Well made video but the 2000's cars took me out of the early 90's setting you were trying to portrait. I'm sure it wouldn't have been too difficult to film around them and only include cars which could have been seen in 1991. 80's-90's vehicles are still fairly common. The great film, "The Squid and the Whale" had this same problem, only it was more glaring as the film was set in 1986.
I personally did not enjoy the video as much as others did. The changes in scenes were much too abrupt, especially the scene where Sam and Charlie kiss. The song that played throughout didn't quite suit the video and overall it did not flow so well and it was a little difficult to follow. The effort was great and it was a good attempt.
no offence but i didnt like that the narrorater was a girl when i read perks of being a wallflower i picture charlie talking to me and like the letters were made for me and that i was speciel
Why are people giving this person a thumbs down? All she/he said was that she/he didn't like the book as much as most people do. Don't give people a negative response for not agreeing with you. They're allowed to form their own opinion.
ok i dont care if u are Emotional, but i don't want to be forced to read it in school, ok you all love the book great, i do not. i over reacted with that comment i know, but its all alot of you talk about...im so sad i want to die...umm then do it? stop complaining so much we dont wanna hear it...
not bad. not bad at all. i am in love with the book, and to be honest this is pretty darn good. even if the narrarator was a girl; who gives a shit? i like the voice, the pics. the whole thing. great job.
this was totally not how i saw the book play through my mind as i read it, for about the intire deration and a few weeks after reading the book i wanted to be a director just to put this book into motion, this book was such fine art.
Love the ideas, especially all the coloured shots and the umbrella sequences. The photograph slides were also fantastic; I loved the introduction of the characters at the beginning - kind of weird to see how other people imagine them!
mmm i know what you mean... im not sure wether or not it really IS being made into a film i personally haven't heard anything that would indicate that it would
IF it did, i think might go see it but im not sure how a motion picture would be able to do this novel justice
it makes me sad that they could take these words and try and put them somewhere more acceptable. ya know? the perks of being a wallflower doesn't seem like the sort of book that was made for people who can't think without a screen infront of them. it just wouldn't be the same.
I didn't know how I felt about the part. I first thought it was corny and didn't fit the tone of the book, but as it went on, I kind of grew to like it, and I guess it was really good to do something different.
Positives; The actress who did Sam was great, really meotional, and just fitted in perfectly.
Patrick was also good.
The whole faded in and out of the page was good too!
pretty good, except for the repeated wiping of the infinite C<3S thing. overdone symbolism much. also, the song at the end.. yeah, no. you'd have done better just closing with one of the songs charlie mentions in the book.
it was one of the requirements for the project but i definitely agree with it being better without... also, all the slides at the end... well i found it a bit much but it was all to accommodate for that stupid song :P
0:46 Seconds, KIN KIU SHOE OMG... (highlight of movie)
Voice at the end = extremely cheesy.
This video is too scattered, I hate videos with music tracks in the background drowning out everything else for the most part. I also noticed you repeated clips 5-8 times in a row, lack of footage?
To be honest, this was definitly one of the better videos that i've seen for this book, but there were still some negative aspects. Such as, the actors did not really fit the physical description that we were given for these characters in the book. And a major thing, Charlie is not female, but yet a female narrated? :S
But again, definitly one of the better videos, even other videos that were school projects. =)
just btw the only reason a female narrated (and actually acted as charlie)was because we were in a group of four girls and really didnt have any other choice :/
Well made video but the 2000's cars took me out of the early 90's setting you were trying to portrait. I'm sure it wouldn't have been too difficult to film around them and only include cars which could have been seen in 1991. 80's-90's vehicles are still fairly common. The great film, "The Squid and the Whale" had this same problem, only it was more glaring as the film was set in 1986.
UnusualTastes 7 months ago
God DAMN, good video, but that ''look into your mailbox'' song was annoying as fuck
DrownedByTheStone 1 year ago
@DrownedByTheStone lol THANKS and I completely agree!
sweettart2121 1 year ago
i would have suggested the song 'Asleep'. and a boys voice. unless that was a boys voice. in which case i apologize.
also, i doubt mark elizabeth would ever wear a crown. and the acting in the kissing scene could have been stronger.
it was good though! i liked it. just thought i'd say what I think could have made it stronger. and i love the smile at 1:33.
goodnessgraciouslove 1 year ago
I'm sorry if this is harsh but your voice makes the book sounds crap, and it's amazing
chazziegirl95 1 year ago
or orthodontia for that matter please and thankyou
sweettart2121 1 year ago
i don't have a fucking lisp its the feedback :)
sweettart2121 1 year ago
Charlie has a beautiful jacket :D
I don't mind, if he is acted by a girl, for that makes him appear a little bit "wallflowerish"
But you could have removed the enamel ;-)
Just this minute I discovered the book once again under a pile of rubbish in my shelf. And after seeing this video I feel like reading it again :)
Good work, I hope, the school project was dignified with an "A" ;-)
FloAusMainz 1 year ago
ugh.
ModBeatnikGirl 2 years ago
That was pretty awesome :)
Some parts could have been a little clearer but it was differently good!
I always pictured Charlie being a little girlish ;)
CaityJenny 2 years ago
the perk's of being a wall wlower is a good book im reading it in school and as soon as i read the first page i fell in love with it
vinnieglez14 2 years ago
Very nice. I am curious though, the song at the end. Was that something that you four wrote?
Duckie82 2 years ago
mhmm
sweettart2121 2 years ago
I personally did not enjoy the video as much as others did. The changes in scenes were much too abrupt, especially the scene where Sam and Charlie kiss. The song that played throughout didn't quite suit the video and overall it did not flow so well and it was a little difficult to follow. The effort was great and it was a good attempt.
jcooncome 2 years ago 6
Too bad Charlie is a male in the book.
pattbenhill 3 years ago 4
Very evocative.
Lisa
LisaNova 3 years ago
oh shut up u twat
flanksrob 3 years ago
why is charlie a girl?
666bl2 3 years ago
no offence but i didnt like that the narrorater was a girl when i read perks of being a wallflower i picture charlie talking to me and like the letters were made for me and that i was speciel
thekorupter 3 years ago 14
1:33 I love that smile! xD
pivotm4ster 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i agree with atm8162. this book is nothing special & it's boring. by the way: can someone tell me what happens at the end? because i just don't get.
CrazeyCandy 3 years ago
you must just not get it because the book changed my life and at the end charlie remebers that his aunt used to touch him
taylorthigpen 3 years ago 2
Why are people giving this person a thumbs down? All she/he said was that she/he didn't like the book as much as most people do. Don't give people a negative response for not agreeing with you. They're allowed to form their own opinion.
CorpseBride777 3 years ago 2
best fucking book. fuckin a.
IEatFlowers 3 years ago 2
I love the book. I can relate to it so much.
RepublicMan4ever 3 years ago
this is really cool, i love this book, and this is a cool version
ayemaynedayyy 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
fucking EMOs kill urselves, make the world a better place
atm8162 3 years ago
grow up.
ayemaynedayyy 3 years ago 3
ur right it was a bad comment
atm8162 3 years ago
lmfao its a good book. how is it emo? stupid fuck. go die u fucking cunt
IEatFlowers 3 years ago
ok i dont care if u are Emotional, but i don't want to be forced to read it in school, ok you all love the book great, i do not. i over reacted with that comment i know, but its all alot of you talk about...im so sad i want to die...umm then do it? stop complaining so much we dont wanna hear it...
atm8162 3 years ago
hahahahaha how is it emo? hahahahaha
SpadeAndArcherBand 3 years ago
i love this book so much. im re-reading it currently. the video was awesome.
what song was in the end? original? i really liked it!
omfgdevon 3 years ago
that book is amazing
sinniemam 3 years ago
How funny of you to mention Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close, that's my favorite book followed by Perks of Being a Wallflower!
RhyanRossi 3 years ago
not bad. not bad at all. i am in love with the book, and to be honest this is pretty darn good. even if the narrarator was a girl; who gives a shit? i like the voice, the pics. the whole thing. great job.
jodiannezook 3 years ago
charlie is not a chick...don't like the voice.
hebyjeeby 3 years ago
AS I'VE SAID
we made the movie for a school project
and we were in a group of four girls
we made do with what we had
sweettart2121 3 years ago
i actually really like the voice....
rhgillam 3 years ago
i freaking love this book. but why is the narrator a girl?
PrettyinPunkOO7 3 years ago 3
because we made the movie in a group of four girls
it was for a school project
we made do with what we had
sweettart2121 3 years ago
i am so glad someone else knows the alternate routes
CliffDeathCab 3 years ago
i love that song :))
sweettart2121 3 years ago
i loved perks of being a wallflower but another great song by the smith besides 4 asleep is frankly mr shankly
hamilteno 3 years ago 2
this is really good, especially for a high school project. my only complaint would be that you didn't include "asleep" by the smiths. well done!
jm629 3 years ago
this was actually a first try at making something like this
we were very proud of it at the time
but are definitely getting MUCHMUCH better
to see a more recent project go to 'kiranaway- please don't kill the freshman'
please comment:))
sweettart2121 3 years ago
What's the song? Really loved the book.
Retard777 3 years ago
this was totally not how i saw the book play through my mind as i read it, for about the intire deration and a few weeks after reading the book i wanted to be a director just to put this book into motion, this book was such fine art.
PittsSteelers 3 years ago
I like the song towards the end. Is it original?
xxheartagramrosesxx 3 years ago
I think thats how everyone pictured bob..
bzzmusic 3 years ago
awesome!!!!
lizjoshabby 3 years ago
Love the ideas, especially all the coloured shots and the umbrella sequences. The photograph slides were also fantastic; I loved the introduction of the characters at the beginning - kind of weird to see how other people imagine them!
Sweet video, though.
All best from England!
Jalxsland 4 years ago
thankyouthankyou :)))
sweettart2121 4 years ago
ughhhhhh highscool was sooo lame
ughhhh
worst!
notthatbadtoday 4 years ago
i dont know what this has to do with anything but i agree like eight thousand million percent
im dropping out asap
:)
sweettart2121 4 years ago
what is the book about???
pinklivy94 4 years ago
oh well thats kind of a difficult question :/
its about a boy who is rather socially awkward (for reasons that you discover eventually)
its a really really good book though you should read it
i highly doubt that you will be disappointed
:)))
sweettart2121 4 years ago
oh!
pinklivy94 4 years ago
so what is it really about???
pinklivy94 4 years ago
pardon ???
sweettart2121 4 years ago
what is it about? like thw hole story? (what does the back of the bok say???)
pinklivy94 4 years ago
Um Charlie looks like a girl.
ladyscene1 4 years ago
charlie IS a girl
not in the book
in this video
becauseee we were in a group of four girls so we kind of had no alternative
for the boys we asked were very unhelpful and disinterested in the project
i think we pulled it off anyways
sweettart2121 4 years ago
Yeah you pulled it off, but it was still be better with a guy. But I guess you made lemon aid out of lemons
bzzmusic 3 years ago
If this was a movie, it'd have to be the kind of movie where the actors are really damn good. I mean, *really* damn good.
Selene147 4 years ago
i definitely completely 100% agree
sweettart2121 4 years ago
It wouldn't work with already famous actors, hollywood would screw this up seriously. Indie film would be the only way to go with this one.
bambamm89 4 years ago
i think if it was done right
it would be a simply beeyouteefull indie film
however i think it would be quite an undertaking to try and represent such a book on film at all
sweettart2121 4 years ago
wait...charlie is a lesbian?!!? Haha, jk. Really good job.
mbsams1fan 4 years ago
if it is made into a film i don't think i'll go see it. it would ruin my perspective.
keeptheareaclear 4 years ago 3
mmm i know what you mean... im not sure wether or not it really IS being made into a film i personally haven't heard anything that would indicate that it would
IF it did, i think might go see it but im not sure how a motion picture would be able to do this novel justice
sweettart2121 4 years ago
it makes me sad that they could take these words and try and put them somewhere more acceptable. ya know? the perks of being a wallflower doesn't seem like the sort of book that was made for people who can't think without a screen infront of them. it just wouldn't be the same.
keeptheareaclear 4 years ago
thats exactaly how i feel.
lizjoshabby 3 years ago
No one could ever convey the emotion and feeling that stephen chbosky put in the book, in a film. it's just not meant to be that way.
keeptheareaclear 3 years ago 4
thats really great =D
xthumbelinaXtristax 4 years ago
thankyou thankyou thankyouu :)))
sweettart2121 4 years ago
is it REALLY going to be a movie?
and if so when?
glorskia 4 years ago
Steven Chbosky said he was writing a screenplay for it...but I don't know when. :]
Mehp.
riseneveryangelslain 4 years ago
not to shabby
corrosive33 4 years ago
thankyou thankyou :)
sweettart2121 4 years ago
i like it-greetings from germany
lovelyKate007 4 years ago
wow thankyous from canada :)
sweettart2121 4 years ago
I didn't know how I felt about the part. I first thought it was corny and didn't fit the tone of the book, but as it went on, I kind of grew to like it, and I guess it was really good to do something different.
Positives; The actress who did Sam was great, really meotional, and just fitted in perfectly.
Patrick was also good.
The whole faded in and out of the page was good too!
Thanks for making it though. :)
clicheddisaster 4 years ago
Lol. Cute girl voice, Charlie.
ekameveileb 4 years ago
why thankyou ;)
sweettart2121 4 years ago
pretty good, except for the repeated wiping of the infinite C<3S thing. overdone symbolism much. also, the song at the end.. yeah, no. you'd have done better just closing with one of the songs charlie mentions in the book.
ameliahoov 4 years ago
it was one of the requirements for the project but i definitely agree with it being better without... also, all the slides at the end... well i found it a bit much but it was all to accommodate for that stupid song :P
anywhooooo
thanks for the comment
sweettart2121 4 years ago
0:46 Seconds, KIN KIU SHOE OMG... (highlight of movie)
Voice at the end = extremely cheesy.
This video is too scattered, I hate videos with music tracks in the background drowning out everything else for the most part. I also noticed you repeated clips 5-8 times in a row, lack of footage?
Maybe I'm just not easily amused.
chrisbahen 4 years ago
you suck chris go away :)
sweettart2121 4 years ago
To be honest, this was definitly one of the better videos that i've seen for this book, but there were still some negative aspects. Such as, the actors did not really fit the physical description that we were given for these characters in the book. And a major thing, Charlie is not female, but yet a female narrated? :S
But again, definitly one of the better videos, even other videos that were school projects. =)
shakebear 4 years ago
Thankyou very much :) im glad you liked it
just btw the only reason a female narrated (and actually acted as charlie)was because we were in a group of four girls and really didnt have any other choice :/
THANKS FOR THE COMMENT :)
sweettart2121 4 years ago