@adamantis4657 They were not always forbidden,there are many paintings in churches that picture people or angels playing lutes and ouds,flutes,violins,lyras...
@adamantis4657 Why the heck is it bad to use traditional instruments?Make clear to your brain that I DONT talk about dances and crazy rhythms.HAVENT THE HOLY FATHERS PLAYED PSALTIRI OR TANBUR OR LYRA?
Anyway,I have blocked you since you irritate me ta malla.Bye bye short-brained bro.
2)Do you know the main and real reason of why instruments were forbidden in Churches(of course instruments were used for learning music).Because they were reminding pagan periods.Well,that is a nice example of Dark Age logic,so that "anathema" is .Stop spamming my inbox or I will be forced to report you!Stop sending me those stupid messages!!!!!
You think Simon Karas and Chrisanthos were stupid...Poor guy
2.) LOL - U COULD NOT BRING ANY ARGUMENT AGAINST MY STATEMENTS u only prove THAT I WAS RIGHT
3.) I am not FANATICAL but ORTHODOX - u ARE NOT
4.) Instruments WERE FORBIDDEN BECAUSE the Music of the Church is SPIRITUAL and NOT SENSUAL. Also Jews used instruments - BUT THEY WERE ALSO FORBIDDEN as the HOLY FATHERS SAY
5.) INSTRUMENTS WERE ALWAYS FORBIDDEN BECAUSE THE HOLY FATHERS have forbidden them. Greece can not allow
As u can see form your own posts - greeks are not ORTHODOX ANYMORE. Such silly conclusions and arguments that are DIRECTLY AGAINST THE TRADITION OF THE CHURCH.
The greek New Calendar CHURCH is FULL OF INNOVATION and MODERNISM and u have proven me right.
@adamantis4657 You vile Dark minded poor person...Go burn a witch.Byzantines were not always right...Obviously Christians are far away from Christ.(By the way did Christ forbid instruments?Haha)
Now I understood what kind of person you are and I will not reply to you again.Have a good night and burn many instruments in your dreams.Don't forget to pretend to be a Christian.
YES - CHRIST HAS FORBIDDEN INSTRUMENTS THROUGH THE HOLY FATHERS.
The title of the vid is a bit irritating because there is no instrumental orthodox music. Instruments are forbidden in Church Music.
This is perhaps religious byzantine Music but not Orthodox Church Music.
adamantis4657 2 months ago 2
@adamantis4657 They were not always forbidden,there are many paintings in churches that picture people or angels playing lutes and ouds,flutes,violins,lyras...
AlexBouzouki 1 month ago
@AlexBouzouki: ORTHODOX ICONOGRAPHY!
This is SYMBOLIC and not real. NO IN ORTHODOXY INSTRUMENTS WERE NEVER USED FOR CHURCH MUSIC. NEVER
It is only the Greek Modernised Church that goes form ONE INNOVATION TO THE NEXT:
PEWS, ORGANS, IMMODEST CLOTHING etc...
adamantis4657 1 month ago
@adamantis4657 U mad bro?
AlexBouzouki 1 month ago
@AlexBouzouki: Everything I WROTE IS TRUE!
Why do u wonder? That the Greek Church is fULL OF INNOVATION? Yes it is true:
NEW CALENDAR, PEWS, ORGANS, IMMODEST CLOTHING, PEOPLE DO NOT MAKE PROSTRATIONS etc..
The Greek Church is VERY MODERNISED and INNOVATED!
adamantis4657 1 month ago
@adamantis4657 U mad bro?
AlexBouzouki 1 month ago
@AlexBouzouki: U MAD BRO?
What is it? A statement a questions or what?
Do u not can ask and discuss in a NORMAL WAY? Is the ghetto style or what?
adamantis4657 1 month ago
@adamantis4657 No,it is just SARCASM to short-brained people like YOU sir!
AlexBouzouki 1 month ago
@AlexBouzouki: Your SARCASM does not work!
Instead of posting nonsense - WHY DO U NOT PROVE THAT I AM WRONG? ha?
Come on - when I am wrong - than show where and why! IF NOT REPENT and WEEP over your sins!
adamantis4657 1 month ago
@adamantis4657 God help you...
Now solve your personal problems instead of pretending to be somebody on the Net.
AlexBouzouki 1 month ago
@AlexBouzouki: NO GOD HELP U!
Because again instead of proving me wrong u blame me and post nonsense!
When I am wrong PROVE IT and I will ask forgivness!
IS THE GREEK CHURCH FULL OF INNOVATION? YES:
Especially in USA they even have ORGANS - YES ORGANS - what horrible INNOVATION and TRANSGRESSION AGAINST THE HOLY FATHERS.
They HAVE PEWS - horrible. THEY SIT DURING LITURY - can u imagine - THEY SIT ON PWES LIKE PROTESTANTS.
Immodest Clothing - women are dressed like on beach!
adamantis4657 1 month ago
@adamantis4657 Why the heck is it bad to use traditional instruments?Make clear to your brain that I DONT talk about dances and crazy rhythms.HAVENT THE HOLY FATHERS PLAYED PSALTIRI OR TANBUR OR LYRA?
Anyway,I have blocked you since you irritate me ta malla.Bye bye short-brained bro.
AlexBouzouki 1 month ago
@AlexBouzouki: Do u want that people think u are silly?
1.) Instruments WERE NEVER USED IN ORTHODOXY - NEVER - can be proven from church history. NO PSALTIRI NO TANBUR - sorry.
2.) Instruments in CHURCH ARE EVEN FORBIDDEN BY THE HOLY FATHERS - many have written against Instruments and why the church does not use them
3.) It is against HOLY TRADITION - NO ONE CAN CHANGE HOLY TRADITION.
Whoe ever sets ASIDE ANY TRADITION OF THE CHURCH - ANATHEMA (7th Ecumenical Synod)
adamantis4657 1 month ago
Comment removed
AlexBouzouki 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@adamantis4657 Go for it,prove to be a fontamentalist.
1)Stop the fucking capitals
2)Do you know the main and real reason of why instruments were forbidden in Churches(of course instruments were used for learning music).Because they were reminding pagan periods.Well,that is a nice example of Dark Age logic,so that "anathema" is .Stop spamming my inbox or I will be forced to report you!Stop sending me those stupid messages!!!!!
You think Simon Karas and Chrisanthos were stupid...Poor guy
AlexBouzouki 1 month ago
@AlexBouzouki: WHY DID U CANCEL YOUR POST?
1.) Stop TO CURSE
2.) to be against INSTRUMENTS is not FUNDAMENTAL but NORMAL ORTHODOX TEACHING and ALWAYS WAS
3.) AS U CAN SEE FROM YOURSELF - GREEK NEW CALENDAR CHRISTIANS ARE FAR AWAY FROM ORTHODOXY
4.) The Holy Fathers HAVE FORBIDDEN INSTRUMENTS for MANY REASONS. The Orthodox Liturgy is SPIRITUAL and SENSUAL.
The Liturgy is an ICON of the heavenly LITURGY of BODILESS HOSTS.
adamantis4657 1 month ago
@adamantis4657 1)Ι canceled the first post because I had made a syntax mistake.A thing that you usually tend to do.
2)It is obvious that you can not answer me.
3)Your fanaticism is outstanding...
4)The only truth is that instruments were forbidden because they were reminding the pagan period.
5)In some areas of Greece instruments were never forbidden.
6)Cursing is way better than what you do.
7)Sorry,you got reported
AlexBouzouki 1 month ago
@AlexBouzouki:
1.) NO because u cursed and u wanted to hide
2.) LOL - U COULD NOT BRING ANY ARGUMENT AGAINST MY STATEMENTS u only prove THAT I WAS RIGHT
3.) I am not FANATICAL but ORTHODOX - u ARE NOT
4.) Instruments WERE FORBIDDEN BECAUSE the Music of the Church is SPIRITUAL and NOT SENSUAL. Also Jews used instruments - BUT THEY WERE ALSO FORBIDDEN as the HOLY FATHERS SAY
5.) INSTRUMENTS WERE ALWAYS FORBIDDEN BECAUSE THE HOLY FATHERS have forbidden them. Greece can not allow
adamantis4657 1 month ago
@AlexBouzouki:
6.) CURSING is not GOOD - I posted the TRUTH
7.) I DO NOT FEAR your "REPORTING"
8.) U should fear GOD because ALL MODERNIST AND INNOVATERS are CONDEMNED and CAST OUT FROM THE CHURCH.
adamantis4657 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hey bro,I do not hide my cursing
Fucking ignorant fundamentalists.You see?
You have no arguments.You have NEVER written a sane thing.You have no proof for what you say.
You wrote 8.) U should fear GOD because ALL MODERNIST AND INNOVATERS are CONDEMNED and CAST OUT FROM THE CHURCH.
This is your God,not mine.And yours is not the Christian God.
MY God you not give a freaking shit about using even an electric guitar in a Church
PS:You are a 60 year old hypocrite that pretends to be strong via Net.
AlexBouzouki 1 month ago
@adamantis4657 PALEOIMEROLOGITIS MAN?
AlexBouzouki 1 month ago
@AlexBouzouki: I AM NOT AN OLD-CALENDARIST!
But the Old Calendar Greek Church is not SO MODERNISED LIKE THE NEW CALEDNAR CHURCH.
Because the Greek NEw Calendar CHURCH IS FULL OF INNOVATION! As I told u 3 TIMES NOW.
adamantis4657 1 month ago
@AlexBouzouki: GREEKS = NOT ORTHODOX ANYMORE!
As u can see form your own posts - greeks are not ORTHODOX ANYMORE. Such silly conclusions and arguments that are DIRECTLY AGAINST THE TRADITION OF THE CHURCH.
The greek New Calendar CHURCH is FULL OF INNOVATION and MODERNISM and u have proven me right.
THANK U.
adamantis4657 1 month ago
@adamantis4657 You vile Dark minded poor person...Go burn a witch.Byzantines were not always right...Obviously Christians are far away from Christ.(By the way did Christ forbid instruments?Haha)
AlexBouzouki 1 month ago
@AlexBouzouki: LOL - U PROTESTANT GREEK!
I was not talking about "Byzantines" - I WAS TALKING ABOUT THE HOLY FATHERS and HOLY TRADITION.
YES - CHRIST HAS FORBIDDEN INSTRUMENTS THROUGH THE HOLY FATHERS.
U hippie Protestant greek!
U SEE: I WAS RIGHT: NEW CALENDAR GREEKS ARE MODERNISTS AND INNOVATORS.
adamantis4657 1 month ago
@adamantis4657 U HIPPIE?HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
HAHAHAHAHAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
Now I understood what kind of person you are and I will not reply to you again.Have a good night and burn many instruments in your dreams.Don't forget to pretend to be a Christian.
YES - CHRIST HAS FORBIDDEN INSTRUMENTS THROUGH THE HOLY FATHERS.
hahahahaHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH BYE BYE FANATIC LOSER!!!!!
AlexBouzouki 1 month ago
@AlexBouzouki: LOL - now u have lost your mind! LOL - u crazy protestant hippie.
adamantis4657 1 month ago
amazing.
ROBHUGHES1453 8 months ago