This only makes me love him more. He is beautiful no matter what those dogs thought. As far as I'm concerned he was the Angel and they were the 'devil's children' INCLUDING THAT STUPID RAOUL!!!!
R: But clearly Madame Giry, genius has turned to madness
MG: Madness? MADNESS?! Did you not hear all of what i just said???!!!!!! He was beat as a child!!!!!! He was never loved!!! He smarter than 10 your IQ's put together!!!!!
the man who has poor erik in the cage looks like he has some serious problems with drugs and madame has a very good heart.. by the way dosent raoul look like ashton kutcher
@Mshottie6 She was only trying to protect him. Read THE PHANTOM OF MANHATTAN by FREDERICK FORSYTHE which reveals the nature of her relationship with him, and how she did everything for him ; it also happens to be the sequel to this story.
This only makes me love him more. He is beautiful no matter what those dogs thought. As far as I'm concerned he was the Angel and they were the 'devil's children' INCLUDING THAT STUPID RAOUL!!!!
mrspuckerman93 1 week ago
Stupid guy. He deserved it.
101rocketmail 1 week ago
I could cry knowing things like this actually happened back then
TheAwkwardMomentXD 2 weeks ago
'Clearly, Mdame Giry, Genius has turned into madness.'
Madness...? THIS IS OPERA!!! *KICK*
Ewing5150 3 weeks ago
GO PHANTOM AT 2:06 TO 2:15 THAT GUY GOT WHAT HE DESESERVED
LB126Penguin 1 month ago
Hey anybody ever wonder who Meg's father is? ... Just saying.
earlandbob 2 months ago
@earlandbob ewwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww.....
funfunfunny1234 2 months ago
@SDBlovebunny101 "Down Once More" or it's at the end of "Past the Point of No Return" not sure...
earlandbob 2 months ago
The fact that if you look VERY closely at 1:43 and there's no disfigurement... Kinda awkward :P
GamerGirlElla 4 months ago
I got nightmares from this, I can go to haunted houses, watch thousands of scary movies, and I get nightmares... from this.
NelenaPonesNiley 8 months ago 3
@NelenaPonesNiley Haha, really? I have a very low tolerance for horror, so...I'm impressed ;)
liveforlife2494 8 months ago 2
Anybody know the name of the song where she is leading him down to the phantom 'keep your hands at the level of your eyes'
SDBlovebunny101 8 months ago
R: But clearly Madame Giry, genius has turned to madness
MG: Madness? MADNESS?! Did you not hear all of what i just said???!!!!!! He was beat as a child!!!!!! He was never loved!!! He smarter than 10 your IQ's put together!!!!!
( Lol. Sorry if l dramatized it a bit )
RedRosesLast4eva 1 year ago 10
@RedRosesLast4eva That was basically me when I saw this the first time :)
liveforlife2494 1 year ago 4
This scene is sooooooo sad. :(:(:(:(
LittleLotte616 1 year ago 3
The little young actress even looks exactly like a young Madame Giry! It's sad what Erik went through, only Madame Giry showed compassion.
clover220 1 year ago
the man who has poor erik in the cage looks like he has some serious problems with drugs and madame has a very good heart.. by the way dosent raoul look like ashton kutcher
MegaCooties 2 years ago
@WhySoSilent2123 I agree.
DarkEyeHope 2 years ago
poor erik. he never did anything wrong until madame hid him from the world.
Mshottie6 2 years ago
Comment removed
DarkEyeHope 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Mshottie6 She was only trying to protect him. Read THE PHANTOM OF MANHATTAN by FREDERICK FORSYTHE which reveals the nature of her relationship with him, and how she did everything for him ; it also happens to be the sequel to this story.
DarkEyeHope 2 years ago
so he didnt murder the man before she took him away
garrychelsea 2 years ago
@Mshottie6 U better not blame Madame Giry, she saved Erik's life!!!!!
DetectiveJulie 4 months ago
This part is sad. I love Miranda Richardson as Madame Giry!
stephowrites 3 years ago 7
I can see that *peers at channel and grins*
liveforlife2494 3 years ago
*sniff - this is so sad:(
He was so horribly abused & neglected as a child - it's not easy to watch...
rhapsodyenbleuclair 3 years ago 11
I know...it hurts.
liveforlife2494 3 years ago 4
@rhapsodyenbleuclair You said it. I'm grateful to Madame Giry for having the heart, and kindness to save Erik.
DarkEyeHope 2 years ago
Poor Erik...
7webykinz2 3 years ago