Added: 4 years ago
From: rubyruby777
Views: 73,895
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (141)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • The original is so basic and simple that you can't make a remix without adding something. I think this one turned out quite nice.

  • I think it was good, but the original is always better.

  • best achievement of the remix is the extension of the original song which is too short

  • I'm a huge fan of Jon Brion and all his underscores, this being my favorite one. So soulful and beautiful. this is amazing, i love it! if anyone can spare literally 1 minute to see what I did with the original, please search Newman - Row. Thank you!! -god bless

  • How happy is the blameless vessel's lot? The world forgetting by the world forgot. Eternal sunshine of the spotless mind. Each prayer excepted, and each wish resigned.

  • This is good! :)

  • Bearing in mind that you managed to get a time sync in reason I salute you! I think that's one of reason's weakest features....

  • @MrHathouse and that is why (or should i say that is the "reason" ;) i changed to ableton live! much more possibilities to alter samples and even warp them very accurate without having to use another program like reason recycle.

  • @rubyruby777 Ah right. Yeah I use cubase and I'm constantly annoyed that they haven't implemented a similar feature to reason's quantise audio thingumy. Doing it manually takes hours!

  • Everyone wants to be a critic... It's great.

  • You should haev EQ'd the piano so the higher end of freqs dont swamp with the snare or high hats.

  • drums are loud . . . but it still sounds nice.

    original is better , but i enjoy this :]

  • Whilst folks are free to dis/like this song, the 'oh the original row is soft' crit bothers me. Dudes, it's a REMIX. That's the point. Remixes are -meant- to be a new take on a song, or show it in a different way; the original soft Row still exists, the remix has 'taken' it away in any real sense. As it stands, I am all for adding the drum's beat, and drums -- what I do think this remix lacked was a bit 'more'. It's hard to articulate, but it feels like a nice draft rather than final version.

  • Nice :)

    do you like my version?

    I made it with FL Studio.I didn't use any samples from the original...I have replayed the main tune with a vst. :)

  • could i use this beat an freestyle to it?

    love it if u can get bk to me n the folowing week

  • Can I download this on itunes?

  • the drums fit nicely, however, it now sounds just like a really nice track... not absolutely beautiful as it was before

  • great film thankyou for actuallyu remixing it

  • Drums are too loud.

  • This is beautiful.

  • I like it. except in the middle when everything else stops. and then comes back in. its too rough of a transition. but that beat really sounds well everywhere else

  • awesome song, excellent work =)

  • pretty good, a little rough

    mos def covers this song with drums so well

  • Personally, I LOVE the remix. 

  • i definitely dig this :).

  • Perfect this remix!  Reminds me "Looper"... Congratulations!!!

  • this would sound amazing with as a slow-paced techno remix

  • so down, the drums give it a pulse..FEELING IT

  • I love the original so much.. however, I do think this is equally amazing. I dont think the addition of drums or harmonica or whatever ruins the song; if anything it compliments it. Well done :)

  • The drums kind of make it sound like a Maroon 5 song. I still like it though.

  • i will make a rap for this and show it to you cause i like it it alot :)

  • gotta love it. great song.

  • yeah, the drums sound distracting from soft sound piano

  • Although it fits the song, but it kills it. The beauty of the song is the beautiful solo piano, it simple & meaningful. By adding stuff to it you tend to distract people from the best part.

  • sounds good :D

    new favorite

  • There's not much variation in the song, just the same 1, 2, 3, 4 and so on.. kinda boring. Need some detours! Not knockin em but maybe that's just his style. Jus sayn

  • love it

  • accetible

  • dayum i kinda liked this actually how can i get this instrumental?!

  • It's raining outside right now :(

  • JMO, it just doesn't sound natural to me, free, but that's just me. He has a feel, but it's seems more apprehensive and slightly contrite.

  • My man Jay Electronica ripped dis sample. Jay Electronica is da future of Hip Hop

  • Liked it, but just sorta lower the volume for the drums so we can hear the piano. That'd be nice.

  • listen to jay electronica

  • also check the death metal remix version and get it as a ringtone xD

  • I love the orignial but whenever I hear it now I exspect drums and when I don't' get them I come and listen to this. :] Well done.

  • Anyone got the midi of this? I need it. Bad :D

  • This is good. I love making up remixes in my head when i first hear a song, and this is def what i thought of.. Great fucking movie too. :)

  • Its good if you want to make a 2 pac love song. but couldnt have the same feeling on someone

  • Maybe you prefer the drums,

    But I feel it ruins the peaceful feeling of the song.

    ;/

  • na bad mate gud remix  gud job

  • I didnt care for the particular drum line. I would have played something different. But still cool. Good job.

  • Aus10hxc you are right, not bad at all :)

  • Pretty decent. I prefer the original though. Adding drums takes away from the simplicity of a single piano playing - which is what makes "row" so beautiful.

  • I beg to differ. That's why the origional version is also available on youtube. You clicked on this video expecting a remix I presume. I did. Very nice mix, 5 stars.

  • I did expect a remix, and I heard one. Hence my review and opinion during my previous comment. I never said it was bad - I simply said I prefer the original. Everyone has their own opinion.

  • True, I kind of jumped to a conclusion there. My bad.

  • I liked this remix more then the original song, not that the original wasn't beautiful, there just wasn't enough going on to hold your attention.

  • whatbrains: yeah, if you see it in the context of the film, it's unbelievable. There's more going on there; little children are singing "row row row your boat" over it, and it's raining, and it's...beautiful.

  • I know, I've seen it but I'm just talking about the song. Not it's use in the movie. Good thing to point out for people who haven't seen it.

  • i love this it made my day listening to this hahah

    (:

  • I thought this was really good.

  • i love you

  • whats the bpm on this song?

  • You could make a rap song with this remix: "Yo, meet me in Montauk, n*gger."

  • "Crazy hair dye bitches ... aight ...."

  • "And then some f*cked up n*gger is stealing your ho's panties, you know what i'm sayin'"

  • HAHAHAHAHAH

  • idk, to be honest the added parts sound too synthetic.

  • what's the matter with you?! you don't have to listen to it. just calm down and be easy...

  • Cool mix. Any idea how to play on piano? I'd like to learn it

  • wtf is wrong with u!?!?...r u retarded or something?...if u don't like it...then don't listen to it

  • thas not cool, even if you were drunk, thats not a good excuse, dude.

  • where can i download this?...this version?

  • Good but I think the a better choice of drums were used.

  • great..but no drums, please :D

  • fruity loops?

  • propellerhead reason

  • AMAZING

    EXCELLENT

    WICKED

    KILLER

    HELLA TIGHT

    .. needless to say i love it, keep up the good work m8

  • nice work dude

  • Outstanding.

  • loooooooooooool

  • Nice idea! The drums are a bit loud in the mix though, and need to EQ'd a smidgen!

  • im a gloomy guy so i didnt realy love it but i did enjoy it! it was nice

  • "Im a gloomy guy". Lol, moar like I'm a fag/emo, amiright?

  • what the fuck?

  • Pretty much the soft way of breaking the news lol

  • I agree with call3328. changes it from a sumwhat gloomy kind of song it makes it bright and sunny. good work.

  • very relaxing... I like it very much

  • this is great!

  • LoveLoveLove it XD

  • awesome

  • cool cool, changes the mood. I won't compare it to the original

  • I can dig it ^.^

  • Really great work! Is it available for download anywhere?

  • im quite possibly going to listen to this very often, it would be nice to have it on my iPod too. Does the user have plans for making this downloadable? I would most definitely pay $.99 for this, well done rubyruby777!

  • absolutely brilliant!

  • WOW that was a great remix

    you did an excellent job!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Is it possible to get a copy??

  • like it but agree that the drums are a bit loud.

  • the drums are too loud but I still get that tingling feeling from the original. I still like it...

  • drums are too loud, but it's okay

  • Really nice beat but it just doesn't work that well with this piece.

  • Blasphemy. Pure blasphemy.

  • It really bugs me that it seems all the people who dislike this remix are getting thumbs down. Why?

    For example, I don't think it's unreasonable for them to be really uncomfortable with the drums - the song was constructed to have a soft legato feel that's completely undermined by the sharper staccato nature of adding in a freaking drum.

    But, many are subconsciously convinced that anything about eternal sunshine is automatically fantastic. YES I LOVED THE ORIGINAL, but this remix fell short.

  • (And now let the thumbs fall...)

  • fyi i don't give thumbs down for people who dislike it...

    and as for myself, i liked the difference between the soft piano and the spiky drums. but thats just a matter of taste ;)

  • i cite 'It really bugs me that it seems all the people who dislike this remix are getting thumbs down. Why?'

    hes saying People. not commenting on you only..

  • @rubyruby777 FYI - Jay Electronica

  • @shinybattery plus the people were only exercising their right to share their opinions

  • getvideodotpl in this site you just copy link to the special place and click save file us...

  • man, it is great. espacially from 1:22 to the end. ... masterpiece

  • DOWNLOAD PL0X

  • Hey man, it would be amazing if you have it for download!

  • Didn't like the remix, sorry

  • very nice

  • i like

  • amazing, beautiful, feels like im watching the movie

  • This is absolutly amazing.

    Is it available for download anywhere?

    its beautiful!

  • amezing dud

  • nOOOOOOOOOOOO

    nOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!

    wOw!

    zuena mui sigur roe o mogwai..

    me ekivoko??

  • ...in english? ;)

  • I think he is saying that it sounds a lot like sigur ros or mogwai, then he asks if he is wrong

  • I do love your remix. really.

  • Beautiful.

  • good job

  • muy chida la cancion !

  • Dude, this is great, by chance could you send it to me?

  • Very creative! =]

  • reallt succesfull!!

  • this is peachy. this is a good remix to burn to. do you have it anywhere where it can be downloaded?

  • The drums are awful. It would sound so much better and more fitting had the snare been hit only at the third beat. This is too funky for such a pretty pianotrack.

  • It's alright.... My personal opinion, The song was fine left as it was.

  • Wow, Amazing :)

  • i like it!

  • you know what would be the ultimate remix? everything except the intro repeated for ten glorious minutes

    oh yeah

  • this song is aswem you trid somthing new end it is somthing ther go on

  • this is unreal! brilliant!

  • May I get it too?

  • Can you please send me this remix! It's so wonderful! I am a huge fan of the movies and I need to have this song, it just makes me smile!

  • Great! I really like it. :)

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more