It always matters, my friend, and no it does no sound the same. It would be in a different key. It's also Toccata and Fugue in D minor and so it should also be played in D minor, because the song is called Toccata and Fugue in D minor.
I accidentally clicked on this link after listening to a classical version and I decided to log into youtube for the first time in over two years to comment. You really need to turn down you gain dial and take a plasma welder and melt the knobs off your amp. You definitely have enough skill to play this, but you have no taste. Please stop ruining this song and remove it.
It isn't a lack of taste, it is different taste. I like the classical version and this one, the classical one is more ominous though =P. You did nobody a favor by logging on to just be rude to this man. Oh and to the player, you have some amazing skills.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
You fucking suck you stupid son of a bitch. And next time, don't name a video something that it isn't. This is just the Toccata. Mother fucking faggot.
open your eyes and read what he's saying: ''A free interpretation of Bach's original piece of music for the organ. The language I'm speaking at the end of the clip is called Afrikaans.'' do you understand it?
no, that's right. the violin uses a bowing action, which makes it easier to run off a fast series of notes. on the guitar, you have to strum to hit each note individually, so to play a violin piece you have to takes all the half chords and individuals and run them together a little.
but to play a guitar piece on a violin, you just have to hit the frets fast enough to keep up with the bow.
but on violin u don't even have frets, it's a lot harder to make clean sound, the trick is to hit the string accurately, and that's hard. I bet u haven't played violin. : )
LOL, you'd win that bet! Sorry, i can be a pompous ass sometimes. Have to keep reminding myself to put "in my opinion" in front of some of these comments.
Thanks for telling me that, i'll remember it for the future
It's so hard to find new ways to adapt old classics like that. But this one Bach piece works so well with the Shredder here, it's one of those really hard songs. Almost dragonforce Guitar Hero 3 level here.
wow ur comparing this to dforce wow dforce sucks the farts out of mj (the singer) ass god dam lol this is so much harder than tard dforce god...............
lol dragone force suck's dick really they do they are good in studio but live omg omg omg way bad every one that's like 1000 people say they suck did and have seen them live and liked them then did not cause they suck dick..........
Alright stupid shit. Dragonforce admits to recording slower in the studio than their music comes out to be. Second of all. Look up rusty cooley. Third look up michael angelo batio. Fourth look up about 100 neoclassical guitarists and they kick herman li's ass. Because dragonforce isnt anything special. I kill dragonforce and im 18. Then again I probably play more than herman li because hes only in it for the money.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Well I don't know where you got this idea that Dragonforce records at 85% and I could be wrong, they do. But when I saw them live back in 2004 before most people even knew who they were... They definately can play that fast. And before you talk anymore shit, let's see some of this awesome ability.
this is only the toccata portion with a little bit of the fugure. since a fugue is two lead melodies it would mean its impossible to play the fugue and it's supposed to with once guitar. though i suppose it may be possible to do if you use hammer ons and pulloffs to play both parts using both of your hands haha. abut 2 years ago i started playig thisand i got about 3 minutes in before the fugue really begins and its killer. this song will push your limits,
The Organ is one of the Most Difficult Instruments to play. You could play this on Guitar after about 1 months Practice. It would take you over a decade to even concider playing it on the Organ. T&F is recognised is being the Most Difficult piece to play on the organ.
Dude, if you know how to play the piano, it's not that hard to play the organ. I mean, yea, it's still hard, but it's easier b/c you know the notes and all. And all I'm saying, is that it's equally hard to play on the guitar as it is on the organ. ^^
bwahaha :) dude, ekt vergeet hoe belaglik goed jy is. as iemand ooit weer vir my vra wat "creative expression" is kry hulle die link na hierdie video toe. brilliance.
AWESOME!!!!
RichiePoo28 9 months ago
i have got the exact same lamp standing right next to me in this moment xDDD
btw nice playing... but to much overdrive in the chords i think
SlipknotFreak0815 1 year ago
This is so fucking Awesome
keevre 1 year ago
Again, as with other versions of this on electric guitar, less reverb and volume is required. More consistent timing.
DoctorLawyerWhatever 1 year ago
Nice job, good energy about this interpretation, I like very much.
dextor314 1 year ago
nice but the time was just a bit off
leatherjck 1 year ago
Bach rocks!
apaloosa01 1 year ago
Actually, there is a part of the fugue in the video...
Ramaznaz 1 year ago
It's awesome how, in that entire Afrikaans sentence, only one word sounded different to English.
"En dit is 'n plastic padda."
UndefeatableTwilight 1 year ago
Hey man, fuck all these people that are talking shit... you and this other guy i've seen doing this song are the only good posts on here just about.
morbidgod 1 year ago
Fucking sucking
8888Luter 1 year ago
lol
8888Luter 1 year ago
headbanging to bach.....eeeeeh yeah noooo.
classicalmannick101 1 year ago
you suck.
blackeyed1230 1 year ago
Jimi Hendrix would be proud of you...
Obeijin 1 year ago
lol.. an that is a plastic frog.. for those wondering what he said :) goed gespeel boet.. groete van engeland af!
phantomlucretia 1 year ago
fucking epic
gtardoriffic 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hay what's up ...how are you ?
Hi EveryOne all of my friends.
We have New Band Rock Pop Song Came Out Now
on TheYoungBluesRecords :)
Check Out PLZ
Plz ADD & Subscribe Me PLz
i wish you will like our songs & Videos :)
sincerely
The Young Blues
AlldaysBanglamusic 2 years ago
there are parts that are a... shit. sorry, but it's true. even so, you play very good this song
Willy1093 2 years ago 2
Thank God. You actually did it in D Minor.
psychobugler 2 years ago 3
whys that matter? Equal temperement dictates it'll sound just about the same in any minor key.
Chefodeath 2 years ago
It always matters, my friend, and no it does no sound the same. It would be in a different key. It's also Toccata and Fugue in D minor and so it should also be played in D minor, because the song is called Toccata and Fugue in D minor.
psychobugler 2 years ago 2
Awesome.
MOLRobocop 2 years ago
There were a number of parts that were played WAY faster than needed, but the parts that I COULD hear were awesome!
alexnobody1 2 years ago
1:06 was exactally what I was looking for.
WheaalMoa3n 2 years ago
Bach can rock!
frosty92314 2 years ago 11
this is frickin amazing. and im going to tell u that adding some pinch harmonics would add a lot. but keep it up.
fusetheband 2 years ago
too much distortion and a little too much liberty taken i think... can't really do that with Bach. But very good job, very impressive
MasterNobodyD3 2 years ago
this song is so fucking creepy and i just love your version also man!
88mphsss 2 years ago
nice but there definetly is better! keep playin tho :)
SpotNote 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
naaa not that good too much distortion and so it sounds gay metal homosexually
fatcat363 2 years ago
are you saying metal is gay
videogamefreak123 2 years ago
your "Afrikaans" sounds a little Dutch =P
South Africa? ayways best performance of Tocata and Fugue on guitar so far!
VortexGenie 2 years ago
Whoa this is seriously the best rock version ive seen of this piece so far! Good job man!
JepHanz 2 years ago
I accidentally clicked on this link after listening to a classical version and I decided to log into youtube for the first time in over two years to comment. You really need to turn down you gain dial and take a plasma welder and melt the knobs off your amp. You definitely have enough skill to play this, but you have no taste. Please stop ruining this song and remove it.
Randyo16 2 years ago
It isn't a lack of taste, it is different taste. I like the classical version and this one, the classical one is more ominous though =P. You did nobody a favor by logging on to just be rude to this man. Oh and to the player, you have some amazing skills.
boogerhaze93 2 years ago
your guitar sound is good!
nice perform, pls add beat or background music!
Darkuillity 2 years ago
very nice after going thru other versions that are played with no passion so boooring and plain...
Alpia 2 years ago
nice
TheRealEricLester 2 years ago
yeah yeah so its not really toccata & fuge, still an alright level of playin, ive the guy a break y'all.
lullylewj 2 years ago
and the fugue??
Red0Stratrock 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
You fucking suck you stupid son of a bitch. And next time, don't name a video something that it isn't. This is just the Toccata. Mother fucking faggot.
IGOLDBERGI 2 years ago
i think he didn't know better.
conraydo 2 years ago
clam down man lol
weridoman69 2 years ago
open your eyes and read what he's saying: ''A free interpretation of Bach's original piece of music for the organ. The language I'm speaking at the end of the clip is called Afrikaans.'' do you understand it?
orkiwutz 2 years ago
Jesus christ.
Calm the fuck down
Cinatas666 2 years ago
very nice ! we ran in music today nice cover !
AznS0ulja 2 years ago
alguien tiene la TAB??¿?¿?¿?¿¿?¿?¿?¿?
chafa666 2 years ago
no fugue!!!!!!!
kamcbk3 2 years ago
buahahaaha wtf is that?
3sx 2 years ago 7
wat happened to fugue?
KevinH2294 2 years ago
Was looking forward to seeing you try "Fugue". But oh well.
alexwilsonNC 2 years ago
ever heard of a dictionary? lol Dude it's cool keep practicing ok cheers
medra1980 2 years ago
the video's caption says "Toccata and FUGUE" Sherlock
medra1980 2 years ago
and you were playing toccata the whole time, never fugue
medra1980 2 years ago
Comment removed
medra1980 2 years ago
tastefully done!
armchaircriticTV 3 years ago
Ive also got a CortX2 and would love to be able to play that! well done!
superman737373 3 years ago
ahh!! amazing!! :)
zuckergoscherl96 3 years ago
which guitar is that?thanx
fillfucker 3 years ago
True, but playing the fastest guitar part on a violin isn't nearly as hard as playing the fastest violin part on guitar
theclash06013 3 years ago
i think ur wrong.
figaro001 3 years ago
no, that's right. the violin uses a bowing action, which makes it easier to run off a fast series of notes. on the guitar, you have to strum to hit each note individually, so to play a violin piece you have to takes all the half chords and individuals and run them together a little.
but to play a guitar piece on a violin, you just have to hit the frets fast enough to keep up with the bow.
jm2cloud 3 years ago
but on violin u don't even have frets, it's a lot harder to make clean sound, the trick is to hit the string accurately, and that's hard. I bet u haven't played violin. : )
figaro001 3 years ago
LOL, you'd win that bet! Sorry, i can be a pompous ass sometimes. Have to keep reminding myself to put "in my opinion" in front of some of these comments.
Thanks for telling me that, i'll remember it for the future
jm2cloud 3 years ago
I'm a shitty guitar player (I'm a drummer!) but I've always wanted to try that.
Gratz on doin' it :))
r3dfiv3 3 years ago
so cool, so impressive. u a skilled man.
if65group 3 years ago
I can/could see a metal band get off on this piece. It's got a ton of energy.
jrssjdca 3 years ago
It's so hard to find new ways to adapt old classics like that. But this one Bach piece works so well with the Shredder here, it's one of those really hard songs. Almost dragonforce Guitar Hero 3 level here.
MercenaryX21 3 years ago
wow ur comparing this to dforce wow dforce sucks the farts out of mj (the singer) ass god dam lol this is so much harder than tard dforce god...............
vampreen12356 3 years ago
You're fucking stupid.
This is nowhere near as hard as dragonforce is. Just because you don't like DF doesn't make their material easy to play.
StewieSwan 3 years ago
lol dragone force suck's dick really they do they are good in studio but live omg omg omg way bad every one that's like 1000 people say they suck did and have seen them live and liked them then did not cause they suck dick..........
vampreen12356 3 years ago
Alright stupid shit. Dragonforce admits to recording slower in the studio than their music comes out to be. Second of all. Look up rusty cooley. Third look up michael angelo batio. Fourth look up about 100 neoclassical guitarists and they kick herman li's ass. Because dragonforce isnt anything special. I kill dragonforce and im 18. Then again I probably play more than herman li because hes only in it for the money.
COBalexiCOB 2 years ago
Alright stupid shit, wanna get a source for that ignorant claim?
Or shall I get you some footage of them in the studio recording solos?
Secondly, Dragonforce isn't neoclassical, so I don't see why you brough that style into this?
StewieSwan 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Well I don't know where you got this idea that Dragonforce records at 85% and I could be wrong, they do. But when I saw them live back in 2004 before most people even knew who they were... They definately can play that fast. And before you talk anymore shit, let's see some of this awesome ability.
Fag. Seriously. Kill yourself.
ThrDthPwrPrg 2 years ago
I saw them at leeds uni, its all effects, I used to love them until I saw that...
cigoke 2 years ago
DF's guitarists are very sloppy, i've seen them play alongside the best, vai, satch, freidman etc. Li can't compare.
direngrey4569 2 years ago
you rock!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Jbamski 3 years ago
Wow... Bravo. I believe it's no easy playing this song with the guitar.
ludinhavi 3 years ago
played right and in full it's rediculously hard.
emericanchaos 3 years ago
lol
"The language I'm speaking at the end of the clip is called Afrikaans."
some stupid people out there...
digglefallen93 3 years ago
i expected to head something interesting
rodstartube 3 years ago
Trash!!!!
tetevaovao 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
YOUR FU*KING GAY!!! you masterbate in the mirror
PunkMonkey81 3 years ago
Idiot...
HerrNiekur 3 years ago
this is only the toccata portion with a little bit of the fugure. since a fugue is two lead melodies it would mean its impossible to play the fugue and it's supposed to with once guitar. though i suppose it may be possible to do if you use hammer ons and pulloffs to play both parts using both of your hands haha. abut 2 years ago i started playig thisand i got about 3 minutes in before the fugue really begins and its killer. this song will push your limits,
shadowslayer22 3 years ago
I finger tap from 1:07-1:24. I need to seriously hone my shredding skills =P. I cheat, haha.
disclaimer05 3 years ago
sounds like your saying and that is a plastic bottle
bloodymarriage 3 years ago
this song is hard to play on guitar i just started playing this song and the notes get really hard to play at the speed they require
xlganondorf 3 years ago
that is amazing! you are crazy good lol
Angel759 3 years ago
Delay mees´d it up....Try a different time!
But anyway, you´re awesome!
Jadanegoes 3 years ago
Bach rocks!!!
KassiopeiaMond 3 years ago
... i dont hear fugue in that tho maybe im just tired but can someone point it out?
Pownzorer21 3 years ago
you are good
guisoconmermelada 3 years ago 2
Now who says bach ain't cool?
slashvrfan07 3 years ago 4
the question is... is it harder on organ or guitar?
tyuru2 3 years ago 3
You Are kidding me
The Organ is one of the Most Difficult Instruments to play. You could play this on Guitar after about 1 months Practice. It would take you over a decade to even concider playing it on the Organ. T&F is recognised is being the Most Difficult piece to play on the organ.
cleric50 3 years ago 4
i take it you'v not played guitar?
BornDead616 3 years ago
Dude, if you know how to play the piano, it's not that hard to play the organ. I mean, yea, it's still hard, but it's easier b/c you know the notes and all. And all I'm saying, is that it's equally hard to play on the guitar as it is on the organ. ^^
dbskiluvu 3 years ago
both
BlargenCalipink 3 years ago
is that a wine bottle on the table? great! you made me start drinking again. haha.. just kidding.. great played :)
sondrehovdenhotmail 3 years ago
dude ur room is messy
vova929 3 years ago
Simply stunning ... Great Job !!!!!
hunterofazeroth 3 years ago 2
Man - That's fucking impressive...!
Eilertso 3 years ago 5
what are you all on about? that just about as "nothing special" as the sound of his guitar..
DMendes01 3 years ago
bwahaha :) dude, ekt vergeet hoe belaglik goed jy is. as iemand ooit weer vir my vra wat "creative expression" is kry hulle die link na hierdie video toe. brilliance.
deedlebag 4 years ago
wat is dat nou weer voor verneukt nederlands
mukkezz 3 years ago
dat is afrikaans jonguh!
BazzdeK 1 year ago
I know BazzdeK, was een grapje, enne waarom reageer je eigenlijk op een comment van een jaar oud? XD haha
:P
mukkezz 1 year ago
YEAAAAAAAAAHHHRRRR!!! *bangingmyhead*
SinisterFelix 4 years ago
kickass, man. this is the shit! ^_^
annalouhoo 4 years ago
Excellent.
ROBERTTHESCEPTIC 4 years ago
dude tabs this out for us guys (me)who suck! i love this song
darkgifted1 4 years ago
wat effects did you use?
sounds most delightful mate
punkythepirate 4 years ago
ooooohhooo yeeeeeeeeeesssssssssssssssss!!! great!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
vanerock79 4 years ago
awesome man... i love it
good work
shredgod666 4 years ago
Sick man....SICK!!!! all i can play is kick-drum and shred the stick-babe
PlanB214 4 years ago