Added: 4 years ago
From: guida91
Views: 113,339
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (296)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • iv met this girl at her concert in perth xxxx

  • @xoxkizziexox What was she like?!!

  • @TRISTAN029

    she has like the best american accent, and she was blonde at the time

    and yer she was pre kool (:

  • PEOPLE! THIS SONG WAS WRITTEN IN 2005!! Before Twilight was even out! She just put it on the record in 2007! Get over it! Twilight has nothing to do with this! Now stop flooding Kelly's songs with Twilight comments some people actually have a personal connection with these songs!!!

  • luv this song and twilight as much as everyone, but this song is NOT realated to twilight, kelly clarkson makes her own music and is her own artisit

  • WHO CARES ABOUT IF IT IS OR ISNT ABOUT TWILIGHT!!!! ITS A SONG!!!

  • this should of been in new moon

  • it's a kelly song not a twighlight song. people get your heads on straight the world dosen't revolve around twighlight.

  • you can't even spell it right it is Twilight

  • Okay, people, this is just stupid. Every song that is about someone leaving someone else is not about Twilight. I can appreciate that you find similarities between the two, but I find similarities between this song and my life, too, and I have no vampires in my life. Please stop saying 'this is a Twilight song'. Yes, it's similar to the NM angst, no it's not a Twilight song.

    Oh, and guida91, the song is wonderful but the blinking title completely drove me crazy. I think I have seizures now.

  • I`m a huge twilight fan(book wise, don`t plan on watching the movie). But enough already, aren`t you ppl tired of talking about it all the time!

  • i <3 kelly clarckson, im going through a phase with all her music, sober is another im loving. i always listen to her when i do my 50 push ups and 100 sit ups each night:) this song is my best push-up song:) sober is my sit up song:)

  • Woahh.. Is this what the stuff on ''My December'' is like.. I reallii fell in love with kelly clarkson when i heard like the 'Because of you' (or w.e its called) when I was younger and i stopped listening to her music shortly after, this is the first time i've listened to her in ages.. i gotta saii.. woahh shes cool

  • I have new respect for her.

  • Comment removed

  • I love song!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • omfg, THIS IS NOT ABOUT TWILIGHT!!! In fact, Twilight is a shitty film version of average books that spit in the face of horror tradition. GODDAMN VAMPIRES DON'T FUCKING SPARKLE!!!! The obsession has got to end. Why is as soon as they make a stupid movie out of it, its infinitely more popular. I have read the books, even enjoyed them, but the movie blew it all out of proportion and its fucking retarded. I

  • i think the reason why people are obsessed with the story because of the love.. the pure love.. n ppl are starved for true love... and the story portrays.. real love.. the kind thats for the company of another person not really what u can get out of them or the booty or the looks.. its about that person their soul.. n being with them forever.. as a society.. we dont really get that.. we get hate.. war.. and porn stars.. u cant blame ppl for wantin to believe n the thing we see the least.. .

  • It's not true love when Bella just falls for the nearest penis that walks by after Edward leaves. It's also not true love when all Edward has to do is be on the rag for one day and leave, and Bella believes him. Edward and Bella don't represent true love. Not by a mile.

    Why Twilight is so popular is because everybody is curious how a human can "do it" with a vampire without being eaten. It's sexual intrigue at its finest.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • actually ths is gna b in the new moon soundtrack! but i luv the soong

  • @rokdhotnez i luv u

  • @rokdhotnez Amen to that.

  • i luv this song it reminds me of when my bf left me n it reminds me of when edward leaves bella.i can feel bellas pain 4 it happend 2 me 2.

  • I am going to play this song while reading new moon.

    I guess I am so hard going to cry :')

  • I always thought of this song as Bella's because of the part "whisper's taunting all the things you said" and "shadow's linger only to my eye"

  • who evers song it is, Edwards or Bellas, its a great song and i LOVE it!

  • It's not a song that was written for Twilight.

  • Yeah I know. I was just tryping that so people would stop saying, "No, Its Bellas!"

    or, "This song is totally Edward" and stuff.

  • So Whats with the blinking title?

  • It's really horrible this blinking something... Normally things like this aren't important to me but this time...

  • haha i so agree!

    it's so unnecessary

  • that damn blinking title so so damn annoying STOP WIT THE FUCKIN BLINGKING TITLE IT DOSENT DO ANYTING BUT ANNOY PPL!

  • stop blinking the damn title

  • I guess it could be Edward or Bella, they both felt this way.

  • or maybe it's bella's song. more bella than edward.

  • love it and love the turn her music had taken. Amazing<3

  • so twilight

  • so edward....

  • haha, you think :) I love this song, especially if it is like edward

  • lol. i didnt even think about it but ya, your right... i freakin love twilight. :)

  • omg, it is like edward! holy crap...

  • More like Bella ya know? Like the part in the second book when Edward leaves? Ya... ^.^

  • Scare song but one of the best abulms

  • Kelly Clarkson's music has gotten really deep and dark. I am not sure if I like it yet. I can appreciate her vocal skills, but at the same time, her music has taken on a melodramatic, sinister, dark cast.

  • yeah. she likes to change things up. like her next album she's thinking about making it a country album.

  • This is one of my my favorite songs!

  • Brilliant song xx

  • I have never known whether it a boy or girl

    that committed suicide.

  • i love this song,its so beautiful kelly rocks!!!

  • kelly Clarkson is my favorite! Kelly Clarkson you are the best! (and one of the only albums in my Ipod besides Linkin Park^ ^)

  • this is my fav song off of this album

  • This isn't my favourite song.

    But I Love THe music, so the intro.

    There are bits in this song i like (:

    x

  • is there a video of this song? ^^ i love this song!!

  • Where in this song does it sound like Evanescence!?! The begining resembles their sound in only a fraction, if you listen to Kellys Haunted and Evanescence's Haunted the only similarites are the female vocals. Kelly is more Pop, Evanescence are more harder, Raw, Goth and Rocky. To compare the both of them is just silly.

  • actually, kelly's vocal fits more rock than Amy lee's and is more powerful even in this one small clip, U can tell that.

    defining kelly as being more a pop is retarded as if U only heard a few tracks off her on previous 2 albums. My December is specifically not a rock album but rock songs in it are more rockish than Evanescence does.

  • I'm confused

  • She looks like a princess in that red dress.

  • This song is a total summary of New Moon by:Stephenie Meyer...just read the lyrics...its made for the book...it perfectly plays out the scene where Edward tells Bella he's not coming back and where she looks everywhere for him and where she falls into depression from it... just awesome..

  • Oh my God! I agree.

    I bloody love that book, it's fantastic.

    Great association there :)

  • are you stupid. the album is like the best. well you`ll come crawling back to the album when something happens to you that relates to the lyrics of the album.

  • Kelly is like not even allowed to be a great singer anymore because everyone just wants to hate on her size! *coughcough* 666me999 *coughcough* Kelly is one of the best singers ever and she will always be a legend!

  • i totally agree with you

    kellys one of the best singer in the WORLD

    theres not many good,new singers anymore

    Kelly is and always will be a LEGEND

  • cok guzel ya bayıldım ama yinede SEBNEM FERAH BİR NUMARAA..........

  • where is the other half of the song?????????

    y does it repeat????

  • I love it! ok and shes not fat, just cause shes smart enough not to be anorexic like all those other whores out there doesnt mean shes fat

  • damn i LOVE!!! this song!!!

  • i love this song!!! and kelly clarkson aint anything like emo music, lol omg preps. but this song rocks! i like this side of kelly it gives her more of an edge. she dose what she wants!!!

    *~ashley~*

  • kelly is one of the best and how dare any of u insult she is NOT fat, she is one of the HOTTEST people around and any of who insult her have a look in a mirror because u will see the only ugly person is you!

  • I do love that she isn't a stick though! She's so gorgeous. I love her so much. She's such an inspiration and role model.

  • They are both great singers and artists so everyone just needs to move on both Haunted are equally wonderful in my opinion^^

  • Why are people comparing her to evanescence wow she has the same song title fucking hell grow up if it aint geeks comparing computer games its fucking geeks comparing singers

    Fuck off!!!!

    P.s i fucking love her and all her songs

  • OK, that blinking is REALLY annoying

  • To the emo comments, she's doing a different theme on each album she does :D She has no specific genre

  • is kelly clarkson emo?

    i mean i like her songs but latley shes sounded a little bit emo like her hcore metal singing and now this whole new cd???kinda scary

    shes come a long way from miss independance

  • no, she said that every cd would be a differnet style music, the next one is going to be country/rock/blues

  • ohh ok that makes more sense then

  • Every now and then her voice flat or sharp... but overall, a great, strong song.

  • I've never heard this song before, but it's so deep. I can make connections to it. : )

  • i dont know about you but this kinda reminds me of evanescence a lil bit right? but still good

  • So, Kelly can't use a title called Haunted if Amy already did that? That's bull shit. THIS song is about a good friend who did suicide. The song doesn't sound like Evanescence's Haunted. It just the same songtitle. And there's nothing wrong with that.

    Oh and I love Evanescence's Haunted btw :)

  • No i wasn't saying that i know she can and i also love this song as well but yeah i think kelly is better off singing pop and rmp cuz i love her old stuff too

  • there is no similar melody and beat between this song and their songs. the only thing this song reminds u of Evanescence's song is because both songs are giving off dark vibes in a heavy guitar and drum sound and pure female voice. there's nothing but that.

  • be careful people like Kelly and if you insult her someone might kill you

  • awesome song

  • when is the real music video coming out?

  • My favorite wish: That Kelly and Amy Lee would sing a "duet" together. That would sincerely ROCK!!! I would gladly provide an original, un-copyrighted "suggestion" of a song (meaning: change it any way you want to, it would be my pleasure to provide it just to facilitate that venture)...:)

  • Oh that would be great!

  • it's my fav song from my december!

  • this song is about kelly's friend that commited suicide.

  • really? thats so sad =[

  • damm right kelly rocks! ( and amy lee rocks 2 i got the cds) so yea

  • KELLY ROCKS MY FRICKEN SOCKS!

    SO DOES AMY LEE!

    wtf... y the crap are people yellign at each other about this. it is simple.

    KELLY= BEST SOLO ARTIST OUT THERE (she is just so cute!)

    AMY LEE: BEST ROCKER GIRL OUT THERE. ( she's alsways so goofy and random. :p)

    it is appearant that they both have more talent then all of us.

    lol.

    if you agree, say so

  • why is hollywood expected to be poles? its discusting and it just makes everyone of them look bad! kelly is NOT fat, shes perfect, and everyone in hollywood should not pay attention to what all these judge mental freaks are saying

  • SO DO YOU!!

  • kelly is way better! amy is killing evanescence she's freaking stupid firing everybody in the band! kelly is the best!

  • Yep, kelly is the best and she has done a good job changing from pop to rock, she sounds soooooooo much better now. LIVE LONG AND FREE KELLY

  • Amy is fine as a "Studio Girl". Just can't sing live.

  • wow...kelly looks really gothic in that red dress...lol...

  • amy lee!!..wtf!! how are you even comparing then you idiot!! kelly has obviously proven she has a beautiful real voice...amy lee might as well be voice shopped compared to her

  • LUV THIS SONG! Haunted, Judas, Sober, and Don't Waste Your Time are my favorite songs off her album!

  • yessssssssssssss finally i like kelly but evanescence and amy are the best.

  • Why the hell does everyone call Kelly fat?Isn't anyone famous allowed to be healthy anymore?:/

  • I totally agreee. :]

  • Exactly kelly is not fat, besides she looks good anyway.

  • Thank you! I think she is the perfect role model for girls when it comes to weight. And even IF she was fat (which she's NOT. she's just healthy) she'd still be beautiful.

    sorry. end rant.

    her music is what this is about.

    Which is awesome music!

  • why the hell is everyone comparing her and amy lee,the r sooooooo different,they dont even belong in the same catagory,there different,just enjoy both of them,there the best singers i think,but there dofferent

  • this is the best song in the entire album

    kelly clarkson rockz!!!

    better than amy

  • how can you say that

    amys done alot more then that fat cow

    and she is a better singer you just have shit in your eyes mate

  • kelly isn't even fat. she looks just right and well it isn't a crime to be healthy. And kelly has an amazing voice and I'm not saying that Amy hasn't got a good voice because her voice is okay, but what's the point of listening to a Kelly Clarkson song, if you're just going to insult her and by the way, I think she might have done more than Amy Lee.

  • kelly is WAY better than Amy

    amy sounds like a corpse bride or something. LMAO

  • I Agree!!

  • LAWLZ!

    me too

    but i do like judas

  • amys open lol

    and that thing with being a evanescence

    fan and now your not thats just sad how can you say

    you was a fan you cant have been if you dont like them now so your abit sad love

  • people can change their taste in music

  • This is awesome! Amy writes her songs so you can't quite tell what the meaning is. Kelly is a bit more open. They sound totally different AND their music type is different.

  • I dont get what all this is about everyone is comparing to very different people! They write completly different songs and although kelly's My December album sonds alot like Amy's stuff its a lot differnt Kellys changed and although i still love her she isnt the same!

  • Evenescence latest album totally sucked. Kelly is totally becoming an awesome songwriter and performer. her vocals are amazing. She's definantly better than Amy. I use to be a total fan of Evenescence, but Kelly has won me over. Obviously, Ben Moody and David Hodges think so to seeing as they wrote a few songs with Kelly on her second album.

  • All of Amy's songs are like depressing and all her songs sound the same.I still like her though. Kelly is awesome too!

  • I thought this was a cover of Ev's song. But it isn't, and gah. This is just a damn good song. I like Kelly. I though my december was gonna be a rip off b/c it's so familar with Ev's new album. But hahaha, I'm not comparing. Amy & Kelly are great.

  • but amy better

  • Kelly Clarkson...absolutely fucking amazing

  • but not as good as amy a

  • Since almost everyone else is being rather negative, I'm going to say that I think Kelly is amazing.

    Go Kelly!!

  • yes see amy is the best

  • amy lee is the hottest. i love her green eyes, great personality, and her voice and piano skills, and her respect towards herself. oh kelly is okay. she's hot and great voice, but Amy is a godess

  • shuppppppppppppppppppppppppppp­pppppppppp

  • yer fuck up

    if your telling me to shut up

  • my fav!

  • who ????????????????????

  • I love her new look and sound...

    And I like how she could care less what people think of her....

    Go Kelly!

  • i did not say she was

    and i did not say she did nick the song its just

    what she did to amys home and it had fuck all to do with her so why did she do it and this song and sober i just think ok grow up a

  • hmmm that dress and that staircase looks a lot like the dress Amy Lee was wearing in Call Me When Your Sober and that staircase is familiar too...

  • yeah it does

  • There's nothing wrong with Kelly Clarkson OR Amy. I like them both. Kelly did NOT steal the song 'haunted' from Amy.

    Oh, and Kelly is NOT fat. -.-

  • but amys and lot better init and

    mate talking about judge if noone did

    judge where would she be the hole tv show thing

    she would not even bee singing so fuck up ho

  • Will all of you stop bitching about kelly and amy, there both great singers and there not the same so shut the FUCK UP ABOUT IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • amy oooo my fucking god are you that

    fucking stupid mate emo emo you need

    to the what music is mate emo sweet got

    if you think amy lee/ evanescence are emo you are

    lil sad boy/girl who dont know anything about music

    and kelly is a bad role model amy is welll better

  • you what mate kelly is fucking shit next to

    amy bitch fuck up you dont know what you are talking about go back to your room and listening to your pop ok amy is best ooo and by the way kellys face is to big for her body

  • Amy Is Some Dumbass Dipshit Emo Bitch

  • maybe we dont want to be maybe she makes

    us so mad we have to tell guys on here about it init

  • Um...if you all hate it so much, why don't you just go watch another video and leave this one alone. This is seriously a waste of your time. Go be happy.

  • it's hard like people keep giving me shit cuz i don'tlike s inger i hav to ryply thats how i am if they stopped i would too

  • amy is not emo and i have to say kelly is

    the whore and i would like to know who

    darkchick101 was talking to and about i seen amy

    live she rock's unlike kelly when she sing's i think its a guy singing and if amy wants to talk about

    her life and whats she haz done let her lats why she

    is big in rock and kelly is a wanna be rock qeen a

    and all kelly talks about is man hateing i mean what the fuck if you dont care about men why are you fucking writeing about them stupid cunt

  • Okay,Everyone Commenting Bad About Kelly Is Pissing me Off,But You Are The Most.KELLY ISNT FUCKING EMO YOU ASSHOLE Amy Sucks Ass And Kelly Is Way Better