Very good to my ears. I have just posted the same tune - the chord at 46 always feels awkward to me. You made it sound very musical rather than an exercise. Well done. Im subbing you for this as I play classical guitar too. Cheers
No emotion, this piece must be played Moderato con Espressivo and there are supposed to be a lot of interpretations in this piece. You are playing it in a monotone way.
sabes como tcar, pero desgraciadamente no le sabes dar el uso adecuado al estudio, primero investiga que es lo que estas estudiando y despues ponlo en practica, por que asi solo me da a entender que solo te aprendiste la partitura y no sabes ni siquiera que estas tocando. es un consejo de musico a musico, no me lo tomes a mal, te hara bien. creeme, suerte
Apoyando would mute the second string, so it doesnt seem like a good way to play it, maybe for technical purposes its alright since its a study and its really ugly anyways :)
Very well played, there is a lot of variations on the right hand you can try to develop technique, this is why I like the etude. There is Pima mama Pima imim Pima mima Pima cami Pima Pima Pima Pami ( this tremolo version along with im seems fastest ) Pima PiPi Pima PiPm Pima PmPi Try them out everyone, you will develop a strong right hand and nice job Joe, I really enjoy the clean playing !
Your playing is excellent, I think the best performance of this Etude on Youtube. I would follow the dynamic markings in the music a little more closely though, as your playing makes you out to be a bit of a typewriter...an excellent typewriter, don't get me wrong. LOL But a typewriter nonetheless.
Also interesting that you use "mama" for the repeated 16ths. That would make for a great exercise for those who use "mimi" (like me).
You're good! I can play 2 songs of Carcassi; study in A minor and Caprice in C. Don't know more about them than that.. I've played the classical guitar for 5 years. I'm gonna put some videos or audio tapings so that people can say what they think. Anyway, GREAT!
Try to play this study by skiping the repeated notes.I think that it will make it by far more interesting and an excellent practice to improve your left hand travelling along the neck.
Well i'm on Swedish language course. When i finish it then i have to start work IT crap like that , damn i don't wanna work but who's ganna play for my guitar strings ;)
No way i was IT , not anymore just i'm not so good on C++ but i was doing C on UNIX Shell net programing , Perl , Python too. I loved a lot Python ;-)
Thx Joe, this one sounds like song very melodic. Thx Joe this time i'm at school i don't drink schools coffee but after listening it i felt in my moth like i've drank good one with special flavor.
Finally, a musical performance of this piece. Nice work. I can tell by your technique that you've studied guitar. Are you a music major?
gear1152 1 month ago
Very good to my ears. I have just posted the same tune - the chord at 46 always feels awkward to me. You made it sound very musical rather than an exercise. Well done. Im subbing you for this as I play classical guitar too. Cheers
fieldfullofthistles 3 months ago
This is also a very beautiful piece when played Tremolo. I prefer it way more!
ahmed55555 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
4 people who have soul
JOCKATEO 11 months ago
Very nice
traverd 1 year ago
very good your video I know the fiare also the number 2 but not aussibien than you! ;-)
lauriedu93 1 year ago
4 guys missed the like button... I LIKE IT!!!
GNO1GNO 1 year ago
young man, you are an inspiration. you play beautifully and have a real future if you keep at it. Thanks so much for sharing!
roccop2 1 year ago
excellent
congratulations
esta chevere el video ya casi me lo aprendo
siga adelante
paisessuramericanos 1 year ago
No emotion, this piece must be played Moderato con Espressivo and there are supposed to be a lot of interpretations in this piece. You are playing it in a monotone way.
M34tgr1nd3r 1 year ago
Very smooth playing--a joy to hear.
singbaileybird 1 year ago
sabes como tcar, pero desgraciadamente no le sabes dar el uso adecuado al estudio, primero investiga que es lo que estas estudiando y despues ponlo en practica, por que asi solo me da a entender que solo te aprendiste la partitura y no sabes ni siquiera que estas tocando. es un consejo de musico a musico, no me lo tomes a mal, te hara bien. creeme, suerte
skinderth 2 years ago
thanks Joe!! I'm learning a lot of Carcassi's 25 Etudes. Carcassi, Sor, Aguado, Carulli, etc. were the early masters!
keto6789 2 years ago
jajajaja estos estudios son inolvidables, no como los de Sor que son una tortura jajaja
oninotna16 3 years ago
y es que la verdad q aburre sor,prefiero carcassi!!
thespoykid 2 years ago
you're so very right man... so very right!
jordanviach 2 years ago
I quite like this piece I might have to try it
BeatriceBlake 3 years ago
Apoyando would mute the second string, so it doesnt seem like a good way to play it, maybe for technical purposes its alright since its a study and its really ugly anyways :)
AllegroVirtuoso 3 years ago
my flamenco teacher makes play the 16ths apoyando ... have u tried that?
chu71 3 years ago
AllegroVirtuoso 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Bondayjee 2 years ago
Comment removed
Bondayjee 2 years ago
Your playing is excellent, I think the best performance of this Etude on Youtube. I would follow the dynamic markings in the music a little more closely though, as your playing makes you out to be a bit of a typewriter...an excellent typewriter, don't get me wrong. LOL But a typewriter nonetheless.
Also interesting that you use "mama" for the repeated 16ths. That would make for a great exercise for those who use "mimi" (like me).
Work out those dynamics a bit, otherwise - bravo!
JapJackson 3 years ago
You're good! I can play 2 songs of Carcassi; study in A minor and Caprice in C. Don't know more about them than that.. I've played the classical guitar for 5 years. I'm gonna put some videos or audio tapings so that people can say what they think. Anyway, GREAT!
Elv1s93 4 years ago
Try to play this study by skiping the repeated notes.I think that it will make it by far more interesting and an excellent practice to improve your left hand travelling along the neck.
manicos1 4 years ago
Thanks for your tip. It's an interesting thought.
I was focusing on my right hand only and didn't pay attention to my left hand.
ClassicalJoeNo1 4 years ago
the repeated notes of each chord should be done in the following sequence:
a m i a m
Zupanssi 4 years ago
You're right. Check this out,
watch?v=X9uDRZ-eT8c
I would like to practice my weekest a-m combination.
ClassicalJoeNo1 4 years ago
sorry for my wrong spelling.
I mean a-m is my weakest combination. So it's good to practice and gain control of it.
ClassicalJoeNo1 4 years ago
no, its pima mama. also though with pima mimi and pima mima
m1letic 4 years ago
Well done! but, it's not a little fast?
My Best
Marcos
mom17565 4 years ago
IMO, it's an etude. 1st, play it whatever sounds good. 2nd, play it whatever speed I can control.
Thanks for comment.
ClassicalJoeNo1 4 years ago
Well i'm on Swedish language course. When i finish it then i have to start work IT crap like that , damn i don't wanna work but who's ganna play for my guitar strings ;)
Vidas666 4 years ago
I'm working on my English course. I don't want to work either. Damn, who's gonna pay for me nail polish sand paper:)
ClassicalJoeNo1 4 years ago
***LOL*** You are man of my type. I think same way like you ;-)))) See you around , cheers!
Vidas666 4 years ago
true! same type.
I'm learning C++ & JAVA. IT nuts:)
ClassicalJoeNo1 4 years ago
No way i was IT , not anymore just i'm not so good on C++ but i was doing C on UNIX Shell net programing , Perl , Python too. I loved a lot Python ;-)
Vidas666 4 years ago
Thx Joe, this one sounds like song very melodic. Thx Joe this time i'm at school i don't drink schools coffee but after listening it i felt in my moth like i've drank good one with special flavor.
Vidas666 4 years ago
Thanks for listening very morning.
I'm going to back to school next week. No more coffee mate later, lol...
ClassicalJoeNo1 4 years ago
You going to music school , don't you?
Vidas666 4 years ago
No, nothing to do with music. How about u?
Playing the guitar is my hobby.
ClassicalJoeNo1 4 years ago