Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (161)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • HOLY SHIT! JENNIFER HIT THAT NOTE At 2:31 ! I REALLY didn't expect her to!!! She sings with SUCH confidence!

  • She killed 'Stir It Up'

  • On TV they touch some of the Jhud vocals, it is better here, especially the creshendo, they just butchered it in studio, sounds a hundred times better here!

  • @theoneandonly2503

    Yes, it's too bad the TV broadcast edit version of this was so botched..

    I'm so glad I was able to post this and share with everyone..

    Btw, Fantasia also killed it that nite.. check out my two vids of her songs on my other account (MyExclusiveVideos account)

    Regards, Lauri

  • I watched this on tv and this video doesn't give J Hud her dues. She tore it up!!

  • was ok need more from her thank you tasia prove that she is best right now

  • Sorry her renditions did nothing for me.. She didn't even do the signature whoooo's patti does in over the rainbow.. I have never like J.Hud that much...no versatility to me...she hit the high g wayyyy to early on over the rainbow...i just didn't like it...sorry...nobody can do Patti songs really because patti just sings in a way that is just really hard to keep up with.

  • @pattifan Jenny has skills but I guess Patti is just on another level,she did ok maybe its the quality of the video...

  • @ThaWiseJester that didn't help your right lol...but I saw it when it aired and I was hardly impressed she is a good singer but Stir it up was an awful choice for her imo.

  • @leshager2009 Maybe if you had a brain you would realize she did this live without any practice and Patti had hers recorded and was singing longer than Jennifer at the point she recorded this. It is tough for someone like Jennifer that is in demand so much for her voice and only fresh on the scene. Everything takes time and it is not like the watered down bullshit like beyonce, ashanti, magic in the recording studio covering their bad voices.

  • This is the vrsion of the song that I'm use to. I know the other version too but I have just heard the other version to.

  • Why does it seem like she's trying too hard???m She did the same thing in dreamgirls. Her and Joss Stone both do too much by trying to sound soulful.

  • There should be a BHC4 with Jennifer singing Stir it Up.

  • I'm writing that sheet music now

  • jennifer hudson has been blessed with a powerful soulful voice she can sing anything.

  • please I think she sang "Stir it up" better than Patti! I may be in the minority but Jennifer had a different forceful tone on the song that delivered (IMO) the song better.

  • actually, I retract.... it's a damn good version of an absolutely difficult song

  • not quite Patti quality 'though, is it????

  • any body have the video for this?

  • There are several postings of the video clips of these two songs from the BET and WGN broadcasts of the UNCF Patti LaBelle Tribute - just do searches and you'll find them here on YouTube.

  • Sing Jenni!

  • u go jenny in sum parts it looked like u was not even singing it just looked like u were just saying words an dat makes u look good go jhud jhud fan to da max

  • That's not nice, but thanks for your comment.

  • Are u even serious? Get a grip.

  • I love J. Hud. She's were it's at right now. Mandown!!!!

  • There is a little x on the upper right hand side of your screen...use it. Well at least consider that before being so rude. With the greatest respect, if you dislike her talent, then so be it...but rudeness? UNCALLED FOR.

  • she should definitely fire her stylist. fantasia sounded great and had the crowd rocking!!!

  • Jennifer does come off wrong to a lot of people.

  • They both will be around a long time.

  • How can you be soooo heartless to say that about someone's family...you are sick!

  • yea you def nailed it right on the head. jennifer hudson is waaaayyy better than fabntasia. take away the oscars n grammys n u still have a modern patti labelle. its pretty funny when patti herself tells people how incredible jhuds voice is. where is fantasia right now? prolly tryna get rid of that bad case of larymngitis shes had since......was it 04? when she was first seen in the public eye?....jhud is#1 keep trucking boo!

  • Well if Im crazy then so are millions of people out there who belive FANTASIA IS THE TRUTH. And of course its very noticeable with every performance Fantasia gives. Why do you think the crowd is always on their feet when she sings or performs? Sorry cant say the same for JHUD. And based on Jhud poor album sales a lot of people agree with me SHE BARELY MADE GOLD. Fantasia 1st studio album was already 3 xs platinum in 4 months. So yeah Ill be crazy

  • i agree 100% fantasia is great i think she just need better writers and marketing management. Plus the girl can actually sing live. Jhud does a lot of screaming. Someone should tell her that every song is not suppose to be song like And I am telling u.

  • I think they both did a great job!!! DESIDES Patti enjoyed both of them the most so i think all in all it was great!! I loove them all!!

  • I was lucky enough to be at this extraordinary show and recorded this and every performance of the evening on a great little digital recorder..

    I'm so glad that you all are loving this and the other audio files.. Thanks again to the generous Jojo from Atlanta who turned my audio files into videos!

    And since they cut off Fantasia's version of "Somebody Loves You" on the TV broadcast, you can hear the whole amazing song (as well as others that didn't make it) on my audio recording...

    Enjoy!

  • @MyExclusiveVideos Did Beyonce Perform?

  • Sorry but both of these performances were not good. Just because a person has a "BIG" voice does not mean that have a "Good" one she needs to learn more control. She becomes FLAT too often then not. She need vocal training. FANTASIA IS MUCH BETTER with her delivery, stage presence and of COURSE HER VOCALS ARE BETTER. Which is why Fantasia won American Idol.

  • I liked Fantasia better. Her delivery is excellent. Jennifer has a great voice, but she comes across as a little boring on stage. I guess after Fantasia ripped shit up, what else can you do... You can't just stand there... People want to hear you sing, but they also want to see you PERFORM....in my opinion, she chopped up the notes in Over the Rainbow. She could have done that better. Was a little disappointed...

  • jennifer has alot of control her and fantasia has to diffrent types of voice both of them will be around for awhile , i just want to to knw can u sing half as good as these women why u posting your native comments

  • If you can read, I clearly stated that both of them can SING. In my OPINION, Fantasia was better. Her DELIVERY was better. Hopefully, they both will be around for awhile. To answer question, Yes, I CAN SING...You don't have a CLUE of who this is. This conversation with you is OVER.

    Have a blessed evening.

  • I won't fight you on the performance part. Jenny's still learning to get really comfortable on stage - not everybody is a natural like Fantasia. Patti didn't really start getting down (like she's famous for) until welllll into her career w/ Labelle.

    But please don't be fooled Ms. Hudson is a legend in the making.

  • I enjoy them both. In concert, people come to SEE you as well as HEAR you... I wish the both of them well in all of their musical endeavors. Jhud can sing, but Fantasia can Sing and Perform.

  • I saw her performances the other day when it aired. Jennifer butchered Somewhere Over The Rainbow. She needs to be coached. She still hasn't learned how to use that big ole voice of hers.

  • You are tripping! After listening to her sing this...I can definitely hear that her voice is maturing and has more control than it did in the idol days!

  • GREAT JOB!!!!

  • Took me to church with that one.

  • was this recent or is it old?

  • Sept. '08-Oct. '08, before her family tragedy...it's just airing now.

  • it was taped in sept. of 08

  • She has such a strong voice

  • SHE IS GOOD EHHHH? SO AWESOME, MY IDOL SANGIN LIKE NEVA B4.... wait she has but u get it right? LOL! GO JENNIFER!!!!

  • Good LAWD! This heffa sung this!! DAMN!!!

  • LOVE JENNIFER!!!

  • Amazing job!

  • WORK WORK WORK!!! I'm so proud of her...sing through the grief, baby! Make 'em proud in heaven!

  • i know, that was the same thing my cousin and i said last night when we watched on b.e.t. together last night. she did a good job on those songs that she sang! she's another one that puts feelins/emotions into her songs as well as Fantasia.

  • This event took place before the tragic murders, early Sept. I believe.

    "Somewhere Over the Rainbow" =SPECTACULAR!!

  • She brought tears to my eyes..this woman has so much talent!

  • LOL!!!

  • I saw it tonight; Jen killed it.

  • I know she took me in!!!

  • where's the real video

  • Yeah Jennifer is greatness!!! She can in fact control her voice really well, it shows here. She has a BIG amazing instrument LOL

  • Just watched it. J-Hud is AWESOME!!!!

  • It's on now! "Stir It Up" was flat, and uninspired. I'm sure the other performance is better.

  • I enjoy Jennifer Hudson, but she doesn't always "Nail It"

    INDEED, "STIR IT UP" was flat as day old beer.

    Period...

  • DON'T THE old beer or THE KARAOKE KOOL-AID!!!

  • I just seen the show and Jenny sang the hell out of "somwhere over the rainbow" WOW!!!

  • SINNG ITTT STUPIDDDDDDDDDD!!!

  • Amazing...she even did the ascending Glissando at the end that patti is famous for!!! WOW

  • Jennifer did her thing. Just wonderful!

    You go girl!

  • Im not a big fan of "Stir It Up'..but she really does a good jjob on this. She makes it interesting enuf to listen to and she doesnt over sing it. But she absolutely burned, "Somewhere Over the Rainbow", to ashes. And we all know its not easy to sing it like Patti can...

  • She is a very good singer.

  • I do not want to get into a back and forth thing on here. You have your opinion and I respect that and I have my opinion please respect that. I call it screaming you call it belting. Yes there are a lot of great singers who belt or scream, call it what you want. As far as I need to learn something about music honey, that is so uncalled for. You know nothing about me. As always be blessed, safe and stress free VizionaryVideoz and everyone else.

  • She sings over the top like Patti. Most black female singers scream and shout and that is what they call singing. It is about who can scream and sing over each other. Look at Fantasia, Chaka, Whitney, Natalie, Patti, Aretha. They all scream and shout. And they are all considered some of the best singers. I am black so this is not a race thing. It is just a style and the way most black female singers sing.

  • Learn something about music Honey, all races do "scream" and BTW it's belting not screaming...Belting and high chest notes are not screams

  • It's not screaming Honey..Learn something about music..those are belts and high chest notes...it has nothing to do with race..Christina, celine, and even Barbra Streisand

  • Stir it up Jen!

  • i don't understand, why would they wait this long to show this on tv.

  • I can't wait to see this show!!!!

  • She may be LOUD and that's because her voice is so POWERFUL but it is still on a MUSICAL level! AMAZING!! ***** =)

  • After hearing that, I'm laughing when I think about the fact that some Beyonce fan dare to say that Jennifer don't control her voice!

  • Comment removed

  • she tore up Somewhere over the rainbow. Damn she did it like Patti! Absolutely a master class in vocal control and just old fashion Mahalia Jackson soul! Seriously tore it up! Gave me chills and blew me away...

  • beyonce would be next in line after yolanda,fantasia,and jennifer.

  • well, they got some chicks, in Yolanda, Fantasia and Jennifer to really sing these songs like they're supposed to be sung. These are really 3 of the only chicks that I think could have sung these particular tunes, in the same key with the same fierceness that Patti used to in her prime. Jennifer did a great job, here. Im sure Patti got up out of her seat for this one...you gotta sing these songs like Patti would have, or you should just leave the microphone alone.

  • I love jen and fantasia, but you can not compare the two. Jen is a powerful singer and tasia is a powerful singer in her own right. I just can not wait to see this on tv. Jen sang the hell out of somewhere over the rainbow. love it love it love it!!!!!!!

  • Tasia was the better of the two during AI. But, what nobody can deny is that when comparing "AI Jhud" and Jhud today--the progression is absolutely mind boggling & she wasn't a joke back then. What folks who talk about her being "loud" or having "pitch problems", don't understand is when the girl opens her mouth--fans don't care about her volume, pitch, dancing, dress etc. All we want is for her to not stop and that's the true appreciation of a music fan.

  • yassss u r so damn rite omg

  • If Jennifer ever reads these posts, I want her to know that everybody is still praying for her and her family. I can't imagine what she is going through.

  • Too Loud?Plzzz don't compare her to Fantasia, she can blow her out of the water everytime,we all know Jennifer should have win AI!

  • I used to think that way, but Fantasia is def better...

    I luv Jennifer too, but Fantasia got some major pipes.

  • Some people act like that American Idol season was close. It wasn't. Fantasia stood out from the beginning, and ran circles around everybody.

  • Fantasia was the best by far! And thats saying alot when u have Latoya, Jennifer, and George in the game! they got kicked off way to early, but in the end the right person won!

  • not trying to compare but joss stone also did a good job on this song with a duet with patti labelle

  • SING WOMAN!!!!

  • NO NO....SANG WOMAN!!!!!

  • Amazing...she even did the ascending Glissando at the end that patti is famous for!!! WOW

  • Good performance, not her best though.

  • We are all sending our prayers and love to Jennifer in these sad and challenging times of her awful loss..

    May she and her surviving family and friends find grace, blessings and compassion in the days to come...

  • I liked it

  • Patti Labelle is my ultimate favorite singer, I have started loving Jennifer hudson apparently my gilr Patti loves her just as well, cause did'nt she request for her to be one of the ones to sang for her show?

  • SANG Jenni! =)

  • J-Hud betta do it.

  • ha ha u just gotta luv her

  • I love it a whole lot better than the songs she did last year, but i just wish she could have sang a little softer at the beginning and built her way up to belting...it would have made a more whole performance. But she did well...

  • very pretty!!

  • LOL!!!

  • You can say what you want about Jennifer, she's a GREAT belter but she will never have the VOICE CONTROLL Patti and FANTASIA has!! SORRY, I love you I do, but No Mame!

  • Hopefully, with time, she will develop better voice control. Doesn't she look gorgeous in those two pictures?

  • she doesn't need patti's or tasia's control, she IS jennifer, she is unique and she does jennifer quite well, she needs not to be anyone else

  • Jennifer is tearing it up and doesn't have to get back for NO one.

  • y r u on her page and at her concerts if shes so disappointing ? sound like you r a fan but in some serious denial. get off her page then! dah

  • Comparisons between Fantasia and Jennifer are really NOT in spirit of this UNCF Tribute to Patti LaBelle... Patti's graciousness and sincere appreciation of ALL the performers who honored her will be obvious when everyone watches the broadcast on Jan. 24 & 25...

    For now, please just enjoy ALL the audio files I've posted with the generous help of Jojo in Atlanta, who (in the spirit of everyone helping out!) contacted me and offered to turn my audio files into videos - Thanks again, Jojo!

  • THANK YOU for this comment. I watched the UNCF Tribute to Patti LaBelle (as I watch ALL UNCF broadcasts) and they were both great. Patti enjoyed them both and the entire program was awesome! Bottom Line...we all have our preferences and there's no need for the comparisons and nasty comments passed back and forth. (I'll probably receive a nasty comment for saying that) but, oh well.

  • Please STOP this comparison mess,this is immature and utterly ridiculous,if you did not attend then you don't know,wait until it airs and then judge that is the wise thing to do, but children genrally don't have wisdom or use it!!Bless you!!

  • oh,did shereally!!!! I wish youcould have attended is all I can say.Keep hating Tasia we understand.

  • jennifer hudson proved to everybody over and over again she is a beast she redeemed herself from the aretha franklin performance shout to J hudson

  • that aretha franklin tribute was a hot mes at times, but she sounds really good here

  • By the way not meaning to offend anyone but it is basically young people who have to realize Fantasia is not just a singer but a perfromer,entertainer. Something that is far and few between,and many of you young folks don't get her because she is from another time.

  • jeniferrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr­rrrrrr is sangin her assest off........

  • STRAIGHT FROM HEAVEN!!

    LORD this girl can SAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAANG!

  • STRAIGHT from H-E-DOUBLE-HOCKEY-STICKS!!!

  • This chick can sing!!!!!!!!!!!

  • that's one of the most impressive vocals i've heard in my life

  • Amazing...she even did the ascending Glissando at the end that patti is famous for!!! WOW

  • The Power in her voice is unbelievable.

  • The Greatest Singer Of This Generation =) nuff said

  • Yeah RIGHT!!!! Can you say FANTASIA.

  • I can .. Fantasia

  • Well, you should know that Jennifer is simply no a better singer. I attended two of Jennifer's concerts and each time I left sorely disappointed.

  • umm whatever you say .. I like them both, so not to be rude but just honest, I could care less about that last comment .. but thanks for your opinion .. have a nice weekend

  • I was wondering when someone would tell the truth,because this first song????IDK

    Love Jennifer though.

  • We love you Jennifer.

  • NEGRO U BETTA SANG!

  • Sing Jenny!!!

  • Click on "more info" in upper right box to get all the details about this amazing evening!

    And to hear more audio files from that Tribute to Patti LaBelle, click on link on right which says:

    "More From: MyExclusiveVideos", which is where we're posting all of them.

    Enjoy!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more