On the issue of this major rip-off, I don't see any concensus likely to arrive. People that like the candy ass pop music will simply defend him. And the radical geeks cracking up original music on obscure PC's and trackers will continue to be offended anytime they get ripped off.
Its crazy also how it is two racial & social worlds coliding in an explosion: Cool Black Hipsters VS Cerebral White Geeks.
Was that dope you werr smoking? haha, you're so mellow in this video I love it! You''re just telling it like it is, relaxed. "But, you know, whatever," great way to end it.
@BLAZINBEATS123 ... the difference there is that Dre credited the music he sampled and paid royalties on them. Timbalard did not. He has done this on more than one occasion.
it seems to me that only other DJ's and producers get a kick out of hearing a sample or a score re-worked into a rap song or a R&B track. Timberland is so talented this guy sounds so gullible, even though I know a sample from the original i'm still trying to finger out what he be grabbing for some this sickiest tracks I ever heard. I know he don't even sweat it do you even listen to him man.
@Divinecyphr Lol yeah man i listen to him. Everything by Tim you heard I probably own. I know a lil bit about production myself, and I agree he is very talented.
he's not soooo much of a great producer if he can't come up with his own shit........regardless of whether he made it hotter or not. And it dissapoints me too as a fan.
I agree kid.. I was laughing, cause, i already knew it, just was waiting for someone else to expose him, I make beats also, but what pisses me off is that he made millions but beat jacking...
Agree with almost everything you said. Not sure if he made it better because an older generation wouldn't think so. All he did was modernize the sound.
He didnt credit the original artist, end of story. Take any hip hop cd, dance music cd or pop record with a sample and it credits the original author. He didn't credit because it was an unknown song, that 99.9 percent of the population had never heard
You're right. If he gave the credit to the originals he would've been getting just as much money and props. Timbaland let his ego get the best of him and tried to snake 100% credit for other heads' hard work.
this is real shitt. i've been a musician all my life and i know how i feel about the music i make, and for someone to go around and grab whatever he wants out of anyones bag is fuckin wackk, and to claim he's the mind behind that piece of genius is wackk. hes not a musician, hes a noise maker
I couldn't agree enough. It disappoints me as a Timbo fan and pisses me off as a musician. If you're gonna sample give credit or cash. Timbo's living the American dream at someone else's expense. Good video man. Peace.
totally agree ... man timbo should give the credit! he did make the songs hotter so he still is a genius, but damn outright just taking people shit not cool.
and making it sound fresher is done by fine tuning the sounds during the mixing and mastering processes which timbaland doesnt do (he leaves that to other people check his cd). so he didnt really do anything but put his drums on. he should get his ass sued for stealing someones work. imagine if it was yours? as a producer too i know id be pissed
man you took the words right out of my mouth watching this!!! man i was watching this video where he was making beats for jay z and i kinda stumbled on this whole buzz where timbaland took that dude from finlands music lol damn then i watched what he had to say about it and man he was such a dick and then i watched your video and i was like damn this dude is saying how everybody would have felt!
wow exact same path except i also checked out the arabic music that he supposedly stole...and the iranian folksong...and that shit is exactly the same...what a shame
@catandmas thats the thing too eh. when confronted about it, he could AT LEAST TRY to be humble in his answers. I don't know what I am more shocked over....the fact that he jacked the beat or the fact that when confronted he was all like "You're a nobody and I am the king...how are u gonna call out the king?" Like who the fuck does he think he is....money and fame is fleeting Timbaland....keep this shit up and u will see ur downfall soon. Such a damn shame...and I am/was a huge fan of his.
wow Kanye does it dumas. Name a producer that doesnt samples We all knew he sampled beats. Dr Dre sampled whole songs and didnt add shit to. TImbaland adds extra instruments and drums to and give a feel that u can rap to.
the real thing is just that timberland had be screw like a citrus for what i can himself create and know to take the money he take the work of the other musicians and put just is name on it.
it's just a question of money not of talent. the client he produces pay for his job and i just sell them something that is not his property .
You are a perfect example of the media culture that cannot think for themselves and just go with whatever your bias or lazy mind wants to hear without actually looking into it and doing the research! It was NOT from a video game it was produced for the European Alternative Computer Demoscene for which incorporates graphics, music, art and animation on systems that require an extreme amount of talent to produce on due to the limited resources imposed which is the whole point of it. Arrogant prick
And he didn't just take samples!.. Don't you get it yet!?!?!.. fucking hell what the hell has happened to all you people!!?!??.. THINK!!.. HE USED THE WHOLE SONG!!!.. GET IT!!???????????.. DO YOOOOOU GET IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!... When you sample, you use the sample to CREATE your own melody/tune but you DO NOT take an ENTIRE SONG and pass it off as your own without ASKING FIRST!!!!.
Timbaland Is A Good Producer But Not The Best! A Message To You Timbaland! - Dont Shout About Youre The Best And Greatest, Because Youre Not! I Know The Best Producer Ever! And Youll See Him Soon!
What Timbaland did was not good, like you said, he, AT LEAST, should give Janne Suni (original composer) a little credit, or just write his name on the CD as the original composer! I heard from someone that Nelly asked for permission, but since this guy had NellyFurtado in his Username, I don´t think that I can trust his words! It´s really a shame that a producer like him can do something like that, it´s just not right!
Timbaland didn't SAMPLE. He stole entire lines from an exsisting song. How would you feel if he did it to you, no credit, no money for all your hard work?
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
o shut up u fool aint u got nothing better 2 sit and do. who the fuck are you to comment on timbaland u sad cunt. timbalands number 1 every producer samples even dr dre so go fuck
What are you one of Timbalands little hoes or somethin? He should put you on the stroll and make some extra beer money bitch!! Eat a cock wit herpes on top jackass asshole...and god bless!
The original musician has probably not received a penny for that song aside from winning a contest back in 2000.
Big name producers should be helping the little guys get out, not just rip off their shit and carry on with life. This kind of behaviour makes me feel ZERO sympathy for musicians who get their work pirated all over the internet.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
doesnt matter. he takes a song from a different genre and make it his way. so what? there´s (as far as i know) not a single beat he produced that doesnt make ppl dance in the clubs. He probably pays the license if he uses someone´s music. He´s smart. Hes doin buissines, dont hate ppl.
Hey don't smoke. I know it's a stressful situation but you need to do that. lol. Timbaland sucks. If you like Timbaland then you like all the artists that he steals from.
to all you suckas go listen to P.E. - Caught, Can I get A Witness,...."stole" or "copyright" my ass,.."SET HIP HOP FREE" - a rebel with a raised fist....
I know about P.E. man. I met Pro. Griff personally here in the A. Chilled wit him at his crib, looked at the P.E. plaques on his wall, talked about the state of hip-hop AND got drums and sounds from him wit the logo on the disk. I could probably sell them shits on EBay but I use them muthafuckas.
Caught, now in court 'cause I stole a beat This is a sampling sport But I'm giving it a new name What you hear is mine P.E. you know the time Now, what in the heaven does a jury know about hell If I took it, but but they just look at me Like, Hey I'm on a mission I'm talkin' 'bout conditions Ain't right sittin' like dynamite Gonna blow you up and it just might Blow up the bench and Judge, the courtroom plus I gotta mention This court is dismissed when I grab the mike yo flav?
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
fuck the credits ,..it was completed by him,..he made that shit into gold or platinum...you have to understand hip hop made this sampling,,..it like remixing a DEAD into something living,..that is hip hop ,..sampling is a sport,..but if you sample from a white dude and make millions of him he wants to sue ,.calls you a criminal ,..and wants 90% of teh royalties,..for 4 seconds of a notes ...unbelieveable thats why they wanted hip hop dead,.....listen to the radios??
youre an idiot! and a racist apparently. Timbalame STOLE a piece of music made for and loved by a whole movement of computerartists. Timberlands talent, as with most other hiphop artists is limited to theft and a punkass attitude.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
dont come to use youtube and try to change the world stupid,..He still can sample what the hell he feels like it ,..and so we all hip hop producers,...so keep making those computer songs so we can sample them,.. did you know he sampled from a song from a KEYGEN??????? so he is a thief???
It doesn't matter what you call it. Sampling without paying for the sample is illegal and stealing. It has nothing to do with how much better it sounds as his version, what matters is that he stole the melody that creates the whole song.
All Hip Hop IS, Is Sampling ? LMAO, give credits to a song that was downloaded on Kazaa under a Commodore download link ? The kid's name wasn't even on the file. So "sampling" a video game, isnt against the law, becuase that particular interpolation of the game, wasnt copyrighted. If it were, then the finnish kid WOULDNT get a check anyway, hence both being from an original game to begin with. Shoot i sampled that game, does Timbo owe me money too ? Nah commodore should be the one complaining
Man.....I am not on some fuck Timbaland shit but yo! I just feel that his genius is different than I thought. I aint mad at him, I mean he still gave us plenty of hot shit wit the early Missy and all that but yo besides his drums he DOES just copy and paste for the most part and takes FULL credit! Well until he started messin wit Danja who's dope too. Now I dont know who be doin the tracks Danja or Tim lol!
thst great 4 music.....before u make judgements look up other artist thats done the same thing..and dont listen to youtube kids they dont know what theyre talking about..
I hear you man, but dont you have to acknowledge the artist to be paying homage to them? And I'm not judging Tim because I know industry rule #4080 so I'm sure he aint the only one. Plus I've made it clear that am a fan regardless,I'm just.....I dont know slightly dissapointed but I mean I still look forward to hearin what new stuff he might be workin on ya know?
He didn't just steal some song from some video game, the original track "Acidjazzed Evening" was an original composition created entirely by Finnish musician "Tempest", and has never been in any video game. Timbaland took this song and turned it into a ringtone as well as the song "Do It", completely stealing the entire written score and chord structure. This action was illegal, Timbaland has acknowledged it, and he is currently working with Tempest to work on a legal agreement to compensate him
you're 100 percent right ..fact he stole the song .and didn't gave any credit ..Now he's gonnan fight out in court ...gues who'll win ? Right those with the cash
Also funny how all you Mickey Mouse sounding people talk about "he don't even do his shit anymore, he got people" you're damn right he got people.. he just needs to give the main idea and direct a project.. thats the level his in now.. so yall stop crying about a sampled song that was made public.
ok to all of you dropping your 2 cents on the table i got a few words for you all.. TELL KANYE TO RETURN HIS GRAMMYS. Like wtf? you're all now going to complaint about Hiphop being sampled?.. whether is singleshot or a 4 measure melody it is still a sample.like come on.. HipHop is based on sampling since it started. it doesn't matter if is single hit or loops is still a sample. Maybe if timbo would had streched it and pitched yall wouldn't be saying shit now.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I'll give you an info to cheer you up: Timbo took the beat of a VIDEO GAME, you can't give credits to a video game, can you? There was nothing listed by the game, which would have actually been the job of the musican who copied from that beat in the first place.
it wasn't from a video game dipshit. there is a culture in europe called the demoscene where musicians write ORIGINAL music using old computers or old tracker software..
I really like that you like him and still can accept that he did something wrong, alot of people haven't been able to do that... they still defend him and say he was actually right!
its a shame pointblank... not the sampling part but how cats dont give credits 2 the original producer of the song... and timbo is rich from this... its the american way
timbascam ,, a credit to the original writer at least, there is no need to pretend he has created it, or is he frightened that people will discover he doesnt even produce half his material, it is done by his employee engineers and programmers, he just shows up for the cameras.
Yeah man I have since seen all those too. I dont even know what to say. Let me say AGAIN that I am not on a anti Timbaland campaign but...Ill just say that I'm not as blown away by him like I used to be. Like I figured out his formula and I'm not sure I wanted to. Still cant say I'm not a fan though. That's hard.
To CaptinPlanit...are you questioning my knowledge on this music shit??? HA!!!!! DONT MAKE ME FUCKING LAUGH MORTAL!!!!! Not only do I own everything you mentioned, but I can also clearly recall all those artists listing most if not all sample credits on their liner notes. Me personally that's one of the first things I check for when I get new shit. Who's on the beats....
Yes please enlighten me kraldaly! Like. I. Said. I think what he did with it is great. I love it. I OWN it. BUT!! He should have gave some credit to the little guy because he didnt just chop up and work the sample, he cut and pasted the whole melody!! If it was vice versa the 8-bit guy woulda been sued like a mothafucka!
Do you listen to Wu-Tang? Do you listen to Tribe Called Quest? Do you listen to old Boot Camp Click shit? How about some of Dilla's shit?
Did you cry when they failed to mention their sampled sources because they managed to avoid clearance issues? Did you complain because some of their biggest hits are just drums on top of catchy loops?
Quit moaning. That song works wonders in the club. Why? Because as you said, Timbaland made it hotter. So be thankful for that.
obviously not if your making so much comments. ALSO the fact that so much of tim's tune is ripped off, the melody (notation) + sampling (grg's version of it). get informed.
Plenty of people avoided sample clearance, even if they used straight loops. DJ Shadow only cleared 6 samples for Entroducing. Wu-Tang cleared less than half their samples between 93 and 97. A lot of classic songs are based on straight loops, like "Daytona 500", "Mass Appeal", "Can't Lose", etc.
If it weren't for YouTube, people would not make nearly as big of a deal about this. Instead, we get treated to scathing video blog responses.
CaptinPlanit,it would be big news regardless,.Kernkraft did the same years back with lazy jones except that was in a game,they were forced to pay up.Not clearing samples is playing with fire.prime example is blueboy -remember me.A lot of clearence is done behind the scene also, but it's known Janne Sunni never gave permission/was asked. Tim isn't short of money, common sense would be to pay BEFORE release, but it just shows he is greedy and likes telling "stories"
Marketing an artists work, and signing your name to it, are two different things, and in either case, the rightful artist needs to be compensated (Paid real money). Respect yourself, by respecting others!
If, as some of the comments suggest, that,Timbaland is a great artist, or in the least,an artist, then why not write and create your own art? Why borrow (steal)another artists work?
It is blatant and obvious what has been done here by Timbaland, and this is not the first time- JUST STOP IT! Put that energy into creating your own ART!
i know what you talkin about. but, tim produced the song and then the song came to the top! i always hear the do it songs and it really is hot song. but, stealing is wrong. but, without acidjazzed evening, nelly's song would never been produced
He didn't get the copyright. He never even contacted the person who made it. He stole it, note for note, instrument for instrument. He's a thief. Nothing but a petty thief.
shark jaw biting..like it.hehe , he made the song doper..its not a lot of talent to add a kick/snare and convert it to midi also. It's was calculated, and because SO MUCH of Janne's tune is DO IT, he should get a BIG chunk, fairs fair.
he never did FACT, listen to his interview on "idiot in the morning" errr sorry correction, "elliot in the morning" ;-) he incriminates himself even moreso, but then to add more lies to the subject and knowingly mislead fans who put him where he was, is even worse. it's not from a game either, he made matters FAR worse for himself instead of fessing up.
Me personally, I think Timbaland has got to be up there with the best of them, if not the best. I mean he use's live instrumentation on his records and has installed a new sound in hip-hop introducing ethnic/ foreign sounds. Plus, he doesn't like to stay in his comfort zone, as Shock Value has shown. The range and variety of music is great. Fall out boy, Elton John, Dr.Dre & Missy etc
Yeah, I been listenin to Shock Value a lot lately,and I do love the fact that he chose to not follow the current trend of wackness that is most of hip-hop right now. Good music. I like Fall out boy too. Dance Dance!!LOL!! Love that song!
got nothing to do with it, he jacked a tune.. then didn't pay the guy.. not just jacked.. pretty much ripped off the whole song.. someone should tell his a** about "beat club" or should that be "bite club". hypocrital theif that he is.
How the hell you know he didn't pay the guy? how do you know he didn't pay royalties? Are you his accountant? Stop whining and do something prodcutive. go do a pushup or something
I know for a fact it wasn't paid for . TIM admitted it himself on a radio interview and was rude/abusive and lied (great interview tim, your lawyers must be very happy with u.lol) . So perhaps do some research instead of insulting me ;-)
The industrial underground scene is where this started in the early 90's, and if you want to see someone for whom used all the shit you mention as far ethnic/foreign influences, look no further than Iceland's Bjork. When it comes to many of the sounds Timbaland uses, he also takes a lot from the underground 80's and 90's computer/synth scene of that time such as the influence of the 1982 computer system the Commodore 64. Timbaland is a class A thief and i have Zero respect for the man.
Oh yeah i got a question. You look like you know a lot about producer's and junk (with your name being 'beatkidmindstate'). I wanna know what the hype is around J Dilla. I've heard his stuff and everyone say's he was the greatest but i don't get it, like every track is sample based. Can you or anyone else help me understand why he's hyped up so much.
Ok. Good question.....I'll be real and admit that I dont like EVERYTHING that Dilla has done BUT!!!! People like myself love Dilla I think because he played a large part in A LOT of albums that we consider classic. I dont know man.....No one else has that "sound" He was obsessed with music. To the point where I think it played a role in his declining health. Sorry man I cant really explain. But he is NOT overrated. He is one of the best that ever did it. EVER!
Yeah, man i agree with you totally me myself am a BIG Timbaland fan. But, i've not lost respect for the guy because he's a living legend. But, like you said from now on if it's a hot track i'm always gonna be wondering was all this done by Timbo.
Wow!! :) This is the first time I think a fan of Timbaland is agreeing that a bit of wrong doing was done. Great for you!!!
If Timbaland had done this to lets say the Rolling Stones or any other very well known band he wouldn't have gotten away with it. But because this was done by someone who is not a mega star and lives across the ocean, he thought it makes it ok.
I agree. But again I didnt have a concern with him sampling I just thought he should have gave credit to who he borrowed from. If that musician was someone big here that we know, Tim would have to pay up something, I put money on it. But he is still a musical genius and I am still a fan regardless.
could u be more explicit? which song of dre and eminem or dre feat eminem..i dont undersand you..it's made after labi siffre - i got the? or teh second song you called.try to be more clear when you write sumthin :)
On the issue of this major rip-off, I don't see any concensus likely to arrive. People that like the candy ass pop music will simply defend him. And the radical geeks cracking up original music on obscure PC's and trackers will continue to be offended anytime they get ripped off.
Its crazy also how it is two racial & social worlds coliding in an explosion: Cool Black Hipsters VS Cerebral White Geeks.
OBSysteme 5 months ago
I think he did not make it hotter, I like it raw and original, and almost all and popular music signers simply sing in such an annoying voice.
I know this is my subjective taste, but tune on to the radio and listen to all these annoying screaming girls with auto-tuned voices.
damn we are a long way from hearing Armatrading or something like that.
They should shut the singers up and go instrumentals. the signers have message-less lyrics anyways (shake you ass, get me good, WTF!!!!!)
OBSysteme 5 months ago
I think I'm going to do a "Timbaland" on some old hip-hop beats of the 1970's...
jci10 5 months ago
Was that dope you werr smoking? haha, you're so mellow in this video I love it! You''re just telling it like it is, relaxed. "But, you know, whatever," great way to end it.
elginxxxman 1 year ago
Yeah - its a difference betwwen sampling and total rip off :)
Gadboa
MrGadboa 1 year ago
Dr Dre did the same thing for many of the songs on the Chronic in 92 did anyone care ?
BLAZINBEATS123 1 year ago
@BLAZINBEATS123 ... the difference there is that Dre credited the music he sampled and paid royalties on them. Timbalard did not. He has done this on more than one occasion.
funkamentalist 1 year ago
@funkamentalist That's because Dre actually respects other musicians and Timbaland is just a money grubbing asshole.
HellsMaverick 8 months ago
it seems to me that only other DJ's and producers get a kick out of hearing a sample or a score re-worked into a rap song or a R&B track. Timberland is so talented this guy sounds so gullible, even though I know a sample from the original i'm still trying to finger out what he be grabbing for some this sickiest tracks I ever heard. I know he don't even sweat it do you even listen to him man.
Divinecyphr 1 year ago
@Divinecyphr Lol yeah man i listen to him. Everything by Tim you heard I probably own. I know a lil bit about production myself, and I agree he is very talented.
BeatKidMindState 1 year ago
he's not soooo much of a great producer if he can't come up with his own shit........regardless of whether he made it hotter or not. And it dissapoints me too as a fan.
JamaicanBeauty100 1 year ago
he just used the main melody and he changed the melody its not completly the same
slokaka 1 year ago
all u have is an mpc now think about dat and think about wat ur sayin about "stealin" music and not adding anything to a sample
TheDizzydizz 1 year ago
the last part was prophetic I know exactaly what you mean
somethingfunny666 2 years ago
this was pointless can i have my 1 minute and 27 seconds back please?
thabeasst 2 years ago
Comment removed
thabeasst 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Did u listen to what Tim said you mofos??!! the music is from video game idiots!!!
Mwitamath 2 years ago
@Mwitamath Name the game!
Fl4shi 2 years ago 2
Snooooooooop Dooooogggggggg
marrllly 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i make beats . i dont really sample. but i dont see whats the big deal with tim
rowin09 2 years ago
I agree kid.. I was laughing, cause, i already knew it, just was waiting for someone else to expose him, I make beats also, but what pisses me off is that he made millions but beat jacking...
andretti11413 2 years ago 3
Agree with almost everything you said. Not sure if he made it better because an older generation wouldn't think so. All he did was modernize the sound.
joedaman55 2 years ago 2
He didnt credit the original artist, end of story. Take any hip hop cd, dance music cd or pop record with a sample and it credits the original author. He didn't credit because it was an unknown song, that 99.9 percent of the population had never heard
eldictator1 2 years ago
timberlands a hoe, he a dope no more, everything we heard dat got him hot was sumbody elses music
Djmoe2k8 2 years ago
Thanks for being sane, dude.
robobrow 2 years ago
You're right. If he gave the credit to the originals he would've been getting just as much money and props. Timbaland let his ego get the best of him and tried to snake 100% credit for other heads' hard work.
ddaynyc 2 years ago
you can tell you're a BUD-HEAD!!
"you know what im sayin" lol
beloit22 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
"YOU KNOW WHAT IM SAYIN"
"YOU KNOW WHAT IM SAYIN"
"YOU KNOW WHAT IM SAYIN"
Dude!!!!! you dont know "WHAT YOU'RE sayin" lol
Thats why u have to keep sayin
"YOU KNOW WHAT IM SAYIN"
beloit22 2 years ago
Wow buddy you put a lot of effort into that gay ass comment did'nt you? You're a giant douche bag and your girlfriend is cheating on you.
BeatKidMindState 2 years ago 3
You know what im sayin?
beloit22 2 years ago
i totally agree with what ur saying.
its shocking how pretty much 90% of hip hop music is sampled too :/
oftaja 2 years ago
I remember when I heared Big Pimpin' like 9 years ago, I immediatly recognized "Khosara".
mcmatanmc 2 years ago
this is real shitt. i've been a musician all my life and i know how i feel about the music i make, and for someone to go around and grab whatever he wants out of anyones bag is fuckin wackk, and to claim he's the mind behind that piece of genius is wackk. hes not a musician, hes a noise maker
JonnyPaine 2 years ago 2
I couldn't agree enough. It disappoints me as a Timbo fan and pisses me off as a musician. If you're gonna sample give credit or cash. Timbo's living the American dream at someone else's expense. Good video man. Peace.
calculusRockafeller 2 years ago 15
totally agree ... man timbo should give the credit! he did make the songs hotter so he still is a genius, but damn outright just taking people shit not cool.
rolandbeatz247 2 years ago
making the songs takes a genius
putting drums on top doesnt
and making it sound fresher is done by fine tuning the sounds during the mixing and mastering processes which timbaland doesnt do (he leaves that to other people check his cd). so he didnt really do anything but put his drums on. he should get his ass sued for stealing someones work. imagine if it was yours? as a producer too i know id be pissed
chowmein911 2 years ago 3
man you took the words right out of my mouth watching this!!! man i was watching this video where he was making beats for jay z and i kinda stumbled on this whole buzz where timbaland took that dude from finlands music lol damn then i watched what he had to say about it and man he was such a dick and then i watched your video and i was like damn this dude is saying how everybody would have felt!
catandmas 3 years ago 3
Thanks for tha feedback man. Peace!
BeatKidMindState 3 years ago
wow exact same path except i also checked out the arabic music that he supposedly stole...and the iranian folksong...and that shit is exactly the same...what a shame
MuguduTV 3 years ago
@catandmas thats the thing too eh. when confronted about it, he could AT LEAST TRY to be humble in his answers. I don't know what I am more shocked over....the fact that he jacked the beat or the fact that when confronted he was all like "You're a nobody and I am the king...how are u gonna call out the king?" Like who the fuck does he think he is....money and fame is fleeting Timbaland....keep this shit up and u will see ur downfall soon. Such a damn shame...and I am/was a huge fan of his.
JamaicanBeauty100 1 year ago 2
I respect the shit out of this video!
kmg0330 3 years ago 3
Thank you, I appreciate it.
BeatKidMindState 3 years ago
very true what this guy said
khodr081 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
so what u cunts , yh he took the track and made it sound sikkk. alson dr dre has done that and jermain depri u pricks
rockie0708 3 years ago
wow Kanye does it dumas. Name a producer that doesnt samples We all knew he sampled beats. Dr Dre sampled whole songs and didnt add shit to. TImbaland adds extra instruments and drums to and give a feel that u can rap to.
jerz40 3 years ago
the real thing is just that timberland had be screw like a citrus for what i can himself create and know to take the money he take the work of the other musicians and put just is name on it.
it's just a question of money not of talent. the client he produces pay for his job and i just sell them something that is not his property .
recel is also prohibited.
ftgnews 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
yh but its fuckin out of a video game for god fukin sake everyone takes samples
rockie0708 3 years ago
You are a perfect example of the media culture that cannot think for themselves and just go with whatever your bias or lazy mind wants to hear without actually looking into it and doing the research! It was NOT from a video game it was produced for the European Alternative Computer Demoscene for which incorporates graphics, music, art and animation on systems that require an extreme amount of talent to produce on due to the limited resources imposed which is the whole point of it. Arrogant prick
blade004 3 years ago 2
And he didn't just take samples!.. Don't you get it yet!?!?!.. fucking hell what the hell has happened to all you people!!?!??.. THINK!!.. HE USED THE WHOLE SONG!!!.. GET IT!!???????????.. DO YOOOOOU GET IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!... When you sample, you use the sample to CREATE your own melody/tune but you DO NOT take an ENTIRE SONG and pass it off as your own without ASKING FIRST!!!!.
blade004 3 years ago 12
Even then, you'd still credit the song and give them royalities.
GryphonSoul 3 years ago
Aye mannnn, Puff Puff pass!!
Kriminal16 3 years ago
Great video. Major respect to you for saying what I think a lot of Timbaland fans know is true, but are just not admitting to themselves...
otakurocklee 3 years ago
'Preciate that man..
BeatKidMindState 3 years ago
Timbaland Is A Good Producer But Not The Best! A Message To You Timbaland! - Dont Shout About Youre The Best And Greatest, Because Youre Not! I Know The Best Producer Ever! And Youll See Him Soon!
PrickIttwice 3 years ago
What Timbaland did was not good, like you said, he, AT LEAST, should give Janne Suni (original composer) a little credit, or just write his name on the CD as the original composer! I heard from someone that Nelly asked for permission, but since this guy had NellyFurtado in his Username, I don´t think that I can trust his words! It´s really a shame that a producer like him can do something like that, it´s just not right!
Tobibrocki 3 years ago 2
Oh, I forgot, good Vid! :)
Tobibrocki 3 years ago
Thank you.
BeatKidMindState 3 years ago
First of all I want to say I respect you for making this video mate.
Secondly, to all the people who don't seem to understand:
Timbaland STOLE a chunk of music, added a very basic drum loop over the top and called it his "original" ringtone.
So if I take someone else's composition and slap a processed drum beat over the top, I too can sell it as an ORIGINAL ringtone?
Better yet, why don't we all take a chorus of a beatles' song, fatten up the beat and sell it as an original ringtone?
thexela 3 years ago 2
Thanx....
BeatKidMindState 3 years ago
look m8 u r not seriouse timbo is king at beats so what if e sampled
rockie0708 3 years ago
Timbaland didn't SAMPLE. He stole entire lines from an exsisting song. How would you feel if he did it to you, no credit, no money for all your hard work?
GryphonSoul 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
o shut up u fool aint u got nothing better 2 sit and do. who the fuck are you to comment on timbaland u sad cunt. timbalands number 1 every producer samples even dr dre so go fuck
rockie0708 3 years ago
What are you one of Timbalands little hoes or somethin? He should put you on the stroll and make some extra beer money bitch!! Eat a cock wit herpes on top jackass asshole...and god bless!
BeatKidMindState 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
u dikeds every producer samples u prick fuckoff timbos the best ever
rockie0708 3 years ago
Oh, wow. Your computer has spellcheck right? Fucking use it you retarded ape.
SkeltonKid 3 years ago
Timbaland groupies..worse than animefangirls.
GryphonSoul 3 years ago 3
LOL... There is so much truth in your comment that its frightening!
blade004 3 years ago
thanks
GryphonSoul 3 years ago
what tim did was wrong!
not cool
onemin1986 3 years ago
"Complete shark JAW part 3 biting" WoW I was laughing for a while about that.Thats real true man real true.
Shadowlooker12 3 years ago
The original musician has probably not received a penny for that song aside from winning a contest back in 2000.
Big name producers should be helping the little guys get out, not just rip off their shit and carry on with life. This kind of behaviour makes me feel ZERO sympathy for musicians who get their work pirated all over the internet.
afxgrin 3 years ago
Its likely that tempest never recieved any money after winning that contest either. Many tracking 'compos' are for bragging rights, not money
GryphonSoul 3 years ago 2
Thanx for the input ya'll. Input.....Input!!!!
Lol! Anybody know where that's from?
BeatKidMindState 3 years ago
Nice comment! I agree with you man, he should have handled it a little better, given a nod to the dudes that did the original track...
theHermann94 3 years ago 4
and paid hiim royalties!
GryphonSoul 3 years ago
Glad to see a Timbaland fan who is being honest.
Tobbx87 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
doesnt matter. he takes a song from a different genre and make it his way. so what? there´s (as far as i know) not a single beat he produced that doesnt make ppl dance in the clubs. He probably pays the license if he uses someone´s music. He´s smart. Hes doin buissines, dont hate ppl.
krisskrossa 3 years ago
i totally agree!!!
JoannekeTigergirl 3 years ago 3
Hey don't smoke. I know it's a stressful situation but you need to do that. lol. Timbaland sucks. If you like Timbaland then you like all the artists that he steals from.
goggirl21 3 years ago 2
to all you suckas go listen to P.E. - Caught, Can I get A Witness,...."stole" or "copyright" my ass,.."SET HIP HOP FREE" - a rebel with a raised fist....
DZMPLZ 3 years ago
I know about P.E. man. I met Pro. Griff personally here in the A. Chilled wit him at his crib, looked at the P.E. plaques on his wall, talked about the state of hip-hop AND got drums and sounds from him wit the logo on the disk. I could probably sell them shits on EBay but I use them muthafuckas.
BeatKidMindState 3 years ago
Yeah,..Chuck and Flav with one the best producers ever Bombsquad. you be able to use them he aint going to sue because of copyright issues hahaha..
DZMPLZ 3 years ago
Yeah no doubt! I loved their sound. I Would never try to recreate it though. I just like thick drums and hard snares lol!
BeatKidMindState 3 years ago
DZMPLZ 3 years ago
Well said
xfilestube 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
fuck the credits ,..it was completed by him,..he made that shit into gold or platinum...you have to understand hip hop made this sampling,,..it like remixing a DEAD into something living,..that is hip hop ,..sampling is a sport,..but if you sample from a white dude and make millions of him he wants to sue ,.calls you a criminal ,..and wants 90% of teh royalties,..for 4 seconds of a notes ...unbelieveable thats why they wanted hip hop dead,.....listen to the radios??
DZMPLZ 3 years ago
Oh my god! How are you on every one of these videos?!?! Get a life!
Nabeelco 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
you too punk,..hahaha
DZMPLZ 3 years ago
youre an idiot! and a racist apparently. Timbalame STOLE a piece of music made for and loved by a whole movement of computerartists. Timberlands talent, as with most other hiphop artists is limited to theft and a punkass attitude.
fucknuaf 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
dont come to use youtube and try to change the world stupid,..He still can sample what the hell he feels like it ,..and so we all hip hop producers,...so keep making those computer songs so we can sample them,.. did you know he sampled from a song from a KEYGEN??????? so he is a thief???
DZMPLZ 3 years ago
Did he sampled from a KEYGEN song ? Why would he need a KEYGEN ? Does this mean he is using illegal software ?
Or is this a joke of yours ?
vipergtspl 3 years ago
What did you smoke, DZMPLZ?
yahags 3 years ago
It doesn't matter what you call it. Sampling without paying for the sample is illegal and stealing. It has nothing to do with how much better it sounds as his version, what matters is that he stole the melody that creates the whole song.
Jaquitita 3 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
I totaly agree with you
idafauzianamk 3 years ago
All Hip Hop IS, Is Sampling ? LMAO, give credits to a song that was downloaded on Kazaa under a Commodore download link ? The kid's name wasn't even on the file. So "sampling" a video game, isnt against the law, becuase that particular interpolation of the game, wasnt copyrighted. If it were, then the finnish kid WOULDNT get a check anyway, hence both being from an original game to begin with. Shoot i sampled that game, does Timbo owe me money too ? Nah commodore should be the one complaining
MGTheFuture 3 years ago
Man.....I am not on some fuck Timbaland shit but yo! I just feel that his genius is different than I thought. I aint mad at him, I mean he still gave us plenty of hot shit wit the early Missy and all that but yo besides his drums he DOES just copy and paste for the most part and takes FULL credit! Well until he started messin wit Danja who's dope too. Now I dont know who be doin the tracks Danja or Tim lol!
BeatKidMindState 3 years ago
u sound like a good kid but people been doing this since the sixties..its like paying homage to the other artist...
4 example bob dylan wrote "all along the watchtower" and jimi hendrix completly took the lyrics and added their own sound.
begun101 3 years ago
thst great 4 music.....before u make judgements look up other artist thats done the same thing..and dont listen to youtube kids they dont know what theyre talking about..
begun101 3 years ago
I hear you man, but dont you have to acknowledge the artist to be paying homage to them? And I'm not judging Tim because I know industry rule #4080 so I'm sure he aint the only one. Plus I've made it clear that am a fan regardless,I'm just.....I dont know slightly dissapointed but I mean I still look forward to hearin what new stuff he might be workin on ya know?
BeatKidMindState 3 years ago
He didn't just steal some song from some video game, the original track "Acidjazzed Evening" was an original composition created entirely by Finnish musician "Tempest", and has never been in any video game. Timbaland took this song and turned it into a ringtone as well as the song "Do It", completely stealing the entire written score and chord structure. This action was illegal, Timbaland has acknowledged it, and he is currently working with Tempest to work on a legal agreement to compensate him
TheIndigoSky 3 years ago 2
at the end Timbaland makes the money
soylavoz 3 years ago
you're 100 percent right ..fact he stole the song .and didn't gave any credit ..Now he's gonnan fight out in court ...gues who'll win ? Right those with the cash
WARDISWARD 3 years ago
You make a valuable point
lebnaniapride 3 years ago
Thanx....
BeatKidMindState 3 years ago
Yo DirtyMoney23, these people act like they shoulda got paid or sumthin, right.
nox121477 3 years ago
Ok, how do you know he didnt give any credit to anybody, were you there when the contract was written up, probably not
nox121477 3 years ago
true brother! difference between sampling and stealing! Wonder how many others hes rippd!
vzm19glr 3 years ago
Also funny how all you Mickey Mouse sounding people talk about "he don't even do his shit anymore, he got people" you're damn right he got people.. he just needs to give the main idea and direct a project.. thats the level his in now.. so yall stop crying about a sampled song that was made public.
DirtyMoney23 3 years ago
ok to all of you dropping your 2 cents on the table i got a few words for you all.. TELL KANYE TO RETURN HIS GRAMMYS. Like wtf? you're all now going to complaint about Hiphop being sampled?.. whether is singleshot or a 4 measure melody it is still a sample.like come on.. HipHop is based on sampling since it started. it doesn't matter if is single hit or loops is still a sample. Maybe if timbo would had streched it and pitched yall wouldn't be saying shit now.
DirtyMoney23 3 years ago
good point wonder if anyone got sum dirt on any other producers
modelCHICKdancer 3 years ago
Nice response dude. Got some good points.
9664plz 3 years ago
Thanks homie.
BeatKidMindState 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I'll give you an info to cheer you up: Timbo took the beat of a VIDEO GAME, you can't give credits to a video game, can you? There was nothing listed by the game, which would have actually been the job of the musican who copied from that beat in the first place.
Kaaav 3 years ago
Interesting point......You may live.
BeatKidMindState 3 years ago
video game tunes have composers too, they didn't just come out of thin air. Dumbass.
Nayamaus 3 years ago 3
it wasn't from a video game dipshit. there is a culture in europe called the demoscene where musicians write ORIGINAL music using old computers or old tracker software..
patto2k 3 years ago 2
You take a brain from video game,... Use google: "Tempest/damage" commodore scene c64. Fill your empty spaces uder skull with knowledge about topic.
ajemajo 3 years ago
Dirt of ya shoulder was an original by jayz
realthug101 3 years ago
I really like that you like him and still can accept that he did something wrong, alot of people haven't been able to do that... they still defend him and say he was actually right!
jessicad101 3 years ago
Fa sho Jessie Jess!
BeatKidMindState 3 years ago
its a shame pointblank... not the sampling part but how cats dont give credits 2 the original producer of the song... and timbo is rich from this... its the american way
AveMcree 3 years ago
timbascam ,, a credit to the original writer at least, there is no need to pretend he has created it, or is he frightened that people will discover he doesnt even produce half his material, it is done by his employee engineers and programmers, he just shows up for the cameras.
MangoSound 4 years ago
timbaland very stupid person
And foolish
Listen to his old songs and his new songs
Find rapid development
How so?
by Theft !
timbaland big loosssser
ProfessionalProducer 4 years ago 2
Maybe you should check the video of the Arabic music Timbaland stole as well. Maybe your opinion would change.
I mean I USED to think that Timbaland was the best guy in the biz, but I was wrong. He is nothing but a shark.
greattimed 4 years ago
Yeah man I have since seen all those too. I dont even know what to say. Let me say AGAIN that I am not on a anti Timbaland campaign but...Ill just say that I'm not as blown away by him like I used to be. Like I figured out his formula and I'm not sure I wanted to. Still cant say I'm not a fan though. That's hard.
BeatKidMindState 4 years ago
Well Tim was NEVER that creative all he did was steal a song sample and put an electronic drum beat on top of it.
But I know there is some people I cant stop liking even though they are fraudulent and theifs
greattimed 4 years ago
You know, man, you know what I'm sayin? You know, you say you know a lot, you know? You know?
SpamSpammity 4 years ago
.......Nah man do you know what im sayin? You know....well fuck it nevermind. Lickballs!!!!!!!!!!!!!
BeatKidMindState 4 years ago
To CaptinPlanit...are you questioning my knowledge on this music shit??? HA!!!!! DONT MAKE ME FUCKING LAUGH MORTAL!!!!! Not only do I own everything you mentioned, but I can also clearly recall all those artists listing most if not all sample credits on their liner notes. Me personally that's one of the first things I check for when I get new shit. Who's on the beats....
BeatKidMindState 4 years ago
Yes please enlighten me kraldaly! Like. I. Said. I think what he did with it is great. I love it. I OWN it. BUT!! He should have gave some credit to the little guy because he didnt just chop up and work the sample, he cut and pasted the whole melody!! If it was vice versa the 8-bit guy woulda been sued like a mothafucka!
BeatKidMindState 4 years ago
you have no idea how it works do you. maybe i should school you up
kraldaly 4 years ago
Do you listen to Wu-Tang? Do you listen to Tribe Called Quest? Do you listen to old Boot Camp Click shit? How about some of Dilla's shit?
Did you cry when they failed to mention their sampled sources because they managed to avoid clearance issues? Did you complain because some of their biggest hits are just drums on top of catchy loops?
Quit moaning. That song works wonders in the club. Why? Because as you said, Timbaland made it hotter. So be thankful for that.
CaptinPlanit 4 years ago
but you do know they clear their sample?
obviously not if your making so much comments. ALSO the fact that so much of tim's tune is ripped off, the melody (notation) + sampling (grg's version of it). get informed.
cosine303 4 years ago
Plenty of people avoided sample clearance, even if they used straight loops. DJ Shadow only cleared 6 samples for Entroducing. Wu-Tang cleared less than half their samples between 93 and 97. A lot of classic songs are based on straight loops, like "Daytona 500", "Mass Appeal", "Can't Lose", etc.
If it weren't for YouTube, people would not make nearly as big of a deal about this. Instead, we get treated to scathing video blog responses.
CaptinPlanit 4 years ago
CaptinPlanit,it would be big news regardless,.Kernkraft did the same years back with lazy jones except that was in a game,they were forced to pay up.Not clearing samples is playing with fire.prime example is blueboy -remember me.A lot of clearence is done behind the scene also, but it's known Janne Sunni never gave permission/was asked. Tim isn't short of money, common sense would be to pay BEFORE release, but it just shows he is greedy and likes telling "stories"
cosine303 3 years ago
Marketing an artists work, and signing your name to it, are two different things, and in either case, the rightful artist needs to be compensated (Paid real money). Respect yourself, by respecting others!
Lyon Danebridge - on YouTube
LyonDanebridge 4 years ago 2
If, as some of the comments suggest, that,Timbaland is a great artist, or in the least,an artist, then why not write and create your own art? Why borrow (steal)another artists work?
It is blatant and obvious what has been done here by Timbaland, and this is not the first time- JUST STOP IT! Put that energy into creating your own ART!
Lyon Danebridge - on YouTube
LyonDanebridge 4 years ago 3
Think of the amount of work that the Finnish composer put into composing that song.
Now think of the amount of work that Timbaland put into pasting a beat over the top of it.
And NOW think of who got the most money from it? I have zero respect for Timbaland.
thegoldenmuscle 4 years ago 8
true, but this video would last 30 seconds without all the "uhm, you know, know what i mean? what ever" crap.
Saludos
error204 4 years ago
Whatever dickmouth! Know what I mean?
BeatKidMindState 4 years ago
nope uhm, i don't know what you mean, know what i mean? you know.. actually.. uhm.. you know.
uhm, best, you know, regards, know what i mean?
error204 4 years ago
lol! Same to you.....uhm,know what I mean?
BeatKidMindState 4 years ago
yeah, uhm, i'm like, sure, now i know what you mean, uhm, yeah like, uhm, know what i mean?
bye, yeah, uhm like, that you know?
error204 4 years ago
yeh, eehm, idiots, or w/e the fuck i mean...
BeautifullyMonica 4 years ago
you're all right! timbaland is still top but he stole the tune. that wasn't cool
OttoKnallfurz 4 years ago 5
i know what you talkin about. but, tim produced the song and then the song came to the top! i always hear the do it songs and it really is hot song. but, stealing is wrong. but, without acidjazzed evening, nelly's song would never been produced
Ulwan25 4 years ago 2
it came to the top because timbaland was already known. Acidjazzed was good before Timbaland fucked with it.
eRev21 4 years ago 6
More information:
timbalandtempest.ytmnd(dot)com
eRev21 4 years ago
He didn't get the copyright. He never even contacted the person who made it. He stole it, note for note, instrument for instrument. He's a thief. Nothing but a petty thief.
eRev21 4 years ago 4
Is dat weed?
audacity19 4 years ago
I think he got just a little too arrogant and simply thought that no one would even challenge him, but karma is a bitch!
BeatKidMindState 4 years ago
shark jaw biting..like it.hehe , he made the song doper..its not a lot of talent to add a kick/snare and convert it to midi also. It's was calculated, and because SO MUCH of Janne's tune is DO IT, he should get a BIG chunk, fairs fair.
cosine303 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
He got the copyright fools.
So dont come like aaaa he stoles it.
Qtst 4 years ago
Do you even know what you're talkin about?
BeatKidMindState 4 years ago
he never did FACT, listen to his interview on "idiot in the morning" errr sorry correction, "elliot in the morning" ;-) he incriminates himself even moreso, but then to add more lies to the subject and knowingly mislead fans who put him where he was, is even worse. it's not from a game either, he made matters FAR worse for himself instead of fessing up.
cosine303 4 years ago
Me personally, I think Timbaland has got to be up there with the best of them, if not the best. I mean he use's live instrumentation on his records and has installed a new sound in hip-hop introducing ethnic/ foreign sounds. Plus, he doesn't like to stay in his comfort zone, as Shock Value has shown. The range and variety of music is great. Fall out boy, Elton John, Dr.Dre & Missy etc
ChrisBryon 4 years ago
Yeah, I been listenin to Shock Value a lot lately,and I do love the fact that he chose to not follow the current trend of wackness that is most of hip-hop right now. Good music. I like Fall out boy too. Dance Dance!!LOL!! Love that song!
BeatKidMindState 4 years ago
got nothing to do with it, he jacked a tune.. then didn't pay the guy.. not just jacked.. pretty much ripped off the whole song.. someone should tell his a** about "beat club" or should that be "bite club". hypocrital theif that he is.
cosine303 4 years ago
How the hell you know he didn't pay the guy? how do you know he didn't pay royalties? Are you his accountant? Stop whining and do something prodcutive. go do a pushup or something
jindagreatlee 4 years ago
I know for a fact it wasn't paid for . TIM admitted it himself on a radio interview and was rude/abusive and lied (great interview tim, your lawyers must be very happy with u.lol) . So perhaps do some research instead of insulting me ;-)
cosine303 3 years ago
The industrial underground scene is where this started in the early 90's, and if you want to see someone for whom used all the shit you mention as far ethnic/foreign influences, look no further than Iceland's Bjork. When it comes to many of the sounds Timbaland uses, he also takes a lot from the underground 80's and 90's computer/synth scene of that time such as the influence of the 1982 computer system the Commodore 64. Timbaland is a class A thief and i have Zero respect for the man.
blade004 3 years ago 2
Oh yeah i got a question. You look like you know a lot about producer's and junk (with your name being 'beatkidmindstate'). I wanna know what the hype is around J Dilla. I've heard his stuff and everyone say's he was the greatest but i don't get it, like every track is sample based. Can you or anyone else help me understand why he's hyped up so much.
ChrisBryon 4 years ago
Ok. Good question.....I'll be real and admit that I dont like EVERYTHING that Dilla has done BUT!!!! People like myself love Dilla I think because he played a large part in A LOT of albums that we consider classic. I dont know man.....No one else has that "sound" He was obsessed with music. To the point where I think it played a role in his declining health. Sorry man I cant really explain. But he is NOT overrated. He is one of the best that ever did it. EVER!
BeatKidMindState 4 years ago
Oh and he did play actual instruments too.
BeatKidMindState 4 years ago
Yeah, man i agree with you totally me myself am a BIG Timbaland fan. But, i've not lost respect for the guy because he's a living legend. But, like you said from now on if it's a hot track i'm always gonna be wondering was all this done by Timbo.
ChrisBryon 4 years ago
Wow!! :) This is the first time I think a fan of Timbaland is agreeing that a bit of wrong doing was done. Great for you!!!
If Timbaland had done this to lets say the Rolling Stones or any other very well known band he wouldn't have gotten away with it. But because this was done by someone who is not a mega star and lives across the ocean, he thought it makes it ok.
AnalogX 4 years ago
Thanks for your insight and opinion. Much appreciated.
BeatKidMindState 4 years ago
Not a problem.
One good thing out of this, people will be a bit more aware about copyright issues and giving credit where credit is due. :)
AnalogX 4 years ago
helloooo this is hip-hop. People do this all the time.
Dr.dre (eminem) just listnen to the song : Labi Siffre - I got the (Blues). Or better yet : David Mccallum - The Edge (you all know this song).
tobiaskelvin 4 years ago
I agree. But again I didnt have a concern with him sampling I just thought he should have gave credit to who he borrowed from. If that musician was someone big here that we know, Tim would have to pay up something, I put money on it. But he is still a musical genius and I am still a fan regardless.
BeatKidMindState 4 years ago
could u be more explicit? which song of dre and eminem or dre feat eminem..i dont undersand you..it's made after labi siffre - i got the? or teh second song you called.try to be more clear when you write sumthin :)
ametyldiz 4 years ago
Best are Dre, Storch, Timbaland, Pharrell
billionaire35 4 years ago
Don't forget about Dilla and Preemo now
BeatKidMindState 4 years ago
agreed.
maddbruce 4 years ago