Added: 3 years ago
From: BananePuddin
Views: 27,319
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (121)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • As nice as this is, I'm sorry, but Lea Michele hit that final note a lot better.

  • i kinda liked this but they were terrible at the part when they say go it sounded a bit like a walrus dying

  • saw emma hunton as natalie in next to normal she was fantastic!!!

  • I personally hate Alexandra Socha, I went to camp with her and she was a total bitch to every body

  • This is the best version I've heard on YouTube. I think that it sounds better with only guitar.

  • who was playing wendla? it wasnt lea michele was it cause it didnt sound like her :/ i like lea's voice better not that this girl wasnt good i just preferr lea :)

  • @AshleySpencerfan The Wendla here is Alexandra Socha, who replaced Lea.

  • The girl in the middle is INTENSE!

  • fantastic =)

  • alexandraaaaa

  • amazing :)

  • I like Socha until 0:40... It sounded like she was reaching for those notes after that... She's good, but not the best.

    My favorite performances of this song are at the degrassi/SA mash-up and at the 2007 Drama Desk Awards.

  • You gotta move like that when you're into it and its that high up.

  • why they move like that ? just singing !

    I love them voices !

  • Goosebumps! absolutely amazing !

  • I love thi ssong ! so cool

  • all of this dancing.... seriously? sounds good though

  • they dance like that because that's how it's done in the actual show.

  • those are actors, that's how actors sing.

  • That was amazing!!!!! You're so good!! 5 star!!

  • Duncan owns my soul.

  • great show!

  • emma's doing the robot?!

    love this.

  • XDDD you just made my day, so true!

  • I love this song, too. :)

  • The time has seriously come for an acoustic SA cd - or several! The material sounds brilliant when delivered in such a raw style. Holly Brook should do her own set, and then a variety of cast members should release one also!

  • I love this song!

  • I love you Alexandra Socha. She is BOSS with this song, haha. Seriously, she's my favorite Wendla to sing this song I think.

  • Who did that ridiculously fierce first 'mama, the angels'? (The loudest one at around 0:32.) I think it was Socha?

  • methinks Socha also.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • they sound really good, but does anyone else notice how awkward every girl except alex(who looks and sounds wonderful here) and emma(occasionally) move? they seem confused as to what they're doing. the vocals, however, blow me away.

  • I noticed that. I think it's because they want to do the full-blown choreography but can't.

  • cute girls with beautiful voices <3

  • Socha= fierce. I know not many people share my opinion, but damn, Lea's reprise never came close to Socha's.

    *Disclaimer*: I love Lea Michele just as much as anyone. This comment only pertains to this song. Don't burn me at the stake.

  • @largeposterior08 That whole thing just made me want to smile. *Insert smiley emoticon*

  • I agree with that DoloApe06 person .. Thats not them but these people did an amazing job singing still ! Great team work !

  • Do you mean it's not the OBC, or it's not the Broadway cast in general? Because it is, it's the closing cast.

  • this is amazing - so powerful

    well done (:

  • wow sooo pretty awesome *--* good work (:

    i lovee it ♥.

  • Oh, my word. That's amazing! Great power... loved it!!

  • and the on on the far left?

  • Caitlin Kinnunen is on the far left. She played Thea.

  • This is not the girls from spring awakening...who is that girl the second from the right?

  • It is, this the replacements

  • okay no one gives amanda enough credit..this girls voice is so rich and beautiful and shes a beautiful spiritual person..shes a real artist

  • wow

  • i miss this... after 3 times seeing it (august, november and january) i really miss this

    these girls were so fierce <3

  • they sound perfectly fine to me/ if they are singing too loud it just makes the song even more intense. sooo sinnnnggg it girls !! woohoo

  • They're not singing any louder than they did in the show. It was a small room and the acoustics made it so everyone can hear the speakers even without any mics. As you can tell, even the guitar is "loud".

    So all in all, it's not like they're purposely singing "loud," a) that's how they usually sing the song, b) the acoustics.

  • Well, being there in person, they weren't too loud in my opinion. The sound that you are hearing is what my camera picked up, not necessarily what the audience heard. Honestly, if it's too loud, turn down your volume.

  • true dat. as professionals, they should have a clearer idea of blend. that volume is fine for melody, but not for the harmonic lines...

  • I saw this cast in New York on Dec 29th THEY WERE F**KIN AWESOME!!!!!!!

  • i still think that the national tour cast is better

  • Emma Hunton is pretty much god.

  • It closes tonight with a truly AMAZING cast. RIP Spring Awakening 1/18/09

  • I looooooove this song!!!! i showed it to all my friends and they loved it too!!!!!!

  • hehe. im one of those friends. XD

  • i love this. im singing it in our chorus at school and my friend brought it in and we all starting belting it. itss so much fun to sing.

  • not*

  • I still love all of them though and I think they're all amazing and fierce so I'm bashing or anything

  • I'm sorry-- but... as amazing as the other girls sound here, and as much as I try to like Socha... I just don't. Her voice is faaaarrr too strained; I mean, there's BELTING and then there's just painful. I'm really, really sorry, but... she's just not my cup of tea. She also really needs to watch proper tone; she's landing flat in the oddest places :(

  • I saw Lea three times and Alex three times. I know what you mean as far as her sounding strained. Lea has a stronger voice hands down. Oddly enough, though, this video is the strongest I've ever heard Alex.

  • i love this. it is so cool! but i really hate how they say hevin rather than heaven at the end. its a bit annoying. but they all have great voices. also the girl on the right (ilse?) was really good when i saw her on broadway but when she moves here she looks completely robotic and looks stupid!

    now it seems like im bashing this but i actually love the vocal performance!

  • never get tired of hearing them

  • you guys are fierce

  • I love it when it's accapella or just the guitar. It sounds much more edgy and raw.

  • FIERCE.

  • fuck at :32/:33 the way whoever says mama, is fucking awesome

  • that's socha! :)

  • Feirceeeee :D

    This just made me like Alexandra

    :O

  • i love how little accompaniement there is, sounds so much better, really get to hear the power of the song and their voices just stand out so much more, its really great, i love all of them! this song just blows me away everytime...wow!

  • Me too!

  • I love how into it alexandra is

  • this kicks so much ass.

    can anyone tell me who plays who?

    the girl in the middle, and in the maroon is fucking ILLLLLL.

    I just don't like the way they say "bore"

    it's like BOOOOR

    idk its besides the point,

    i love this

  • From left to right: Caitlin Kinnuen as Thea, Emily Kinney as Anna, Alexandra Socha as Wendla, Amanda Castanos as Martha, and Emma Hunton as Ilse.

  • just so no one kills me for saying that lol, i must say as a group the girls sound fantastic here!

  • hey can anyone that has seen caitlin as thea and emily as anna say how they were?

    i myself haven't seen them, but i've seen a ton of video's and live performances (bryant park) and they weren't very strong.

    maybe its just cuz i <3 remy and phoebe's voices but...

  • caitlin REALLY impressed me. her voice is great. emily was good but she didn't really stand out to me

  • you go socha. i like her voice, but that's just me.

  • amazing. i have chills. they r different sounding than the originals, but i like it. they sound younger, which (in my oppinion) makes it more realistic because they girls r supposed 2 b like 14.

    but i still miss the originals

  • I saw all these girls in the show this past Saturday and they were awesome. I was a little worried since the last time I saw the show the OBC were all there, but I was pleasantly surprised. It's still as good as ever!

  • Emma and Caitlin are so great! Caitlin Thea is so perfect she has a harsh but sudle approch to her.

  • HA, having seen her twice live, Caitlin's Thea is anything but subtle.

  • emily and emma are so awesome. emma in particular. she's so amazing.

    alexandra sounds really strained.

  • trust me, I know strained

    she is not strained.

  • i know "strained", too, and in my opinion, she IS strained. ~to each their own~

  • I personally prefer Lea, but Alexandra is still AMAZING. Boo to all the people who just diss Alexandra. Her vocals aren't quite as strong, but I still love her! Here, she sounds incredible.

  • haha

    alexandra haters take THAT.

    she's amazing!

  • this is the best recording ive ever heard of this song. they are AMAZING.

  • that was really amazing.

  • Alexandra Socha, marry me.

  • Amazing! Alexandra is so talented, along with all the other girls.

  • THAT WAS AMAZING!!!!

  • Alexandra is rocking it here!

    And her outfit is cute!

    =)

  • They were fantastic!

    Socha has a wonderful voice!

  • I can shout! I iz gud singer!

  • THANK YOU.

  • exactly.

  • I LOVE YOU

  • Alexandra RULES

  • I really didn't like Alexandra's version of those you've know

    but this performance blew my mind

  • Alexandra fucking Socha. Why are you so amazing.

  • I love Alexandra.

  • I love them all.

    Enough with the Alexandra hate! I think she's amazing. I love the new cast members.

  • I know some people don't like ALexandra's voice, but I love it!

  • I love how into it Socha gets. And I wish people would stop ragging on her voice, she's not as vocally strong as Lea, but I think she's good. She's gorgeous too :)

    And whoa, the harmonies were so dead on.

  • doesn't sound the same :\

  • Of course it doesn't sound the same, they're different people.

    i think that they're fabulous. I think you need to listen to it with an open mind.

  • It sounds like there's an extra part.

    Maybe Ilse got another harmony part?

  • umm...where do you hear the extra harmony?

    through the whole thing, or just at certain parts?

  • Nevermind. I dunno.

  • socha's voice...eugh. :(

  • I love how all of them fix their hair before they start! :)

  • the one on the left end seems reallyyyy nervous!

    but they sound great.

    but if she plans on staying on broadway she should deff become more comfortable.

  • When was this? Awesome, thanks for uploading!

  • soooo good

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more