Yeah and a performance with Taye is on YouTube it's absolutly one of her best "No good deed" and also "As long as you're mine" and "I'm not that girl" I have ever heard.
I don't know what you guys are saying. Idina is the best Elphaba. Ellis, Cusack, Block, Bean, and everyone else stinks. They wish they could sing like Idina
i am positive that i got all of these "no good deed" clips from idina's performances. it may sound like shoshana bean at :42, but it definitely is not. :)
Definitely not the best Elphaba vocally (although she was amazing in London) - but she just had IT. She WAS Elphaba and no one did those songs better than her.
i comletely agree. i used to insist that idina was the best singer of the bunch, but i've been looking them all up lately, and she's just not. but she IS elphaba- i don't think elphie needs to sound perfectly polished all the time- the character and emotions are the most important part.
You have to see this woman live to understand how amazing she is! Such a powerhouse! The last "again" is a small indication of what she's like live!
idinafanboi 11 months ago
@elphanatic elphanatic that was not shoshana it was Idina
idinafanboi 11 months ago
@elphanatic Yeah thats Idina, her voice is not like shoshana bean's, she has a certain umm "tone" to her voice that makes it unique.
MovieGoer19 1 year ago
The last "again" is from January 2nd, 2005... a few nights prior to her departure from the show.
bwayguy22089 1 year ago
This video is AMAZING! What performance did that "Again" come from? I heard her do similar versions, but never this intense!
moviefreak316 2 years ago
the "again" was absolutely AMAZING! the best i have ever heard!
corey9588 2 years ago 16
100% agreed!
bugsbunny7117 2 years ago
great pictures
saint973 2 years ago
the more i hear idina the more i love her!
bmax231 3 years ago 12
I like they "Supply" in this! good "Again" too :) I don't know who I like better..Kerry or Idina =P
musicalchix 3 years ago 3
thats the best "fiyero" ive heard yet from any elphaba!!!
kady2284 3 years ago 4
its so real and so is SJB's...it comes from thinking of the on you love murdered.
RaWrZzZz 3 years ago
Of course SJB's rocks. Her husband died (in the play because Sebastian was Fiyero). He didn't really die, just his character...sorta.
12bmills 3 years ago
exactly. just like idina! she thinks of taye, and taye was fiyero for a while.
RaWrZzZz 3 years ago
Yeah and a performance with Taye is on YouTube it's absolutly one of her best "No good deed" and also "As long as you're mine" and "I'm not that girl" I have ever heard.
Bibifly 2 years ago
Her last "again".....holy shit! That was phenominal!
wickedWitch456 3 years ago 2
I remember seeing a photo of Idina during No Good Deed before I read the novel and from the there I just saw her as Elphaba.
RhainnonRings 3 years ago 2
i love how they have so many different singing in this.
alwayzbored94 3 years ago
I don't know what you guys are saying. Idina is the best Elphaba. Ellis, Cusack, Block, Bean, and everyone else stinks. They wish they could sing like Idina
Tarad21 3 years ago
That's not true. They're all good.
Glindagoodgecko 3 years ago 5
you really give the rest of us Idina fans bad names. Go away
degeorgetitanic 3 years ago 4
Idina is just Elphaba....I mean she just IS.
(: ilyy
winter0babe0kels 3 years ago 4
Yeah, thats Idina. Sho only wishes she sounded this good :]
wildfiretgh 3 years ago 4
i am positive that i got all of these "no good deed" clips from idina's performances. it may sound like shoshana bean at :42, but it definitely is not. :)
rkm711 3 years ago
hate to break it to u, but that is shoshana from 42-49 seconds
sithlord91 3 years ago
@rkm711 Shoshona is not in this video
bmamaxwell 1 year ago
@bmamaxwell I know. I made it.
rkm711 1 year ago
@rkm711 oh sorry replied to the wrong comment
bmamaxwell 1 year ago
Definitely not the best Elphaba vocally (although she was amazing in London) - but she just had IT. She WAS Elphaba and no one did those songs better than her.
NHK1111111111 3 years ago 4
idina is the best...im not saying that ur opinions rong but i like her betther than the rest
the choice is
1. dee menzel
2. steph j block
3. shoshana
gbrangl7 3 years ago 2
Read my post again. ugh
NHK1111111111 3 years ago
not the best vocally...yea she was amazing in everything...i read it
gbrangl7 3 years ago
Well, anyone with ears can tell her voice is nowhere near Kerry Ellis, Carmen Cusack, Stephanie J Block, Eden Espinosa, Shoshana Bean etc.
But she still does the songs best, simply because they're HERS.
NHK1111111111 3 years ago
yea nowhere neer cuz she surpasses them durrr and there not HERS she just sang them 1st...there STEVEN SCHWARTZ'S just rember that...
gbrangl7 3 years ago 2
Shut up.
omgsora 3 years ago
neva...u noe im rite thats y u tellin me to shut up
SnapexxBella 3 years ago
i comletely agree. i used to insist that idina was the best singer of the bunch, but i've been looking them all up lately, and she's just not. but she IS elphaba- i don't think elphie needs to sound perfectly polished all the time- the character and emotions are the most important part.
pianogirl714 3 years ago
I agree. I used to think she'd be the one and only Elphaba I'd like, but now I love Kerry Ellis! lol, so, Its weird, but she is totally Elphiieee
musicalchix 3 years ago 2
wow where did u get some of those awsome clips - i haven't some of them before!
wickedmenzel 3 years ago
i like it, i think maybe you could play around with the volume a bit to even it out so all clips are about the same
alyks777 3 years ago
i luv it!!! 5 stars for you!!!
christineadorno 3 years ago 2