LOL, Manning makes receivers way better. If Gonzolez wouldn't have gotten hurt, nobody would know who Pierre Garcon or Austin Collie are now. 23 regular season wins in a row in a much tougher division than the Saints with a banged team is more impressive than barely beating St Louis and Washington.
wtf peyton manning 99 overall they agaserate his power or whatever in every game he is 99 overall its cheap and in past games brady is like 86 bradys number 1
I spy a Pats homer. One thing its a point in Madden, god it isn't life or death. Manning, I think is better, watching him work with his calling under center is just amazing.
lol brady sits out a year and is still rated higher than drew? thats hogwash.....drew cemented himself as one of the best passers in NFL history last year and he isnt even rated highest in the league....brady is a scrub behind an all pro line and all pro WRs....brady would be garbage on any other team...the same cant be said about manning and brees
ok thats why Brady led the Pats two THREE superbowls with Troy Brown as the number 1 receiver with him being the only good reciever during that dynasty... And umm do u mind telling me who has the all-time record of Passing td's in a season?...oh wait i remembered TOM BRADY!!!! Nope not Peyton Manning OR Drew Brees!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Tom Brady gets credit for leading one of the best built teams in NFL history....he has the measurables, but so does jamarcus russell....Tom Brady wouldnt be shit without the help of his offensive linemen....Deion Branch, Troy Brown, Randy Moss, and Wes Welker.....
Tom Brady didnt operate one of the best Defenses in NFL history.....he didnt kick 3 game winning field goals to win the super bowl....but ur right....he did pass 58 TDs that amounted to absolutely nothing in the post season
@hattrick116 you dont respond to a post 12 months ago jackass but of course i know those arent offensive linemen dumbass........i said brady plays with great offensive linemen and WRs......but instead of saying WRs i named all of them. you're a joke
@hattrick116 make sure you use correct punctuation and dont use run on sentences when you try and correct someone's english. 12 months doesnt equal 1 month. you're a joke
@munckey13 It was a spell check failure. Now, if you want a cookie for pointing that out please hesitate to ask, and take a break to think about what you're saying.
brees better than manning or brady? ur kiddin right brees is totally overrated, maybe brady has had one of the best OL of this decade, but before the arriving of moss, he never had an awesome WR, and peyton he has WR but not OL, brees is nothing compared to them
overrated by who?.......Brees becomes the 2nd passer in NFL history to throw for over 5000 yards in a season.....doing that without a single 1000 yard receiver....doing that with a rookie LG, a career backup C, and a primarily run blocking RT......not to mention his 3 best options at WR missed significant time with injuries(colston, shockey, bush).....you are saying that brees is nothing compared to either of them....but he doesnt have great WRs or great OL and still puts up better numbers
yes man im srry didnt saw the last season, was to busy, i saw some videos, damn brees is good, but i still think that the ebst QBs are Manning and Brady, Manning is the oly QB that selesct the play out of 3 and Brady didnt had a great offense before Moss arrived the Pats.
well if brees keeps playing like he is, without doubt they might get to the superbowl, i mean the pats got to the superbowl just passing the saint got bush he is a heck of a good player, they might destroy any1, but the experience of guys like brady, polamalu and manning also counts towards the SB
well you know that drew just passed for over 300 yards and bush got a td against the win over the eagles 48-22 and brees got 2 td to marcus colston and one to heath evens
@necrohound Let me mention a few..... D-branch, Troy Brown, David Givens, David Patten, not to mention Kevin Faulk and Corey Dillion. Yes, he did have a TON of weapons before Randy Moss that were "awesome"
Vick i would say is about a 90 atm...not better than McNabb yet.
If he works at it and gets his throwing form back, then he could be a 95, but i don't think as far as the traditional QB ratings go he could be more than that, simply because the rigidity of the ratings system for QBs wouldn't allow for a primarily running QB to be more than that, no matter how dangerous he is in real life.
I'm dissapointed Pennington ain't there, he's at least as good as Philip Rivers...
dude, tom brady won all thos superbowls with his best reciever being deon branch.
Peyton manning won 1 superbowl with reggie wayne, marvin harrison (when he was good) andd dallas clark. The one year the patriots get good recievers he breaks peytons record, the Patriots recievers arent that much better than the colts now anyways, if the not the same.
eli manning is 87 yes but why is he getting paid 15 mill a year for the next 6 years and hes only 87, yes i know hes yong and is getting better but still he should be in the low 90s,
I agree with swaggerlikerow13 when is Payton Mannings rating gonna drop how are u going to leave his up and Drop Tom Bradys and Ben Rothisberger is better than Kurt Wayner because whenever Kurt gets sack he fumbles the ball and Ben dosent get sacked
Romo is better than Warner and McNabb i mean he was benched last year there is no way hes a 91 right now and r they gonna have an update with Vick on the Eagles???!!! that would be sick!!!
2007 Season: Grade B+ Offensive line, good blocking back, below average blocking back (fred taylor and MJD), Really bad recievers, 19 overall TD's 3 INT's tieing an NFL record, only 21 sacks (1.3 avg per game).
2008 Season: COMPLETELY crippled and messed up offensive line Even worse recievers (including FA bust Jerry Porter), manages 17 overall TD's and 13 INT's with 42 sacks (2.6 avg per game).
noo tom brady sucks dick he went all the way to the super bowl and got fucked up...and him and randy moss couldnt pull it for there team like they did all season..he should be rated a 60
all you "brady fans" are band wagoners, he has one great season and now everyone "worships" him, peyton is ALWAYS good 30+ TDs a season, and who had the TD record before? brady hadn't thrown for over 28 til recently
tom brady is 2nd behind bitch ass peyton manning haha wow madden fucked up in that category........REILE567 your the biggest idiot if you think drew brees and ben roetlis is better than tom brady, to brady is the best player in the nfl hands down
manning iesnt that good rothlisburger is not that goo just because he won the super bowl doesnt mean he i good romo and cutler arent that god and WERE THE FUCK IS CHAD PENNINGTON HE TOOK THE DOLPHINS TO THE PLAYOFFS AND WAS ONE OF THE MAIN REASONS OF SUCCESS WHY THE HELL IS HE NOT HERE YOUR SAYING A QB UNDER 87 TOOK A TEAM TO THE PLAYOFFS AFTER A 1-15 SEASON?!?!?!?!? WHAT TH FUCK IS WRONG WITH MADDEN????!!!!!
actually i don't eatch football but i watch it and everyone hates fuckheads who comment 7 times on a god damn video for a retarded argument on manning or brady i dont even have a strong opinon about it because i hate brady but dont care about manning why are there so many fucking doush bags on youtube
Another Ben Hater> after driving HIS team down the field in the last minute of the Super Bowl for the win. When Ben gets to 5 SB rings maybe idiots like this will give him his due.
big ben should be one of the last in the league- 17 td with 16 ints...real good. he won both of his rings with the defense around him and santonio makin every clutch catch possible
Where the fuck is chad pennington?! He did so much better then rothlisburger this year and tony homo is on the list but chad pennington who had a 97.4 rating doesn't get on the list?!!! retarted ratings man.
eli should be higher on this list last time i checked he has actually proved hiself in the playoffs thats more than i can say for cutler, rivers, and defintly romo
oh rivers only an 88..whatever my top ten: 1. Peyton-99 2. Drew Brees- 97 3. Big ben- 05 4. Brady-95 5. Rivers-93 6. Donavann-92 7. Warner-90 8. Matt ryan-88 9. cutler-87 10. aaron rodgers-87 tony homo and eli manning shouldn't even be in this discussion..
And rivers was leading most tds with drew brees and he has the best qb rating ...5th in total yard underrated in my opinion. ben roethlisberger is overrated he should be around 13th qb in the nfl with 85
bradys stats 26,446 yds passing 197 passing td's 86 picks and 5 rushing td's peyton 45,628 yds passing 333 pasing td's 165 picks and 17 rushing touchdowns he has only been in the league 2 years more than brady brady has 3 superbowls peyton has 1 but the colts are nothing compared to the pats and you know it
Brees having to throw the ball 36 times every game,Brees has lead the league in most pass attempts since 2006.Saints play no defense,or run the ball effectively.Patriots do both,but Brady is key reason to open up the running game.
lets see look at bradys seasons without moss and welker there pretty good look at brees last year without colston and shockey for most of the season all he did was fall 20 yards short of the season passing record brady is the third best qb his legacy is because of the great team he plays for
Let's look at them,3 superbowls ..... 2 Time Superbowl MVP,has over 150 TD Passes and less than 90 interceptions.Compared to Brees? Nothing he has done,stats don't win superbowls.Look what Brees did in SD,nothing.Comes to a pass happy team that can't play defense,puts up numbers ...... and?
The Pats don't run the ball either,ha ..... that's funny.This would explain why you pick Brees over Brady.Because you don't have a fucking brain to think out of.The Patriots were 6th in the league in rushing last season.Little fact for ya,In 07 when Brady broke all those records,Brees threw the ball 74 more times than Brady.
yeah 6th last year the year tom brady was hurt you fucking joke lets just drop it i could care less about both brees and brady. manning is 100 times better than both brady and brees they cant even hold peytons jock strap
Lol you are retarded,Manning is overrated.Throughout his first 4 seasons he had 71 interceptions total,that's an NFL Record.Peyton can't even hold his own jock strap,because he has no balls.Brady has 3 superbowls and less turnovers and more wins in the playoffs than Manning and doesn't benifit from players will talent like Marvin Harrison.
how can u argue peyton is better, first of all bradys got 3,secondly brady has succeeded with and without offensive talent,and thirdly manning has choked way too many times in the playoffs to be considered better. personally i think they r bof great ,it just comes down to preference
yea, Manning is bad *sarcasm* He lead one of the worst teams in the league, when he came into the league, and his second year, they went from 3-13 to 13-1 in one season. Both are Future HOF, that's obvious, but most QB's can look great in the Patriots offense. (Moss,Maraony((can't spell)) Welker) Both are great and like how ck27891 said it's a matter of preference, and Brady is in his prime.
came 16 yards short of having the most yards in a season in NFL history? read some stats kid. brady has a hell of a offensive line and hell of receiving core. so shut the fuck up you had damn brady dick sucking fag.
Stats don't win games or superbowls,look at Dan Marino.How many superbowls does he have??? Your calling ME a kid when im old enough to be your father??? Hahaha,you KID need a break from the computer.Don't get pussy hurt over one comment chump.Saints can't run the ball,or play D,which leads to ....
Get ____________ and more for free with Swagbucks, a search engine that rewards you just for searching words & phrases as you normally would. Get paid for something you already do with Swagbucks.
tony romo should be dead last. philip rivers went on a tear last year and got the chargers to the playoffs how is he 88??? Mcnabb should be no.3 and brady should be 99 aswell lol.
matt ryan should be rated a 90
PokeFan30100 7 months ago
No aaron rodgers???
GreenBaywins16 1 year ago
Jay cutler is way worse than eli manning
WTman30 1 year ago
@WTman30 more physical talent overall
hattrick116 1 year ago
Cardinals are my favorite, its funny to see there offence is so freakin beastly, but there defence is the crap.
shadownight73 1 year ago
phillip rivers should be higher
TheGoldBoltz 1 year ago
Take out Homo and Rapistberger and replace them with Rodgers and Farve.
desidoe69 1 year ago
he waz retired @ tha time remember yu had 2 update the rosters 2 get vick & favre
ATF11 1 year ago
u thought vick would b 89? ha!
falconfanJJB 2 years ago
for this season: 1. peyton manning 2. drew brees and brett favre, 4. kurt warner, 5. tom brady
everyoneSalegend 2 years ago
where is brett favre?
everyoneSalegend 2 years ago
my latest update is: rodgers with 94 and third best in the game o.O
Jorschach 2 years ago
Vick?!
He is a good QB, even if you hate him you've got to admit it. He should atleast be in the game.
TheDawg412 2 years ago
matt schuab deserves to be in top 4
imdakingofny 2 years ago
aaron rodgers deserves to be on this list.
Boonyakieat 2 years ago 2
where is Favre?
glyan14 2 years ago
wheres rex grossman ?
kieran377 2 years ago
he sucks.
Boonyakieat 2 years ago
lol i was kidding
kieran377 2 years ago
haha, rex sucks.
ChrisJohnson2K 1 year ago
LMAO at 00:13-00:17
sorakeyblade123 2 years ago
put Brees in the hall of fame NOW!! he makes defenses his personal biotch!! saints all the way baby!!
abcd070707 2 years ago
warner 94? yeah right 94-7=87 overall
Codyeagle1 2 years ago
no way that peyton is better then drew brees
gibson4eva223 2 years ago
he is better
SL4VE0WNER1904619 2 years ago
LOL, Manning makes receivers way better. If Gonzolez wouldn't have gotten hurt, nobody would know who Pierre Garcon or Austin Collie are now. 23 regular season wins in a row in a much tougher division than the Saints with a banged team is more impressive than barely beating St Louis and Washington.
jdigitalseven 2 years ago
tom brady be ovbisouly #1
lockness48 2 years ago
@lockness48 my ass
hattrick116 1 year ago
brett farve should be in,jay cutler should go
vietkidd75 2 years ago 8
wtf peyton manning 99 overall they agaserate his power or whatever in every game he is 99 overall its cheap and in past games brady is like 86 bradys number 1
jrfsox98 2 years ago
Brady should be #1
titanrampage 2 years ago
were the fuck is brett fare
10ibrahimovic9 2 years ago 8
@10ibrahimovic9 bro u can get him wen u play online i see u a barcelona fan to ibrahimovic dani alves and messi are soccer
danialves1312 1 year ago
all good teams this year will choke it always happens
redfang150 2 years ago
they didnt know favre was joining my team (mn vikings) otherwise he b up there
GO VIKES!!!
MrMgsguy 2 years ago
Where's Brett Favre?
TheDMV1476 2 years ago
lmao peyton a 99 and brady a 98? the other way around dumb fuck
derick304 2 years ago
fuck no peyton manning is the best and even if ur a pats fan there is no dount peyton manning is the fucking best in the NFL
2WorldWar2 2 years ago
I spy a Pats homer. One thing its a point in Madden, god it isn't life or death. Manning, I think is better, watching him work with his calling under center is just amazing.
kamma333444 2 years ago
ohhh McNabb baby thats my QB
peludo336 2 years ago
same here. he has a lot of talent, i just wish some people could see that.
yourdedede0 2 years ago
thats right drew brees bitchs
prcbeast 2 years ago
1.) Brees 99
2.)peyton 98
3.)brady 96
4.)Rivers 94
5.)McNabb 94
6.)Eli 93
7.)Big Ben 92
8.)Cutler 91
9.)Fitzgerlad i mean Warner 90
10.)i Cant win in the post season Romo Homo 88
xohunnybunxo07 2 years ago
lol brady sits out a year and is still rated higher than drew? thats hogwash.....drew cemented himself as one of the best passers in NFL history last year and he isnt even rated highest in the league....brady is a scrub behind an all pro line and all pro WRs....brady would be garbage on any other team...the same cant be said about manning and brees
munckey13 2 years ago
ok thats why Brady led the Pats two THREE superbowls with Troy Brown as the number 1 receiver with him being the only good reciever during that dynasty... And umm do u mind telling me who has the all-time record of Passing td's in a season?...oh wait i remembered TOM BRADY!!!! Nope not Peyton Manning OR Drew Brees!!!!!!!!!!!!!
13mick13mars 2 years ago
Tom Brady gets credit for leading one of the best built teams in NFL history....he has the measurables, but so does jamarcus russell....Tom Brady wouldnt be shit without the help of his offensive linemen....Deion Branch, Troy Brown, Randy Moss, and Wes Welker.....
Tom Brady didnt operate one of the best Defenses in NFL history.....he didnt kick 3 game winning field goals to win the super bowl....but ur right....he did pass 58 TDs that amounted to absolutely nothing in the post season
munckey13 2 years ago
@munckey13 those aren't Ol's.....
hattrick116 1 year ago
@hattrick116 you dont respond to a post 12 months ago jackass but of course i know those arent offensive linemen dumbass........i said brady plays with great offensive linemen and WRs......but instead of saying WRs i named all of them. you're a joke
munckey13 1 year ago
Comment removed
hattrick116 1 year ago
@hattrick116 make sure you use correct punctuation and dont use run on sentences when you try and correct someone's english. 12 months doesnt equal 1 month. you're a joke
munckey13 1 year ago
@munckey13 It was a spell check failure. Now, if you want a cookie for pointing that out please hesitate to ask, and take a break to think about what you're saying.
hattrick116 1 year ago
Peyton Manning - 49 tds in 14 games
Tom Brady - 50 TD's in 16 games
Peyton could easily get more, but he wasn't a showboat in that game.
D1D4Y1PhillyinLA 2 years ago
brees better than manning or brady? ur kiddin right brees is totally overrated, maybe brady has had one of the best OL of this decade, but before the arriving of moss, he never had an awesome WR, and peyton he has WR but not OL, brees is nothing compared to them
necrohound 2 years ago
overrated by who?.......Brees becomes the 2nd passer in NFL history to throw for over 5000 yards in a season.....doing that without a single 1000 yard receiver....doing that with a rookie LG, a career backup C, and a primarily run blocking RT......not to mention his 3 best options at WR missed significant time with injuries(colston, shockey, bush).....you are saying that brees is nothing compared to either of them....but he doesnt have great WRs or great OL and still puts up better numbers
munckey13 2 years ago
yes man im srry didnt saw the last season, was to busy, i saw some videos, damn brees is good, but i still think that the ebst QBs are Manning and Brady, Manning is the oly QB that selesct the play out of 3 and Brady didnt had a great offense before Moss arrived the Pats.
BTW Go Dallas!! xD!!
necrohound 2 years ago
thank you saints fo life
prcbeast 2 years ago
fuck yo brees can out throw them any day he should be in hall of fame by now
prcbeast 2 years ago
yeah brees souhld be in the hall of fame by now, he has won so much superbowls that he deserve it
necrohound 2 years ago
16 yards from having a nfl record thank you
prcbeast 2 years ago
omg!! 16 yards from a record, and a NFL superbowl? his 3rd one?!
necrohound 2 years ago
you think he gonna break the record and the saints go all the way and wat do you think of bush
prcbeast 2 years ago
well if brees keeps playing like he is, without doubt they might get to the superbowl, i mean the pats got to the superbowl just passing the saint got bush he is a heck of a good player, they might destroy any1, but the experience of guys like brady, polamalu and manning also counts towards the SB
necrohound 2 years ago
well you know that drew just passed for over 300 yards and bush got a td against the win over the eagles 48-22 and brees got 2 td to marcus colston and one to heath evens
prcbeast 2 years ago
brees did not win any superbowls
prsfuture 2 years ago
@prsfuture really now?
hattrick116 1 year ago
brees overrated? wtf? im a falcon fan so i hate brees and i kno he is not overrated!
falconfanJJB 2 years ago
@necrohound Let me mention a few..... D-branch, Troy Brown, David Givens, David Patten, not to mention Kevin Faulk and Corey Dillion. Yes, he did have a TON of weapons before Randy Moss that were "awesome"
hattrick116 1 year ago
man fuck peyton and brady they booth suck balls they should b like 90 or even maybe 80 it all about the return of VICK hes afreaken 100
annel941 2 years ago
Vick i would say is about a 90 atm...not better than McNabb yet.
If he works at it and gets his throwing form back, then he could be a 95, but i don't think as far as the traditional QB ratings go he could be more than that, simply because the rigidity of the ratings system for QBs wouldn't allow for a primarily running QB to be more than that, no matter how dangerous he is in real life.
I'm dissapointed Pennington ain't there, he's at least as good as Philip Rivers...
initiatrix 2 years ago
Chad Pennington is better than Pillip Rivers ...Rivers sucks he's wicked overrated and yeah i know what u mean bout vick
13mick13mars 2 years ago
dude, tom brady won all thos superbowls with his best reciever being deon branch.
Peyton manning won 1 superbowl with reggie wayne, marvin harrison (when he was good) andd dallas clark. The one year the patriots get good recievers he breaks peytons record, the Patriots recievers arent that much better than the colts now anyways, if the not the same.
bLuExbLaCk 2 years ago
Brady has way more weapons plus only broke his record by 1 touchdown with moss and they should both be 99
imsowhiteandnerdy 2 years ago
Peyton sucks, Brady should definitely be number 1
Mariners97 2 years ago
Definetleyy
13mick13mars 2 years ago
jay cutler should be higher i know he does not have wr but stillll
jakesterskates 2 years ago
drew should have a 99 overall
whodaman8888 2 years ago
this list is jacked up! brady should be 99 p manning should be 98
sally13roks 2 years ago
No, Manning is much better
benhgn1 2 years ago
you must be on a whole bunch of drugs cuz brady has 3 reasons why he'sbetter. 2001, 2003, & 2004
sally13roks 2 years ago
all yall pussy as hoes hating on the best qb n the league tom brady go n suck ea's dick so they can take his ratings down
kingmark55 2 years ago
eli manning is 87 yes but why is he getting paid 15 mill a year for the next 6 years and hes only 87, yes i know hes yong and is getting better but still he should be in the low 90s,
motocrossdirtbike 2 years ago
@motocrossdirtbike because coaches don't pay off of madden stats....
hattrick116 1 year ago
I agree with swaggerlikerow13 when is Payton Mannings rating gonna drop how are u going to leave his up and Drop Tom Bradys and Ben Rothisberger is better than Kurt Wayner because whenever Kurt gets sack he fumbles the ball and Ben dosent get sacked
AjstylesTNA24 2 years ago 2
exactly what i am thinkin to myself
martoman217 2 years ago
y is romo and mcnabb higher than rivers? rivers led league in rating and touchdowns
nordstrompimp 2 years ago
yeah i want to no why tom brady up there and he didnt play but when L.T plays and dont do good he goes down
PanteraFan6969 2 years ago
HAHAHA
Papin94 2 years ago
and MICHAEL VICK ???
Papin94 2 years ago 2
wat about jamarcuss russel ???
Papin94 2 years ago
lol
falconfanJJB 2 years ago
y isnt jon kitna in the top ten ?
Papin94 2 years ago
Wow. Why is Tom Brady a 98 when he didn't even play last season?
Shaneomac82 2 years ago
he's a great quarterback
imateenagelabotomy 2 years ago
dude rivers should be at 4 behind brees
cascadejazz4 2 years ago
Romo is better than Warner and McNabb i mean he was benched last year there is no way hes a 91 right now and r they gonna have an update with Vick on the Eagles???!!! that would be sick!!!
APPLE21MVP 2 years ago
Warner is very overrated. Jay cutler is better than him and he is only a 87. Cutler should at least be a 92.
Sammie33Reed 2 years ago
wow, NOBODY says anything about Garrard...
2007 Season: Grade B+ Offensive line, good blocking back, below average blocking back (fred taylor and MJD), Really bad recievers, 19 overall TD's 3 INT's tieing an NFL record, only 21 sacks (1.3 avg per game).
2008 Season: COMPLETELY crippled and messed up offensive line Even worse recievers (including FA bust Jerry Porter), manages 17 overall TD's and 13 INT's with 42 sacks (2.6 avg per game).
Also a 61.2 Completion percentage!
Darkscott626 2 years ago
at least move rivers up i would take him then romo
kevinl9391 2 years ago
damn warner had the biggest leap
kevinl9391 2 years ago
Brady > Manning
cooldude12129 2 years ago
noo tom brady sucks dick he went all the way to the super bowl and got fucked up...and him and randy moss couldnt pull it for there team like they did all season..he should be rated a 60
wilzon121 2 years ago
um no way fag, Brady is way better than Peyton Billboard forehead manning. so u can go fuck urself.
cooldude12129 2 years ago
all you "brady fans" are band wagoners, he has one great season and now everyone "worships" him, peyton is ALWAYS good 30+ TDs a season, and who had the TD record before? brady hadn't thrown for over 28 til recently
makingtheband990 2 years ago
What about aaron rodgers?
slyider1 2 years ago
i think Tom Brady should be rated a 37
carlosZ1981 2 years ago
heres a guy, when he throws the football, the reciever catches it.
brilliant madden, thats why ur a hall of famer and millionaire!......?
carlosZ1981 2 years ago
I think Philip rivers should at least be a 90 ovr. since he led the league in passer rating last year.
volleyballsue 2 years ago 2
how is tom brady a 98 and he only played a couple plays last year.....e
xmanlili 2 years ago 2
because hes tom brady. lol. hes not going away because of a leg injury... he wasnt very mobile anyways.
coolcam28 2 years ago
wtf romo should be 90 overall come on
w2extreme 2 years ago
what i dont get is how eli is in the 80s i thought at least in the low ninetys
casperredsman 2 years ago
eli isnt that good. he wouldnt be paid more than his brother if the giants defence didnt win the super bowl for him.
coolcam28 2 years ago
i have madden 10 already but i dnt get how brady is 98 when nigga was out for a whole fuckin year
robertmendozanasty 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
because hes tom brady. lol. hes not going away because of a leg injury... he wasnt very mobile anyways.
coolcam28 2 years ago
top 3 should go
1 Brees
2Brady
3 manning
goviks37 2 years ago
bullshit brady #1 in my book
fballplayer2324 2 years ago
peyton manning 99 ovr????? no he should be like a 95 not 99
TheNardo17 2 years ago 2
tom is way better then peyton! Kurt is good and i hate the steelers but big ben is better then kurt.
23KINGJAMESDUNKS 2 years ago
tom is not better than peyton. Do u even watch Football?
FlyingMonkeys367 2 years ago
wow brady is the best qb in the league like 3 sb in 4 years hes a monster
hanoverheat21 2 years ago 2
but that doesnt mean hes the best qb..... i think peyton manning is bettter bc he has worse recievers then brady
talktothechalk 2 years ago
Kill ur self ReyandHbk101 Kurt is gaay! ....p.s ur moms better than big ben!!!
xNYsFinestx 2 years ago
Tom rocks
swishajayBeezy 2 years ago
WOW these ratings are crazy. Don't think Kurt Warner should be over Big Ben. Peyton Manning big a 99 since he won the Super Bowl.
bmoreallday1 2 years ago
kurt way better then big ben
ReyandHbk101 2 years ago
peytons been 99 for ten years strait. thats because hes better then tom brady
mgr360 2 years ago
Where the hell is Ryan
nipify96 2 years ago
BRADY NUMBER 1,LETS GO PATS
newyorklove4u 2 years ago
brady is not better than peyton
FlyingMonkeys367 2 years ago
RIVERS??????? WTF HE SUCKS ASS!!!!
OakRaiderz760 2 years ago
SMGWolf 2 years ago
manning is better than brady
FlyingMonkeys367 2 years ago
tom brady is 2nd behind bitch ass peyton manning haha wow madden fucked up in that category........REILE567 your the biggest idiot if you think drew brees and ben roetlis is better than tom brady, to brady is the best player in the nfl hands down
aiaaron3 2 years ago
ur a fuckin dumbaass manning is so much better than brady ur an idiot
FlyingMonkeys367 2 years ago
who threw more int's
kenz1031 2 years ago
manning iesnt that good rothlisburger is not that goo just because he won the super bowl doesnt mean he i good romo and cutler arent that god and WERE THE FUCK IS CHAD PENNINGTON HE TOOK THE DOLPHINS TO THE PLAYOFFS AND WAS ONE OF THE MAIN REASONS OF SUCCESS WHY THE HELL IS HE NOT HERE YOUR SAYING A QB UNDER 87 TOOK A TEAM TO THE PLAYOFFS AFTER A 1-15 SEASON?!?!?!?!? WHAT TH FUCK IS WRONG WITH MADDEN????!!!!!
scott5499 2 years ago
ur a dumbass manning is better than brady do u even eatch football?
FlyingMonkeys367 2 years ago
actually i don't eatch football but i watch it and everyone hates fuckheads who comment 7 times on a god damn video for a retarded argument on manning or brady i dont even have a strong opinon about it because i hate brady but dont care about manning why are there so many fucking doush bags on youtube
scott5499 2 years ago
Another Ben Hater> after driving HIS team down the field in the last minute of the Super Bowl for the win. When Ben gets to 5 SB rings maybe idiots like this will give him his due.
husker69 2 years ago
big ben should be one of the last in the league- 17 td with 16 ints...real good. he won both of his rings with the defense around him and santonio makin every clutch catch possible
infamouslyepic 2 years ago
Where the fuck is chad pennington?! He did so much better then rothlisburger this year and tony homo is on the list but chad pennington who had a 97.4 rating doesn't get on the list?!!! retarted ratings man.
MOVIEDUDE219 2 years ago
how did he do better than roethilisberger when he went to the superbowl? EXACTLY SHUT THE FUCK UP
FlyingMonkeys367 2 years ago
dumbass it takes a team to go 2 a superbowl
kenz1031 2 years ago
brady number 1
celts22208 2 years ago
eli should be higher on this list last time i checked he has actually proved hiself in the playoffs thats more than i can say for cutler, rivers, and defintly romo
Thecincokid 2 years ago
It kinda sucks how drew brees has so much talent but a terrible team to back him up. Its sad
irishplaya1314 2 years ago
reile567 2 years ago
Yea I agree romo has something to prove before he is considered a top 10 qb
eduardo2464 2 years ago
aaron rodgers sucks. eli is decent.. tony romo is alot better than than both those people on your list
FEEDBACKDRUMMING 2 years ago
i see manning still calls a billion audibles before each snap as it was in every other madden game
adrianpetersonroty 2 years ago
Wow rivers should of been at least 90 and i hate the Chargers.
Und3adArmy 2 years ago
i was thinking aaron rodgers might be around 87 or 88...he was 5th in passing tds soo i thought that might give him a boost.
H2player4 2 years ago
And rivers was leading most tds with drew brees and he has the best qb rating ...5th in total yard underrated in my opinion. ben roethlisberger is overrated he should be around 13th qb in the nfl with 85
markrider69 2 years ago
bradys stats 26,446 yds passing 197 passing td's 86 picks and 5 rushing td's peyton 45,628 yds passing 333 pasing td's 165 picks and 17 rushing touchdowns he has only been in the league 2 years more than brady brady has 3 superbowls peyton has 1 but the colts are nothing compared to the pats and you know it
1DJSTUNNA1 2 years ago
THANK YOU someone have brains!!
FlyingMonkeys367 2 years ago
Comment removed
ck27891 2 years ago
Brees having to throw the ball 36 times every game,Brees has lead the league in most pass attempts since 2006.Saints play no defense,or run the ball effectively.Patriots do both,but Brady is key reason to open up the running game.
TheBostonThreeParty1 2 years ago
THE RATINGS ARE PERFECT SO SHUT THE FUCK UP HATERS ONLY BECAUSE YOU HATE BRADY BECAUSE OF HIS GIRLFRIEND! lol
123elpibe 2 years ago 3
Rivers should have a higher rating than mcnabb
MrRod21 2 years ago
Peyton... Still the best! :)
eat it punks
wjkessie 2 years ago
Wow. Roethlisberger WAY overrated. Where is Chad Pennington
Ben: Rating 80.1, 17 TD's, 15 Picks, 3301 Yrds.
Chad: Rating 97.4, 19 TDs, 7 picks, 3653 yrds.
There's really no comparison...
dmarinorules 2 years ago
Ben: Led Superbowl Winning Team
suck it...
willy7070 2 years ago
Rivers and Cutler should both be in the 90's and brady 97 and brees 98
1DJSTUNNA1 2 years ago
Brees over Brady? That must be some kind of joke.What has Brees ever done?
TheBostonThreeParty1 2 years ago
lets see look at bradys seasons without moss and welker there pretty good look at brees last year without colston and shockey for most of the season all he did was fall 20 yards short of the season passing record brady is the third best qb his legacy is because of the great team he plays for
1DJSTUNNA1 2 years ago
Let's look at them,3 superbowls ..... 2 Time Superbowl MVP,has over 150 TD Passes and less than 90 interceptions.Compared to Brees? Nothing he has done,stats don't win superbowls.Look what Brees did in SD,nothing.Comes to a pass happy team that can't play defense,puts up numbers ...... and?
TheBostonThreeParty1 2 years ago
um lets see the pats dont run the fuckin ball either and 3 superbowls led by the pats great 3-4 defense/signal stealing cheating fuckers
1DJSTUNNA1 2 years ago
The Pats don't run the ball either,ha ..... that's funny.This would explain why you pick Brees over Brady.Because you don't have a fucking brain to think out of.The Patriots were 6th in the league in rushing last season.Little fact for ya,In 07 when Brady broke all those records,Brees threw the ball 74 more times than Brady.
TheBostonThreeParty1 2 years ago
yeah 6th last year the year tom brady was hurt you fucking joke lets just drop it i could care less about both brees and brady. manning is 100 times better than both brady and brees they cant even hold peytons jock strap
1DJSTUNNA1 2 years ago
Lol you are retarded,Manning is overrated.Throughout his first 4 seasons he had 71 interceptions total,that's an NFL Record.Peyton can't even hold his own jock strap,because he has no balls.Brady has 3 superbowls and less turnovers and more wins in the playoffs than Manning and doesn't benifit from players will talent like Marvin Harrison.
TheBostonThreeParty1 2 years ago
how can u argue peyton is better, first of all bradys got 3,secondly brady has succeeded with and without offensive talent,and thirdly manning has choked way too many times in the playoffs to be considered better. personally i think they r bof great ,it just comes down to preference
ck27891 2 years ago
yea, Manning is bad *sarcasm* He lead one of the worst teams in the league, when he came into the league, and his second year, they went from 3-13 to 13-1 in one season. Both are Future HOF, that's obvious, but most QB's can look great in the Patriots offense. (Moss,Maraony((can't spell)) Welker) Both are great and like how ck27891 said it's a matter of preference, and Brady is in his prime.
kamma333444 2 years ago
thank you manning is the shit
FlyingMonkeys367 2 years ago
came 16 yards short of having the most yards in a season in NFL history? read some stats kid. brady has a hell of a offensive line and hell of receiving core. so shut the fuck up you had damn brady dick sucking fag.
Vamp1992 2 years ago
Stats don't win games or superbowls,look at Dan Marino.How many superbowls does he have??? Your calling ME a kid when im old enough to be your father??? Hahaha,you KID need a break from the computer.Don't get pussy hurt over one comment chump.Saints can't run the ball,or play D,which leads to ....
TheBostonThreeParty1 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
swagbucks(dot)com/refer/KBank2001
Get ____________ and more for free with Swagbucks, a search engine that rewards you just for searching words & phrases as you normally would. Get paid for something you already do with Swagbucks.
KBank2001 2 years ago
I can see Rivers with an 88, even though he lead the Chargers from 4-8 to 8-8. But he has his good days and bad days.
Gaara34 2 years ago
if manning has 99 overall then why doesn't brady thats fucking bull
2nd: why is romo even on the list he can't even win a playoff game or make it their
and why is rivers overall only 88
he tied for the most td passes last year with brees
cutler had an outstanding season and his should at least be 90 because hes worth 2 1st round picks
roethlisberger's shouldn't be so high the only reason why he won the champioship is because of his fucking defense he sucks a lot
4545646478 2 years ago
i agree with u about everything 100%
ballajo901 2 years ago
brady should be number 1, fuck manning
persianpersuasion17 2 years ago 2
tony romo should be dead last. philip rivers went on a tear last year and got the chargers to the playoffs how is he 88??? Mcnabb should be no.3 and brady should be 99 aswell lol.
cblock356 2 years ago
exactly cblock356, McNabb should definitely be #3 but i think he should be #2.
Frost99030507 2 years ago