Also, how does this woman have anything to do with the film? She is obviously an extra, but an extra talking to herself or into something?! It seems so out of place? Then she sort of acts strangely moving towards the cam? Like she is not supposed to be there? So weird...
You know? I watched this over and over going mad wondering WTF I was meant to look at as I've been focusing so much on the background as it is highlighted a bit. So here I am wondering WTF is this guy on about?! Then I focus my eyes and look at the video in a different way and see the woman walking past and go "oh!" the woman in the back does look like she is holding something to her ear as well though...
yeah I know , however at that time the smallest radio set was the crystal radio set ,which wasnt pocket sized .Radio telephones were . Thats what it probably is !
I don't think shes holding anything. Looks like maybe there's an itch under her hat. She's talking to herself sure, but I'm sure a lot of older people are guilty of that. The shadow between her hand and face might make people think she's holding something, but I just don't see it. Very convincing though.
the zebra morphs into an elephant. For our pleasure. Her foot seems sometimes very close to the street advertisement and then her right foot swings without any trouble the sign seems to no longer be in her way at all. Then the two main walkers are walking at the same pace which is like those crazy monster Ramstein abduction clips prove is normal for greys or reps or dracs or clones. They don't travel through time like a ride at the park they do it because they are master manipulators.
yeah it looks like a clunker motorola, maybe she came back to get her forgotten pin? They say she is a man but her shoes and stockings look female to me. The idea that cell towers would be needed is along the train that she is a human. I saw a video saying Chaplin belongs to the Freemasons. And them being slaves to the entities is as it is.
The underlying radio technology ( frequency hopping) to make mobile phones possible was first conceived during World War 2. Motorola developed the prototype mobile phone in the 1960's. The cellular network topology that made portability possible was also developed in the 1960's by Bell Labs. So it seems implausible that a user in 1928 would have a cell tower and all the associated switching elements to make a call on what we know today as a mobile phone network.
I have commented about this before and i will comment again.MOBILE PHONES WERE NOT INVENTED BY SANTA. GO AND LOOK UP THE RKO PICTURE COMPANY LOGO AND YOU WILL SEE THAT IT IS 100 YEARS OLD AND HAS A PICTURE OF A BLOODY HUGE RADIO TOWER.PORTABLE RADIO TELEPHONES WERE INVENTED BEFORE THE !!!!!FIRST WORLD WAR!!!!!! so much for the argument that radio technology was invented by the tooth fairy yesterday.if she is not just some random old bat,then that is what she is talking on.10/10 RETARD points
@ppaull40 Transister radios were around then and very common. She looks to me like she is cursing at the ballgame. While the technology you are talking about was around it was new and not very popular and away from cell towers, you may as well be trying to talk into a gameboy.
@gunniesack Yeah,thats my point , there is at least a better , ie; more reasonable argument than time travel ! In fact I am sure this is debunked because of those facts ! ......By the way , how do you think radio transitors worked ? By radio broadcast from a tower or antenna !
@ppaull40 Its easy, going through some prts of resevations, I can still pick up a.m. stations, but not use a cell. No towers around. There was not F.M till 69 or 70
If it is a cell phone how does it work if there are no cell towers back then? I'm wondering if a lip reader can try and determine what's he/she is saying. It's obviously some type of very high tech communications device.
Maybe she's holding something cold cause she got hurt or got a tooth taken off or something. At a certain point you can see her change the way she holds it a little bit. Maybe cause it's too cold. And maybe she was just walking and talking to someone but didn't realize the person wasn't beside her anymore because her hand was hiding her sight on her left. Then when she was in front of the camera, that person she thought she was talking to yelled to her saying "Hey you're in front of the camera!"
@Rayved that is the most reasonable and level headed observation i have heard from anyone about this whole ridiculous stupid braindead subject.i salute you
each time i watched i tried to tell myself it was something else, but the physical posture is timeless to holding a phone and the person even smiles and speaks.
The guy dressed as a woman has huge feet. Larger then the other men in the clip. The device has most likely a walkie talkie. Tesla had invented wireless communication before 1928.
Hey, have a look at this video, its the same kind of instance! Look at the frame at 3:28>>> What do you think!! Look this title up here on YOUTUBE : "The Open Road London (1927) "
The actor playing Mr. Hide was struck so hard by the hero that he needs an icepack and his tongue has found a broken tooth.
Or a common man in a common man's slicker with a contrasting cravat/scarf or towel or thik handkerchief or ... something held to the scratch his wife Isabel gave him when she found out he had a girlfreind named Audrey that left a hickey...
This happens sometimes when the hero hits the villain in a black cape and hat so hard that Mr. Hide needs an icepack for a possible broken tooth. And he's working two jobs because he can't get out of his 5 year contract and it doesn't pay much..
It also happens to the common man in a common dark slicker with contrasting light scarf that has a hicky from his girlfriend Audrey and wonders what damage it will do on his marriage because his wife Isabel already suspects something so he's got to ..
Why does everyone assume it's an iPhone? We're no where near time traveling yet. Maybe in the future there will be another leading phone company. (Just the other day Apple surpassed Exxon as the leading company in the Us and the first trillion dollar one at that.
@Silentblogger659 let us suppose if it reallie was a time traveller,, itsnt it possible that in that advanced future, when people could themselves go thru ages, coudnt communicate thru??? maybe she had some device attached to wherever she parked her time machine, which could send out signals for mobile, n sending them to future to communicate??.. i knw its weird, just thought it cud be possible, if dat reallie was a time traveller.
@mateenalimateen your thinking way to much into it..things dont always need a complex backstory to be true..sometimes the answer will be right in front of your eyes
MMM, That is obviously dressed more suited to a Keltic era, my estimation is that this is an alien whom has just returned from a long trip, Looks like he found a coat to try and blend in, and whats up with the show sandels? Just a thought
It's Charles Chaplin pulling a prank.Listnen,this guy was an intellectual and way beyound his time.Btw,this is really something that Charlie would do and come up with.Charlie Chaplin is a mystery on itself.I think it's the genious mind of Charlie.
To talk on the cell phone would take a phone antena to transmit the signal That's why the phones failed on 9/11 the antena was destroyed. It didn't exist in Chaplin's day, indeed there were none in those days. Open your mind far enough and you'll fall for anything. Another Nibiru nut. God keep me sane.
I believe it is a "test"... the people who make this movies want to know if people are watching carefully or not. Remember he said he found it at the extras. where most people don't even check!! it is a test. Confirm. The devil want to know if people are taking it too seriously or not. Peace
The absence of an explanation as to what she holding does not imply time travel. It was a novel video, but my theory is that it is an object intended for some sort of medical relief of a toothache, and her mouth movement was not speech...Can you hear me now? (I couldn't resist, sorry)....
I know what I said earlier, but I have discovered the truth. The device she is holding is most likely a portable hearing aid patented by Siemens in 1924. On their website, there is a photo of a man and woman. The man is holding the device in a similar manner as the old woman in the footage. She is talking to hear herself and looks up prob. because she heard the camera or the crew-since it was silent film they could be as loud as the want.+film cameras back then were also quite loud and bulky
I know what I said earlier, but I have discovered the truth. The device she is holding is most likely a portable hearing aid patented by Siemens in 1924. On their website, there is a photo of a man and woman. The man is holding the device in a similar manner as the old woman in the footage. She is talking to hear herself and looks up prob. because she heard the camera or the crew-since it was silent film they could be as loud as the want.+film cameras back then were also quite loud and bulky
Is it not possible cell phones existed back then? it's not like we're haven't been 20-30 years behind on technology before, there's no telling how long the cell phone existed before being revealed....
It Has to be Paul Galvin the Founder of Motorolla. Motorola started in 1928, and this time traveler fits the height and facial features of Mr.Galvin look it up if you dont believe me. He went back in time and founded Motorola. makes sense. He was in drag to disguise himself from Time Authorities
This can easily be explained. This is not a time traveller. This mysterious figure is an ageing woman or possibly a man making up the female numbers for the scene. No matter how hard you look there is nothing in the hand and it's simply held in an "oh my goodness" nervous, confused manner to the side of the face. Now, remember that this is a silent film, the director shouts, "Slow down!" and the nervous extra replies, "I am I am." They're probably all chattering to eachother. It's silent...
when she turns, u see there is nothing in her hand! thin black device? that's her hand's shadow! there r a thousand explinations for why her hand is in that position, this isn't one of them!
@Chris25311 true, but for all we know if she WAS a "time traveler", she obviously would becoming from a time with updated advanced technology, therefore maybe she would be coming from a time where cell phones don't even need phone towers.
@loveeYhux3 right, they don't need phone towers or satellites, and are also capable of making/receiving calls from the future. but it seems to me that you're arguing the point theoretically, so i won't hate.
that being said, i am a time traveler, and i will be calling you tomorrow, so expect to answer the phone yesterday.
@RobSellsTacos Lol, I'm not saying I'm convinced she's a time traveler, I'm not even arguing that she COULD be, I'm just saying FOR ALL WE KNOW. Just considering how advanced the technology would have to be, so I mean I guess there could possibly be a way.
and now seriously 1-st Suggestion: She is upset about soeone/something and talking to her self and the phone is the hand's shaddow, 2-nd Suggestion: She has a sore tooth and just happens to look like that, 3-rd Suggestion: She may be holding some sort of mechanical music box right next to her ear because its noisy outside and 4-th: She may be a time traveller (Let's BE OPEN MINDED PLEASE!!)
How?????? A phone, REALLY! It is obviously a dictaphone! She is saying, "Time Traveler's log. In 1928. I just wanted to scare people 80 something years from now! Ha Ha!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"
I wondered if it way a walkie talkie(2 way radio) at first but after alittle research i discovered theywerent invented until several years after this film was made. Time travel has been proved to be possible, some think you may only be ableto go backto the time it was invented but i disagree
she/he is a time traveler... the reactions of the body are 100% truly correct... and the guy in fron of her/his is wat to far to tell is talking with him... so its like the movie THE FLY something went wrong and thats it :s
Now, with my last comment in mind, there are many explinations, as to what she could be holding to her ear. In 1924, a company called "Siemens" produced a compact hearing aid that when held, would resemble what she is holding. I hope these explainations help. Keep in mind, no towers to carry a cell phone signal, no way to make a call.
Cameras often play tricks on the eyes, especially when judgeing distnace. She's either talking to the man infront of her, or talking to someone out of frame. But it would look as if she's too far away from anyone depending on the angel or placement or both of the camera. As far as what she's holding, it looks as if she's covering her face by either pulling and holding up the collar of a shirt or whatever she could be wearing under her coat. I mean, she is walking right into the shot. Maybe she
It,s a real time traveler, she/he is trying to get back on the zebra with a sadle and go home. Zebra broke down in the wrong time, had to phone home to get a zebra time machine mechanic. Geez Fucktards
I think your Freudian slip ("he") is part of the answer. It looks like a man. At first I thought that IF it was a woman, she might be holding her hat on, but hats don't generally have something at that location to hold it on. However, if you look at it as a man in a woman's clothing (as very common in the early days of show business), he's probably trying to make sure his wig doesn't fall off and cursing. Remember how expensive film was then, too!
i dont think they had satellites in this time to catch a cell phone signal..trippy idea though.its like the only way to turn back would be like that movie Superman.just fly around the earth until it reverse direction.
towards the end, why does it seem like shes talking? if its not a phone and only a device to hear?...no one is near her, there shouldnt be a reason for her to be talking if its not a cellphone device of some sort, unless shes crazy lol
O.k.. here is some things just throwing out there:
Say the old lady didnt want to be filmed and had something to just cover her face like a purse or something and might of been just talking to herself? was it something pressed to her face "just because" like for comfort. maybe she just did that walking by and put it down a few seconds later.
why do people think there has to be a tower? If the lady can travel in time, im sure they have technology were they can talk with out a tower.
@joesef777 The thing is that time travel is impossible and will forever be impossible. Time does not actually exist other than to count the rotations of planets. It is a measurement and not a physical thing! In most circumstances the things that are counted by time are finite and usually have a beginning and an end. To say that time travel exists would mean that the world has no order as everything would have the potential to change. It would be ciaos because history could be re-written.
@joesef777 There would be no definitive answer to anything as everything could be changed at any moment. And life is certainty on a line not a paradox. Plus. For time travel to exist it would mean that life would be stored somewhere. Like a hard drive for your computer! And to say the world is 4.5 million years old it would have to be a mighty hard drive. I think there is more chance of God being real than time travel ever happening. If time travel was real where is the evidence?
I meant billion! The video looks weird but there are a hundred possibilities and we will never find the answer. Why? We will never travel in time! Just imagine if she was a time traveller. She just happens to walk onto a famous film set. Films are staged and are not just random people walking around the streets. "ACTION"
Sorry to be so annoying but really....honestly...the guy that made this film is doing what people like best. Puzzles. I don't like jokers. Often your the joke!.
Oh yeah I guess I'm busted. That was me in that video.. Thought i was being more sneaky. Darn. Well I g2g meet up with King Henry and feed my pet dinosaur.
Its important to understand that you can see the antenna of this device and the dark part sticking out of her handis not a shaddow, either way that antenna is not her thumb. You should all listen to the Billy Meier contact notes.
It's obvious she's from the future, what are you fucking retarded? Jesus christ, a two year old could have fucking told you this. There's no long explanation for it, she's a time traveler, simple.
She/He is a Luciferian, Their technology is 50 to 100 years ahead of ours. We have to remove the notion that technology is new, rather it is withheld and slowly released. George Orwell was no phrophet, he somehow obtained information of technology which had not been released yet, and also the intentions of those whom had it. Even children now don`t go anywhere without a gps trackable telescreen [mobile phone] which can be eavesdropped on just as predicted in the novel 1984.
I don't know wut to think.... honestally it doesnt look like a cell phone, when she turns I didn't see anything in her hand. Riding the bus I see crazy people all the time talking, dancing, eating things that arnt there..... I mean some real wack jobs. Not shur about this, but I'm open to believeing.
The sheer effort used by the "debunkers" on this piece of video, which shows someone _obviously_ and _unequivocally_ speaking into a hand-held device of some kind -- phone or not hardly matters... makes me think that the video must indeed be showing us something quite unusual. "ExplainDotExe" is a particularly good example, where he applies the exact strategy of which he accuses "chemlin." The "hearing aid" argument is idiotic -- no one, not even today, "chats" into a hearing unless insane.
Mr Cooper, born December 26, 1928, wanted people to be able to carry their phones with them anywhere. While he was a project manager at Motorola in 1973, Cooper set up a base station in New York with the first working prototype of a cellular telephone, the Motorola Dyna-Tac. After some initial testing in Washington for the F.C.C., Mr. Cooper and Motorola took the phone technology to New York to show the public.
I think u are letting ur film-making imaginative mind take root here (not a bad thing by the way). And why are u disproving a radio in favor of a phone? ... I think it appears there is a black device (Maybe shadowing or she's just nuts and talking to her HERSHEY bar) ... On top of which Who would she call? (maybe she brought a friend?) I can't say it isn't possible, Cause anything is. But it's more then likely very explainable. Granted I can't definitively do it lol.
Who would she be phoning? How would she get any signal? And the last chance I got to time travel I had to turn it down because I had no clean underwear. My mum always tells me to wear clean underwear when you time travel,
@MajorityUnavailable Obviously it isn't Tmobile or Vodafon, lol. This is a communication device not literally a cell phone. Who she talks to we don't know, but obviously she is talking to someone.
@MajorityUnavailable Satellite phone? Assuming it's a "time traveler", there's no mention of what time period they are from. There's no known method of detecting satellites at the tim
You're dumb as f***k. That's definitley not time travel. Time travel isn't even possible, because time is nothing more than a measurement.
wolfcurt22 1 day ago
How can "she" even use it in 1928 even if she time traveled? There are now towers/technology to base and link cell phones together, it wouldn't work.
But I find this really creepy.
chrisworld2 1 week ago
@chrisworld2
She must be having a SPECIAL price plan with unlimited calls through time.
WakeUpDz 1 week ago
If its a hearing aid then who is she talking to?
Botskeexp 2 weeks ago
but there where no cellphone towers.
michaeljfigueroa 3 weeks ago
Also, how does this woman have anything to do with the film? She is obviously an extra, but an extra talking to herself or into something?! It seems so out of place? Then she sort of acts strangely moving towards the cam? Like she is not supposed to be there? So weird...
vintagerosenz 3 weeks ago
You know? I watched this over and over going mad wondering WTF I was meant to look at as I've been focusing so much on the background as it is highlighted a bit. So here I am wondering WTF is this guy on about?! Then I focus my eyes and look at the video in a different way and see the woman walking past and go "oh!" the woman in the back does look like she is holding something to her ear as well though...
vintagerosenz 3 weeks ago
If its a hearing aid device,so who is she talking with? No one talking with her
Rkrakatau27 3 weeks ago
Hearing Aid Device invented in 1924 !!! get a life !!!
Legererene 1 month ago
Ok, if it's a time traveler talking on a cel phone in 1928...who the hell is she talking to? Nobody else had a cel phone either.
wrober2000 1 month ago
@wrober2000
other time travellers?
wasupwifdat 3 weeks ago
@wrober2000 she was leaving a voice mail to herself, like some people talk to theirselves
1KillerBitch 2 weeks ago in playlist Best evidence videos
yeah I know , however at that time the smallest radio set was the crystal radio set ,which wasnt pocket sized .Radio telephones were . Thats what it probably is !
ppaull40 1 month ago
I don't think shes holding anything. Looks like maybe there's an itch under her hat. She's talking to herself sure, but I'm sure a lot of older people are guilty of that. The shadow between her hand and face might make people think she's holding something, but I just don't see it. Very convincing though.
MoreLikeBorophyll 1 month ago
Did they just film a random person or was she in the movie
PrincessLily618 1 month ago
just fucking show it god damn 2:39
9Zibby9 2 months ago
Yea it's an ear trumpet, way to go .
Soma874 2 months ago
the zebra morphs into an elephant. For our pleasure. Her foot seems sometimes very close to the street advertisement and then her right foot swings without any trouble the sign seems to no longer be in her way at all. Then the two main walkers are walking at the same pace which is like those crazy monster Ramstein abduction clips prove is normal for greys or reps or dracs or clones. They don't travel through time like a ride at the park they do it because they are master manipulators.
TheSHERIE68 2 months ago
yeah it looks like a clunker motorola, maybe she came back to get her forgotten pin? They say she is a man but her shoes and stockings look female to me. The idea that cell towers would be needed is along the train that she is a human. I saw a video saying Chaplin belongs to the Freemasons. And them being slaves to the entities is as it is.
TheSHERIE68 2 months ago
The underlying radio technology ( frequency hopping) to make mobile phones possible was first conceived during World War 2. Motorola developed the prototype mobile phone in the 1960's. The cellular network topology that made portability possible was also developed in the 1960's by Bell Labs. So it seems implausible that a user in 1928 would have a cell tower and all the associated switching elements to make a call on what we know today as a mobile phone network.
CaptCrunge 2 months ago
It looks like one of those films where the character goes back in time and just throws on random clothes to try and fit in.
PhantomBolt 2 months ago
I have commented about this before and i will comment again.MOBILE PHONES WERE NOT INVENTED BY SANTA. GO AND LOOK UP THE RKO PICTURE COMPANY LOGO AND YOU WILL SEE THAT IT IS 100 YEARS OLD AND HAS A PICTURE OF A BLOODY HUGE RADIO TOWER.PORTABLE RADIO TELEPHONES WERE INVENTED BEFORE THE !!!!!FIRST WORLD WAR!!!!!! so much for the argument that radio technology was invented by the tooth fairy yesterday.if she is not just some random old bat,then that is what she is talking on.10/10 RETARD points
ppaull40 3 months ago
@ppaull40 Transister radios were around then and very common. She looks to me like she is cursing at the ballgame. While the technology you are talking about was around it was new and not very popular and away from cell towers, you may as well be trying to talk into a gameboy.
gunniesack 1 month ago
@gunniesack Yeah,thats my point , there is at least a better , ie; more reasonable argument than time travel ! In fact I am sure this is debunked because of those facts ! ......By the way , how do you think radio transitors worked ? By radio broadcast from a tower or antenna !
ppaull40 1 month ago
@ppaull40 Its easy, going through some prts of resevations, I can still pick up a.m. stations, but not use a cell. No towers around. There was not F.M till 69 or 70
gunniesack 1 month ago
its a mobile in the 20s wtf
bonnie9608 3 months ago
Were walkie talkiez out back then?....If so, i think thats what it iz....
itsKosherLife 3 months ago
That's a cell phone dunno by which mysterious power that was possible but the proof is under the naked eyes.
DanyLofico 3 months ago
@Rayved..plz don't be so naive it hurts. Unless you do it on purpose!
DanyLofico 3 months ago
If it is a cell phone how does it work if there are no cell towers back then? I'm wondering if a lip reader can try and determine what's he/she is saying. It's obviously some type of very high tech communications device.
Calcifermay 3 months ago
It looks absolutely like a phone....she walks the same pace ,as the man in front of her...
rihannalover93 3 months ago
Maybe she's holding something cold cause she got hurt or got a tooth taken off or something. At a certain point you can see her change the way she holds it a little bit. Maybe cause it's too cold. And maybe she was just walking and talking to someone but didn't realize the person wasn't beside her anymore because her hand was hiding her sight on her left. Then when she was in front of the camera, that person she thought she was talking to yelled to her saying "Hey you're in front of the camera!"
Rayved 3 months ago
@Rayved that is the most reasonable and level headed observation i have heard from anyone about this whole ridiculous stupid braindead subject.i salute you
ppaull40 3 months ago
Its a galaxy nexus!
misterJRill 3 months ago
bio-digital jazz, man.
TTplayar 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Right....Who exactly would they be ringing..?
Javanman7 4 months ago
Right....Who exactly would they be ringing..?
Javanman7 4 months ago
Right...Who exactly would they be ringing?
Javanman7 4 months ago
each time i watched i tried to tell myself it was something else, but the physical posture is timeless to holding a phone and the person even smiles and speaks.
VICECORE2011 4 months ago
Did they have portable radios back then ?
Cell phones weren't invented yet, so how could a crazy person pretend to be talking into one ?
Whats with the dude walking in front ? the person on the phone looks like they are following them.
faustini69 5 months ago
Sorry 4:26 - 4:27
gearsiborg 5 months ago
Carefully look at 3:59 frame per frame even pause and look the hand how it changes as if it would be way different than a phone behind it
gearsiborg 5 months ago
Its a radio
Ryanandrewsvfx 5 months ago
@Ryanandrewsvfx a portable radio in 1920s .. rofl that too would be a worthy find!
MightyMessenger777 5 months ago
thats not a woman its a man
MrRobChuck 5 months ago
This shit scared the shit out of me.
i4ill 5 months ago
Its an ipod docing station, shes rockin out in 1928, she partying like its 1979. Lol
Joshvlog123 5 months ago 8
Go to 2:42 . Thumbs up so you and others don't have wait.
Baumron420 5 months ago 2
Comment removed
Baumron420 5 months ago
Ohh.wait radio naa.what about if she is wondering where she leave her umbrella.jaja RL
TheRudyp7 5 months ago
Maybe it just a radio and she is singing..
TheRudyp7 5 months ago
Dude looks like a lady.
The guy dressed as a woman has huge feet. Larger then the other men in the clip. The device has most likely a walkie talkie. Tesla had invented wireless communication before 1928.
kokuryukia 5 months ago
Hey, have a look at this video, its the same kind of instance! Look at the frame at 3:28>>> What do you think!! Look this title up here on YOUTUBE : "The Open Road London (1927) "
SoppyProduction 5 months ago
oh thats me checking last messags lol
alimunth 6 months ago
One of John Titor's time traveler? lol
snakefood2k1 6 months ago
The actor playing Mr. Hide was struck so hard by the hero that he needs an icepack and his tongue has found a broken tooth.
Or a common man in a common man's slicker with a contrasting cravat/scarf or towel or thik handkerchief or ... something held to the scratch his wife Isabel gave him when she found out he had a girlfreind named Audrey that left a hickey...
How many scenarios can there be? Honestly.
committeesq 6 months ago
This happens sometimes when the hero hits the villain in a black cape and hat so hard that Mr. Hide needs an icepack for a possible broken tooth. And he's working two jobs because he can't get out of his 5 year contract and it doesn't pay much..
It also happens to the common man in a common dark slicker with contrasting light scarf that has a hicky from his girlfriend Audrey and wonders what damage it will do on his marriage because his wife Isabel already suspects something so he's got to ..
committeesq 6 months ago
Why does everyone assume it's an iPhone? We're no where near time traveling yet. Maybe in the future there will be another leading phone company. (Just the other day Apple surpassed Exxon as the leading company in the Us and the first trillion dollar one at that.
Scottydonaughty 6 months ago
Try to get some one to read the persons lips...
juan060189 6 months ago
That is a peculiar looking individual :/
Any idea what kid of boots he/she is wearing?
titanx9 6 months ago
youre all retarted..they didnt have the cell phone satellites in space yet, so how could she be talking on a cell phone? she wouldnt be..
Silentblogger659 6 months ago
@Silentblogger659 yeah but in the future there's an app for that.
titanx9 6 months ago 7
@Silentblogger659 let us suppose if it reallie was a time traveller,, itsnt it possible that in that advanced future, when people could themselves go thru ages, coudnt communicate thru??? maybe she had some device attached to wherever she parked her time machine, which could send out signals for mobile, n sending them to future to communicate??.. i knw its weird, just thought it cud be possible, if dat reallie was a time traveller.
mateenalimateen 6 months ago
@mateenalimateen your thinking way to much into it..things dont always need a complex backstory to be true..sometimes the answer will be right in front of your eyes
Silentblogger659 6 months ago
It is a iPhone 4 I bet after that she going to play PAC man the app
KGMedsger 7 months ago
There is a new app on iphone call #uck the Future audience with my iphone 101
EarthBrotherPerth 7 months ago
it's iPhone with InterPeriod service that can be used in any time period. hahaha...
ahmadhaniev 7 months ago
she's using iPhone 11 or 12!! hahaha...
ahmadhaniev 7 months ago
It's possible...
thetdslayer 7 months ago
MMM, That is obviously dressed more suited to a Keltic era, my estimation is that this is an alien whom has just returned from a long trip, Looks like he found a coat to try and blend in, and whats up with the show sandels? Just a thought
BrandonJGasaway 7 months ago
wALKIE TALKIE ... i DONT KNOW WERID
DjKillaKoala 7 months ago
*but
Jax27199 8 months ago
It does look like s/he is holding a phone nut s/he obviously isn't
Jax27199 8 months ago
DOC!
sordanproductions 8 months ago
grande PEPE REYNA de SPAIN y Steve HOwARD de USA!! jajaja
kchaispanos2 8 months ago
grande PEPE REYNA de SPAIN y Steve HOLLARD de USA!! jajaja
kchaispanos2 8 months ago
wtf zebra
haoqh 8 months ago
she's from the Future and an Actor of a certain Show called "Charlie and the CHeap-monks"
tonib000y 8 months ago
It's Charlie pulling a prank on us!!!
walitung 8 months ago
It's Charles Chaplin pulling a prank.Listnen,this guy was an intellectual and way beyound his time.Btw,this is really something that Charlie would do and come up with.Charlie Chaplin is a mystery on itself.I think it's the genious mind of Charlie.
walitung 8 months ago
i just wasted my time watchin this vid..
vlad013 8 months ago
A film maker that has to record a video of his tv, WTF?
1penguin99 8 months ago
yeah its only a props its part of the sceen
raidersnoypi 8 months ago
ever heard of schizophernia?
pippigladstone 9 months ago
To talk on the cell phone would take a phone antena to transmit the signal That's why the phones failed on 9/11 the antena was destroyed. It didn't exist in Chaplin's day, indeed there were none in those days. Open your mind far enough and you'll fall for anything. Another Nibiru nut. God keep me sane.
Spud4X 9 months ago
I believe it is a "test"... the people who make this movies want to know if people are watching carefully or not. Remember he said he found it at the extras. where most people don't even check!! it is a test. Confirm. The devil want to know if people are taking it too seriously or not. Peace
mgtosman 9 months ago
@mgtosman theres no such thing as the devil. sorry.
pippigladstone 9 months ago
The absence of an explanation as to what she holding does not imply time travel. It was a novel video, but my theory is that it is an object intended for some sort of medical relief of a toothache, and her mouth movement was not speech...Can you hear me now? (I couldn't resist, sorry)....
willdogg1954 9 months ago
Riddle me this? Why would a time traveler use this devise in full view of the public?
BrownMaterial 9 months ago
I know what I said earlier, but I have discovered the truth. The device she is holding is most likely a portable hearing aid patented by Siemens in 1924. On their website, there is a photo of a man and woman. The man is holding the device in a similar manner as the old woman in the footage. She is talking to hear herself and looks up prob. because she heard the camera or the crew-since it was silent film they could be as loud as the want.+film cameras back then were also quite loud and bulky
romanoromaker 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I know what I said earlier, but I have discovered the truth. The device she is holding is most likely a portable hearing aid patented by Siemens in 1924. On their website, there is a photo of a man and woman. The man is holding the device in a similar manner as the old woman in the footage. She is talking to hear herself and looks up prob. because she heard the camera or the crew-since it was silent film they could be as loud as the want.+film cameras back then were also quite loud and bulky
romanoromaker 9 months ago
I am Deaf and lip read, and she was talking to her bank and going through security for training purposes.
NickTamotor 9 months ago
Похоже на слуховой аппарат.
Rusfbm 9 months ago
omg ! that 's iphone 10g? hahahahaha
siam194 9 months ago
Is it not possible cell phones existed back then? it's not like we're haven't been 20-30 years behind on technology before, there's no telling how long the cell phone existed before being revealed....
MysteryXIII 9 months ago
I swear. I thought some stupid scream thing was going to pop up and scare me.
sonicmandx12 9 months ago
it looks like a man... and she's too many clothes on for summer.. maybe he or she is hiding
KakkoiiYossy 9 months ago
It Has to be Paul Galvin the Founder of Motorolla. Motorola started in 1928, and this time traveler fits the height and facial features of Mr.Galvin look it up if you dont believe me. He went back in time and founded Motorola. makes sense. He was in drag to disguise himself from Time Authorities
Bearkat50 9 months ago
This can easily be explained. This is not a time traveller. This mysterious figure is an ageing woman or possibly a man making up the female numbers for the scene. No matter how hard you look there is nothing in the hand and it's simply held in an "oh my goodness" nervous, confused manner to the side of the face. Now, remember that this is a silent film, the director shouts, "Slow down!" and the nervous extra replies, "I am I am." They're probably all chattering to eachother. It's silent...
naughtyninja1 9 months ago
when she turns, u see there is nothing in her hand! thin black device? that's her hand's shadow! there r a thousand explinations for why her hand is in that position, this isn't one of them!
samsharon1234 9 months ago
Might be a loonatic talking into a remote control.... no, that doesn't fit
canard1du1bain 10 months ago
it's a shoe.
CASE CLOSED!
RobSellsTacos 10 months ago 2
also did anyone notice that the man and the woman are perfectly in step with eachother? eeeeeeeeerie
RobSellsTacos 10 months ago
this women or man is talking on a phone if it was a hearing device of the time who is she talking to she is walking alone!!!!!!!!!!!!
B1ZARTv 10 months ago
WHOA!!!
MSLADYMYSTERY247 10 months ago
If its a phone she wouldn't be able to talk on it because there were no phone towers in those days!
Chris25311 10 months ago
@Chris25311 true, but for all we know if she WAS a "time traveler", she obviously would becoming from a time with updated advanced technology, therefore maybe she would be coming from a time where cell phones don't even need phone towers.
loveeYhux3 10 months ago 2
@loveeYhux3 right, they don't need phone towers or satellites, and are also capable of making/receiving calls from the future. but it seems to me that you're arguing the point theoretically, so i won't hate.
that being said, i am a time traveler, and i will be calling you tomorrow, so expect to answer the phone yesterday.
RobSellsTacos 10 months ago
@RobSellsTacos Lol, I'm not saying I'm convinced she's a time traveler, I'm not even arguing that she COULD be, I'm just saying FOR ALL WE KNOW. Just considering how advanced the technology would have to be, so I mean I guess there could possibly be a way.
loveeYhux3 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i think is Nina Sharp from Fringe, and the guy from min 3:35 is the Observer ;D
cooOCaina 10 months ago
i think is Nina Sharp from Fringe, and the guy from min 3:35 is the Observer ;D
cooOCaina 10 months ago
@cooOCaina totally agree with you :))
seletchi 10 months ago
and now seriously 1-st Suggestion: She is upset about soeone/something and talking to her self and the phone is the hand's shaddow, 2-nd Suggestion: She has a sore tooth and just happens to look like that, 3-rd Suggestion: She may be holding some sort of mechanical music box right next to her ear because its noisy outside and 4-th: She may be a time traveller (Let's BE OPEN MINDED PLEASE!!)
GeorgiMl 10 months ago
Nikola Tesla said to that lady "OK so you take this piece of ebony and talk to it infront of the camera, so we can freak out future people" :D
GeorgiMl 10 months ago
How?????? A phone, REALLY! It is obviously a dictaphone! She is saying, "Time Traveler's log. In 1928. I just wanted to scare people 80 something years from now! Ha Ha!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"
Xtremeproductions5 10 months ago
america is 100 years ahead in 1928 meaning they have what we have now in 1928!
fat3y 10 months ago
I wondered if it way a walkie talkie(2 way radio) at first but after alittle research i discovered theywerent invented until several years after this film was made. Time travel has been proved to be possible, some think you may only be ableto go backto the time it was invented but i disagree
GazzaToTheBeat 10 months ago
It´s a I Phone -4, the prototype, LOL
Dimix85 10 months ago
lòl_Änÿ_gùYs_wÁNt_tÓ_chat_wÏth_mÊ
LunaiFondaaa414 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Check out my Charlie Chaplin remake movie that I made for my college arts class. Leme know what you think!!!
njkiddsab05 10 months ago
she/he is a time traveler... the reactions of the body are 100% truly correct... and the guy in fron of her/his is wat to far to tell is talking with him... so its like the movie THE FLY something went wrong and thats it :s
RE4Ex2 10 months ago
my guess is an iphone 4 maybe dont know just maybe
RE4Ex2 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I think she's testing new model cell phone SonyEricsson X10,the smallest phone in this moment,that's why we can not see it.
sotir82goran 10 months ago
To those of you who are saying it's a hearing device simply because that's what experts are saying. I confer this to you. Suck it.
You have no way of knowing for sure if that actually is a hearing device! For all we know she might of been a crazy old bat talking to a bar of soap!
chinesemusicDJ 10 months ago 20
Now, with my last comment in mind, there are many explinations, as to what she could be holding to her ear. In 1924, a company called "Siemens" produced a compact hearing aid that when held, would resemble what she is holding. I hope these explainations help. Keep in mind, no towers to carry a cell phone signal, no way to make a call.
GrungeRevival101 10 months ago
@GrungeRevival101 i love it when people are logical and reasonable in these situations. thanks for the explanation!
c0nzo12 10 months ago
Cameras often play tricks on the eyes, especially when judgeing distnace. She's either talking to the man infront of her, or talking to someone out of frame. But it would look as if she's too far away from anyone depending on the angel or placement or both of the camera. As far as what she's holding, it looks as if she's covering her face by either pulling and holding up the collar of a shirt or whatever she could be wearing under her coat. I mean, she is walking right into the shot. Maybe she
GrungeRevival101 10 months ago
we know that the "guys" at bohemian grove love to cross dress, and if they are time travelers they would probably go back in drag...
TheTravis1971 11 months ago
@sandynoden yes that's true she could also be putting something up to her ear and talking to her/himself
tehdeathmech 11 months ago
It,s a real time traveler, she/he is trying to get back on the zebra with a sadle and go home. Zebra broke down in the wrong time, had to phone home to get a zebra time machine mechanic. Geez Fucktards
SelflessEmpire 11 months ago
Comment removed
SelflessEmpire 11 months ago
It's also possible that they had communication devices on set and the director was discussing when and where to walk/stand, etc.
sandynoden 11 months ago
I think your Freudian slip ("he") is part of the answer. It looks like a man. At first I thought that IF it was a woman, she might be holding her hat on, but hats don't generally have something at that location to hold it on. However, if you look at it as a man in a woman's clothing (as very common in the early days of show business), he's probably trying to make sure his wig doesn't fall off and cursing. Remember how expensive film was then, too!
sandynoden 11 months ago
can't see any device in her hand. I think she was just scratching her ear.
hongyewu 11 months ago
i dont think they had satellites in this time to catch a cell phone signal..trippy idea though.its like the only way to turn back would be like that movie Superman.just fly around the earth until it reverse direction.
green67blink66 11 months ago
you are the first person who invented the highest level of stupidity!!! WELL DONE ASSHOLE!!!
louboulos 11 months ago
towards the end, why does it seem like shes talking? if its not a phone and only a device to hear?...no one is near her, there shouldnt be a reason for her to be talking if its not a cellphone device of some sort, unless shes crazy lol
nicensweet2280 11 months ago
She probably had an eargasm from a video she saw on youtube......
MajorityUnavailable 11 months ago
O.k.. here is some things just throwing out there:
Say the old lady didnt want to be filmed and had something to just cover her face like a purse or something and might of been just talking to herself? was it something pressed to her face "just because" like for comfort. maybe she just did that walking by and put it down a few seconds later.
why do people think there has to be a tower? If the lady can travel in time, im sure they have technology were they can talk with out a tower.
joesef777 11 months ago
@joesef777 The thing is that time travel is impossible and will forever be impossible. Time does not actually exist other than to count the rotations of planets. It is a measurement and not a physical thing! In most circumstances the things that are counted by time are finite and usually have a beginning and an end. To say that time travel exists would mean that the world has no order as everything would have the potential to change. It would be ciaos because history could be re-written.
MajorityUnavailable 11 months ago
Comment removed
MajorityUnavailable 11 months ago
@joesef777 There would be no definitive answer to anything as everything could be changed at any moment. And life is certainty on a line not a paradox. Plus. For time travel to exist it would mean that life would be stored somewhere. Like a hard drive for your computer! And to say the world is 4.5 million years old it would have to be a mighty hard drive. I think there is more chance of God being real than time travel ever happening. If time travel was real where is the evidence?
MajorityUnavailable 11 months ago
I meant billion! The video looks weird but there are a hundred possibilities and we will never find the answer. Why? We will never travel in time! Just imagine if she was a time traveller. She just happens to walk onto a famous film set. Films are staged and are not just random people walking around the streets. "ACTION"
Sorry to be so annoying but really....honestly...the guy that made this film is doing what people like best. Puzzles. I don't like jokers. Often your the joke!.
MajorityUnavailable 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
They asked Charlie Chapliin what the device was in her hand and he had this to say..
"AAAAAHHHH!!! WHERE THE HELL AM I?!! WHO ARE YOU PEOPLE?!
AM I DEAD?!! HOW DID I GET HERE?!!! MY GOD MY BODY! IM A SKELETON!!!
HELP ME!!! GOD!!! AAAHHHHHHHHH!!!!"
joesef777 11 months ago
If he/she is a time traveler it's an obvious violation of the temporal prime directive...to not leave any evidence of his/her visit.
halfrunt42 11 months ago
anyway who the hell would he be on the cellphone to, how can you call another phone if yours is the only one and no satalites exist lol
kyerien 11 months ago
Oh yeah I guess I'm busted. That was me in that video.. Thought i was being more sneaky. Darn. Well I g2g meet up with King Henry and feed my pet dinosaur.
sarsarluv6 11 months ago
aliens no question, they look like us
pheildcorn 11 months ago
Its important to understand that you can see the antenna of this device and the dark part sticking out of her handis not a shaddow, either way that antenna is not her thumb. You should all listen to the Billy Meier contact notes.
sweet6b9 1 year ago
It's obvious she's from the future, what are you fucking retarded? Jesus christ, a two year old could have fucking told you this. There's no long explanation for it, she's a time traveler, simple.
SuntanAlbino 1 year ago
@SuntanAlbino ttrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrorolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltrolltroll
SweDXxKushxX 1 year ago
@SweDXxKushxX You catch on quick. :P
SuntanAlbino 1 year ago
She/He is a Luciferian, Their technology is 50 to 100 years ahead of ours. We have to remove the notion that technology is new, rather it is withheld and slowly released. George Orwell was no phrophet, he somehow obtained information of technology which had not been released yet, and also the intentions of those whom had it. Even children now don`t go anywhere without a gps trackable telescreen [mobile phone] which can be eavesdropped on just as predicted in the novel 1984.
you00t 1 year ago
@you00t
I understand you00t votes up mate
pheildcorn 11 months ago
Charles e alden made a cell phone in 1906. Time travel what a joke
MrBigbelly49 1 year ago
I don't know wut to think.... honestally it doesnt look like a cell phone, when she turns I didn't see anything in her hand. Riding the bus I see crazy people all the time talking, dancing, eating things that arnt there..... I mean some real wack jobs. Not shur about this, but I'm open to believeing.
SarahHogan100 1 year ago
@SarahHogan100 It looks like one of the older cell phones I used to have that was short but thick..
sweet6b9 1 year ago
This is a bug in the matrix, the program chose the wrong equipment for the bot
OZU666 1 year ago
Gakak45 hey u never kno
keekeebrownie 1 year ago
The sheer effort used by the "debunkers" on this piece of video, which shows someone _obviously_ and _unequivocally_ speaking into a hand-held device of some kind -- phone or not hardly matters... makes me think that the video must indeed be showing us something quite unusual. "ExplainDotExe" is a particularly good example, where he applies the exact strategy of which he accuses "chemlin." The "hearing aid" argument is idiotic -- no one, not even today, "chats" into a hearing unless insane.
baiyuantongbei 1 year ago
The iPhone does time travel.
supercube86 1 year ago
who hold a cellular phone like that?
supercube86 1 year ago
Mr Cooper, born December 26, 1928, wanted people to be able to carry their phones with them anywhere. While he was a project manager at Motorola in 1973, Cooper set up a base station in New York with the first working prototype of a cellular telephone, the Motorola Dyna-Tac. After some initial testing in Washington for the F.C.C., Mr. Cooper and Motorola took the phone technology to New York to show the public.
brazilianguy17 1 year ago
I think u are letting ur film-making imaginative mind take root here (not a bad thing by the way). And why are u disproving a radio in favor of a phone? ... I think it appears there is a black device (Maybe shadowing or she's just nuts and talking to her HERSHEY bar) ... On top of which Who would she call? (maybe she brought a friend?) I can't say it isn't possible, Cause anything is. But it's more then likely very explainable. Granted I can't definitively do it lol.
davidfan 1 year ago
SHE WAS CALLING HER TARDIS!!!!
rjplowman11 1 year ago
That was my dads girlfriend
UncleMiltonChing 1 year ago
Who would she be phoning? How would she get any signal? And the last chance I got to time travel I had to turn it down because I had no clean underwear. My mum always tells me to wear clean underwear when you time travel,
MajorityUnavailable 1 year ago 21
@MajorityUnavailable Obviously it isn't Tmobile or Vodafon, lol. This is a communication device not literally a cell phone. Who she talks to we don't know, but obviously she is talking to someone.
snakeling22 11 months ago
@snakeling22 So you are honestly telling me you believe she is a time traveller?
MajorityUnavailable 11 months ago
@MajorityUnavailable You apparently have never watched Doctor Who.
EliteSasuke 9 months ago
@MajorityUnavailable Satellite phone? Assuming it's a "time traveler", there's no mention of what time period they are from. There's no known method of detecting satellites at the tim