Anthony=<3. Ok so this wasnt anthonys greatest performance but it didn't suck. But as far as I'm concerned, he's not my favorite idol, he's the only one XD ! He was better than carrie. She was a country hick I'm sorry to say. At least balladeers have class.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I thought it was horrible. He was behind the music for most of the song. As we would say in band, he needs to get on top of the beat. Furthermore, he doesn't have enough soul for a song like this.
he does lag behind the beat a little...but he did an amazing job with this performance...and its not so bad until it takes away from the performance like Chris Sligh's performance of Typical...liked Chris Sligh's voice...but if u really wanna hear somebody be behind the beat and it actually takes away from the performance...listen to that performance...great voice though...
i hate disco night
because everyone struggles with it
joancamo 1 year ago
I know that wasn't awesome but I still really liked it.
xxkmlsmpxx 1 year ago
boot-ay
allthingseuro90 1 year ago
Anthony=<3. Ok so this wasnt anthonys greatest performance but it didn't suck. But as far as I'm concerned, he's not my favorite idol, he's the only one XD ! He was better than carrie. She was a country hick I'm sorry to say. At least balladeers have class.
afedorovmyhero 1 year ago
Sounds flat, totally lacking in soul.
KhemuLuxons 2 years ago
..thanks for sharing
katherineoa 2 years ago
No, he wasn't the best singer. Carrie was, by a mile. I picked her to win weeks before she did.
I loved Anthony though. I thought he was very brave, to face Simon's obvious dislike of him week after week.
drobin3149 2 years ago
To bad he couldn't stay on beat and cue with the music.
I studied music my entire life till I started going deaf.
This guy is good but he could be great with the right music coach.
happymike44 2 years ago
anthony was the best singer in the entire season
HugoJ9 2 years ago 3
Season 4 was the best season ever on american idol!
dkbmc1511 3 years ago 6
@dkbmc1511
It was a great season but I think season 5 wins out of most talent.
helmut4lyfe 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i hated his ass and this was the best performance of that night
which made me mad
BlingyDamon3 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I thought it was horrible. He was behind the music for most of the song. As we would say in band, he needs to get on top of the beat. Furthermore, he doesn't have enough soul for a song like this.
kjgarvin 3 years ago
You must have a lagging computer or something, because he's not behind the music.
ahen236 3 years ago 3
Nope nothing wrong with my computer. Kind of hard to explain to people withut a musical ear, but he's lagging SLIGHTLY behind the beat.
kjgarvin 3 years ago
Nice try, but I've been singing my entire life, so don't talk to me about "lacking a musical ear."
ahen236 3 years ago 2
he does lag behind the beat a little...but he did an amazing job with this performance...and its not so bad until it takes away from the performance like Chris Sligh's performance of Typical...liked Chris Sligh's voice...but if u really wanna hear somebody be behind the beat and it actually takes away from the performance...listen to that performance...great voice though...
qCLEFJones 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
boring!!!!!! sorry to say
luvthamusik 3 years ago
Haha he was my favorite this season!
polkadots9410 3 years ago 3
i loved surrender it was the best
69jewzrcool69 3 years ago
omg, yeahh. totally agree. :)
mardgreen88 2 years ago 2
i love u man!!!!!!
katetsepwe 4 years ago 2
i loved anthony in season four... not his best performance but i still loved it... and i love him too =)
somberNdeep23 4 years ago
I'm a big American Idol fan. I have always loved Anthany. He hit it right on the spot that week.
randyw6106 4 years ago 4
I love his dancing during the intro. Great singer and beautiful eyes too!
trumpeter123 4 years ago 2
I think this season had the most overall talent of any of them. Love this kid's voice.
lobo81865 4 years ago 2
Love this song! Just saw Anthony in the Fantasticks and its great!
SnailArmySoldier 4 years ago
I remember this song from when I was younger.
12Reiner 4 years ago
Anthony is a great performer, very lively and knows how to grab the audience's attention!! Great dancer as well as great singer!!
krystal7575 4 years ago
best male in season 4
lvu16 4 years ago
Love this song!!
krystal7575 4 years ago
Great song... but his version needs some help... but still good! "Paula"
Myrolex 4 years ago
i love his dancing :) lol!!! "i have a chance to shake my bootay!"
aleecia 5 years ago