I really hate how these videos devolve into a competition about whose voice is better. It's all subjective. I love Frances' vocals and felt they fit the character perfectly.
i just want to find a video of the original london cast. i have the cd of that, and out of the different singers i have heard, they are the best,. o and i agree that marius should have gone with eponine. i mean come on!!!! u c a girl one time and u fall in love???thats called unrealistic. and u can c in this that they would be cute together.
can't we all appreciate them for their uniqueness? in musical theatre, that's something really special, and it's because lea and frances both have such stand-out qualities that are so specific to them that we all fight over them. at least they are both strongly memorable and each own the part in their own way. And furthermore, isn't it better as an artist to invoke strong reactions from people then just be sorta bland and okay?
shes supposed to be dieing -_- i would assume shes sounding that way on purpose obviousley if you were dieing you wouldnt sing like you were full of energy, stop hating on her...but i do perfer the 10th anniversery only because there voices were beautiful together and i think the acting they did was amazing for it
She sounds lovely here. Better than all her recordings, anyway. She sounds pathetic... which is what Eponine is supposed to sound like. <-that 's a compliment! =P
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Not only does Frances have an ugly, throaty, nasal, whiny voice, she also has difficulty hitting and especially sustaining the notes. It is an insult to Salonga to be even compared to this trying-hard amateur!
Wow, what an ignorant post! Frances is an amateur? Then how come Boublil & Schonberg (Miss Saigon) as well as Andrew Lloyd Webber (Sunset Boulevard & Whistle Down The Wind) used her vocals in demos and 1st public presentations of their works in front of artists, critics & prospective investors? Maybe they're tone-deaf as well?
Also, do some research on the early days of LesMis. THIS is the original key FYI. If you can't stand her singing then you probably hate the role itself.
@annief31 Very ignorant for you to say that. Of course we're entitled to our own opinions; if you don't like Frances' voice, then fine, that's you. But Frances is most definitely NOT an amateur.
@annief31 I surprisingly disagree with this comment. I love Lea Salonga, but not as Eponine. I thought her technique as Eponine was spot on, but her performance did not feel like the character. Francis has the gypsy-like quality that I see in Eponine. I think Salonga works much better as Fantine. I will say, however, that Ruffelle is very Cyndi Lauperish, but I think it works for this character quite well.
@andromache007 I agree. I like both Lea Salonga and Frances Ruffelle. I read somewhere that in the book, Eponine is supposed to have a gruffer voice (something like that). I think Frances Ruffelle does an excellent job with that.
@annief31 she's not an amateur. She has a unique voice and her Eponine is as amazing as Salongas. They are different, but they are both amazing in an own way.
love both lea and frances but i slightly prefer how unperfect frances' voice is as opposed to lea's perfect polished voice. i think it adds so much more to the character of eponine and makes her more believable. but lea is amazing as eponine
i so agree with lesmeslover95 but i think leas is the eponine~!! but they shoul've sang the song on my own the three of them maybe on the 30th anniversary!!! lea is not overeacting it!! she is the best eponine ever period!!
i so agree with lesmeslover95 but i think leas is the eponine~!! but they shoul've sang the song on my own the three of them maybe on the 30th anniversary!!!
During the 25th anniversary finale, it would have been SO awesome if Francis, Lea, and Samantha had performed "On My Own" together. I would have had a heart attack and died of sheer amazement... Although, not before hearing all three of them singing together. :)
I think that each Eponine plays her beautifully in their own way, but this version of A Little Fall of Rain just doesn't pull me emotionally the same way as Lea Salonga and Michael Ball.
Forgot to add that I think Michael Ball complements Frances' voice perfectly on the Original London Cast performance of this song.
devane85 1 month ago
I really hate how these videos devolve into a competition about whose voice is better. It's all subjective. I love Frances' vocals and felt they fit the character perfectly.
devane85 1 month ago
i just want to find a video of the original london cast. i have the cd of that, and out of the different singers i have heard, they are the best,. o and i agree that marius should have gone with eponine. i mean come on!!!! u c a girl one time and u fall in love???thats called unrealistic. and u can c in this that they would be cute together.
disneysingergirl11 3 months ago
If I was Marius, I would have gone with Eponine, she's so much cooler.
theremarkablecows 5 months ago
Does an entire video of this concert exist?
xXJessWorldXx 6 months ago
At least Frances can hit those low notes. Samantha Barks in the 25th made me wince every time she attempted to do so.
uberathlete 6 months ago 2
I dislike her voice, I can't really tell why... She has an annoying voice...
MuziekFan1995 7 months ago
Samantha has talent. Frances performs Eponine well. Lea sings Eponine perfectly.
KingdomofHongkie 7 months ago 3
can't we all appreciate them for their uniqueness? in musical theatre, that's something really special, and it's because lea and frances both have such stand-out qualities that are so specific to them that we all fight over them. at least they are both strongly memorable and each own the part in their own way. And furthermore, isn't it better as an artist to invoke strong reactions from people then just be sorta bland and okay?
sirimarias 7 months ago 3
shes supposed to be dieing -_- i would assume shes sounding that way on purpose obviousley if you were dieing you wouldnt sing like you were full of energy, stop hating on her...but i do perfer the 10th anniversery only because there voices were beautiful together and i think the acting they did was amazing for it
izziebarrie 8 months ago
She sounds lovely here. Better than all her recordings, anyway. She sounds pathetic... which is what Eponine is supposed to sound like. <-that 's a compliment! =P
MSam2 8 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Not only does Frances have an ugly, throaty, nasal, whiny voice, she also has difficulty hitting and especially sustaining the notes. It is an insult to Salonga to be even compared to this trying-hard amateur!
annief31 8 months ago
@annief31
Wow, what an ignorant post! Frances is an amateur? Then how come Boublil & Schonberg (Miss Saigon) as well as Andrew Lloyd Webber (Sunset Boulevard & Whistle Down The Wind) used her vocals in demos and 1st public presentations of their works in front of artists, critics & prospective investors? Maybe they're tone-deaf as well?
Also, do some research on the early days of LesMis. THIS is the original key FYI. If you can't stand her singing then you probably hate the role itself.
KateBushDepot 8 months ago 15
This has been flagged as spam show
@annief31 Very ignorant for you to say that. Of course we're entitled to our own opinions; if you don't like Frances' voice, then fine, that's you. But Frances is most definitely NOT an amateur.
aceandspades84 8 months ago
@annief31 I surprisingly disagree with this comment. I love Lea Salonga, but not as Eponine. I thought her technique as Eponine was spot on, but her performance did not feel like the character. Francis has the gypsy-like quality that I see in Eponine. I think Salonga works much better as Fantine. I will say, however, that Ruffelle is very Cyndi Lauperish, but I think it works for this character quite well.
Kole101111 7 months ago 7
@annief31 Well I happen to love her "ugly, throaty, nasal, whiny voice". Eponine's role is also about emotions, you know.
andromache007 5 months ago 5
@andromache007 I agree. I like both Lea Salonga and Frances Ruffelle. I read somewhere that in the book, Eponine is supposed to have a gruffer voice (something like that). I think Frances Ruffelle does an excellent job with that.
JessFeser 5 months ago
@annief31 she's not an amateur. She has a unique voice and her Eponine is as amazing as Salongas. They are different, but they are both amazing in an own way.
YourFavouriteNub 4 weeks ago
love both lea and frances but i slightly prefer how unperfect frances' voice is as opposed to lea's perfect polished voice. i think it adds so much more to the character of eponine and makes her more believable. but lea is amazing as eponine
lesmizfanatic90 9 months ago 2
not a fan of lea. for me, she's too polished. Love Frances and love Samantha
philippa230493 9 months ago
But MY FAVORITE IS HER
lisa131003 9 months ago
She looks so uncomfortable in his arms.
1419sunnyside 10 months ago
i so agree with lesmeslover95 but i think leas is the eponine~!! but they shoul've sang the song on my own the three of them maybe on the 30th anniversary!!! lea is not overeacting it!! she is the best eponine ever period!!
prettyalexis1214 11 months ago 2
i so agree with lesmeslover95 but i think leas is the eponine~!! but they shoul've sang the song on my own the three of them maybe on the 30th anniversary!!!
prettyalexis1214 11 months ago
omg she is awful!!! Lea is the best 'Ponine to me!!
futurstarsinger 11 months ago
During the 25th anniversary finale, it would have been SO awesome if Francis, Lea, and Samantha had performed "On My Own" together. I would have had a heart attack and died of sheer amazement... Although, not before hearing all three of them singing together. :)
lesmeslover95 11 months ago 27
Frankie is hot!
kfag101 11 months ago
she is SO amazing
lea is SO overrated
myopicmaniac 11 months ago
I love Lea, but Frances IS Eponine to me and always will be.
JulianSacrifice 11 months ago 8
I think that each Eponine plays her beautifully in their own way, but this version of A Little Fall of Rain just doesn't pull me emotionally the same way as Lea Salonga and Michael Ball.
theguiltyonesing 11 months ago
I like this version of Eponine best.
roberto18giron 1 year ago
She & Samantha Barks Are My Favorites! X
mileycyrusfan310 1 year ago 3
she is way better than lea! Lea overacted
kfag101 1 year ago 2
shes the original but this looks like the parody of the 10th anniv.
Mrdv904k 1 year ago 18
@Mrdv904k thats probabley because you saw it first :P
izziebarrie 8 months ago
She is just Fantastic!!
Paris1832 1 year ago
This is beautiful! Frankie is vocally my favourite Eponine and it's so nice to find clips of her singing.
EponineJondrette 1 year ago 2