This was a brilliant theme, quite reflective of the music of Brecht and Eisler in style and political content. Progressives of every shade of red need to respect Rzewski and his bold piece through each struggle for social justice we encounter. You CANNOT separate the music from the revolutionary fervor here---as Rzewski intended, they are one.
De pie, cantar que vamos a luchar, avanzan ya banderas de unidad, y tu vendrás marchando junto a mi, y al fin verás tu canto y tu bandera florecer la luz de un rojo amenecer que anuncia ya la vida que vendrá...
Maestro !!! Thanks for the tribute to Chile and Salvador Allende who gave his life on a day like today (September 11,1973) 37 years ago. Long Live Salvador Allende !!
You're so right. It's a very catchy tune, and a wonderful choice for variations.
I remember the controversies when Rzewski began composing like this in the 1970's, and how he was mercilessly attacked by some in academia. It was a rather sudden change in style for him, but he certainly has done an excellent job with it.
"The People United Will Never Be Defeated! 36 Variations on ¡El Pueblo Unido Jamás Será Vencido! ...tells rather innocuously of human struggle for change. The theme for the Variation comes from Sergio Ortega who wrote the anthem of the same name to a pop-tune he picked up at the time. Rzewskis hour-long treatment for piano takes this tune as its ever-recurring kernel and goes far and wide with it."
Rzewski's a funny guy. Definition of the word "radical chic". I don't really mind that a silk-shirt-wearing product of Harvard and Princeton shamelessly used this tune to make himself so goddamned hip in the 1970s because I don't give a shit about radical politics anyway, but these variations sure do make pretty piano music. Viva la variacion!
This is a major disappointment for me. Is THIS Rzewski? You know, Harvard, Princeton, Yale, Trinity College... But this one sounds like Sailor Moon theme played by an enthusianistic 16yo japanese schoolgirl...in one of those sexy uniforms...wow, those girls are HOTTT. Wow.
Seriously?! This is the theme upon which his "The People United Will Never be Defeated" variations are based. This is a Chilean revolutionary theme. The variations that he apparently no longer has the technical facilities to play are more virtuosic and "academic". He's old and apparently out of practice, but do not insult his compositional skills on a piece that isn't even "his". Judge the variations all you want, but this theme is a traditional song that he didn't write. Ignoramus.
You've mentioned em (though misspelled as Chile) and their you know... evolution or something.
But top tier? Look, I don't speak german well. I know "das Tier" is like "an animal", but "top tier"? What is this, king of the beasts?
Anyways, "why would I want to make music that makes sense when none of the world makes sense" Good point. Why? I just don't get it. It makes no sense. No reason, no coherence, no nothin, you know like arty stuff and things like that.
Umm...yes...um...OK. "This is a Chilean revolutionary theme. " Let this be the basis. The word "Chilean" makes no sense, because there is no such word as "Chile". So I thought this must be a misspelling of the word "chili" which totally makes sense, because there is a famous band named after it. Like the Red Hot Chili Peppers. They are great.
"revolutionary" is the exact same case, "revolution" is pointless, but "evolution" is a known and working thing since Thales and stuff.
Umm...yes...um...OK. Chile is a South American country. Chili is a spicy pepper. One is a county and the other is a food. Hence, a Chilean revolutionary theme is a theme that originated in the nation of Chile.
"Revolution" is when a people overthrow their government, which is how my country came into existence. The same thing happened in countless countries: France, China, Russia, etc.
Wow thanks, there IS such a country! Huh, sorry for Chile. Amazing. What a name. Red&hot...gee. Must be a place.
But concerning "revolution" I still have to say, that you're wrong.
You know, I don't want to act like a smartass, but I think you still pull a bang, because there is just no such a thing. You still kinda misspell the word "evolution" which is a well-known theorem saying a^2+b^2=mc^2 or something, and named after its originator Thales since 1460.
Clearly you neither speak English well nor have ever taken a legitimate history class. The American, French, and Russian (Bolshevik) Revolutions were some of the most important events in Western history.
I think you overrate the importance of rebellion, language, history, sense, coherence, compositional skills, universities, animals, Ortega, top gun, and chili.
I don't want to spoil your fun, but huh. You are a tough one.
One of America's greatest 20th century composers. To attend a Rzewski concert is to have a never forgotten evening. Thanks for letting me know your music for the last 33 years. Onward and upward Frederick.
This was a brilliant theme, quite reflective of the music of Brecht and Eisler in style and political content. Progressives of every shade of red need to respect Rzewski and his bold piece through each struggle for social justice we encounter. You CANNOT separate the music from the revolutionary fervor here---as Rzewski intended, they are one.
XylophoneNoir 1 week ago
I have to play this song for my exam of piano, this video helped me a lot. So thanks for posting it.
Ascotg 8 months ago 2
Why does he have to use score? He himself composed it...
Laudan08 9 months ago
Buenisimoooooooo
adelantoni 11 months ago
De pie, cantar que vamos a luchar, avanzan ya banderas de unidad, y tu vendrás marchando junto a mi, y al fin verás tu canto y tu bandera florecer la luz de un rojo amenecer que anuncia ya la vida que vendrá...
fisarmonicista 1 year ago
Like it!
BranSheanew 1 year ago
Maestro !!! Thanks for the tribute to Chile and Salvador Allende who gave his life on a day like today (September 11,1973) 37 years ago. Long Live Salvador Allende !!
Tome1973 1 year ago
i dig it!
piano12161770 1 year ago
I saw him play in Cologne about 15 years ago. Very moving performance
TimJakeGl 2 years ago
does anyone know where can i find the piano sheet for this peace???
Predatorwazza666 2 years ago
El pueblo unido jamás será vencido!!!!!
El himno de la Unidad Popular Gobierno derrocado por la CIA
antignorantes 2 years ago
I can't get this melody out of my head! I love it! Especially at 2:12 where he gets all Rachmaninoff-ish, haha. Great Composer!
chexg 2 years ago 5
You're so right. It's a very catchy tune, and a wonderful choice for variations.
I remember the controversies when Rzewski began composing like this in the 1970's, and how he was mercilessly attacked by some in academia. It was a rather sudden change in style for him, but he certainly has done an excellent job with it.
PianoplayerPaul 2 years ago
The melody isn't his, though...
"The People United Will Never Be Defeated! 36 Variations on ¡El Pueblo Unido Jamás Será Vencido! ...tells rather innocuously of human struggle for change. The theme for the Variation comes from Sergio Ortega who wrote the anthem of the same name to a pop-tune he picked up at the time. Rzewskis hour-long treatment for piano takes this tune as its ever-recurring kernel and goes far and wide with it."
jlaurson 2 years ago
I grew up on this, and I love his interpretations! He has donted so much to our Chilean history by adding his variations to our theme.
cenzi6 2 years ago 5
Rzewski's a funny guy. Definition of the word "radical chic". I don't really mind that a silk-shirt-wearing product of Harvard and Princeton shamelessly used this tune to make himself so goddamned hip in the 1970s because I don't give a shit about radical politics anyway, but these variations sure do make pretty piano music. Viva la variacion!
NastyBadBird 2 years ago 11
@NastyBadBird I dont give a shit your give a shit and
VIVA LA REVOLUCIÓN
antignorantes 1 year ago
@antignorantes The same here. At the moment, in my sad Italy, a good revolution inspired by this composition would be a real blessing!
MarcheseCadmio88 3 months ago
ignorance, ignorance
200715209 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This is a major disappointment for me. Is THIS Rzewski? You know, Harvard, Princeton, Yale, Trinity College... But this one sounds like Sailor Moon theme played by an enthusianistic 16yo japanese schoolgirl...in one of those sexy uniforms...wow, those girls are HOTTT. Wow.
reallyhatejazz 2 years ago
Seriously?! This is the theme upon which his "The People United Will Never be Defeated" variations are based. This is a Chilean revolutionary theme. The variations that he apparently no longer has the technical facilities to play are more virtuosic and "academic". He's old and apparently out of practice, but do not insult his compositional skills on a piece that isn't even "his". Judge the variations all you want, but this theme is a traditional song that he didn't write. Ignoramus.
physicsgeek21690 2 years ago 2
Um... you mean like Red Hot Chili Peppers? Are they like...evolutionary and stuff?
Anyways you've opened my eyes and I no longer think Harvard, Yale, Princeton and stuff like the way I actually did before.
I kinda begin to recognise that this old dude has a strong fanbase all over the world, even in places like you know Mexico or Europe and stuff.
Thanx alot!
reallyhatejazz 2 years ago
Red Hot Chili Peppers? What does a rock band from California have to do with my comment? And what do they have to do with top-tier universities?
The rest of your comment is incoherent.
physicsgeek21690 2 years ago
You've mentioned em (though misspelled as Chile) and their you know... evolution or something.
But top tier? Look, I don't speak german well. I know "das Tier" is like "an animal", but "top tier"? What is this, king of the beasts?
Anyways, "why would I want to make music that makes sense when none of the world makes sense" Good point. Why? I just don't get it. It makes no sense. No reason, no coherence, no nothin, you know like arty stuff and things like that.
reallyhatejazz 2 years ago
-I'm speaking English, not German.
-I have no idea what the Chili Peppers being "evolution or something" means. And I didn't bring them up, you did.
-Top tier universities are universities that are among the best in the world.
physicsgeek21690 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Umm...yes...um...OK. "This is a Chilean revolutionary theme. " Let this be the basis. The word "Chilean" makes no sense, because there is no such word as "Chile". So I thought this must be a misspelling of the word "chili" which totally makes sense, because there is a famous band named after it. Like the Red Hot Chili Peppers. They are great.
"revolutionary" is the exact same case, "revolution" is pointless, but "evolution" is a known and working thing since Thales and stuff.
Gee, you are smart.
reallyhatejazz 2 years ago
Umm...yes...um...OK. Chile is a South American country. Chili is a spicy pepper. One is a county and the other is a food. Hence, a Chilean revolutionary theme is a theme that originated in the nation of Chile.
"Revolution" is when a people overthrow their government, which is how my country came into existence. The same thing happened in countless countries: France, China, Russia, etc.
Gee, you are smart.
physicsgeek21690 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
Wow thanks, there IS such a country! Huh, sorry for Chile. Amazing. What a name. Red&hot...gee. Must be a place.
But concerning "revolution" I still have to say, that you're wrong.
You know, I don't want to act like a smartass, but I think you still pull a bang, because there is just no such a thing. You still kinda misspell the word "evolution" which is a well-known theorem saying a^2+b^2=mc^2 or something, and named after its originator Thales since 1460.
But thanks for Chile. Awesome.
reallyhatejazz 2 years ago
Clearly you neither speak English well nor have ever taken a legitimate history class. The American, French, and Russian (Bolshevik) Revolutions were some of the most important events in Western history.
physicsgeek21690 2 years ago
I think you overrate the importance of rebellion, language, history, sense, coherence, compositional skills, universities, animals, Ortega, top gun, and chili.
I don't want to spoil your fun, but huh. You are a tough one.
reallyhatejazz 2 years ago
oh god, thats such a brilliant discussion :D
reallyhatejazz youre awsome
pianomarius 2 years ago
@pianomarius
I can't see how anyone could really hate jazz. I think I'll go listen to some now
philnoll 2 years ago
@philnoll
me too.
hiromi uehara <3
pianomarius 2 years ago
yes, that's it. But some of her stuff like kung fu campion is not my taste
philnoll 2 years ago
wtf is wrong with you physicsgeek
don't feed the trolls
robbiethemann 2 years ago 3
composers are not performers. not this one anyway.
darkdss 2 years ago
He was when he was younger, don't be so disrespectful. This guy was one of the few people who could play the Stockhausen Klavierstücke no. 10.
flammesombres 2 years ago
u stupid fuck,can t u see he s old?.pay some respect to one of the greatest living composers
Tacitus87 2 years ago
Is he Polish or Russian?
hirstern 2 years ago
Polish-American
qtpipi 2 years ago
American.
jlaurson 2 years ago
ahhh cringeworthy ending. that was tragic. the worst time to make a mistake.
not the best way to end an hour long piece aaaaagh
robbiethemann 3 years ago
민중이여 단결하라! Peoples be united!
gnsksj 3 years ago
The melody sounds like one song of the bulgarian band Nova Generacia from 91. Search "Patriotichna pesen" and tell me your opinions.
ShwangShwing 3 years ago
The beginning is really similar, but later It's diffrent.
hirstern 3 years ago
I can listen to this a hundred times and not get sick of it! Simply amazing!!!
Irelandlass7789 3 years ago 3
Simlpy Stunning!!!!!
A divine privilege listening to the composer himself playing his own holy and great OPUS!
SUPERB!!!
charlesalkan 3 years ago
Comment removed
marderend 2 years ago
that is lovely indeed!very good !!
EilisErina 3 years ago
AMAZING AMAZING AMAZING
goldberg72 3 years ago
Baaaa-Voooooooooooo! That was sweeet! what a privilege to us all to listen to this!!!!
christian6657 3 years ago 2
One of America's greatest 20th century composers. To attend a Rzewski concert is to have a never forgotten evening. Thanks for letting me know your music for the last 33 years. Onward and upward Frederick.
ipmoic 3 years ago 4
This composition is brilliance. I am interested to hear the rest from the composer himself!
Chopinesque 3 years ago 2
As a pianist, he has a very warm tone. His music reminds me of the poem of Walt Whitman somehow. Thanks for posting.
AHN5D 3 years ago 2
Its ironic, I like Hamelin's version of this better than the actual composer's. lol
celach 3 years ago 2
me too.. i feel Hamelin interpreted the song more lively and passionate..
rvn10rvn17 3 years ago
All Composers arent pianist.
MrRockin 3 years ago
Very interesting. Never heard of him til now. Thanks
sagalat 4 years ago
AMAZING!
nikolaclar 4 years ago
thanks for sharing...you have great taste!
boomchuckaboom 4 years ago