I'm a huge fan of Jon Brion and all his underscores, this being my favorite one. So soulful and beautiful. this is amazing, i love it! if anyone can spare literally 1 minute to see what I did with the original, please search Newman - Row. Thank you!! -god bless
How happy is the blameless vessel's lot? The world forgetting by the world forgot. Eternal sunshine of the spotless mind. Each prayer excepted, and each wish resigned.
@MrHathouse and that is why (or should i say that is the "reason" ;) i changed to ableton live! much more possibilities to alter samples and even warp them very accurate without having to use another program like reason recycle.
@rubyruby777 Ah right. Yeah I use cubase and I'm constantly annoyed that they haven't implemented a similar feature to reason's quantise audio thingumy. Doing it manually takes hours!
Whilst folks are free to dis/like this song, the 'oh the original row is soft' crit bothers me. Dudes, it's a REMIX. That's the point. Remixes are -meant- to be a new take on a song, or show it in a different way; the original soft Row still exists, the remix has 'taken' it away in any real sense. As it stands, I am all for adding the drum's beat, and drums -- what I do think this remix lacked was a bit 'more'. It's hard to articulate, but it feels like a nice draft rather than final version.
I like it. except in the middle when everything else stops. and then comes back in. its too rough of a transition. but that beat really sounds well everywhere else
I love the original so much.. however, I do think this is equally amazing. I dont think the addition of drums or harmonica or whatever ruins the song; if anything it compliments it. Well done :)
Although it fits the song, but it kills it. The beauty of the song is the beautiful solo piano, it simple & meaningful. By adding stuff to it you tend to distract people from the best part.
There's not much variation in the song, just the same 1, 2, 3, 4 and so on.. kinda boring. Need some detours! Not knockin em but maybe that's just his style. Jus sayn
Pretty decent. I prefer the original though. Adding drums takes away from the simplicity of a single piano playing - which is what makes "row" so beautiful.
I beg to differ. That's why the origional version is also available on youtube. You clicked on this video expecting a remix I presume. I did. Very nice mix, 5 stars.
I did expect a remix, and I heard one. Hence my review and opinion during my previous comment. I never said it was bad - I simply said I prefer the original. Everyone has their own opinion.
whatbrains: yeah, if you see it in the context of the film, it's unbelievable. There's more going on there; little children are singing "row row row your boat" over it, and it's raining, and it's...beautiful.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Hey I was drunk and wanted to be a slighty retarded post-drunk-commentor which everyone else is on youtube. Not alot of comments make sense here, neither does mine.. Or yours.
im quite possibly going to listen to this very often, it would be nice to have it on my iPod too. Does the user have plans for making this downloadable? I would most definitely pay $.99 for this, well done rubyruby777!
It really bugs me that it seems all the people who dislike this remix are getting thumbs down. Why?
For example, I don't think it's unreasonable for them to be really uncomfortable with the drums - the song was constructed to have a soft legato feel that's completely undermined by the sharper staccato nature of adding in a freaking drum.
But, many are subconsciously convinced that anything about eternal sunshine is automatically fantastic. YES I LOVED THE ORIGINAL, but this remix fell short.
The drums are awful. It would sound so much better and more fitting had the snare been hit only at the third beat. This is too funky for such a pretty pianotrack.
The original is so basic and simple that you can't make a remix without adding something. I think this one turned out quite nice.
VirusSI 1 month ago
I think it was good, but the original is always better.
crishellreads 2 months ago
best achievement of the remix is the extension of the original song which is too short
edan305 2 months ago
I'm a huge fan of Jon Brion and all his underscores, this being my favorite one. So soulful and beautiful. this is amazing, i love it! if anyone can spare literally 1 minute to see what I did with the original, please search Newman - Row. Thank you!! -god bless
nuevohombre92 4 months ago
How happy is the blameless vessel's lot? The world forgetting by the world forgot. Eternal sunshine of the spotless mind. Each prayer excepted, and each wish resigned.
ScaryThingsGoRAWR 4 months ago
This is good! :)
PianosBestFriend 6 months ago
Bearing in mind that you managed to get a time sync in reason I salute you! I think that's one of reason's weakest features....
MrHathouse 7 months ago
@MrHathouse and that is why (or should i say that is the "reason" ;) i changed to ableton live! much more possibilities to alter samples and even warp them very accurate without having to use another program like reason recycle.
rubyruby777 7 months ago
@rubyruby777 Ah right. Yeah I use cubase and I'm constantly annoyed that they haven't implemented a similar feature to reason's quantise audio thingumy. Doing it manually takes hours!
MrHathouse 7 months ago
Everyone wants to be a critic... It's great.
DavidDaveson 7 months ago
You should haev EQ'd the piano so the higher end of freqs dont swamp with the snare or high hats.
themuffintree101 8 months ago
drums are loud . . . but it still sounds nice.
original is better , but i enjoy this :]
beckyluv15 9 months ago
Whilst folks are free to dis/like this song, the 'oh the original row is soft' crit bothers me. Dudes, it's a REMIX. That's the point. Remixes are -meant- to be a new take on a song, or show it in a different way; the original soft Row still exists, the remix has 'taken' it away in any real sense. As it stands, I am all for adding the drum's beat, and drums -- what I do think this remix lacked was a bit 'more'. It's hard to articulate, but it feels like a nice draft rather than final version.
ohthesovietkitsch 9 months ago
Nice :)
do you like my version?
I made it with FL Studio.I didn't use any samples from the original...I have replayed the main tune with a vst. :)
gfx909 9 months ago
could i use this beat an freestyle to it?
love it if u can get bk to me n the folowing week
wamla12 11 months ago
Can I download this on itunes?
lidiluvu 11 months ago
the drums fit nicely, however, it now sounds just like a really nice track... not absolutely beautiful as it was before
pixithemis 11 months ago
great film thankyou for actuallyu remixing it
mcphee9 11 months ago
Drums are too loud.
audioboxer1 1 year ago 4
This is beautiful.
rasberiez 1 year ago
I like it. except in the middle when everything else stops. and then comes back in. its too rough of a transition. but that beat really sounds well everywhere else
justindavis2012 1 year ago
awesome song, excellent work =)
juancho8710 1 year ago
pretty good, a little rough
mos def covers this song with drums so well
tiffuhny 1 year ago
Personally, I LOVE the remix.
StellaSmithian 1 year ago
i definitely dig this :).
lightthiscity11 1 year ago
Perfect this remix! Reminds me "Looper"... Congratulations!!!
thigoromano 1 year ago
this would sound amazing with as a slow-paced techno remix
sabness69 1 year ago
so down, the drums give it a pulse..FEELING IT
beerdrinker420 1 year ago
I love the original so much.. however, I do think this is equally amazing. I dont think the addition of drums or harmonica or whatever ruins the song; if anything it compliments it. Well done :)
Seabearr 1 year ago
The drums kind of make it sound like a Maroon 5 song. I still like it though.
Fuukuie 1 year ago
i will make a rap for this and show it to you cause i like it it alot :)
djcoreyboi 1 year ago
gotta love it. great song.
MyndiRandomSocks 1 year ago
yeah, the drums sound distracting from soft sound piano
Lazizkhodja 1 year ago
Although it fits the song, but it kills it. The beauty of the song is the beautiful solo piano, it simple & meaningful. By adding stuff to it you tend to distract people from the best part.
slashybluesy 1 year ago 3
sounds good :D
new favorite
CookiesAreStellar 1 year ago
There's not much variation in the song, just the same 1, 2, 3, 4 and so on.. kinda boring. Need some detours! Not knockin em but maybe that's just his style. Jus sayn
popnutty 1 year ago
love it
Siobhananders 1 year ago
accetible
badbehemot 1 year ago
dayum i kinda liked this actually how can i get this instrumental?!
MrFamousAlien 1 year ago
It's raining outside right now :(
TommiiDinosaur45 1 year ago
JMO, it just doesn't sound natural to me, free, but that's just me. He has a feel, but it's seems more apprehensive and slightly contrite.
popnutty 1 year ago
My man Jay Electronica ripped dis sample. Jay Electronica is da future of Hip Hop
Dru912 1 year ago
Liked it, but just sorta lower the volume for the drums so we can hear the piano. That'd be nice.
TehDDC 2 years ago 3
listen to jay electronica
henrybernsen 2 years ago 2
also check the death metal remix version and get it as a ringtone xD
11suedehead11 2 years ago 2
I love the orignial but whenever I hear it now I exspect drums and when I don't' get them I come and listen to this. :] Well done.
SuperSheepskin 2 years ago
Anyone got the midi of this? I need it. Bad :D
FEL1XXRocker 2 years ago
This is good. I love making up remixes in my head when i first hear a song, and this is def what i thought of.. Great fucking movie too. :)
husnbunkr012 2 years ago
Its good if you want to make a 2 pac love song. but couldnt have the same feeling on someone
thelovefornets 2 years ago
Maybe you prefer the drums,
But I feel it ruins the peaceful feeling of the song.
;/
Katowman 2 years ago 3
na bad mate gud remix gud job
mcphee9 2 years ago
I didnt care for the particular drum line. I would have played something different. But still cool. Good job.
1337douchebag 2 years ago
Aus10hxc you are right, not bad at all :)
gugli100 2 years ago
Pretty decent. I prefer the original though. Adding drums takes away from the simplicity of a single piano playing - which is what makes "row" so beautiful.
Aus10hxc 2 years ago 22
I beg to differ. That's why the origional version is also available on youtube. You clicked on this video expecting a remix I presume. I did. Very nice mix, 5 stars.
rabidfish02 2 years ago
I did expect a remix, and I heard one. Hence my review and opinion during my previous comment. I never said it was bad - I simply said I prefer the original. Everyone has their own opinion.
Aus10hxc 2 years ago 8
True, I kind of jumped to a conclusion there. My bad.
rabidfish02 2 years ago
I liked this remix more then the original song, not that the original wasn't beautiful, there just wasn't enough going on to hold your attention.
whatbrains 2 years ago
whatbrains: yeah, if you see it in the context of the film, it's unbelievable. There's more going on there; little children are singing "row row row your boat" over it, and it's raining, and it's...beautiful.
thelavabrothers 2 years ago 2
I know, I've seen it but I'm just talking about the song. Not it's use in the movie. Good thing to point out for people who haven't seen it.
whatbrains 2 years ago
i love this it made my day listening to this hahah
(:
CrazyAsRice 2 years ago
I thought this was really good.
zoethezed 2 years ago
i love you
wattyfatpie 2 years ago 2
whats the bpm on this song?
lkman4 2 years ago
You could make a rap song with this remix: "Yo, meet me in Montauk, n*gger."
Dodec84 2 years ago 2
"Crazy hair dye bitches ... aight ...."
Dodec84 2 years ago 3
"And then some f*cked up n*gger is stealing your ho's panties, you know what i'm sayin'"
Dodec84 2 years ago 4
HAHAHAHAHAH
MissTarick 2 years ago
idk, to be honest the added parts sound too synthetic.
nightre 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
You wanna know what? Honest to God.
This blows, this stinks, this fucking sucks.
You think you can do a masterpiece better with some cheesy computer-drums and whatever else is there. I hope you burn in hell for this.
sickmotherfucker 2 years ago
what's the matter with you?! you don't have to listen to it. just calm down and be easy...
rubyruby777 2 years ago
Cool mix. Any idea how to play on piano? I'd like to learn it
defgmx 2 years ago
wtf is wrong with u!?!?...r u retarded or something?...if u don't like it...then don't listen to it
r13nqb89 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Hey I was drunk and wanted to be a slighty retarded post-drunk-commentor which everyone else is on youtube. Not alot of comments make sense here, neither does mine.. Or yours.
sickmotherfucker 2 years ago
thas not cool, even if you were drunk, thats not a good excuse, dude.
thefridgeigator 2 years ago 2
where can i download this?...this version?
r13nqb89 2 years ago
Good but I think the a better choice of drums were used.
Thorpe 2 years ago
great..but no drums, please :D
ramon68 2 years ago
fruity loops?
jahmin2000 2 years ago
propellerhead reason
rubyruby777 2 years ago
AMAZING
EXCELLENT
WICKED
KILLER
HELLA TIGHT
.. needless to say i love it, keep up the good work m8
whufc4vida 2 years ago 2
nice work dude
rockytheafg 2 years ago
Outstanding.
EverGreenVideos 2 years ago
loooooooooooool
Jesse93z 2 years ago
Nice idea! The drums are a bit loud in the mix though, and need to EQ'd a smidgen!
WondergirlPD 2 years ago 3
im a gloomy guy so i didnt realy love it but i did enjoy it! it was nice
skelitalmisfit12 2 years ago
"Im a gloomy guy". Lol, moar like I'm a fag/emo, amiright?
Cynvalas 2 years ago
what the fuck?
skelitalmisfit12 2 years ago
Pretty much the soft way of breaking the news lol
whatbrains 2 years ago
I agree with call3328. changes it from a sumwhat gloomy kind of song it makes it bright and sunny. good work.
thisisn8n 2 years ago
very relaxing... I like it very much
SevenofLein 2 years ago
this is great!
chris22208 2 years ago
LoveLoveLove it XD
aimeechicken 2 years ago
awesome
anthonyok 2 years ago
cool cool, changes the mood. I won't compare it to the original
call3328 2 years ago
I can dig it ^.^
jessienpa 2 years ago
Really great work! Is it available for download anywhere?
batistabomber88 3 years ago
im quite possibly going to listen to this very often, it would be nice to have it on my iPod too. Does the user have plans for making this downloadable? I would most definitely pay $.99 for this, well done rubyruby777!
flickityclick20 3 years ago
absolutely brilliant!
playedinptown 3 years ago
WOW that was a great remix
you did an excellent job!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Is it possible to get a copy??
McDoogaller 3 years ago
like it but agree that the drums are a bit loud.
markdingwall 3 years ago 2
the drums are too loud but I still get that tingling feeling from the original. I still like it...
jolorulz 3 years ago 2
drums are too loud, but it's okay
Ceb773 3 years ago 2
Really nice beat but it just doesn't work that well with this piece.
Deftone318 3 years ago
Blasphemy. Pure blasphemy.
queensorkings 3 years ago 2
It really bugs me that it seems all the people who dislike this remix are getting thumbs down. Why?
For example, I don't think it's unreasonable for them to be really uncomfortable with the drums - the song was constructed to have a soft legato feel that's completely undermined by the sharper staccato nature of adding in a freaking drum.
But, many are subconsciously convinced that anything about eternal sunshine is automatically fantastic. YES I LOVED THE ORIGINAL, but this remix fell short.
shinybattery 3 years ago 10
(And now let the thumbs fall...)
shinybattery 3 years ago 8
fyi i don't give thumbs down for people who dislike it...
and as for myself, i liked the difference between the soft piano and the spiky drums. but thats just a matter of taste ;)
rubyruby777 3 years ago 5
i cite 'It really bugs me that it seems all the people who dislike this remix are getting thumbs down. Why?'
hes saying People. not commenting on you only..
OllieGief 3 years ago
@rubyruby777 FYI - Jay Electronica
iluvc0mpton 10 months ago
@shinybattery plus the people were only exercising their right to share their opinions
K0anna 1 year ago
getvideodotpl in this site you just copy link to the special place and click save file us...
ksiezyc85 3 years ago
man, it is great. espacially from 1:22 to the end. ... masterpiece
ksiezyc85 3 years ago
DOWNLOAD PL0X
Zekusuu 3 years ago
Hey man, it would be amazing if you have it for download!
Zekusuu 3 years ago
Didn't like the remix, sorry
djphillips 3 years ago 3
very nice
kobe24mvplakers 3 years ago
i like
odeath 3 years ago
amazing, beautiful, feels like im watching the movie
anthonyok 3 years ago
This is absolutly amazing.
Is it available for download anywhere?
its beautiful!
aimeechicken 3 years ago
amezing dud
redhotchiliendpepper 3 years ago
nOOOOOOOOOOOO
nOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!
wOw!
zuena mui sigur roe o mogwai..
me ekivoko??
qwbithakk 3 years ago
...in english? ;)
rubyruby777 3 years ago
I think he is saying that it sounds a lot like sigur ros or mogwai, then he asks if he is wrong
esotsm54 3 years ago
I do love your remix. really.
sinner1saint2 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
You have destroyed a beautiful song.
Alecifer 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i agree...nice try
holzy4565 3 years ago
Beautiful.
mindless192 3 years ago 2
good job
rammlnguollo 3 years ago
muy chida la cancion !
tainy27 3 years ago
Dude, this is great, by chance could you send it to me?
PortalOfTears 3 years ago
Very creative! =]
bibibond 4 years ago
reallt succesfull!!
egemen222 4 years ago
this is peachy. this is a good remix to burn to. do you have it anywhere where it can be downloaded?
faidsept 4 years ago
The drums are awful. It would sound so much better and more fitting had the snare been hit only at the third beat. This is too funky for such a pretty pianotrack.
DoktorOoh 4 years ago
It's alright.... My personal opinion, The song was fine left as it was.
Kyle1818 4 years ago 4
Wow, Amazing :)
Mouskea 4 years ago 2
i like it!
Ostmob 4 years ago 2
you know what would be the ultimate remix? everything except the intro repeated for ten glorious minutes
oh yeah
barelyapianist 4 years ago 3
this song is aswem you trid somthing new end it is somthing ther go on
redhotchiliendpepper 4 years ago
this is unreal! brilliant!
coolfada 4 years ago 2
May I get it too?
ContraWagner 4 years ago
Can you please send me this remix! It's so wonderful! I am a huge fan of the movies and I need to have this song, it just makes me smile!
Drratburn 4 years ago
Great! I really like it. :)
teefreakin 4 years ago