shia, sunni, shitte, ghadir khum, islam (must watch!)

[Jaibajrang29]

Lots of confusion here. There were no sects or divisons at the time of the Prophet (saws).

Man has made himself a judge, but the only judge is Allah.

Islam was pure, but man has diluted it.

There was no abuse and no hatred in those days, why abuse and hate now ?

The campanions loved each other for the sake of Allah and the Messenger.

Ali named his children after Abu Bar, Umar & Uthman and he even gave his daughter's hand in marriage to Umar.

So why abuse him ?

Allah is watching.

[smoothie408]

shittes hitting themselves over hussain(r)s death which is something that happened AFTER the prophets time and most importantly this happened over mans judgement and not appointed by allha(swt) and also sunnis committing suicide or killing other people which is no doubt not only haram but very evil and misleading this does not set a good example to others as islam is oneness and is accepting to mankind

[smoothie408]

lailaha il allah muhammed al raulalah and nothing else.. the addition to ali waliallah is not part of the shahada to what we all should fall under as muslims.. but this does not excuse the fact that sahaba of the prophet(s) to go against ali for political power and the killings or the qurans in spears.. the problems fall under politics and educationally as a "political SCIENCE" p.s. (atheist fall under science). as a negetive, they are taken to an EXTREME level that is stupidity as i see

[smoothie408]

ok guys before we start what happened 1400 years lets just all relax lol.. anyways i dont consider myself to be sunni or shitte however if there was really a split in islam i would consider to be shitte just because of the event of what happened at ghadr khum and ALI(R)s philisophical standpoint and recognition towards world ethics and recognition that was of course passed down through generation... however, muhammed sullallahalaiwasalam is the last messanger of allah and the islamic shahada is

[alipowerdark]

really islam is shia. & if u search about imam ali u will what im saying guz. i swear really islam is shia.& if is not god kill me now

[UsmanAli771]

Allah says, "They are the best people,". He says, "Surely Allah was well pleased with the believers when they were swearing allegiance to you under the tree." (Qur'an - 48:18) They were fourteen-hundred men including four khulfas in the Hudaibiyah. Allah the Exalted also says, "Allah has certainly turned with mercy to the Prophet and to the Muhajereen (the emigrants) sad the Ansar (the supporters) who followed him in the hour of distress." (Qur'an - 9:117) They were thirty thousand.

[666kaz999]

3:20.. you said there were over 100,000 sahaba present. Where were they at the time of Abu Bakr's (ra) election?? thanks

[666kaz999]

2:36.. if every1 gave oath of allegence to Ali (ra) at that point, there would be two Chaliphs/Leaders/''Mawlas''.

From my understanding Mawla means 'beloved friend'. The reason the Prophet (saw) gave this sermon was because people were angry at Ali (ra). This cleared up everything.

Please can you answer my question in regards to having two Leaders at the same time. Thank you :)

[gfareed]

QURAN MAJEED DOES NOT CONTAIN THE CONCEPT OF INFALLIBLE IMAMS.

[jamcalgary]

very nice vdo but pls do not use this kind of music in such vdo jazakallah

[MuhammadAhmad1]

The Khawaarij, former Saba’ites, were of the same belief of the Ithna Ashari Shia today, namely that Allah had appointed Ali to be Caliph. And yet, Ali agreed to arbitration with Muawiyyah. The million-dollar question, asked of course by the Khawaarij: how could Ali agree to arbitration if it was a matter decreed by Allah?

Would Prophet Muhammad agree to arbitration and negotiation on the matter of his Prophethood? So why would Ali arbitrate and negotiate on the matter of his Imamah?

[bhuils]

@MuhammadAhmad1 Get u r million dollars from shaitan, he will give u tons. Any one who read history of siffin knows the treachery used by Amr bin aas and Mauwiyah (LA), by holding Quran on spears, which is a satanic act in itself. When both parties are muslim soldiers (200,000 in no.) and at risk of death, u don think about positions no more, if arbitration saves them all. Kill and Win has been WAHABI formula, its not ISLAMIC. AND DONT POST U R IDIOCY ANYMORE WE R FED UP WID U

[barriofino87]

FACTUAL HISTORY IN BRIEF

The Kaaba split open for Alis mother(a.s) to

give him birth. He was the prophets(pbuhahf) brother in this life and the hereafter.

He was the greatest arab.

Chosen at Ghadir

They all gave bayat.

The first caliphs congratulated him.

When the prophet died a FEW! companions left the burial and elected abu bakr. They DRAGGED Ali (as) to the mosque,(tabari history) and burned down Fatima Zahra(pbuh) house,(bukhari)

Alahuma sali ala muhammad, wa ale muhammad

bloodyhistory

[sharika1986]

i can't wait till judgement day so that allah will reveal the truth and radiallahu anhu imam ali ibn ali talib and to the ahlul bayt. Allah swt is the master of judges

[epoxsam]

obviously this video only concerned what Shia viewed and never what Sunni looked at it... In the eyes of any Sunnis, Ali (r.a) is one of the Four Guided Caliph. at the time of Abu Bakr (r.a), Umar (r.a) , Ali never went against them, moreover he gave his daughter in marriage to Umar (r.a) and if i'm not mistaken he named his sons Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman.. what Sunnis understand it was ALI's (r.a) LATER FOLLOWERS WHO BECAME MISGUIDED. BY THE WAY WHO THE HELL DESERTED ALI (r.a)? THEY WERE SHIITES!

[bahrain1988]

@epoxsam there is a hadith sahih in your books that say that there will be 12 imams. you have four. where are the other 8?

[Emasterthug]

peace to all:

as sunni and shia muslims there is more to agree than to disagree. we both have 5 daily prayers and fast and have many other similarities. the only difference is leadership. as a shia muslim, instead of fighting we must coexist and have respect for our different beliefs. instead of fighting each other we should fight together and overcome this senseless hatred. the true Jihad today is to try to make peace among all muslims. inshallah we can all be friends.

[DehSeeker]

Mawla means: leader, friend, protector

now look at the context,, if u still cant handle the truth.. nobody can help u

slm

[DehSeeker]

Prophet saw said: do I not have more right over the believers than what theyh ave over themselves? "The people cried out: "Yes, O messenger of Allah."

Then He (saw) held up Ali's hand and said..

Prophet saw said: For whoever I am his Mawla, Ali is his Mawla.

O Allah love those who love Ali and be the enemy of the enemy of Ali, help him who helps Ali, and forsake him who forsakes Ali.

[epoxsam]

the opposite word for "ENEMY" is "FRIEND"!!!!!!!!!!

[maryamsm]

wow u misspelled the MOST IMPORTANT part of the whole history!!! u wrote All is his mowla rather than Ali!!!! MY GOD! that was the point of the whole video!

[jambe1234567]

lol its okay brother

[shilapaul]

I am a new muslim revert and I don't understand why muslims are debating whether which group is better and which is not. The thing that I understand is that I believe in the Oneness of "ALLAH" and that Muhammad (bpuh) is His slave and messenger. And i also believe that all muslims have the same faith as mine. Then why the division? There is only One God, one religion and one faith. Allahu Akbar!

[12imams]

salams. congratulations.

its not about division.. some with closed mind preach hatred to one another.. but the talk is about promoting truth... u see any religion, if you think its the religion of god.. u follow it 100%. u look in all corners for truth till u find it! and thats why u need to follow the proper path! god will judge u on that for he will say u had all avenues to worship me better! good is ok. but better is best.. u know what i mean..?

[cupid100]

Islam is indeed one religion. Your faith should not be only on the oneness of Allah, prophet hood of Mohammed (pbuh) but also on the Imamat of Ali (as). This video is one of the testimony of this fact. Full Kalma is "La ilah a illallah Mohammed ur Rasool Allah, Ali un wali ullah wasi urr Rasool Allah wa khalifatahu bila fasal"

Meaning: I testify that Allah is one. Mohammed (pbuh) is His Prophet and Ali (as) is His and Prpohet's friend and first Khalifa/Imam of Islam.

[cupid100]

(cont)

There is no division but this is a complete faith, those who are adhered to complete faith are called shias and those who dont read the last part of kalma and are not sticked to it are sunnis. The matter is simple but people have made this the issue of their ego but remember dear think about your life after death when you'll be answerable for your faith to Allah. So think and be attentive and accept what you find right and keep praying to Allah that He keeps you affirm on the right path

[cupid100]

(cont2)

In this video Prophet pbuh has exclusively said that whoever takes me as their leader Ali is their leader and remember Prophet pbuh never says anything but only deliver the words of Allah :)

[fasiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii]

yes u r right d0nt put ur head 0ver this try to be a good muslim Allah will help u

[bahrain1988]

@shilapaul u are right all muslims have the same ideas but when you go deep in the history of islam then you will find out the deffrences in sects. other than history we are all the same. i am a shia. ill tell you if you are a convert do not choose sects just read alot and gather ideas from both sects that you think is true. i do not want you to get a headache and tell you all the diffrences in history between sinna and shia

[saussier]

may i know the version of the hadith pls

[saussier]

we all are brothers

if u like it o not

we said the same shahadah

so dont deny other groups

just believe in what u think is most making sense of ideologies and practices

if they dont want listen,let them be

let Allah judge us all

[lebanezeboy7]

very nice video

[BroGento]

The Qur'an is 1 book and Islam is 1 religion. Muslims worship Allah(s.w.t)and declared Prophet Muhammad(s.a.w) as Allah's messenger. Thats it. Nothing more nothing less.

Please say NO!! to division. Division and denomination creates war and war is not peace.

Muslims 1 body of brothers and sisters.

Islam - 1 religion.

The Noble Qur'an - 1 Book.

Allah(s.w.t) - 1 and the only God worthy of worship.

[sistermelanie]

Yes the mutazilah were oppressed, but not by the Shia. There is a very good book that discusses all of this history, i think you would appreciate it... Its called, "Divine Justice" by Shahid Mutahari

[sistermelanie]

Salam alaykum, Actually i am taking a class right now all about the Mutazilah and ashariah, they both have flaws to them and distortations in their logic. If you would like to discuss this further let me know...

[eradicator147]

its true.. we should unite

thn there wont be any wars.. or terrorist because islam does not allow slaughter of any1 whether he/she is sunni, shia or any other person frm any religion..

and if muslims unite NO OTHER COUNTRY WILL DARE TO ATTACK MUSLIMS WITHOUT ANY REASON.

[FA4A16]

i totally agree with u. god bless u people who think like that

[sistermelanie]

My friend, where are you getting your ideas from? You say the prophet is not holy???? Thats not what the Quran says! Have you read the Quran, it precisely tells us to: Follow Allah, then follow The messenger, and then... follow those in authory of you. You probably dont understand. Because you only interpret the verse in ur own way. You dont rely on any other evidence but ur own mind. Thats Illogical. Knowing the grammar, the time of the revelation and the event it came for are all useless to u.

[infesto7]

how is it then that you cannot even define the work of an artist all by yourself and you say that you do not need an interpreter to help you with islam...when you can not even explain properly how an unborn child's soul is taken and you want to think for yourself?...i dont mean to sound rude but i think i've managed to anyway, the point is how can our unperfect mind comprehend the depth of his words without someone helping us with it?

[shkookoo]

waiting for wahabis response? whats that? they're busy blowing themselves up? good riddance.

[RASYL12345]

Allahu Akbar!

Ya Allah! Ya Muhammed! Ya Ali!

[sistermelanie]

dear brother, i am also curious about how you study these quranic verses too. Do u just follow your own interpretation then?

[sistermelanie]

so who then is the holy Prophet to you???

[sistermelanie]

salam alaykum, some sunni sources that reference this quranic verse 5:67 being revealed right before this sermon are: -tafsir al kabir, v12, pp 49-50, -Asbab al-Nuzool, p50 -Nuzul al-Quran -al-Fusool al Muhimmah -Durr al-Manthur, -Fathul Qadir, by al-Shawkani -Fathul Bayan, by Hasan Khan, -Shaykh Muhi al-Din al-Nawawi -al-Sirah al-Halabiyah, by Noor al-Din al-Halabi, v3, p301 -Umdatul Qari fi Sharh Sahih al-Bukhari, by al-Ayni -Tafsir al-Nisaboori - & other such as Ibn Mardawayh

[jonashabab]

mashallah may allah bless u

[jaafarkourani]

wa laykum salam, Of course! the ones who create new sects are the hypocrites, & Islam is only one religion. Unfortunately, many labels had to be added to distinguish different scholarly schools of thought & who is following the most authentic ways of the prophet(S). Now i bring a question! How do we know which way is right? That is why we need to pay attention to big evidence like the hadith of ghadir khum, we must hold on to these sorts of proof, in order too be part of that ONE Islam.

[alina22407]

Beautiful job Melanie!