Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (364)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • His hair is pretty.

  • did anyone count those hairflips???

  • i wish he'd do this song THE FULL version of the song D: id be so happy if he did

  • i love you Brett You Are Mi Favorite. And You Have A Gr8 Voice ♥

  • wow he sucks wow scotty rocks

  • @floridagirl20111 You Say That Because You Think Scotty Is Hot! So Dont Be Hatin Some People Love Brett. I Know I Do

  • uhmm heck no...

  • im sorry, the kids good, but better than the origional? no fucking way. not even. Jim Morrison was Jim Morrison. nobody else sounded like him at the time. this dude sounds like a black female soul singer/every other american idol contestant that makes it into the finals.

  • Woohoo he's doing better than the original. Dunno much on all the show related business, have watched a few vids abut him till now, but I hope he'll go on with his way and never stop doing music and singing!

  • I loved his voice and was sooo upset when he didn't make it through.

  • This is as close as I can get to Rober Plant covering Jim Morrison aaaaand I'm okay with that :)

  • i luv him i voted 4 u

  • he may be weird gay looking freaky but god gave him a great voice and he better auditon again

  • @zlzFUNNYMANzlz What exactly is weird gay looking? I'm just curious...

  • @zlzFUNNYMANzlz you mean kind of like the lead singer of Aerosmith? LOL... it never ceases to amaze me. There are just too many judgemental fucks like you in this world. Please, find a gun, and use it to blow your brains out - you aren't using them anyway!

  • May not be the best performance of night, still it was a pretty good performance. Brett was one of my favorite and should've gone farther.

  • I thought he did a kick ass job

  • I thought he did a great version of the Doors classic but I didn't think it was the best song of choice, I personally wished Brett would have done a song by Journey or Styx instead

  • is she girl or boy.......

  • @bridgelove8378 Oh shut up

  • He's so cute

  • He is good singer, if American can embrace a very unique voice with so much quality -He will be more than American Idol..

  • I wish he would have made it further!

    I think people just didn't vote for him because he is different.

    EMBRACE diversity people!

    He would of had my vote :)

  • @chloeisthename

    would have? I assume that means you didn't vote for him xD

  • @Zinobreaker

    I actually did, i ment if he made it further

  • @chloeisthename

    Oh I get it now :D

  • Haters, you are all jealous of his amazing personality and beauty. Let me just say one thing, Brett does not care if you hate on him so I suggest you show him some love.

  • hes so faminin ,he remind me myself!

  • he is sooooo... amamadorable!

  • before I red ur comments I was actually thinking he was a queer woman...

  • Jim Morrison would be turning in his grave. Thanks American Idol. Let the dead rest next time.

  • i think his voice is ideal for rock music

  • for me he is the winner of america idol. thats it.

  • He is sooo gay

  • omg , sweetest guy in the world<3

  • awww i just want to tousle his hair! it looks so soft!

  • Brett keep singing, you are the best

  • He's so cute....

    the teddybear kind...

  • DUDE U SUCK!!!!! COLTON!!! COLTON!!! *keeps cheering*

  • You suck.

  • in love with him <3

    

  • Me toooooo!!! I wanna hug you Red ApPle :D u sooooo BOMB!!! beshos!!! I wish I could meet you :D

  • Such an awesome fucking voice and personality.

  • That hair.

  • AHHH no one can match Morrison!!!

    wtf with the duck

  • @sooner4949 there was a blind dude? lol

  • the blind dude was better than this guy

  • @sooner4949 who? scott macintyre?

  • gay or not he was one of the best of the season!!!

  • She has to be Amrican Idol:-))

  • They should've put Colton through instead of him. What BS.

  • He ruin the whole song reallly

  • is he gay?

  • @2fresh4u1000 yeah 

  • Seriously? How the hell did stefano do better than him?

  • she should have done simply red lol

  • @dirty06maggot she a guy dude

  • @yaanimerules lol i meant " he"

  • what does tyler say at 0:16? "Bad breath and you were on fire again"???? Great performance by this guy, it stands out in my mind this season. Your new American Idol will be Haley Reinhart I think

  • i really want to pet his hair...I say that in the least creepy way possible. lol

  • I LOVED his singing

  • What a way to ruin a song.

  • Colton would have done better fuck Brett

  • that's bad

  • i miss him i wish he didnt get kicked off! he was one of my three favorites!

  • oh my... I can't stop listening to this. I thought for sure he'd go through. he might be a little too "original" for some people, but he's so damn good. this song is such a cheese fest and he made it awesome! his voice is so addicting! I keep wondering why the judges never gave him a second chance... I'm still more pissed at that than when Pia got voted off. which is saying a lot. people can say what they want about him, but I bet they all wish they could sing like him.

  • Brett stood out, just like Casey, Paul, and James. I wish the judges gave him a chance.

  • i think it would be better if he sing another slow rock song, not light my fire, i just think it's not suit his voice characteristic...

  • i thought he was a girl

  • He's so gay, but he's p. good.

  • wut a faggot

  • Comment removed

  • i will light his hair on fire, the last excesism still hasnt happen and hes the one we have to find!!!!

  • I totally dig his rendition of this song.. besides Jim Morrison hated this song so I don't think he woulda cared who sang it as long as it wasn't him lol.

  • this is a fuckin sacrilege

  • I actually don't think he was that good. Don't go yelling at me for thinking so, but his style of singing just didn't appeal to me. I wish Jacee Badeaux had made it instead of him.

  • @haroldfangbar I agree. He had a great voice, but I didn't really like his style of singing.

  • Some strong parts, but more weak parts. Over all: Irrelevant. He can be glad to have made it so far.

  • I counted 13 hair flips. XD

  • dont stop u got it

  • thats a guy

  • i so loved him!! i heard he got kicked off and i was like "WTF??? WHY??" i voted for him 8 times....

  • LOVE the hair flipping!!! "Come on baby, light my fire!" ;)

  • He was my fave too. He didn't make it cause of the ego, attitude, insecurity and also chip on his shoulder, feelings of inferiority America couldn't relate to or accept. I'm sure of it. Otherwise, he was very talented and loveable, likeable. He should not have mentioned being bullied right off. He rubbed it in and turned people off. Everyone has been bullied. Get over it, already, obstacle he must overcome before reaching his goals. Got to realize he is all that and go on.

  • James durbin is better :)

  • i liked him and love this song <3 the doors but i think paul should win and anyone who's competition to him shud be eliminated no matter the order

  • Love you Brett! Thats sounds weird cause my name is the same as his and imma girl!

  • This guy should have made it into the Top 10! This was A GREAT performance!

  • It's such a shame he got kicked off... He was my absolute favourite.

  • @xZexionIenzox Yeah, it pretty much ruined this season of Idol for me... Paul McDonald is my favorite contestant after him, but he was the best... =( I hope he auditions next year...

  • @xZexionIenzox I was pissed off at America for voting a man with such talent off the show. He was my fave from the word "go".

  • @xZexionIenzox YEAH IT IS A SHAME!!! HE GOES THEN CASEY GOES THEN PAUL GOES THEN NOW JAMES!!! WTF

  • Yeh she sounds good !!!!

  • It was really quite good. Somehwere in the competition he should have chosen to sing George MIchaels 'Everything She Wants.' He would have won the show with that!.

  • He was my fav! Not sure how much longer I will be watching the rest of this season.

  • Comment removed

  • Is it just me or does it bug anyone else how he sings "fire"...really annoying like nails on a chalk board

  • @merkur18 LOL...I wondered if I was the only one who found it annoying.

  • @endtimezprophet i did too lol. it was all those hair flips.

  • i would love to hug him !!!! lol !!!!

  • i'm gay and this made me uncomfortable

  • The reason he didn't make it is really simple. This is a competition in which you need to differentiate yourself from the original artist and be current at the same time. It's a classic song that is no longer 'current'. So when america has the top 5 guys go on, who are you going to kick out for him? Maybe Scotty who had a whole audience group to himself? doubtful. Lusk? over the top in this case made him standout. Abrams & Durbin? clearly not. McDonald? too unique. process of elimination

  • SO GAY!!!! Glad he is gone!!!!

  • @recycle07071983 =O You are so mean!!! There is ABSOLUTELY NOTHING wrong with being gay!!! And you don't even know that he is... You can't just judge based on the way he acts or looks... Besides, he's an insanely talented musician and singer, so stuff like that shouldn't even matter!!! He was definably the most unique of everyone, and he's so sweet too... He deserved to win more than anyone else!!! I was so sad when he didn't make it... =(

  • @ILoveKnuckles4Ever Whoops, that should say, "Definitely"

  • fuck that jew now you know why he never went through

  • One word: Awkward

  • thats a handsome woman

  • gay

  • @NationalMan So?

  • @dragonongkh this performance just is .. so..

  • He is better than sefano in my opinion xD.

  • @CleaTheChameleon btw i live 2 neighborhoods away fom him thats not y we like its cuz of his amazing story and if u know him like me u would no y.

  • im glad he was eliminated. never liked brett. he didnt make it cause he sucks.

  • He should still be in it !!! he's sooo good !!! Love you Brett!!!!

  • why shit did get trough but brett not ?

  • sorry below i meant " he" jajajajaj but i still think he is good!

  • she isn't a great singer, but she does have an interesting voice, and she is original, unique, she has the personality to be a great musician, that's something really difficult to find in nowadays singers, like madonna for example, she doesn't have a great voice, but she is a great performer, she transmits a message , that's why she is the queen of pop, however look at leona lewis,she has an amazing voice, but not the personality of a real musician, she is boring ,and now she's been forgotten!

  • I LOVE HIM. he's so precious. I am so soooo sad he did not get through. LOVEEEEEEE HIM.

  • For some strange reason he really reminds me of a cockerspaniel. I just hope he keeps singing and flipping his hair. When he got booted off he should've sang I whip my hair. :) I wish he would've made it through.

  • he looks like a girl... that's why he sucks

  • @Fredo86IZ

    he looks like a girl, that's why he sucks? that's a pretty lame argument.

  • @katekate132 It's not an argument you dumbass... its just a comment...

  • @Fredo86IZ What is the need for that comment? Just because he doesn't look like the stereotypical male...big deal. You're obviously too small minded to see that.

  • Looks like Carrot top just butchered The Doors

  • cannot believe hes gone, he was so gd!

  • Do you know what HQ means? lol

  • man he has such a good attitude and i really wish he would've made it thru , and gawd i love his hair flippin xD you're awesome man

  • i voted ALL NIGHT LONG until it told me to stop!!! why didnt he make it!?!!?!

  • what a fag

  • @xAuzzY haha true that

  • am I the only one that thinks he did himself a disservice wearing that big star of David? Your name is already Lowenstern....why play to any antisemitism Americans may have?

  • dude was amazing wonder why u americans have such bad taste in music to vote him off

  • i wish he stayed

  • he shoulda gone through over ashton

  • It sucks he didnt make the Top 13

  • Anyone else thinks this guy kinda looks like Kenny G?

  • Oh, Brett. Just let me say: you sure lit my fire! :D <3

  • I LOVED this version so much. (and i remember both jose's and Jim's very well) I sincerely hope he continues to let his LOVE LIGHT SHINE SHINE SHINE. I wish him the Best and Wild Blessings.

  • personnally i think he was the only one from those who got eliminated that was kind hearted the other ones like the karaoke dude and the black dude that sang omg but brett was awsome and deserved at least the wild card

  • I'm gonna miss all that hair shakin' this week. :)

  • the way this guy moves and looks reminds me of a young robert plant, does anyone else see it?

  • @zamboni757

    OH GOD, Yes. I just now realized WHO it was...Mr.Plant. good on you 757. right on point.

  • @aikman6699 Jacob is one of the best this year so shut the fuck up hater and Brett was the sweetest he made my heart melt.

    FUCKING HOMOPHOBIC.

  • HE AND JAKOB ARE PROBABLY SLEEPIN' TOGETHER...BOTH ARE AND HAVE TOTALLY ANNOYING PERSONALITIES AND VOICES....NOW I HOPE AMERICA GETS IT RIGHT AND DUMPS  JAKOB RUSK THE OTHER FLAMER

  • @aikman6699 u are a sick idiot

  • this is really gay in case noone said it. i didn't take time to read comments. SCISSORS UP

  • someone will probably sign him he has so many fans now

  • dissing Brett says that you're jealous of his talent and confidence.

  • I LOVE THIS KIDDDDD

  • This guy sucked hard. It is a shame he made it in to the top 24 when someone more deserving would have been better.

  • he is a great kid but i dont think he would have made it much farther because some of the voices he is competing with are just ridiculous!!!!!!!!!!!

  • loved him

  • I loved this kid. Shame he didnt make it. Really good performance plus he's really funny.

  • totally love brett<3 hope to see him again:\

  • I loooved him so much, right after I heard him sing Bohemian Rhapsody. Dammit, he was so nice and loved to hug and defintely was actually...one of my favs. My first fav matter-of-fact. Dammit, I wanted him to make it. So bad.

  • @YounngRose Me too... ='( I fell in love with him and his voice when I first saw his audition... I was so sure he was going to win... So I was really shocked and sad when he didn't make it... If you have a facebook account, you can add him and send him a message or something... =D (That's what I did)

  • Gi624 is gay for Brett lmao

  • I hadn't seen this performance again since Brett did it on the Idol stage and because of the badmouthing he was getting from the jocks and cheerleaders table I thought maybe there was something bad about it I'd missed, but watching it again here on the Tube I have to say Brett is a star, those idiot "fans" at Idull don't have any idea what good is and the judges are a bunch of clueless pollwatchers.

  • Lmao yea your all right he should have stayed so we can keep laughing and making fun of him hahaha. Damm you voters for taking away my comedy. We had our next sanjaya

  • @jac7232010 Here's one of the Idull morons now.

  • really? american idol, u lose.

  • I like Brett and would have liked to see him go through but this was not a good song for his voice. This is a classic and Morrison had such a big voice it just didn't work for Brett here to take this one on. Sorry to see him go. He is young and he'll be back.

  • When I first saw this, I found it funny that a ginger was singing "Light My Fire" as if his fire wasn't already lit.

  • haters go to hell! Brett is great whatever you say!

  • this is no acceptable....

  • He is a red apple in a pile of green apples!!!!! He is such a good singer and light my fire was a good choice of songs! Whip my hiar is probably the best choice of songs for him tho....

  • he should have stayed!! he better come back next year

  • Coming from someone who's never heard the song before this, I really like this performance. But I have nothing to compare it to, so yeah. All I know is I really did like this guys performance and wish he would have stayed..

  • @mcmouse091

    Listen to the original and you will see how horrible this was. It is an insult to Jim Morrison.