Rosier (Cover) - High and Mighty Color

[b4k4ever]

...posted a comment 2 years ago on this and happened upon it again by chance. and yet still no one seems to be addressing the "By the time I knew~I am the trigger" section and the fact that it sounds like completely different lyrics!!!! did anyone ever confirm this or am I just not hearing it right?

[abcdefg123456875]

@thekillerose

Damn straight! ^_^

... And by the way, @Fimbu1vetr , what does IMO mean?? I spend most of my time reading books, so I only know the really basic text/internet slang :P

[B33ZL3D1CK]

Good song just stumbled across it

[Fimbu1vetr]

This cover is better IMO.

[downsports]

この曲やった度胸は認めるけど、うーん？どうなんだ？

ここまでボーカル下手だとちょっとな～、イントロのデスボイスだ­けだな、聞けるのは。



[abcdefg123456875]

I seroiusly don't get why people are debating over which version better! How about we just keep it at, both songs are epic, Luna Sea gave it Luna Sea epicness, and HaMC gave it HaMC epicness?! There!

[thekillerose]

@abcdefg123456875 thats that. :)

[LilitheFurore]

*cringes*

I haven't heard one good cover of this song. Proves that Luna Sea are the one and only band who can do this <3

I don't dislike high and mighty color but I just don't like what they did with it. Ryuchi is the only one who can sing this and the guitar with sugizo is just so much better,

Nope this is not for me, nothing can top the original.

[GrimRip89]

@LilitheFurore ofc the original is better then the remix verson but HNMC did a good job at it XD

[abcdefg123456875]

And @AliceDeMalice

You suck.

[abcdefg123456875]

I can never listen to this song once, I always have to RAPE the replay button!!

[rampage222555]

lol raping that replay button endlessly I really love this cover

[rampage222555]

fkn amazing cover, there is hope for new music bands!

[NuclearSoftWorks]

This is one hell of an epic track man.

[lovification]

聞き入ってしまう魔力。。。

スゴイよね。

[Vampiresax]

gracias por subir el video <3

[syunbiohazard]

リフをベースラインに忠実にした訳ね

[kana00lala]

つまり、LUNA　SEAが素晴らし過ぎるって事だよ。

こういうのを聴くと、絶対本家がすぐ聴きたくなるけど

LUNA　SEAより良かったら嫉妬しちゃうからｗ

[meimeisellspanties]

This is an awesome cover of Rosier! I love both versions! XD

[jagex4uck]

71 people got crashed in the old style way

[AliceDeMalice]

It sounds so...lame!

As if they're 75 years old or something, unbelievable.

[akiraman26]

Would be a good intro to a gundam cartoon

[EmiChinify]

Woo! Love It!! ♥♥♥♥ ;D

[Machio48]

いやぁマーキーやっぱりいいね( ´ ▽ ` )ﾉ

[chihiroaway]

ボーカル以外いい

[I8nited]

Awesome cover!!

[nobupumisuzu]

爽快感ないなぁ〜(>_<)楽器隊ももっとINORANpart­を強調してほしかった。

[lmao458]

good cover but I don't like the solo much, I think it sounds better in the original

[moonbump]

スピードが遅いなー・・・

[lobo5o]

@moonbump and in english that is?

[Shounendiver]

@lobo5o the speed is too slow, it says. I don't think so XD

[lobo5o]

@Shounendiver ah ty i cant read that n was wondering.

[kmfdmsucks13]

Personally I love this song by Handmc. Maki and Yuusuke made a great combo. Yes, it's not the original and yes it's different but does that really matter? A cover doesn't have to sound exactly like the original since the band who does the cover makes it fit into their own style to do an imitation of the original. I've heard a lot of horrible covers. Like bands that cover Depeche Mode songs are always horrible. This song rocks and will always be a favorite of mine

[SesyyyTravisaa303]

heÿ_äñÿ_gúÿs_wÅÑt_t0_chãt_wîth­_mê

[fyourcouchnigga]

Haha they cant play the original so they cover it up with power chords.

[PlasticElectricity]

the name of this song is my last name.. :3

[victory21222]

@PlasticElectricity  mine too!

[Eddy3443]

I personally have much respect and admiration for Luna Sea and usually am not a fan of covers of any sort, but much like MUCC's cover or dejavu, High and Mighty color did a pretty fine job of covering a Luna Sea song, but of course the original is a vintage of greatness.

[coheedgirl013]

It's actually pretty good :D

People shouldn't be too harsh it's just a cover

[MakotoMiura]

Nothing, really NOTHING could beat the original.

Luna Sea ftw!

[orkimagure23]

スレイブにがっかり・・・

[DonS3phir0th]

awesome cover :) but the original is very good too.

[HyperShan3]

Personally, I actually prefer this more than the original! An awesome cover! =)

[FallenAngeal]

@HyperShan3 what!?!? not a true Visual kei fan then....

[HyperShan3]

@FallenAngeal What's Visual kei?

[FallenAngeal]

@HyperShan3 Visual kei a sub genre to jrock. in other words it's the real jrock. Here are my favorite bands you should try to listen to them.

1. the GazettE (My favorite band)

2.SID

3.Nightmare

SID and Nightmare make anime openings.

[HyperShan3]

@FallenAngeal Sweet I remember Nightmare - They did the intro & ending of Death Note ("The World" & "Alumina")! I'll check them out!

[FallenAngeal]

@HyperShan3 yea... I suggest the Gazettes because they simply own every rock band in the whole planet of rock music. They simply have the looks, the style and the Music!!. Just listen to PLEDGE, their new single and you will see what i mean. BTW SID did an opening for Bleach recently (ranbu no melody). These are visual bands. I hope i explained it well enough.

[HyperShan3]

@FallenAngeal Cheers for that - Ill make sure to definately check them out! =)

[FallenAngeal]

@HyperShan3 Cool Dude i'm positive you will like it.

[ryuusenka1]

i miss them T_T

[shuyananahara100]

@ryuusenka1 Well, Halca, Yosuke and Tony (Syn) are friends they usually see each other I feel that this band will come back. Also Sassy and MEG along with Mckaz are still friends. xDD

[ShiGe001]

メタルに影響されたバンドだからと言っても、これは受け入れられ­ない。

完全に失敗だろw

[JRockinPop]

No guys i personally prefer H&MC's version to Luna Sea's...even though both are great! They've added some freshness and some metal-style to the song which lacked those before ^^

[opn61]

どんなバンドかは知らないけど、Rosierにデスボイスは合わ­ない。

そもそも、美声でもない下手な歌手が歌ってる時点で腹立たしい。­

[atyeclipse]

actually do a cover for the song is okay for as long it didn't change the original music and also add things unnecessary in the song...

[imaici]

コメント見て思ったが、

スレイブって重い曲苦手な人多いのか？

[opn61]

@imaici

そんなことはない。

[Lashauk]

@LykayaMamato indeed, I just heard the original, does not reach the level of original music, but both are very good, I do not have to complain about

[LykayaMamato]

One question: WHY?

What the fuck is wrong with all those new japanese bands?

They deface the old, GOOD music. Non-talented band shouldn't even cover songs...

[JRockinPop]

So friggin awesome! Nice combination of Yuusuke's and Maki's voice ^^ H&MC (Y)

[idola97]

ﾘﾗﾋｲ 

[Max33link]

AWESOME ! The two version are AWESOME !

[Mikysek1000]

Nice :)

[insomniac584]

失敗....

[keizokate]

vocal dynamics? wtf. seriously? HaMC turned an alright song into something far more dedicated to rock with the bouncing of lyrics between yusuke and maki. it's the same performance, even the voice pitch and the variance of his vocals, when the singer of luna does this song; luna's take on this song feels so lacking in energy =(

[deathmasks]

Good cover, but whats-his-name just doesn't have the vocal dynamics of Ryuichi. Maki rocks the chorus though.

[asada20]

原曲も好きだしこれも好きだしブラステの最凶レイ○カヴァーも好­き

ベース聞こえないって言ってる奴はなんなの？

ベース知ってんの？

[R9564]

普通にベース聴こえるじゃんｗ

[SpreadBeaver777]

Jの歌詞の部分は　この曲で一番伝えたいこと　って行っても過言じゃないから

そこだけはちゃんとやってほしかった

[purplecubeman01]

redoing a song by luna sea? thats a first this is one of their best songs after all lol

[Otakugirl003]

I like the both versions, but I prefer this. Unfortunately, Maki left that awesome band :'(

[orkimagure23]

好き嫌いわかれるが俺はすきだよ

メタルに影響されたバンドだし

ドラムがうるさいのはハイカラらしさじゃいか

ベースも意図的に聞こえにくくしてるんだろな

[TheMissMemory]

The orginal is much better I have to say...

No one can beat Ryuichis voice!!!

[jlyh55]

Do they have a MV for this??

[purplecubeman01]

they do a good version of roister, but luna seas origional is better, they add a plesant twist to the song though, its quite good, in my opinion

[VisualXxKei]

どちらも非常に優れている

<333



[VisualXxKei]

I like both versions. Specially this version because they were inspired by

a very EPIC band~ :3

[XJAPANVISUALSHOCK]

うーんやっぱ作った人の曲を越えられるカバー曲はどんなにすごい­アーティストがやろうとも無理だって証明できるね（笑）

[wishcat]

este cover, para mi, quedo mejor que la versión original :) la diferencia la hace makii :D

[kurosakibleachigo]

@wishcat eS QUE MAKI ES MAKI, LA VERDAD SI

[MyMadness90]

Awesome... Now, THIS is a great Cover :D In my opinion, it's better than the original >:D

[honeylee10]

@MyMadness90 you gotta be kidding me!

[pg86]

Whos the new female singer of High and mighty color?

[bluebolt001]

@pg86 its halca

[gothicducky31]

@pg86 It was Halca until the band disbanded last month

[kantallica]

イマイチ感は否めないかなぁ。

俺はイントロで期待した分残念な感じ。

やりきっちゃえば酷評されなかったんじゃないかな。

まぁバンドとしてはメジャレーベルだしそれは難しかったのかもね­。

[NelSonMeTalKidz]

Is Makii sang this version?

[ayuumiie]

@NelSonMeTalKidz yes it's Makii ^^

[NelSonMeTalKidz]

@ayuumiie Thank you :) her voice is unique!!

[fpsFALSE]

@NelSonMeTalKidz

Yeah, Makii was still in the band when they did the Rosier cover.

[reboot0529]

女性Voマーキーさん？

彼女が終始歌うべきじゃないかなあ…

この曲をカヴァーすることは結構プレッシャーあったと思うけど、­なかなかのもんだと思います。叩くほどひどくはないでしょう。

[JENNIFERJENNIFER5859]

wow XD

[81kenken]

今まで色んなカバー曲を聞いたけど、ここまで酷いのはない。

原曲に比べて、疾走感がなさすぎ。まず、出だしから重い…。しか­も、全然メリハリがないし、デスボイスなんか必要ない。

それに、リズム隊が随分と劣る。ベースは聞こえんし、ドラムも無­駄なオカズが多い。

最近の流行といえば、そこまでなんだが…。

[yuuyuu39]

酷評するとハイカラが可哀そうだけど…、

ギターソロの最後の速弾きは逆に曲をチープにしちゃうね。

でも、この名曲をカバーするのは相当プレッシャーだったのでは！­？

よく健闘したと思います。

[JBalmoreS]

I like this version over Luna Sea's, but the monolouge is missing and I really liked that about the original.

[Yonezawadrx]

Cooooool

[alrick13]

Good cover but most of the time the version you hear first will be better, as for me since this is the first version I listened to, in my opinion it is better

[nobsherc]

this version is more "harcore", the solo is much better and maki's vocal adds a lot too, but ,even then, i prefer the original (by a small margin)

[JBalmoreS]

The chorus is amazing! :)

[mizunolovetolove]

いくらなんでもこれはない...。

[bbbhope]

ルナシーの感じが、ドストライクだって言う人には、少し抵抗ある­かもね・・・

俺はこういう路線も好きだし、結構いいと思う！

[R9564]

この曲のどこが酷いって言うんだ？

最高のカバーじゃないか。

[daitajunkie]

ひ、ひどすぎる、、、、

[sake46]

i wished one ok rock was asked to a cover for one of the songs think they would have done well

[PapyMandarine]

Luna Sea rocks !

High and mighty Colors ? Yeah they rock too !

[kazuya74]

wow i like this version

[missionsix1999]

女棒読み。

男ヘナチョコ。

演奏カス。

文化祭レベル。

ｼ━━━━(　´_ゝ｀)━━━━ﾝ

[Tristessa326ck]

I'm not too crazy about the music, but Maki's voice really shines in the chorus!

[phantomj17]

I like Halca version than Maki's

[AfroBotSays]

@phantomj17 Halca did a rosier cover as well?

[phantomj17]

The girl is Maki.. but i like their version over the Luna Sea version ^^

[pantsuno]

いいね！

[inuyasha276]

i love this song it is epic baby!!!!!!!!

[spukkanal]

fuck yeah, this is great! ^__^

[SeanNovember7]

サビ以外もﾏｰｷｰがやったほうが良いと思う

今更言ってもﾏｰｷｰ居ないけど。帰ってきてﾏｰｷｰ。。。

[fantasyqueen12]

i really like this song they coverd this song well i think this is maki

[RevolutionarySamurai]

bit too raw in comparison to the first version

nice heavy guitar tho!

[shunhiyoshi]

すご～～いへこんでいましたが、

このサビを聴いて、もりあがりました！！　ありがとうございます！

[QuilavaKing]

I didn't realize until I heard this song, but Yusuke actually has an amazing voice when he's not screaming.

[aristokraticassassin]

@QuilavaKing if you want to hear another song where he is not screaming you should listen to there song "You" though it doesn't have Maki in it... I still think Halca is amazing but I like Maki better.

[shuu703]

軽いなぁｗｗｗ

[reidafloresta3196]

High and migthy color owna com qualquer musica^^

melhoraram a musica

[KiryuL91]

Luna Sea & High and Mighty Color are great

[R9564]

iPodでこの曲のイントロが流れると、超テンション上がるｗ

I'm upping the tension from iPod from flows this song's intro time.

[ShadowsBekon]

I first heard Rosier when i discovered Luna Sea last year and immediately loved this song in particular. Luna Sea has a lot of good songs and a few really awesome ones. This was by far my favorite and this cover is simply great.

[oldelpaso678]

I like this song because the recording quality is much better than the old version, obviously. But, when Luna Sea play this song live it is amazing.

[pesky89]

idk if recording quality is better, but it may seem like it cause this version is less dirty, yet heavier sounding

thumbs up for H&MC they did this song justice i think

[karmaryo]

suck baby

[alesiswisses]

uff exelnt song so great

aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

[CrystalShinigami]

Hey, don't be mean to the High and Mighty Color. They were attempting a new sound for a great song. The bottom line is Rosier is a terrific anthem of tortured love, and though Luna Sea is best, keep in mind it is the ORIGINAL. The original tends to always be better than a copy, but I give the High and Mighty Color props for trying, it's hard to fill in the shoes of such a great band AND a great song. So, kudos High and Mighty Color. Rock n' roll.

[horn1110]

I love original music than this music.

[AOKIANAYA]

ベース聞こえないとか言うやつ　耳聞こえてないんじゃないの？？？

[AirCello1]

eww no way not even close...BLAH

[qick07]

u suck

[qick07]

this songs adds another element...its heavier while keeping the the harmony of the other song....i dont knw how u luna sea fans cant appreciate this....if it wasnt for X Japan...a power metal band Luna Sea wouldnt be discovered in the first place

[AirCello1]

i can't appreciate it because im not feelin it,this cover sounds watred down despite its "heavier element" this guy's voice sounds weak, like he doesn't want to sing, the chick is so-so, it doesnt make me want to move to the song and i dont like how they added that extra babbling. i like the original because it makes me want to dance along to the song and ryuichi's voice is more lively. but thats just my view nothing against h&mc but for me the original is waaaaay better!

[Grzegrzolka]

cover is one thing and playing someoen's song is another - you can give something from yourself and this is rather good. But as a big fan of older Luna Sea this cover doesn't satisfie me.

[ZenStrive52]

WTF is this cover? lame gay!

[jonj]

Hmmm i think they didnt cover it with the intention to imitate, but to recreate therefore little to no basis of comparison. they only kept bits of the chords progression and drum structure and lyrics. other than that its a pretty good song on its own imo, and a very creative cover.

[Fome]

ベースが全然聞こえないなあ。

[Kaptenhuahua]

The original crush this version into pieces.

[KillahBounce23]

I love this song.

LUNA SEA is good too but I'm a big fan of Haikara.

[lastdrawnbreath]

H&MC is really good. I forgot about them for a while XD I'm a shitty fan!

[dramatic5555]

ベースがぜんぜんダメ。音が痩せて聞こえる。

[umabou2008]

やっぱ　本家やろ

ギターがスケベこいてる

もっとこう一本、スタイルがなぁ　エクストリームかぁ　どこ盛り上げたいか　なんとなくサブイ

[619kammy]

I actually prefer this version over Luna Sea's due to Halca's excellent performance here

[mastachief200]

Halca didn't join till 2009 look at the post date of the video

[619kammy]

bah ment Maki

[Ideokai]

You're crazy.

Halca did pout on a good performance, BUT, this is LUNA SEA. I don't understand how ANY cover could be better than LUNA SEA. I just can't comprehend it. xD

[Kougasomoi]

@Ideokai- I agree... covers are usually not better than the original. :D However, MUCC does really well with their version of Dejavu, its not better, its just as good and the only song on the tribute to LS album that I really liked.

[oRoChiIYIaRu]

Halca just sucks...

imo H&MC without maki is nothing...

but anyway LS is better

確かにベース聴こえないですね

[sakurakikyoudeinu]

amazing, high and mighty color is the best, no more words

[R9564]

カバー曲だけど、この曲が一番好き。

[darkCoHeedxiii]

I like both version but this one is more heavier

[Faelivrinie]

It's awful. They tried hard, but it's not their level.

[RemonMokushi]

H&MC's cover is even better than the original IMO...

[dwoverdose52]

Cool cover it's different from the Luna Sea one but I do still prefer the Luna Sea one better.

[xDisRazyboix]

This is the first one I actually heard the male singer more then the girl.

[shunsuke975]

これはこれでイイよね

[mc34ftr223]

デスボイス→男性ボーカル→女性ボーカルって変化が味噌で狙いな­んだろ。

Bullet For My Valentineとか好きならありじゃね？

まぁ男性ボーカルは確かに弱いからもうちょい全体メリハリあれば­なお良かったな。

[00REbirth]

Regardless, Luna's is still the better... HandMC just did a great job with the cover on the tribute album.

[Parabellum13X]

Why are people saying this one has more emotion?

It has a lot less, if anything.

[unagi0709]

この曲はｌｕｎａｓｅａがタイトにやるからカッコいいんだなぁ～­ヘヴィだと少し下品だｗｗｗ

[lindseynicol91]

This is a very good cover.

It's pointless to compare it to the original though.

Luna Sea is too amazing.

[cronichazel]

crap, i meant to thumbs up this comment. :[ i hit the wrong button

[NishiLoVe01]

i reeeeeeeeeally like this version better XD

[yuta1028xxx]

おれluna sea好きやけど

これもかっこいいじゃん！

[ctverec4]

well this is no great quality.. :D

[AsiaBxD]

i like most the original but guitars and chorus in the cover are nice too.

[andypavon]

The original one is awesome, but i prefer this one, it has more emotion, i guess...