Added: 3 months ago
From: TheXFactorUSA
Views: 337,970
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,344)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • She has a great voice and seems like a true artist even though shes only 14 and im sure she can make a terrific singing career, but in this competition she really stood no chance compared to what Melanie had to offer. And the songs she chose just dont make that big of impression.

  • Simon seems way nicer than he did when I was younger

  • Janet Devlin #2 ;)

  • usually i don't mind nicole.. but come onnnn!!

  • Why there are so many dislikes? She's not disrespecting U2, it's HER own version, wich was beautiful. And LA, you're so hipocritical, analize your own contestants and then tell who's doing the same every week.

  • Too much from the backup singers on this one.

  • Why the hell are there so many dislikes?!

  • zzzzzz I-)

  • i havent heard of the song before but after drew sang it it became a favorite. she really did good here but i was also expecting she'll do a cranberry song for rock week hehe.. this is kinda slow but IS STILL REALLY GOOD AND WAY BETTER THAN THE OTHERS

  • @finkpetchay ahahahaa LOVE you i thought she might do zombie shed be AMAZING

  • evrything was perfect drew you doing your thing remember dont let others change you of who you are! love ur voice HANDS DOWN to you voice drew LOVELOTS

  • L.A shut up. "No Woman no cry" was Reggae, and "Missing You" was a Hip Hop song. THIS WAS ACTUALLY ROCK!

  • I shoul say talks because thats all I have heared

  • Astro sings Rap and thats it

  • @lanefair95 your opinion, period.

  • I think L A used his negative comments of contestants other than his own, to influence viewer opinions.

  • Every single people has its own point of view, from mine, this was , one of the most beautifull performance of the entire competition, PLS before any answer to my opinion, listen to this two or three times, its amazing, her voice and passion to sing, the soft melody , the chorus !, everything sounded very very nice.... a hug from ecuador.

  • I agree with EVERYTHING Nicole said.....

  • 738 people dont know what real talent is!!!!!!

  • Hey guys

    Seventeen year old guy here. Struggling artist. All I want to do is sing! Please please please check out my cover of this song and like this comment so others see it! It'd mean the world to me.

  • great vocal drew ur a winner in my eyes

  • I agree with L.A. Reid that Drew has an original voice.

  • I can imagine her doing zombie by the cranberries

  • Her voice reminds me of Alanis Morissette...

  • @darckiend what? really?

  • I think that Simon dont know what's rock.. Melanie & Drew sang good but it's not the week theme..

    LA is the expert .. he picked a real rock song for Marcus who is R&b soul singer and sang it very well and rocked the place..

  • I was waiting for this to go somewhere the entire time but she kept it at slow. Snore. Sorry. Love Drew. Hated the performance. My favorite by her was Just A Dream.

  • Justin Bieber é bem diferente de Demi Lovato, que por sua vez é bem diferente de Coldplay ou U2 ou Nelly Furtado.. pra mim são estilos bem difentes e ela soube dar um toque especial em cada musica.. amo a voz desta menina.

  • PERFORMANCE OF THE SEASON! SO TOUCHING! <3

  • seems like Simon lost his brain, he has no new ideas... he's been doing with Drew songs that already had been sung on the British version, by girls of the same age and the same vocal style of Drew... check "With Or Without You" by Diana Vickers (season 5 TXF UK) and "Fix You" by Janet Devlin (season 8 TXF UK)... btyw, this girl is PERFECT, I can't understand why she was voted out...

  • I have to say that girls really ruled this show . They have definitely some talents in the girl`s group !

  • I'm glad Drew's gone, I mean lets face it can you see this boring act in a pepsi commerical????

  • @TheDarthEmperor she has a voice and should have won . if it wasnt for nicoles fear of going with the truth he would not be there against a little girl

  • @rara232329 thats why nicole broke down like she did

  • @TheDarthEmperor soo every good song has to fit a pepsi commercial?

    no slow song would work for a pepsi commercial. and that's not because they're boring

  • Marcus I loved you from day one!! You have an amazing voice. This performance was awesome!!

  • LA is meeeean

  • For those who complain abut the song choice, there's absolutely nothing wrong with the song. Original is a classic ROCK song, but this version sounds more like a psalm.

  • pepeelgrillo20009: stop being close minded, let me just remind you that their styles are totally different and both is great in what they do! dumb _ _ _ _

  • thumbs up to make Drew come back!!!!

  • I listen to this rendition over and over again! I prefer this version:)

  • me encanto su version :)

    

  • Nice intense thanx

  • me gusto mucho la versión de esta canción...esta chica tiene que estar en la finalll

  • any changes in what, does astro change its singing, its always rap, always and always the same thing. Drew is really good at what she does, and people like it, why change what people like. screw all the haters, she is pure talent

  • @dcbmf astro, she, josh, they all have their own style no one can or should make them change their mind to what they like doing.. they should call jay z or britney spears and tell them to change their gender..

  • @dcbmf

    Well said

  • Screw AsTro ; Drew is pure Talent yo yo

  • @thecolorliz that you cant sing and your an untalented broad

  • Goo Drew , despite d elimination ,, yuu can do it ! continue your dreamm keyshhh ? hehe !

  • Why so many dislikes here?????

  • I loveee drew:')

    LA says she does the same thing but so Astro omg Astro so up himself-.-

  • Nicole is absolutely right

  • i like drew but i cant see changes in her songs

  • i like her voice when she did the audition singing baby and it was one of my faves now... its boring i agree with LA

  • I agree with nichole!

  • Man she is a Ange, but I think she need to try more harder, I'm dreaming every day with her singing The Cranberies or Sarah Mclachlan... I think She will doing even better

  • i love la reid

    ^^ ASTRO gonna win boy

  • Drew Can You Change A Little Please I'm Begging

  • I think LA is right, Nicole and Paula are also right. Simon is not letting that girl receive the critics, she has to accept the judges help. I also agree with people saying that Astro has been doing the same over and over, I think some of them did not really understand they had to perform Rock songs. However I find that girl Drew boring and flat (great voice) but always the same sad version of any song like when she sang What a feeling by Irene Cara, the girl just does not show any passion

  • Now simons just crippling her, because for once, Paula is right. She'll go longer not only in the competition but also in her career if she is able to mix it up. When simon tells her not to, he's making her think that she doesn't need to. Not helping...

  • i'm sorry but when astro raps he makes it fun to watch and to listen to, but drew sings so slowlyy and its makes it boring and hard to listen to 'cos you feel like sleeping! no doubt she's a good singer but just change it a bit and stop doing the same thing every single week!!

  • i think that LA reid and nicole are right when they say something like that because it`s boring when she sings only slowly songs. if she want to be famous, she have to do something diffrent!! and astro is rapper! if you think eminen, you can see that he is rapper too and he only raps.

  • Personally this isn't the type of music I'm into, but Drew is good at what she does and people love her for that.

    You don't see Adele switching up her style..... LA is soo annoying at times.

  • hate the rappers like astro, love drew, love her genre and voice :P

  • Paula gives the best advice, she should do the genre since her fanbase is huge! :) People would still vote for her no matter what! :) I think LA is quite right thaat she has been doing the same thing since we first saw her! Simon has got to change her style if he wants her to come out of the competition with more supporters! All the best to you, Drew!

  • Wait. That was rock? o.0

  • she is not even goood

  • What has happened to ROCK WEEK ????

    I though they were all going to sing ROCK SONGS, with up tempo beat !!!

    I can't stand her singing all those sad songs !!

  • In the beginning I didn't really like Drew, but LA with this unfair behavior is forcing me to like her and hate his guys >.<

  • I got to admit I'm getting a bit bored and frustrated with Drew... Week after week what ever she sings sounds exactly the same, it's like she's singing the same song over and over again!

  • @reday23 You´re right, the problem is Simon, however, if she wants to stay in the competition, needs to pick better songs in order to appeal other people who like her voice,

  • i do like drew, but i think this was a bad performance, a really bad performance

  • is this rock weekend? or sad song weekend?

    i'm confused

    

  • Agree with LA . . I don't think she can sing like that but I do like her personality

  • Is it just me or is she just hypnotizing!?

  • Look for Diana Vickers, she was on the x factor uk, and I believe Simon was her menthor, mark my words, he will get her a contract whether she wins or not, and he will make her a star... Diana and Drew are very similar, and very, very Simon's style...

  • @reday23 Cheryl was Diana Vickers mentor actually. However i do agree that Simon will get Drew a Record Contract regardless of whether she wins or not.

  • LA's Astro has been rapping throughout this competition and he's asking her to be different??

  • I agreed with Nicole 100% i was waiting for the beat. So glad they finally listened with the next song she did =]

  • I love her style. It's very good.

  • She is a good singer but they should give it another genre she is very good with slow songs but to be a complete artist must not only handle multiple genres pop or ballad

  • LA Reid is so jealoussssss

  • Hey DREW. It's "With" or "Without" you. ....NOT, "Weeeeth" or "Weeeethout" you.

  • Drew is a rip-off of Diana Vickers/Janet Devlin, both singers are from the X Factor UK. Could she win? I don´t think so

  • @jaimek88 totally agree, but I don't think it's her, it's simon's view on her, he wants to get a diana vickers out of her... but I like diana way better, she's got more energy and force...

  • just vote Chris or Drew. Its a wrap!

  • Shes Really Good ! I Love Her So Much ! But I Think Rachel Crowe , Josh Krajick Or Atsro Is Gonna Win . No Hate / Disrepect , But Like LA Said , Her Competition Is Stiff .

  • I'M SO WITH SIMON!

  • Her voice is suits these kind of songs! What's wrong with

  • L.A. is so annoying, his comments are really really pointless not totally pointless maybe 98% pointless. he is just so jealous about drew. DREW we love you just be yourself and stay what you are! prove to them that you are not like what they said. GO GO GO GO DREW. I LOVE YOU :D

  • wtf is wron with LA... its not like astro does anything else than rap the same kind of songs =/

  • thank you for butchering my fav song

  • Drew is AMAZING! don't listen to anyone else but you're heart Drew...do what you love!

  • Drew pleeeeeeeease pleeeeeease sing Avril! Underground. And this time with a dance pop kinda tempo.

  • simply amazing

  • La ried is just making up BS. First he goes on about you me and Dupree movie. Which tbh is a pretty well known movie and now he goes on about singing a song that are sung by 40 year old when sky scraper was blatantly sung by Demi lovata who is like 20 something. Im glad simon had a go at la.

    How bout we make Astro sing an Adele song without rapping?

  • This kid is a threat to La 4 obvious reasons , she gotz '''''TALENT''''''.

    Way 2 to go Simon DREW fan-tasTique

  • ok so I'm gonna say my opinion, She is amazing, her voice is amazing, she looks amazing and she's singing in her style! So what do you want her to do? It's like expecting Lady Gaga to sing a ballad or Adele to sing a Rihanna song... That's impossible, Drew is Drew and you can't change her!

  • @cherylcolefansimca exactly!!! im with you on this! I love Drew! shes gonna win!

  • @shoresy594 you didn't understand what I was going to say. I wanted to tell that LA have to shut up with his pointless criticism, because people sing song they can perform the best. Do you think that a rock star is going to sing jazz or smthn' ?

  • You people call this rock ? She's going to be a depressing artist if she wins. So boring !

  • i personally think LA wants to become a Simon on the American Idol

    .____.

  • LA Reid is always looking down on Simon's girls. SERIOUSLY. He looks down on Melanie and Drew. EVERY TIME.

  • Drew rock stop hatimg

  • This is really bad of LA and unfair... Drew doing the same thing over and over again??? Well, you want her to rap like Astro? you want her to rap every week which is what your boy has been doing since the start of the show?! Come on! be fair....

  • SHUT UP LA REID!!!! Give Drew a Break! What DO You Want Her 2 Do?

    Rap Like Astro!

    She is very talented and like she said she is trying to stick to her genre!

  • she just accidentally cut simon off lol

    I really like her, I think she's going to go REALLY far. she's like a taylor swift with double the talent

  • I really hate how LA Reid is bagging on Drew for doing the same thing every week, when his boy Astro has been doing just that. Astro has been doing rap every week, and that's because that's the only thing he's good at. Drew has stuck with her genre because she's good at it. Voters obviously agree. I agree with Simon: LA Reid is just trying to get inside her head.

  • @KidApollo100 yeah i hated when simon bagged on chris. this is not even rock, she flipped it into a more pop oriented song. but i agree astro does the same thing every week.

  • @fruitypebbles904 THANK YOU!!!!!!!!!

  • the only reason LA doesn't like her is because she made justin bieber's "baby" into a better song in the auditions.

    shes amazing

  • aww.. i like drew but i dint like the talk to the hand gesture.. idk, LA was trying to reach out.. sad

  • amazing performance, but i still love the version by boyce avenue and kina grannis more.

  • drew your my fav but i hope you do something fast tomorrow :O)

  • she's good at what she does but she does do the same thing all the time. the judges weren't wrong for saying that.

  • wow! i want to listen to her over and over again!!! Oh, over and over again! Please do Regina Specktor's Fidelity you would b so freaking amazing!!!!

  • Come on LA Reid after your DisAstro momement and lackluster cantor Marcus Cant'y, you got to lash out at a beautiful voice and talent of Drew? I can see why you want to deflect attention away from your guys. (Sheez!) She is doing herself just fine and your guys are next to be out the door.

  • Don't watch her sing if you're gonna hate. She's amazing, period.

  • For her age...She is better than perfect, very unusual voice, and if she can hone a talent for writing music and lyric's, she will have a very good chance at fame!

  • L.A Reid is a hater!!!!!!

  • yes she always sings the same but i still wanna vote for her bc i love her voice :)

  • May I just say one thing there are people like her in the industry but....BUT nobody knows about them because it's not on the radio because people do not want to here slow song that take 4 minutes to get through one verse all I'm gonna say. Sorry Drew but you're boring and I'm over it.

  • what choreography?

  • your calling her boring because she sounds the same? WHY?! Selena Gomez souns the same in her songs, Eminem sound the same in his raps, Katy Perry sounds the same in her song. How can a person change their voice to please others? this her voice, i love it and i wouldnt want it to change

  • @moenasser7 selena has no talent, so dont bring her up xD eminem and katy bring personailty to their songs.

  • drew isn't boring, shes being herself ,unique and original in all her songs

  • She reminds me of Alanis Morisette.

  • The top comments are ridiculous, is it not good enough to be amazing at singing anymore? Just because she's not a circus freak like Lady Gaga or a stripper like Rihanna, she's more talented than anyone else in the competition by far.

  • Love Drew, but she's has some growing to do. She will be outstanding one day...but I don't see her at this point being able to any upbeat songs....but good luck to her because I loved her audition.

  • Drew needs to sing a better song tonight. She's still my favorite. However, Leroy, Astro, and Melanie also does the same thing over and over again LA Rein so stop picking on Drew for god's sake.

  • OMG QUESTION TO LA REID - DOESN'T ASTRO DO THE SAME OVER AGAIN? I MEAN RAPPING!!

  • @reinislillais if yur gonna go with that logic then all the other contestants do the same thing to....SINGING!!

  • I think a Florence + The Machine's song will be great for her :)

  • shes winner..please shut up u fat idiots all the day sitting at computer a critizing...how can u sing for 5m??

  • It was - ok

  • simon pleeeeaaase give her a better song please, it's just a dream

  • She has an amazing voice. But she does do the same thing every week.

  • ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ You're boring!!!!!

  • They are different songs.. She's singing them in HER style.. She's consistent! She has great tone and technique. Adele doesn't sing different genres, does she? She does what she does best and people love her for it.

  • @adrianomelette that fact that you even compared this dull thing to adele is ridiculouse

  • @adrianomelette i agree her style is beautiful and i like it. but she really should try out new genres right? its a competition! u cant win by singing same genre over and over!

  • @adrianomelette Her style? The words are "With" or "Without" you.....NOT "Weeeeth or Weeethout' you.

  • DREW SHOULD SING DIFFERENT SONGS..

  • its the same genre of song ..u got nothing to offer?

  • L.A REID WAS RIGHT!!! IF SHE CAN SING A ROCK SONG LIKE A "ROCK SONG WOULD BE", SHE WOULD WIN

  • its midnight.....i started watching this at 8.  nuff said, yur boring.

  • she is so... boring.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • If She sang A 'Rock' SOng She WOuld Be the Potential

  • she has a beautiful voice

  • BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOORRRRR­RRRRRRRIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIINNNNNN­NNNNNNNNGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG­!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    

  • How is this a rock song?

  • she has a wonderful voice and was my fav at the beginning of the competition. she sounds the same every week lol a bit boring to be honest. totally agree with three judges

  • I love drew, however sweet child o mine would have been so much of a better song choice, I didn't care at all for that song or performance

  • her fans say her voice is not bad but use the synonym unique. wow!!! so my farts and your breath are unique

  • guys simon started it with sayin that chris is singing reggea... he got it started

  • It's wonderful, but I was expecting more at least a high note or something, but still she did great

  • With or without Simon mentoring Drew, she does fine performance. Now, WITHOUT LA, Nicole, and Paula in the panel of judges will even be better. Drew--Brilliant.

  • Her voice is unique that's for sure and I like her but its true, she's sounds the same every week now. I agree with nicole. I was also waiting for that upbeat tempo to come in but it never came