YouTube Bachelorette: Videos from the Guys!

[astronautjenny]

What's up with the douchey douchersons? Put a shirt on.

[HulloKat]

James is so great xD

[KhaleeqaIDRUS]

I wish you had chosen James because he seemed so funny and creative that you would never get bored of him but somehow I do understand why it was John that you chose. I like him too and he handsome indeed. I'm so happy for you, Carlie. Lots of love from MALAYSIA!

[kellyness]

"my name is easy to pronounce to most english speaking people." LOL!!! omg.

[EuroEditz]

"Hey JOHN this in not mtv...  JAMES all the way he shows you that hes trustworthy.

[danceloveclaire]

6:18 Filmed with a toaster?

[mrmexi14]

body builder = GAY run carly

[potterfan678910]

PUT A SHIRT ON

[brighteyedorion]

hahaha if she doesn't want james, I'll take him! I was LOLing the whole time

[Dina8485]

Say it with me carly-- john = TOOL

[Dina8485]

GIANCARLOS THE ONLY ONE I LIKED!

[manonmoon12]

she already picked john the douche-bag,  the guys a big headed fag who loves his body more then anything else

[MegaJackassfan]

john kinda looks like a well -flips hair- u know what i mean and he is trying to hard

[MegaJackassfan]

James is hilarious

[cookiecake333]

1st guy!

[roxynikko2]

1st guy for sure!

[kelseysmiff]

JAMESSSSSSSSSS

[auburngirlash247]

love you bye lolol

[clarey27canada]

Since when do "the basics" include waffles?

[maddycuupcake]

some people are so rude, i think john seems nice!

[LeeUnited4eva]

Lmao at the dude at the end what a fucking fake fag

[TheEragonHalo]

@LeeUnited4eva right hes a complete doucher

[soccerplayingbanana]

at first i liked john but then he started to bother me....

[RaeBae7]

John's video made me uncomfortable...

[samconroy]

John: A body builder which wears pink shirts... (ohh dear)

[JollyJont]

I love John! He is like a character from a sitcom or a movie haha!

[tonysvlog2]

am gonna go hit the gym... FUCK OFF!

[AMZ519]

i think you cut the right guy. he was a little too shy and not youtube savy enough for you carley. but the rest of the three are gonna be tough. I say Giancarlo and James are the best!

[boy577]

WTF John is just all the way wrong

[StarStar3333]

should picked james

[Diabolical05]

this is faker then reality T.V

[dickersonsarah11]

who else now loves guys with beards

[Mireya97]

james is so funny! Love him! :D

[TheSgirl13]

james is perfect. He fits so well with your family it seems.

[TheSgirl13]

james is the one

[marykate3001]

JAMES! Choose him!

[MrTroll652]

giancarlo sounds like a little mangina

[Sushihater445]

James all the way xD

[Sushihater445]

John comes off to be a little....douchy.. no offence :P

[ChrisAlhanouch]

john is gay ryan is a douche either gian carlo or james

[heyparisray]

JAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAMMMMMEEEEESSS­S !

[scousebikerbird]

100% James <33333

[ehseagelssoar13]

awww did giancarlo say "love you bye" ? precious.

[webkinz5089]

lol i thought john was a little creepy...

[chocoxbananaxo]

anyone else see white dots appearing to the left of her face???

[EureDudehelt]

best choice for her might have been giancarlo ! even though i want to say CHOOSE JAMES ! :). I think its kind of sad that the douchy guy won.. but maybe he's nice... hope so.

[TheRandomnessGirlsx2]

I reallyyy likeee jamess! Like if you agree!! He sorta looks like shay xDD

[AllAboutLilly]

douuuuuche.... LOL

[yady753]

awww you should totally date James.He has a sense of humor, is creative and seems like he would get along with your brothers..what's not to love

[herpderpq]

john



[Maggiehish]

Ryannnnnnn.

[Maggiehish]

John Is Showing Off Way Too Much,

[VictorJv2011]

so typical for girls like carlie to like buffed dudes with small penises and a huge ego.

that first dude seemed to be real nice...even the fat one with the guitar.

girls like carlie would never pick guys like them...GZ Carlie, I like you even less now.

[obieezx11]

YER SHE WENT FOR JON WITH THE LOOKS AND THE BODY TYPICAL HE WILL LOVE HIM SELF MORE THAN HE WILL HER JUST TYPICAL THO CHICKS ALWAYS GO FOR THE BODY AND LOOKS WHO CARES THAT HE LOVES HIM SELF RIGHT LOL.

[kamile10001]

James reminds me of Shay ;D

[nickezdaman4]

"Hey Carlie i'm actually videoing from my hotel room in New York City, all 410 square feet of it" ...FUCK OFF

[crlnewlls]

@nickezdaman4 410 sq feet is a relatively small space...he was being sarcastic, pointing out that that's how it is in nyc. smaller hotel rooms. he is a douche though

[DashboardQueen]

@nickezdaman4 I think he was actually stating the square feet to emphasize on how small the hotel was, 410 square feet isn't big at all. I do agree though that he comes off as cocky.

[linggay1990]

please give giancarlo another chance he's so sweet and cute i'm sure you'll be happy with him.. :-)

[faradayagain]

i don't think john is a douche like everyone says, but i do think he came on a little strong.

[faradayagain]

ryan, these are professional youtubers. what's up with that quality bro?

[faradayagain]

omg i love james!!!!

[Kimkotzt]

I have the same ikea pillows :)

[GleekGlambert21]

Poor carlie. shut up everyone!! She chose John for reasons she will only know. Maybe you don't see it, but hes a sweet guy. We have only seen him once. Don't call him names. Think about how poor carlie feels right now :( Leave her alone.

[PeaceChic3]

John = douche of all doches

[PeaceChic3]

Ryan seems kinda douchy

[BlueEyedGoodie]

John is super hot but his speech is totally effed up and annoying.

[Fr0Benjamin]

john's a d-bag

[MsPositronic]

John seems like a huge-ass jerk. You picked the wrong guy. I'll be laughing my ass off when he breaks up with you.

[TheCheyennePeppers]

Ugh! John is SUCH A DOUCHE!! I don't even like men ,but I would TOTALLY go on a date with James!!

[mjw712]

Giancarlo please please please!

[bellajenella]

giancarlo said... "I love you bye" ?

[yady753]

@bellajenella hahaha i noticed that too and thought it was weird but i am sure it was his nerves :(

[tessbaby211]

I really don't think John's shirt is tight enough

[StageDoorJohnny1688]

James is the one!!!!

[anubis92543]

james is awesome

[SNAZ101]

Wait... Is this just blunt horeing yourself out online??

[chachaluv7]

Oh my gosh, John no please. James yes please! Him or Giancarlo :]

[AvonleaGrace]

John seems so full of himself. Gian or James! James would be my pick! : )

[tomberly77]

James!!!!!!:DDDDDDDDDDDD

[tomberly77]

Respond to this video...

[macnchaz]

I think Giancarlo is way better looking than John!

[macnchaz]

James = Shay

[macnchaz]

Giancarlo!!! HE'S SO CUTE!!!

[EDHxoxo]

" So im about to head to bed" lol ohhh John - Pick Gian ..something or James 'ypoo!

[bulletscary]

Pick John and then make him do a Marathon with Shay First and see who wins

[CupKake2126]

JAMES!!!!!



[nelliefedotova1]

i kinda think that john is a little bit of a showoff!!!!

[MissKai001]

@nelliefedotova1 lol totally one min hes in his room then the gym then bed whit no shirt on i think a little bit of a overachever !!:)

[SmileyFaceSmurf]

PICK JOHN YOU KNOWU WANT TO.... he can always play with cooper and he seems like he is going to be very good to your family....... he is like another shay carl he seems he would always make everyone happy! (I'm not just saying him for his looks)

[syberblade50]

james!!!!



[JasmineVlogs]

JOHN.

Pick John ;D!

[forevermaisiee]

james,james,JAMES!

[JKconfuzzled]

James reminds me of Shay :p

[oogallecta]

I like James. He seems funny

[TaylorMadeGlamour]

Whatever you do, don't pick John. Dude is only gonna try and get that ass.

[PatientxWhatsername]

I get bad vibes from John O_O

Go for James. 

[justpeacemakers]

Giancarlo yesssss :)

[waterloo995]

John is a fag for sure...Except for the first guy all the other guys are lame with lame jobs..

[IlliterateNick]

All about James! Don't mess this up Ms. Stylez.

[whateverohh]

...I actually like John. He's not incredibly douchey, he's confident and really wanted to highlight the one thing he already knows he has in common with Carlie, fitness. Also, he was playing to his strengths. Not gonna lie, he has a NICE body. It was kind of him to show us ;)

[HeyHeyDayze]

john is SO posed for hat shot where hes laying in bed....douche

DONT DATE JOHN >.<

[GKstar7]

john....yeah you are a douch :)

[ExesandErin]

Giancarlo and James! Whichever one you don't pick, I'll happily take :P

[J3SSICAxoxo]

james!



[MikaForTheLose]

No for John! I don't think he's straight.

I think Giancarlo and James would be the best pick for her!

I think James kinda looks like Shay and Casey to!

[GLAM0URdol]

Johns an idiot "all 450 square feet of it" Who says that?

[GLAM0URdol]

Jaaaaammes!!

[AwsomeBestFriends]

I stop after James bc I no hes video is better

[crayolasky0]

john is a douche

[crayolasky0]

james!!!



[Summeri3reeZ]

buh for john :(

[xPanicSmoshx]

i like giancarlo and john :o

[iARELiLY]

james has a dog. hes the one.

[matanunchileno]

U need fuck? ,call me

[boastfuls]

@matanunchileno she doesn't want herpes

[JStamCasual]

pick John he's hot

[awesome271201]

James looks like casey from a distance

[Dandytheone]

James is the one :) carlie pick him please

[lostangeleno]

james is so awesome

[robertha]

LMAO, JOHN IS A FUCKING FAGGOT. THE REST NEED TO LEARN HOW TO BODY BUILD LIKE HIM BUT NOT ACT LIKE HIM, ALL 400 SQ FEET OF DOUCHE FAGGORY, GTFOUTTA HERE AND SMOKE SOME CALI WEED DOUCHEBAG

[snowangel246]

james all the way. He is so sweet and funny. :)

[mykindoffairytale]

during the entire video i was waiting for jackson's video... carly i think you made a mistake in editing.. :3

[avatarluvr88]

james is my favorite!

[utubemegastar]

John is like almost too perfect lol

[LoCashFan]

I think would be best for ya. GianCarlo!!!! The others were just too damn FAKE!

[6MarilyN66]

how the hell did this all start? o___o

[fabs080405]

this is a fuckin easy one....john is a total douch fag, ryans vid was so shitty, james is funny as hell and looks like ur brother, and giancarlo is nice, so JAMES(or shay:D) or GIAN!!

[DolceWilds]

Ok...after watching this.. i have to admit i really like giancarlo ! I guess he was just really shy on the 5 min date video. Definately pick him ! And if not then james. But definately not john. Please don't pick john. Major douche.

[kca3kids1]

Go for James, Carlie. He's the most like the brothers you adore, would make you laugh, would fit into your family, and would treasure you more than himself.

[bobbygeorgiela]

"One-thirty am in the morning"

LOLOLOLOLOL

[babyinblack]

Gotta give it up to James!! He's really funny and made me smile the whole time for his video.

[TurnoverAbid]

james' video. LOLWUT!

[angieandmika4ever]

Giancarlo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[JustJake97]

I want Giancarlo to win! I don't like Ryan or John! James is ok I guess.... haha

[fabyl2003]

I'm with Team Giancarlo :)

[prettyfrikkenawesome]

Giancarlo is my vote!!! James looks like Shay and Casey too much:/ but if you're looking for a serenade he's the guy. John bragged about himself too much, ugh. And I skipped Ryan.

[TheAdoptedShayTard]

Aw Gian's "okayloveyoubye" was so cute!

[ksanfor]

giancarlo!!! :)

the ryan guy was boring as hell.

[stayathomedad666420]

lol at john and ryan

[Payshack]

Ohh, John, eew.

[reebs1230]

James looks like Carlie's brothers!

[madbakersam]

BORING !

[leahc66]

giancarlo reminds me of brett :D

[latexprimus]

that muscle dummy guy seems like a doyche he was so full of himself

[AbbySanfacon]

Giancarlo. He seems down to earth and has a good background. You also have to look at what is best for Cooper and he seems like he would be great with him :)

[MissMegaZord]

Giancarlo or James. I can't decide. The others seem a little douchey.

[kentaohio]

James FTW

[4BriO]

James is awesome. Get him.

[noratard]

i would soooooo go out with james!!

[surfergirl27]

P.S. Last guy just wants to be on camera because he likes to look at himself all day.

[surfergirl27]

GIANCARLO seems well rounded AND cute and he lives in L.A...James seems funny like he is one of your brothers...Ryan ummm he will find someone where he lives and the last guy seems full of himself and seems like he would marry himself. :D

[katastr0phi3]

Giancarlo omg <3333 "okayloveyoubye" so sweeet!

[MyGeek85]

Giancarlo seems really nice

[kaplanb2]

john is such a tool

[USMC010Parra]

doesn't Giancarlo look like Brett the Intern

[shebabe03]

John seems like hes full of himself! hes really reaching with the no shirt in bed thing lol

[amychita]

Giancarlo! omg if you dont date him I will :p

[Bomber8597]

James ftw!

[iheartkiwisxoxo]

Giancarlo!

[logansheaa]

Her boobs are way too big now...

[xbrokenXcrayonsx]

Protein really doesn't do any good...I wish people would stop prescribing to what the media wants them to. :/

[krissu96]

@xbrokenXcrayonsx Thats one of the stupidest comments i have seen in youtbue for a while. Ofcourse it doesent do you any good if you dont work out. Wow seriously how did you come up with that ?

[OzPawz]

Giancarlo and James ftw. John seems nice but definitely a workaholic.

[xxcokecookiexx]

Id pick Kassem