Sherlock Review - A Study in Pink (Part 1)

[MrWHOAdventures]

May I ask the jazz song played at 2:40

[naerulinnupesa]

@MrWHOAdventures It's Baker Street by Gerry Rafferty.

watch?v=WkS169P_Eeo

[kurumais]

cumberbatch and freeman are absolutely amazing in this its a blast to watch them play off each other

nice review

[ImagineWizard]

Aww, you spoilt it at the end ...

You can actually, depending on the version of movie maker, make a subtitle more similar to the one in Sherlock to the one you have.

[ImagineWizard]

Love how you say '221b Baker Street' at the same time Sherlock does :D

[TheRomanianHistorian]

Nice hat.

[EvilRobotFilms]

I think this series is definatley more enjoyable than the movie

[ScienceOfDeduction1]

@MrTARDISreviews you are awesome! i love the little spoofs you do of the episodes...i have yet to watch your dr who reviews..and i completely agree with ur opinions 100%

[meatballguy1]

Is me or does Sherlock sound like Alan Rickman? (Professor Snape in the Harry Potter movies.

[BuddhaPacific]

@meatballguy1 I thought Sherlock sounds a lot like Pierce Brosnan. 

[TardisAdventures]

series 2 should have come out by now :( has it been cancled?

[bambilover26]

@TardisAdventures i heard that they're waiting a year from the first air date, so this coming spring. if this is true, a large part of my soul will die between now and then. i'm already rationing the first 3 for myself (i'm making myself wait about a month between each episode), to make it last longer and it has to be one of the most painful self-inflicted tortures that has ever existed.

[FandPrulethesky]

You actually had me ROFL. The fact i was already laying on the floor shouldn't bother you though :)

[Lunatic1603]

5:09 I totally agree with you

That voice! It gives you goosebumps <3

[LittoHeavaG]

@LlansleyNinja141

I am the only one of my friends who hates Dr Who. I didn't mind the christmas one with David Tennant, but I just hate Matt smith...

[LittoHeavaG]

@LlansleyNinja141 OH MY GOD THANK YOU.

[blackskullthunder]

Cummberbatch for Doctor number 12!

[quotecat7]

Why doesn't anyone make a Sherlock- video with "Baker Street"? It's such a great song and it's so obvious to do it and yet, there are all kinds of more or less good songs with Sherlock clips but not "Baker Street"! Why?

[morriarty01]

I find myself agreeing with you this is a brilliant episode and they have done beutifully with modernising it

[CompletelyHC]

Ahhhrrrrrghhhh his voice is awesome! Like chocolate XD

[PenelopeHawthorn]

Thank you for making this! :) I'm making a fanmade sherlock/doctor who crossover movie and I need to capture the characters as perfectly as this show did. This really helped me! :]

[alicebacks1]

:(

[MikbaninX]

Why do you have to do commentaries on the show? Why can't you just post the show in parts unedited?

[SolrSurfr3]

I can't think of anything about your review that I disagree with. I was kind of skeptical about this series at first, but they really did the characters justice while adding some really cool twists and changes. And yes, Benedict Cumberbatch is absolutely amazing. I can't believe I'd never heard of him before this!

[ZOINKSation]

I think that Cumberbatch would make an excellent Master in doctor who! Can't you just imagine him skulking around in his TARDIS with a laser screwdriver?

[Shyguy825]

The show was okey. That´s all have to say.

And good review by the way!

[SyberiaWinx]

I enjoyed part one of your review and can't wait to watch part two. I hope you will do the other two episodes, if you haven't already. The BBC series was actually my first experience with Sherlock Holmes, and I love it. I run a forum for the series as a result.

[59span43]

I love your review, you cover all the elements that make this a dynamic movie. I too was taken by the text implication. If it doesn't continue on as a series, then BBC needs new executives making decisions. All casting is superb.... just love it!!

[XxLi3rose123xX]

I totally agree with you, at first I didn't think much to the trailer. My parents recorded the series for me.I actually didn't see the eps until, the series finished. And I felt really stupid, because I didn't reliese how bl**dy amazing it was! Best show in years, I love Benedict! My favourite actor, now. Everything about the show I loved! I even wrote 3 fanmade eps because I loved the show so much! About Adler/Hounds/ Sherlock falling off a building. Plz check my chnnel 4 Sherlock stuff :D

[TheGalifreyGuy]

Sherlock reminds me of Torchwood and cool review

[queenoftheoutlands]

Catlin Moran described Cumberbatch's voice as "a jaguar inside a cello". I have to say I agree. Guh, that voice. And sometimes I think he doesn't need to breathe he talks so darn fast. Anyway, another great review. Can't wait for your take on the next two episodes

[MEW458]

You are so good at this! Not only were you spot on, but you did it with humor! Bravo!

[Dafney94]

*like. And great review, and loved the episodes myself.

[farshnuke]

Right, this has confirmed it. When I finish my b00k (end of march tops, the whole thing only took 4) you're getting a digital draft because this review shows how excellent a reviewer and epically self referencing you are.

[MrTARDISreviews]

@farshnuke Thanks alot mate =) I look forward to reading it =D

[farshnuke]

@MrTARDISreviews Thanks, I look forward to your response, and, well, finishing it. :) lol

[anikanskywalker121]

@MrTARDISreviews how do you not get copyrighted on your video's

[pilosop0tacio]

hahaha! love the ending

[pilosop0tacio]

great review! :)

[imaof4]

I came to the BBC adaptation the other way 'round. I ignored the Jude Law / Robert Downey , Jr, as in. completely . Once ti had been announced Moffat/Gattis were writing this new programme, I was on tenterhooks until it's broadcast.

And I wasn't disappointed. Loved Martin Freeman in Hitchhiker's The Office. Definitely looking forward to the Hobbit!! Just looked up Bernard's filmography, and although I've seen a few of the projects he's been in, I've no recollection of him.He's stellar as SH

[MrTARDISreviews]

@imaof4 Apart from this i've only seen Benedict in 1 other thing and that's 'Four Lions' where he plays a potty mouthed police officer. He's only in it for 2/3 minutes but he's hilarious =D

[Strobertat]

LOL awesome. nice review. shame I wasn't able to watch this episode but oh well, the other 2 were awesome. love the guy who plays him and also (Sherlock for doctor who) yeah don't hind it, your thinking it too :D

[WhovianWars]

an amazing review of part one also nice touch with the baker street song shame the singer died not so long ago :( but anyway look foward to part 2

[HyperBlob1]

I havn't seen any of the Sherlock episodes...that's soon hopefully gonna change