Red Dead Redemption: Hero vs. Outlaw

[Boogla19981]

If you want to have fun put in some cheats and it wont save then be an outlaw, then next time you go on you will be right where you left off.

[XxBE4STxJKFxX]

well if you people want to be a hero and outlaw just do this....

singleplayer-hero

multiplayer-outlaw

this way you get to be john marston play through the story as a hero and do all the other shit you can do in singleplayer (besides killing)and play the multiplayer as an outlaw,form gangs or paussies,and kill people(because it just makes more sense)

[eurokevin5]

1.14. You have to buy that safehouse :D

[ThemanwhokilledChuck]

lol hero is broke

[ADN307]

it was hard to be bad cus when u do missions or bounties u get honor and its annoing

[ChocolateAndJelly123]

I SAVE A GAME BEING GOOD, AND A GAME BEING BAD, THERE, PROBLEM SOLVED!

[SlyTheGod999]

"Hero! How about hero! Let's be a hero"

*shoots lady in the head*

[flybirdefly]

@Gamb1000 LOL EXACTLY! i'm gonna make 2 profiles good, were i save them back and forth (just in case i mess up.) and have one account that is just for fun to kill everyone :D RDR for the win!

[thecrackisalie]

I can't play the outlaw when I'm John Marston. I just... I just can't.

It feels wrong, considering everything he does is for the sake of reuniting with his family and giving them all a fresh start. It's like I'm spitting on his grave or something. :/

[Reyzoom]

or you make 3 saves, hero, outlaw, nobody ( nobody as in you dont care what side your on

[Reyzoom]

i became a hero, if i wanted to rob, kill, and other things i justed put on the bandana, but i might become a outlaw, i dont know

[AFO6919]

outlaw 

[mudgeon1]

just put on the bandana then you dont have to chose

[toredtobluetoblack]

MARIO VS MASTER CHIEF

[TheSuperhoppin]

wtf the anotations say i can only vote for outlaw this thing is riged

[TheWallinator74]

Outlaw.

[Number4Crow]

The Hero has way better perks then the outlaw,you can get shit cheaper and peaple let you commit crimes, the outlaw horse is a horses ass and you have to pay more for shit

[RedDeadRedemptionROX]

how about 3 profiles? hero, outlaw and cheats ;)

[NICKREAPER316]

Am I the only one that prefers playing as a hero?

[tyler10274]

Hero, you don't get shot at you get discounts and you still get to dispense your own style of dat der' frontier justice :P

[cambohoo16]

@tyler10274 outlaw at one point the police wont follow you you get a special horse and also discounts out of fear

[BOBMARLYRULZdontwory]

hahahaha he just point blank popped her in the face

[TheEZ130]

it wont let me vote

[linkinparkrulz4life1]

i go for hero

[APooOnAStick]

The game gives you good honour for everything. No matter who hard I try, I always seem to be good in the end.

[xURSCREWED299x]

I have 2 saves on Red Dead Redemption, one is the good guy save and the other is the bad guy save. Ah, fun times..

[altairdamasco]

the right side of the screen is the right way to go

[151hobbes]

well i just play the way i would react. i save someone and he repays me by stealing then i shoot him. that simple. if a woman being bate for a bunch of thugs of her own will well she get shot to bad. cold hearted person here. mess with me i mess with you...

[jfsl98]

@DeathStarCommander that's why he raised at the end of undead nightmare

[empxephos]

I love how he got +5 fame for shooting the woman in the face....such sexism

[horseboyken]

I always go 'Hero" I never even tried being bad

[buzzmaster3D]

HERO

[reliy31]

Outlaw



[XxNiggasBeHatinxX]

''Turns on Xbox 360 and puts RDR on and becomes a hero'' ''Goes to cementery and says sorry'' ''Goes to hideouts'' Hero to the END!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[sithico]

i like both someone pisses me off i become the outlaw and blow them away with the shotgun,but if a civilian is getting mugged i will act to beat the mugger's ass

[BrynC67]

Hahaha there wont be no nookkie for the marston pmsl :L

[delgado4652]

I lost at poker and lost all my chips...that's when i decided to kill that bastard Herbert and become an outlaw!! :D

[lankinator24]

OR...make two game saves! When you're bored of being a Deadly Assassin, go to the other save and be a US Marshal!

[lankinator24]

being an outlaw can get old after a while

[Happyface191992]

I'm a hero right now and trying to find the best way to become outlaw. I beat the story mode and pure good and i need some tips on how to become evil (Outlaw) easy.

[lankinator24]

@Happyface191992 go to thieve's landing and just keep killing. Crack safes in Blackwater and kill all the police.

[kimmiecase]

@Happyface191992 keep on killin jackin horsis and killing peppol and killing police 

[MegaRedzed]

HERO

[MultiKnull]

Hero....You get discounts everywhere and you wont get that stupid slow horse you get when you are desperado

[daani1414]

@mayorbee2 nothing

[MrJaimemart]

i think is better to do a outlaw acc and a hero acc

[13sim19]

theres only voting for the outlaw

[Jaysmemories]

Be the bad guy, and dont get far enough to save your family. Just fuck shit up!

[hiuho2547]

I can't choose "hero"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[soefhweuihsusd]

John - Hero

Jack - Outlaw

[DoomRaider122112]

I cant click on the right!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[lupaguy]

only chuck norris decides whether your a hero or an outlaw

[sammoTboy11]

Freaking hero till the end! You get discounts at stores, and people like..recognize you and appreciate you whenever you're in towns, also its cool to read about yourself in the papers!

[majorkrieg]

@sammoTboy11 If you kill a man in "The Prohibitionist" stranger mission, you get discounts in certain places, but if you warn the man, saving his life, the prices in those places get doubled... And about the discounts at stores, well if I'm not wrong, you can get the same discounts if you have low honor as if you have highest.

So, as the other guy said, OUTLAWS TO THE END!

[tyler10274]

@majorkrieg  low honor has 1 discount store at Thieve's Landing and ALL other stores double their prices o even run out of the store the second you go in. High honor gives discounts everywhere except Thieve's(Bias to heroism imo)

[grizzlegod]

be a hero until u get the bandana then you can be both :)

[Ncs666]

Tying hookers to train tracks is just too fun...

[MrNinjanaut]

one side lets u pick flowers for old men, and one side lets you tie hookers to train tracks... hmm... tough one..

[megaspartan100]

when i was john before he was killed i was a hero because that was what john wanted to be, when i became jack i just killed anyone and everyone for jack's revenge

[SKM2411]

there is no hero link

[blipp27]

I started being good but i was like nahh bad is way more fun :)

[GaMeSkZeRo]

Outlaw Forget Being A Hero

[Cosmickillercon232]

it wouldn't let me vote for hero lol

[DippersandSmiles]

@Cosmickillercon232 cause you are late.

[ThyrsoidMoe117]

I just use my bandanna to pose as a hero....

[xXPRicanFinestXz]

red dead redemption is kinda like the metal gear solid series it kinda "forces" you too be specific hideo kojima admitted it mgs wants u to not get alarms and kills while rdr kinda gives u more hero options

[Mrjay1134]

outlaw all the way

[wescomark65]

I ussually be good as Marston then when I beat the game I be an Outlaw with Jack :)

[TheBattlefield10]

2:12 if he shot that women she did a rotate :D thumb up if you saw that

[Tahlia350]

LOL you can only click outlaw

[alkomaple1]

alan wake is finnish game and i'm made in finland LOL

[DreamStepper]

most of the time if you help the bandits they still shoot you

[Beej224]

Clint Eastwood's character "Blondie" or the "man with no name" wasn't bad.

[TheJpsteven]

outlaws



[retrogamer2007452]

the entire concept for these versus videos are fucking stupid. They just talk about video game characters and pick the more popular one.

[bb8497]

I like being an outlaw more because it's funner but being a hero is like better for you...

[66bb99qq]

i like the horse you get when you reach the lowest possible honor

[Todd6794]

"Oh hey honey, I just put a woman on the train tracks to get 5 gamerscore"

[Am4EyS1nqxX]

hero is better the people loves me :D and you can be an outlaw when you had scarf

[URINALSKILLZ]

be both

[Yodio12]

hey honey! I just tied up a woman and put her on the train tracks for 5 gamer score points. XD

[NightFall845]

can some help me? i was a hero and i wannted to be an outlaw, so i started killing cops and i think i got to the max of my low honor it says Desperado and when im killing more cops the honor dosent go any lower is something wrong?

[thundara32]

@NightFall845 you're at the lowest honor.it doesnt go any lowrer cus of that.

[jgardstein]

you should shorten your interduction is so long its like 45 seconds

[GuitarShredder1854]

u can get it for 10 in chuporoso too i think

[PlayItRough09]

CHUCK NORRIS vs. BRUCE LEE!!!!!

[feelinf1ne]

@PlayItRough09

didnt know they had games?....

[PlayItRough09]

@feelinf1ne

They do movies aswell

[feelinf1ne]

@PlayItRough09

lol its hard to recognize sarcasm on youtube

[PlayItRough09]

@feelinf1ne

yes "sarcasm" lol

[2WorldWar2]

i cant fuckin be bad sometimes i try but i just like being a good guy and hearing people chear for you and stuff when u save their life. and i feel bad to do wat he did at 2:14 ... he shoots the poor lady in the face after she has her hands up on her knees :/

[jamesundeee]

Lol, I forgot I had the Bandana, had it equipt for 75% of the game and never got any honor. I had no Idea

[metaknight234]

In the time you gave us to click it you couldve jsut givin us the results in this video. It would've saved the trouble of editing an extra episode just for the results.

[redlilsleepy1]

how u get the bandana

[rambo7567]

@redlilsleepy1 you buy it in theives landing tailor

[verminslayer]

LOL he shot that woman right in the face. Cold killa

[JAMamation]

Hero. But id o like being a drifter like Eastwood.

Remember folks, Eastwood gave Norris permission to be badass.

[Chiller295]

Kratos (God of War) vs. The Aprentice (Force Uleashed)

Both have Full powers and all their weapons.

[koukouroukou12345]

that hey at the beginning was so annoying lol

[MrBloggo]

video starting :HEY!! Th-

Me : AAAA

[xxlittlenoob]

Butt Plugs?

[liLLiPaDDy]

there'll be no more nooky for the Marsten

lol

[Iamthtrandomguy]

just flag rummys comment



[HFKZikoavich]

Chuck Norris should be in Red Dead Redemption!

[benjijackxxx]

@HFKZikoavich Your absoloutly right ! roflmaochopper

[MrHerrowDer]

i started off good, then i lost my way and slaughter people !

[trtrea]

I only shoot people during missions or if there are bandits then when theres one left he get on his knees and I pop him in the face.

[xXJack214Xx]

@rummy12399 yeah um you see.. if i hadn't already finished the game i would be really pissed off with you so please don't fucking spoil the end cuz im sure there are lots of people who want to actually find it out by themselves ;) just saying

[aaronbxiii]

@rummy12399 LOL!

[Agent47Hit]

@rummy12399 fuck u spoiled me goddammit!

[CoolAlliki]

@rummy12399 You sir, just ruined at least 50 peoples lives. Awesome.

[devilkid151]

I want to be an outlaw/hero like Alan and hsi dog xD

Thumbs up?

[TheGostofSparta]

Hero because the stores are open and people are friendly and you don't have to worry about the law. Win!

[NoMidsForMe]

@TheGostofSparta but if your bad the law doesnt have to worry about you

[MrLuke4me]

i be hero just cause i have pity for some of the people...but id be happy to tie up a couple of bandits or drunks with my lasso and burn them a molotov...i only killing the bad or uselss people ;P

[TheManiac205]

OUTLAWS TO THE END!!!!!!!

[Thawvideos]

@TheManiac205 Bad boyz  4 life

[EyeProbablyNeedHelp]

Is Rob Talbert DJ Keemstar???

[JustSayin07]

outlaw is better... you get a horse that came out from hell literally

[legofan1006]

will you do a mario galaxy one?

[brandon052695]

OUT FUCKING LAW BABY!!!!!

[azerskater]

OUTLAW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[impopinyourdropin]

lol "Moral thing to do, kids!" *shoots girl in face*

[tomakin11]

jonh dies

[Pala16123z0r]

Getting it tomorrow... MAYBE... Here in Denmark it's sold out EVERYWHERE! :O So annoying >.<

[loading08]

john marston is not good nor bad he doesnt help anyone only himself

[DeadSarow]

@loading08 And how is that? He constantly saves the lives of hookers, mexicans, and officials. I'm guessing you haven't done much playing.

[grassman2k8]

lmao how the person representing good says bad is better

[hitmansam37]

wow

[shawnz64]

Yeeeees. Finnaly I can kill those stupid whores without one pulling out a cell phone and ruining the fun.

[djzombieking]

i did the trophy on ps3 that you need to put a women/men on the rails but i dont have the throphy!!!!!

[yaj16yaj]

LOCKERZ.com is a legit website(CEO was former vice pres of amazon.com) that gives prizes (i.e. iPods, PSPs, shirts, etc.) for FREE to its members, they earn ptz through watching vids and answering questions called dailies and even by logging in. but the only way to join is to get invited, so msg me ur e-mail account, and i'll send u an invite. thanks. I ASSURE YOU THIS IS 100% TRUE!

[FXIX]

Outlaw gonna be fun, but it makes you feel evil which motivate you to be hero first instead :(

[thanx4life]

i have a question... does the saving system work like GTA? like... several slots to save your game in?

another thing is: at the end of the game can you roam aroiund? i mean... you dont die do you?

[TheHeyZeus]

@thanx4life You can roam around..

[ListenSilently]

The sex argument convinced me of the hero side

[razzereful]

i use a bandana

[kevynspeed]

i only be an outlaw when i put on my bandanna, so i dont ruin my fame and honor

[xXKaM1KaZe]

The game is called red dead REDEMPTION! You almost have to be good.

[L4ionh4rt]

what about the perks you get for being good / evil?

[IRAMBOerdei23]

Really do you even become an outlaw because the story line makes you a hero any way, so do you just kill people and not do missions?

[weed4today]

these guy didn't list the perks that come with good or bad if your good everything is cheaper your wanted is half off what it would normaly be if your bad poeple will not report your for anything list than murder and a black horse will could at your call but everything is like three times as much money too buy

[Dominater521]

@weed4today except at theieves landing you get a discount there

[XxSp3EdYxX]

yo you guys should do a jak vs ratchet Versus

[ninjasinmyhat]

This game is great, amazing even, but with story missions, you really don't get a choice (I didn't finish the game so correct me if I'm wrong). Most of the story missions that I've done only give you +Honor, and there's never really a choice whether to do something good or bad. The only times I've seen this are with random encounters and stranger missions.

[Cazrick13]

awesome conan reference

[oL0MAXv]

RED DEAD

[SegaSunnyD]

theres an achivement in the game called damsel in distress it wheres you hog tie a girl and put her on train tracks and...... well you know, no hero comes to save her

[onecrazehmofo]

@SegaSunnyD its definitely called dastardly dumb ass

[SegaSunnyD]

@onecrazehmofo well srry i dont own the game it was at a friends house im not a game nerd (and yea it was in the vid but i commented first)

[carlitocoolio]

@SegaSunnyD its called dastardly

[SegaSunnyD]

@carlitocoolio um i alredy know that now cant you read past comments and no need for anyone to get all worked up cuz someone got something wrong

[Freekietime]

Just become a hero and whenever you want to rob people or anything, just equip your bandana (only $25 at the tailor in Thieve's landing) which hides your identity and prevents honor and fame from changing.

[runestarbrawler]

@Freekietime ohhh thats why i wasnt getting fame/honor

[Ps3COD4Fan]

@runestarbrawler LOL fail.. oh and how do u put the bandana on?

[runestarbrawler]

@Ps3COD4Fan you gotta go into the inventory or watever

and press equip/unquip

[azerskater]

@Freekietime I like being a badguy. It's awesome to see people cower from you.

[Freekietime]

@azerskater true but they also cower for you when you're wearing a bandana :P

[psicoskull]

@Freekietime exactly what i did, who wants to be a outlaw when you can be a hero while burning towns????

[MrLAG95]

What if you guys did a battle of between Halo Reach Beta and MW2 multiplayer? I mean each is an epic online experiance, why not let the veiwers decid. And just another suggestion, Reach vs. HAlo 3. I know the first isn't out yet, but when it is see who the fans stand by in the end.

[shrector123]

@MrLAG95 wow you sir are a person with taste and don't relies that there only point shoot games nothing more

[MrShinsengumi09]

I havent played this gasme yet, but I REALLY want to. That Said, I would probably play as a hero, seeing as how there are notorious villains in the real wild west, but not many famous heroes of the wild west. plus, heroes get the ladies

[GearHawkAccel]

HERO in the first time playing the story and free roaming OUTLAW ON THE SECOND TIME PLAYING THE HISTORY AND IN THE FREE ROAM! MUAHAHAHAHAHA!

[BowserRTR]

I have a suggestion for a Versus video. Prince of Persia(Old Prince) vs Prince of Persia (New Prince)

[blackmarvel94941]

lol i think im gonna be a hero when i get tha game

[manonthemoon5210]

indeed buttsex



[zzzIdividedbyzerozzz]

Hero for the main story... with outlaw deeds on the side.

[theevilm1]

um. . . Butt Sex?

[withafork01]

@theevilm1 ha ha ha lol

[iHyperPinoy]

@theevilm1 indeed

[spongeaang98]

Good, because this game punishes you more for being bad.