Added: 3 years ago
From: dukedevlinluvah
Views: 8,787
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (104)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • @YouSuckHaveANiceDay (cont) had to work with. And, as an afterthought, I was kind of wondering why so many people can readily accept SS/HG or SS/HP, but can't get past MM/HG. I guess so many people base the laws of attraction on how a person looks, both in fiction AND real life. Sad, isn't it? Anywya, kudos to you for making this and I hope you continue to vid!

  • I guess I'm the stupid on e to not read the description before watching this. I got the point, but I thought she actually did wake up in the end. Now I'm sad ): Other than that (and my first though-->HP fans will literally ship ANYTHING), I actually did kind of like this. I say "kind of" because though it was well edited, I do wish there were at least a FEW more clips or something used. It got just a bit monotonus after a while. However, you really did do a good job with what you had to (cont)

  • @YouSuckHaveANiceDay First of all, thank you very much for leaving such a long comment! I'm surprised you think this video is well edited, because I personally find those flashes of other clips in it a sign of bad editing considering I now know how to prevent them. I do see what you mean with it becoming a bit monotonous. If I would make this today, it'd be much more awesome. AND OMG I KNOW it's ridiculous! People love slash, people love SS/HG, but make it MM/HG and they fake gag. :/

  • Creepy as fuck

  • @TKDmidgit Good thing fuck aint creepy ;o

  • This video is really beautiful! Minerva and Hermione are my 2 favortie characters!

    I see Minerva and hermiones relationship as a love there only can be between a teacher and pupil. I dont see as a "real love" relationship, maybe it sounds a bit confusing, but I understand!

  • this is great. i wish there was more mm/hg vids online. i know what some people think about may-december relationships but as a young woman who is attracted to much older women i think this was lovely and i think you are brave to upload it and then to deal with critisism so rationally. well done :)

  • @minervamcgonagall86 Honestly, I didn't expect so much criticism... if they were both men, most HP fans would have just shrugged it off. I'm glad you like it so much and I agree with you; there ought to be more videos concerning couples with big age gaps out there.

  • @minervamcgonagall86 ... and thank you (:

  • I always thought that hermione and minerva were perfect for eachother, same interests, and both are very academic.

  • I am sorry but this is a little gross.

  • @MsWho132 No need to be sorry, if we can talk about this in a normal way it's all cool. :) Why do you think it's gross?

  • @dukedevlinluvah well Its promoting sexual child abuse. I am all for the gays and lesbians but I'm never ok with child molestation. I'm not looking to fight and I'm not going to offend you but it was a very disturbing thing to watch especially when these two characters are in no way romantically involved because Ms. J.K is not a supporter of pedifiles.

  • @MsWho132 You're not offending me, you are being reasonable. I don't mean to offend you either, but I do disagree. (: See; there is nothing physical going on between them. Hermione goes into a coma when she's 11, and at that point there is nothing going on. Time passes, and Minerva falls in love with a distorted memory. I don't see how that's child abuse. Hermione never knows about this, she's unconscious throughout it and there's nothing sexual going on.

  • @dukedevlinluvah Ooh also; this is a love story, not a sex story. (: There is no mention of sex anywhere, nor is there any footage indicating it. That you interpret it that way is in your mind, it is in no way intended.

  • @dukedevlinluvah I am confussed. What is this distorted memory?

  • @MsWho132 The distorted memory is of Hermione and the way she was before she got into the coma. Hermione is unconscious throughout the entire video, all the things she 'does' are in Minerva's (distorted) memory and imagination. Before Hermione got into the coma, there was nothing between them. After Hermione got in the coma, Minerva slowly started to fall in love with the memory of her. But there is nothing physical going on.

  • So beatifull))

    But I'm AD/MM shipper, actually...

    But I really like your video))

  • @RachelUKMabel Nothing wrong with AD/MM. (: Thank you for your comment!

  • This video is just beautiful - not all relationships are "fetish", this is a "relationship" i have always loved - thank you for the beautiful video

  • @Wicked743 Thank you for your wonderful comment.

  • @dukedevlinluvah - just got your thank you message. You are very welcome. These days I write Hermione/Minerva myself and gave only once come across someone who didnt' understand and called it morbidly gross. I answered her kindly that slating someone's writing without giving any possible feedback in itself is morbidly gross. Once again, this video is still wonderful and I have not seen many (if any) other Hermione/Minerva ones out ther e- probably STILL for the same reaons...

  • @MysteriousFlower22 That is probably because most members of the HP fandom pair characters purely for their physical appearance to write smut. I can't stand that - the entire point of finding inspiration in a fandom lays in the outline of characters presented, and the charm of filling the mystery in with your own imagination.. not to flatten carefully developed characters so the barely pubescent can describe their sexual fantasies. I'd like to read a Minerva/Hermione story by you, please PM me.

  • Much offense to anyone involved with this insane creepy fetish of "pairing" fictional characters together sexually who have never been involved with one another, and making uncomfortable and borderline-psychopathic videos depicting their passionate and irrelevant relationships. This is the weirdest and most disturbing thing i have ever seen..why make this?? what the hell is the point in displaying your mad fantasies about old vs. young fictional lesbian stalker fantasy. get some help dude, jesus

  • @giopizz 1) it's not a fetish, I don't get turned on by it. 2) there is nothing sexual about this video. 3) one of the characters is in vegetative state here, so not much passion going on. 4) this video is indeed irrelevant, making your message a waste of time 5) if this is the weirdest and most disturbing thing you've ever seen I suggest you open your eyes to the real world 6) there's no stalking in here and 7) the POINT is that I'm creative and wanting to share it. Leave jesus out of it.

  • @giopizz Ooh I forgot; their relationship is not uncomfortable because THERE IS NO RELATIONSHIP. As mentioned, one is in veg. state and the other is falling in love with the memory of her. It has nothing to do with psychoses and/or borderline. Mind your words with me sweets, I'm a psychology student.

  • @dukedevlinluvah oh god im so sorry i didnt know you were a psychology student where were my manners? If i knew i was speaking to such a prestigious figure as yourself I would have minded my comments. this is still very fucked up and honestly very creepy...it just IS. and i know you'll say "Ooh no its not creepy its an expression of love and faith and bla bla bla" but your wrong. If you ever do become a therapist or whatever the fuck, warn me not to ever come near you or your "wisdom"

  • Manners have nothing to do with this, it's a common sense thing. You can throw names of mental or personality disorders my way, but I know what they mean so I'm not remotely intimidated.

    Also, "it just IS" is no argument.

    In your first comment on my video you asked what the point was. Also you suggested I find help. I don't need help - I'm not the one with a problem. You seem to have a problem though with about every person who makes pairing fan videos, I suggest YOU find yourself some help.

  • I love this pairing but I simply must picture Minerva in her late twenties at best.

  • @AWildDOEET I think she's beautiful regardless. <3

  • @10misschb Thank YOU :D

  • This video is great ! It's so sad but the Minerva's sadness is very touching... I love it, it's very beautiful. Sad but very beautiful. Bye... =)

  • @HPWorldd Thank you very much for your lovely comment

  • I'd never considered this pairing before, but you've done a really good job of making it believable. It's very beautiful and very sad.

    Also, if you're still having problems with the flashes - it always helps me to render in a lower setting (like 512 kbps) first. The video renders much quicker that way, and though it won't be high quality, it's clear enough to check for flashes. After that, you can just render using a higher setting.

  • @FiryClaw Thank you very much :D

    I'm so much better with Vegas now than I was then, but thank you for the tip. :)

  • Great video!

  • @ggirl20121 Thank you!

  • @Hippie1Personified Thanks!! :D

  • I love this pairing, and I love this vid. Great job. :D

  • @ilike2eatbabies1218 Thanks so much! :D

  • DARN YOU!!!! You made me cry. 5 stars for the spectacular vid!

  • Thanks so much!

  • OMG

    i started crying at the end of the video!!

    thx 4 posting it!!!!!

  • Thanks for telling me what you think!!

  • I am supised of how mutch i loved this video!! It was really good made !

  • I'm very glad to read that, thank you for telling me!

  • I absolutely love this video! I haven't watched and fanvids with this pairing or read and fanfics with it; I was never interested. Yours is the first one and now I am exciting to learn more about this pairing! Thank you so much for changing my mind!

  • Wow, I'm thrilled my silly video had such impact! I hope you enjoy the pairing! :D

  • I love this pairing and your video! Beautiful done!

    But why this song! Don't worry, nothing wrong of you, it fits perfectly, it's just not my style. xD

    I would love a soft emotinal song by Within Temptation like Memories or Forgiven. Or by Evanescence like Lithium.

  • Thank you very much!

    Within Temptation and Evanescence have beautiful music, but I have simply heard too much of them in high school so I'm.. kind of.. tired.. of them? (A)

    Plus, Anouk is a Dutch singer and relatively unknown abroad. I think my music videos could get her some foreign attention :) Thank you for commenting!

  • I'm dutch so I guess I have heard Anouk far too much. :)

  • Ja daar kan het ook door komen :p

  • I LOVE this video !! Thanks for sharing ! :D

  • X3 thanks for watching

  • I have recently started reading some fanfic between Minerva and Hermione and I can see some people seem to find it hard to understand (though I think this is more because they see the actress that played her, not the woman she is in the books and cannot see beyond age) I personally enjoy reading the fanfics, the ones no one seems to understand (Bellatrix/Hermione Hermione/Narcissa). I enjoyed this vid :-) Beautifully done.

    What programe do you use?

  • I am so glad to see your comment! Thanks so much! :D

    I use Sony Vegas Pro 8.0

  • @MysteriousFlower22 can you tell me the fanfictions i been looking for som storys like that

  • Sorry if I offended you, but thats just my opinion.

  • I personally think there is no point in commenting if you have nothing to say that can help make it better, or help the maker of it feel better.

    I don't mind negative comments, I do mind plain insults. There is a difference. If you think there is nothing I can do to change it, why bother telling me? It's totally pointless.

  • What is this?? This is like really stupid.

  • usually people stop thinking out loud at age 6. if you don't have any criticism I can work with I prefer you don't comment.

  • Comment removed

  • Sorry, but I don't like it. If you can't deal with the fact that I don't like your video, I don't know what to tell you. I am going to comment if I want to.

  • You could tell me why you don't like it and tell me how to improve. That's what proper feedback should be. Just saying it's 'stupid' is an insult and below your level if you're older than 15, unless you have a mental disability.

  • FOr your information, I am not older then 15, and far from having a mental disability. If I think it is stupid, then I can say it is. If you don't like getting negative comments, then you should have chosen not to have your video commented on at all. There isn't anything you could do to make it better, I just think the idea surrounding the video is rediculous.

  • I usually don't mind Minerva/Hermione, because Hermione has already graduated, but Hermione is just too young in this vid. Sorry to say, but I find it perverted.

    I do love Anouk, though. Good choice of music.

  • I see your point, but I don't think it's perverted.

    Nothing happens between them, Minerva is just very attracted to Hermione. :)

    Thanks.

  • What is the song????????

  • Read the description.

  • uuuuhh.... this was really quite disturbing. so hermione falls in love with minerva???? what the heck!!??? creeeeeeeepy..................

  • Have you even watched the video? Hermione is a veggie during the entire video. Minerva is the one in love.

    And even if it was Hermione; what's so creepy about it?

  • Dude you totally used a McFly lyric at the end of your message xD

    was it on purpose??

  • No, I don't know McFly xDD

  • Quite amazing actually, I love it.

  • *Crying* Excellent work..So beautiful. Lovett! xxxxx

  • I'm so glad you like it! It was one of the most unusual vids I ever did. :)

  • where can i hear here voice? on youtube all i can hear is music

  • I don't think you can, actually. Like Minerva can't either. :)

  • Beautiful...just beautiful!!

  • Thank you so much!! :D

  • Aw sweetie! Unusually sweet of you? :D

    I LOVED it! It looked simply amazing! The sadness was touchable, the feelings were there for me to reach and the song sank deep into my heart, next to you I guess :) I loved this vid!

    "Lost in this vid" is more like it! :D

    Thanks for posting, looved it <3

  • ö

    *is stunned by your kindness*

    Wow... <3 *sits in you next to vid* Yuo are the bestest. x3; <3333 And you're welcome haha

  • Awh hun! :D <3

  • Femmeslash, hmmm? What's this world coming to, anyway! heh heh XD

    I LOVED it, but of course your videos are very easy to love. ;~}

    I thought I had subcribed to you, but nope...

    So I did!

  • Haha xD Well all is possible in magical fictionland ;D

    Oh thank you so much!!! O_O; <3

  • Oh my god. When I saw this pairing, I was like 'wtf' but this video actually made m want to cry. I mean. Wow. It was beautiful and the end where you made it look like she was alive, then it turns out to be a dream...Wow. Just wow.

  • Thank you SO much! That is exactly what I wanted to achieve. :D Thank you a hundred times for your comment. :D

  • Aww, that was so sad! The ending was done fabulously, it's very believable and an interesting idea. Poor Minerva! :(

  • Yes I feel bad for her too. =[ Glad you like the video so much! :D

  • Really sad but beautiful, I love this sweet pairing. (It's one of my favorite pairings, together with Hermione/Ginny and Hermione/Bellatrix. Yes I love Hermione and femmeslash. :) ). Their relationship seems so strong to me, very belevable. Thank you.

  • Thank you SO much! :D That's a big compliment. :) <3

  • Wow, that was amazing! You've done alot with the few clips that we have of Minerva!

  • (there are more but I'm lazy)

    *ahem* Thank you so much! Glad you seem so impressed. <33

  • Wow hun, this is wonderful, all of it!

    there are so many great things..

    I love the ending.I'm always excited

    to see what new vids you are coming

    up with. 5 Stars!! favs...

  • Aww that is so sweet of you to say! Your comments always make me smile. <3 :D

    Well my next video is part 2 of "I'll love you 'till the day I die..." =] So I hope you liked that story because it will continue!

  • Thank you SO much!

    I am a twisted mind. =]

  • Honey, that was so sweet! A very sad ending :( 5 stars

  • Aww thank you so much! =D I expected people to be 'scared' of this pairing but so far nobody is. n_n haha Glad you like it!

  • This video is perfect.I don't know why you thought that it wasn't that good that it seemed to be.I liked it really much.

  • Wow :O

    Well there are some flashes of things (like Harry and Ron's face) that shouldn't be there but I can't help that they're there.

    That's so sweet of you to say. :D Thank you <3

  • Aww thanks so much!! :D

  • AWSOME!!

  • THANK YOU SO MUCH!! =D

  • This is a sad video. But it is very well done! Great job! 5 stars.

  • Yay thank you so much! Yeah I didn't think the song left a lot of space for happiness. xD

  • This was really great and sweet vid, ^_^ but it was sad too. :( You have made awesome job! :)

  • Aww thank you SO much sweetie! <3 :D

  • that was such a good video, i like how you used such a random pairing and you really made it work, it was sad though :(

    but really good, great job =)

  • Thank you SO much! Yes it was supposed to be. Song didn't leave much space for a happy ending in my opinion. =D

  • yeah, that's true, but you did a really good job at putting the clips together and really made it work =)

  • Yay thanks so much! =D <333

    Something entirely different: I won't be on MSN this evening because it's my uncles girlfriend's birthday. I haven't even met her so yeah I'm curious. She comes from Peru or something and came to the Netherlands for him so yeah I'm dying to meet her. x3;

  • oh, that's fine, i understand that you have a life besides just staying on the computer, lol.

    Well i hope you have fun with that, and i'll ttyl =)

  • Awr this vid was so sweet but sad =(

    The ending was realistic instead of just a happy ending for the sake of it. I've never seen many Minerva/Hermione vids and you made the couple work. It looked really realistic!

    Good job!

  • Yay thank you very much!! :D I'm glad to see you back in action. x3; Because you HAVE to see my Luna video 'Stil Alive'!!

  • Thnx! I'm shattered. Our flight was delayed 3 hours. We were supposed to fly at 10 to 12 and instead we didnt fly untill 3:15 in the morning. *Sigh*

    I'll check out the vid now, i LOVE luna XD By the way thanks for tagging us! I'll start making it now, I'll have to do it without Danni coz she's in Turkey for 2 weeks, she went on friday and wont get back till next friday. I've done enough blabbing for now. XD

  • Pfooh... Wow I can't imagine flying... Let alone getting nervous about it for 3hrs. xD

    Ok great! =D Aww you didn't go together? xD

  • Nope, i only went for one week and i flew out on the Monday and she didnt go till Friday x

    I've watched your Luna vid, thanks sooo soo much for the dedication <33

    Much love

    Lauren x

  • You always come up with the most original ideas!And you did a great job once again:)

  • Aww thank you very much! :D

    Do you happen to know how to post this as a video response when it doesn't show up in my list of options? I have to pick a video when trying to post it as a video response... but all my videos are in the list except this one.

  • O_O,no idea,it should be on the list...maybe try to upload it a secon time...dunno..or just curse YT :P

  • I'll just curse YT ;D

    Uploading takes hours and I have 'till October 31 so yeah. x3;

  • Interesting paaring, but.....I like it! Something new ^^

    The storyline is amazing, sweet and sad!

    Well done!

    But I´m really angry about you, because I nearly start crying! Not really nice! ^^ xD

  • Aww really!? I'm happy now; I didn't think it was good enough with my crappy cutting of scenes. xD

    <3 Thanks for your comment.

  • Ohmy O____O". First of all, WEIRD SHIP, but that's the whole point of course :D, second, GREAT STORYLINE, so creative and sad, trird, I was so stupid not to read the last line of the story and I thought they were finally "together"... but then I read it... so SAD XDD ! Great job on this one hun! 5/5

  • Haha silly girl. Glad it had something of a surprise left for you. xD

    Thank you so much!! :D

  • A Minerva/Hermione slash,ey?

    Now thats one I haven't seen, let alone heard of....until now..

    heh, it was absolutely beautiful.

    Any McGonagall slash i would love....

    I just love Maggie Smith

    haha

    thankyou....it was pretty...

    <3 elliot

  • Me too! She's underrated by most HP fans I'm sure. x3;

    Glad you liked it so much sweetums! <3

  • thats very sad :-[ this is the first video of Minerv anad Mcgonall! :-D something completely different. but is very sad. good job!

  • Thank you so much! I was hoping it was. x3;;

  • Interesting storyline....you should win the "unusual couples" contest, because I haven't come across any other Minerva/Hermione vids on youtube :) The ending was sad, but at the same time, realistic.

  • Haha that's up to AWhiteRose88 to decide. xD

    That's exactly what I meant to make it! Thank you SO much!

  • when you told me about this vid hun, i was expecting it to be good, but hunnie this is bloody brilliant, its so sad and aww i loved it soo much, wheni saw the couple i was a bit skeptical but you've warmed me to them so much, its really great :P

    5 stars and a fev darling :P

    xx

  • YAY for real? A fav? Thank you SO much!!! :D <3 Glad I didn't disappoint you. x3;;

  • Oh wow that was so sad :(

    But you made it so believable, well done!

  • Thank you so much! :D <3

  • Great vid never thought id see one of those beautiful <3

  • Aww thank you SO much!

  • Omg. O_O That was sad. T_T Great video though. :D

  • Thank you so much! =D <33 It's meant to be sad. Glad I managed. =D

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more