear60 That's incredibly interesting. I can't imagine the kind of insight you must have in music to have detected that sort of thing.
gustopheles 6 months ago
she goes out of tune by a microtone in her acapella vocalese/coloratura
Marmalade000000 11 months ago
Je suis assez stupéfait de sa bonne diction française malgré l'incompréhension du début du 2ème couplet : "Oû va la jeune indue" ou peut-être dit elle : "Oû va la jeune fille"! Dans le 1er couplet elle vocalise lié comme Callas! Ce qu'elle fait est assez brillant bien que le contre-mi final ne soit pas juste!!!
ioSonoCallas 1 year ago
@ioSonoCallas "...et brave leur foureur!" Grubi inverse systématiquement le "u" et le "ou". Charmante curiosité.
Le mi conclusif est juste en queue de note (le portamento l'induit) . Votre comparaison avec Callas est étrange.
car Si la soprano slovaque est en "terre d'élection" (clarté, hauteur d'émission, aisance technique, style) la Divine est en difficulté" surtout en "live" (premier mi escamoté, piqués aproximatifs et vocalisation contrainte). Son art était ailleur je crois.
BEVER29 1 year ago
7 people missed the like button... Again!
bananasgurl 1 year ago
that E was a tiny smidge below pitch
skitzo429 1 year ago
I love love LOVE how she approaches her E at the end!!! XDDD Not to fond about that vibrato on it though..But still! That E makes Natalie Dessay's sound so weak! Bravo Gruberova!! XD
kit11104 2 years ago 2
OMG!!!
faeydra 2 years ago
Perfect. The best ever. I have never heard anything as beautiful in my entire life. Thank you, Ms Gruberova.
Browneyedsnowflake 2 years ago 3
Beloved Gruberova. For me one of the best Ou va la jeune Indoue I heard. She truly is the absolute and superior master of her voice. Everytime I hear and see hear singing tears come into my eyes.
adeeo 2 years ago 3
holy high E at the end!
emilylengriffin 2 years ago 9
@emilylengriffin calantissimo!
MrMaxmorphing 6 months ago
No, no, e no!! Perché quell'orribile portamento in TUTTE le cadenze con sovracuto finale? Il peggior difetto della Gruberova.
Richarzh 2 years ago
@Richarzh Ho pensato esattamente la stessa cosa!
3F93 1 year ago
Perfect.
thx 4 postting
cuncinews 2 years ago
the great gruberova.....I get seriously shocked everytime i hear her singing that final note xD she truly is worth of the name "the Geat Gruberova" *****
killerbunny123123 2 years ago 6
Nice post! Thank you!
Rudziewicz 2 years ago
i really love it. it's gorgeous
masterka 2 years ago 4
Ou va la jeune indue !!!
French is not good
Peccato
Because the music and interpretation is perfect....!!!
ChrisPaulPf 2 years ago