Ron Paul is absolutely right in letting Israel be FREE to do whatever it wishes. Its enemies will take care of Israel themselves. USA should just stop POLICING world and give the responsibility to the one that deserves it i.e. United Nations.
haha, go on blah blahing, look what happened yesterday, idiot. hamas offered a concrete truce to israel in return for 1967s borders, and look how the US responded. your comments look rather retarded now.
God just give these guys a test on foreign policy, monetary policy, the constitution and the history govt so we can just make Dr Paul pres. I mean really none of these idiots would stand a chance.
Ron Paul is the only one that represents the things that made America the great country it once was! Respect for the Constitution, individual liberties, free (as in "free from big corps controlling gov'") market and entrepreneurship.
A true old fashioned American, that obviously won't make the cut...
How could anybody not like Ron Paul? He is the only straight talking politicain. All the other ones have been bought and paid for by Coroporate America and special interests.
Ron Paul has them all SO shaken up that they are now making crucial & blatant mistakes which will blow their bullcrap WIDE OPEN! Go Dr Ron Paul..."Champion of the Constitution!"
McCain looks so disappointed that he can`t bomb someone, they all laugh...bet the stage stunk, everyone but Paul shot thier shorts with the shit they`re full of
Huckabee fact he is insane. Chuck Fact I'm just supporting him for the money I will get if he get elected, then I will film DELTA Force 20 the Iraq Showdown
There is nothing false about this guy and ill tell you why. He NEVER smiles throughout this hole thing. Look at the other candidate. Always smiling for the camera. Ron is SERIOUS about what he is talking about
plus.why the hell do we give money to fascist leaders in the middle east and all while our own country has an epidemic of poverty?! we give them billions and billions, I think the idiots who decided to do that should have their names and egos listed on a plaque for everyone to see what traitors they are! even complete idiots should know dont give money to your enemies!
CONCORD — State officials say they will conduct a hand recount of Tuesday's Democratic and Republican presidential primaries at the request of two minor candidates.
Ohio Democrat Rep. Dennis Kucinich, who received less than 2 percent of the vote, and Republican Albert Howard of Michigan, who received about 44 votes statewide, are expected to pay a $2,000 fee to start the process, state officials said.
Ron Paul has proposed doing away with the federal reserve and the income tax, bringing home the troops immediately, defending the borders and ending the war on drugs and guns...those are just a few of the solutions he has offered. VOTE for freedom!!! Vote for Dr. Ron Paul!!!
He hasn't said how he intends to do all the things you've listed! I mean, him being a Republican and all (yeah right), how does he expect to get along with all the Dems. in Congress and get this done?
allphaursus - Why would him want to "get along" with the Dems who are crashing our economy, funding an unconstitutional war. We just lost our first class triple A status for borrowing money. What would that mean to you? Can YOU borrow money w/o collateral? Fed reserve prints money $ borrows from China.
go to ronpaul2008 for his platform. Republicrats are all alike- speak out of both sidea o/their mouth but VOTE THE SAME!
GIVE FACTS! Don't just tell me that the economy is crashing. Tell me where your idea of our economy crashing has come from. Also, tell me exactly why you call a war on terrorism, unconstitutional. As much education as you may think that you have had, is not enough to convince the majority, that you are smart! Take my advice. Don't sit home and drink on a Friday night and think you are correct. Just shut up and let the real protectors of this land protect us!
OK then, that must mean that the last (how many?) wars we have been in were unconstitutional, right? Just tell me gats, did congress declare war during vietnam, desert storm, korea? The answer is NO! We haven't declared war in many years on our enemies. So don't give me one example, when there are several. You also forget that Congress gave the thumbs up to go into Iraq!
Gloom and Doomers are all alike. This counrty is going to hell in a hand basket, you all figure. But you keep your asses right here instead of moving to a GREAT country.
I'm in Australia mate, also are you aware that the M3 money supply for your country is now at around 18%. M3 is a measure of the current level of inflation and this number has been rapidly increasing over recent years, when inflation is out of control the value of your hard earned US dollars diminishes, this is not good for the overall economy.
Are you aware that we are fighting a war also? Since that is the case, then I have to be a little more optimistic than a lot of folks and say that I think our economy is quite strong considering what has happened "over recent years", to paraphrase you. I am not trying to make it seem as though there are not any problems with our economy. But I refuse to think that all is lost!
The war you are fighting is one of the main contributing factors as to why your economy is weakening. Through the excesses of government your nation is going bankrupt, how can you have a healthy economy when you have an increasingly weak dollar? Whats going to happen to peoples purchasing power when you have runaway inflation? What are you going to do when other countries you trade with demand more and more US dollars in exchange for goods?
are you aware that we are bankrupting social security to finance this war? for what?? for profits of the upper 2% of the nation.. last time i checked my gas wasn't getting any cheaper.
perhaps 'all things considered', it's a wonder that we aren't worse off, true. but all is not well.
OK, so you pick the war on Terror to blame for Social security going broke! I can't even imagine how many excuses there have been for S/S going broke. Can you?Let me lay this out there for you. You and I may even agree on this one. When it comes to our government being in charge of private finances, they get an F- ! And just think, some want them in charge of our health insurance? Congress also put a stop to Bush's S/S reform! Remember?
alphaursus-go to dailypaul com for a real education. Articles,links,and views are shared with like minded people. This way you can do your reading and research with freedom loving,economically independent people. See Saxo Bank article via link. Expanded-extended war means Uncle Sam will TAKE you next! Draft measure ready to go - 18-40, men and women.
Well I hate to say it but I don't expect him to "get along" with dem or reps in congress since so many of them represent companies leaching off of gov contracts and depending on legislation to maintain monopolies of sorts but weve got to start turning the tide somewhere...and he is the only one offering to fix it where its broke, by limiting Our 2 biggest problems right now are the war and the economy, both caused by the fed not following the constitution.
twin2k6 - go to ronpaul2008 com to see what HE WILL DO! Come join the r3VOLution, one by one they are realizing Dr. Paul is the ONLY one who knows what is going on. The others laugh, run their mouth, and say nothing. RP accepts NO corp bribes or $ from lobbyists - "we the People" are the ones defending civil rights and freedom of speech!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I'd like to hear Ron Paul claim credit for what he has done. The others give long lists of their achievements and Dr. Paul is more ideological. His real world actions would tell his story best.
Ron Paul served in the millitary, never voted to raise taxes, votes in favor of the constitution everytime, voted against the war in Iraq, voted against the patriot, to much to list...I believe people like you enjoy being willfully ignorant...Do the country a favor and stay home on election day!
Why do we have to fund them? Honestly why do we fund Israel? We don't fund Canada or Germany or France ... Israel is quite a wealthy nation, they have a growing technology sector, thanks to us their military is quite strong. It's time they start to be their own nation. They're more than capable of taking care of themselves. If there was a full scale invasion by another country then sure we could come to their aid. But I don't see the need for the continual flow of money.
We give 3 times as much money to the arabs than to israel who we supposedly care about and are our main allies. Is it me or does this guy make sense or what? Damn I wish so many people didn't have their heads in the sand and actually listened to reality.
During all of the applause for Ron Paul I hear one female voice that is very loud cheering for him each time. Thank you whoever you are! I'm cheering like that in my living room.
ron paul soooo fucking right i used to hate ron paul but now i like him! bush and the globalist believes that they has the right to decide where israel borders should be,but hello globalist israel is a nation! and USA it is a nation! it is not part of mexico and canada,so lets respet every nation border and let's make mexico respect USA border
I'm loving those split screens. Huckabee looks like he had no idea what the world was really about until he started to LISTEN and LEARN from President Paul.
Sorry, I accidentally gave you a "thumbs down" when I meant to click "thumbs UP."
Yeah, Huckabee is a moron. He thinks he can fix the economy by taxing the hell out of citizens, selling endless government bonds, and continuing the pointless Iraqi war. Unfortunately, Huckabee is not the only moron on stage and in the room.
Poor Arab countries like Egypt gets all that aid. Saudis have investment in the US of about a $trillion dollars. They can help themselves very well, but of course, Egypt is being paid go be not threating to Israel, while Palestine is being bulldozed to dust.
Unfortunately, Paul has to keep try hard to avoid being called anti-semite..
well when your a paul in fox noise infested waters....you better bring more than a hook line and sinker to show these sharks how its done......AMAZING DEBATE TONIGHT BY DR. PAUL
RON PAUL FOR PRESIDENT 2012!!!
BrettMariee 9 months ago
he is so intelligent..if he had stated this any other way he would have been stamped an anti-semite
hailtotheking324 10 months ago 3
@hailtotheking324 perfect I love it when people like you speak up like that since it shows me I am on the right side :) RON PAUL 2012
qortin 5 months ago
Ron Paul is absolutely right in letting Israel be FREE to do whatever it wishes. Its enemies will take care of Israel themselves. USA should just stop POLICING world and give the responsibility to the one that deserves it i.e. United Nations.
aatayyab 1 year ago
Ron Paul For Freedom!2008
thegzspot 4 years ago 11
This comment has received too many negative votes show
blah blah Ronnie israel left alone will be gone
tiroxz 4 years ago
haha, go on blah blahing, look what happened yesterday, idiot. hamas offered a concrete truce to israel in return for 1967s borders, and look how the US responded. your comments look rather retarded now.
ThisIsSize 3 years ago 2
hahaha missed the point with US money and Tech given by Us israel bitching at germany in no time
tiroxz 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Today's MONEY BOMB time!
Please donate as much as you can!
ronpaul2008(DOT)com
And please help spread the word!
jwilson770 4 years ago 2
God just give these guys a test on foreign policy, monetary policy, the constitution and the history govt so we can just make Dr Paul pres. I mean really none of these idiots would stand a chance.
bgabbs69 4 years ago 10
Ron Paul is the only one that represents the things that made America the great country it once was! Respect for the Constitution, individual liberties, free (as in "free from big corps controlling gov'") market and entrepreneurship.
A true old fashioned American, that obviously won't make the cut...
rubenximenes 4 years ago 4
RED ALERT!! VOTE FRAUD IN NH PRIMARY CONFIRMED!!
PAUL WON MORE THAN 20%!!
watch?v=moay6TFSVGg
They need $65,000 to file recount!! Go to Grannywarrior. com to donate!! They have over $30,000 already! Please donate any amount!!
drxclassic 4 years ago 3
How could anybody not like Ron Paul? He is the only straight talking politicain. All the other ones have been bought and paid for by Coroporate America and special interests.
czubspenx 4 years ago 9
Because most people only believe what they are told on TV and are to lazy to have to think for themselves.
bgabbs69 4 years ago 4
Ron Paul has them all SO shaken up that they are now making crucial & blatant mistakes which will blow their bullcrap WIDE OPEN! Go Dr Ron Paul..."Champion of the Constitution!"
keepitrealTV 4 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
he has no chance ppl stop with this propganda you make urself look like those conspiracy theorists.
KypHeM 4 years ago
AMERICA WAKE UP ! Ron Paul is out there, make the right decision!
Thleepricon 4 years ago 8
The more the corporate candidates talk, the more people will realize what they REALLY stand for
WendiGearhart 4 years ago 5
Huckabee is a liar claiming he is unaware of the floating cross on his ad.
poopiefase 4 years ago 4
work it boy!
TetragrammatonMan 4 years ago
McCain looks so disappointed that he can`t bomb someone, they all laugh...bet the stage stunk, everyone but Paul shot thier shorts with the shit they`re full of
pilgrim79 4 years ago 5
Awesome, he is awesome
frostymxer 4 years ago
Hell, I'm a proud Democrat and I might be tempted to vote for this guy
chaplinfan48 4 years ago 12
I love Ron PAul!
RP4409 4 years ago 3
good go vote for him, he is our only hope.
kaiserious 4 years ago 3
Do it...if not for yourself, for the future generations of our country
WendiGearhart 4 years ago 2
did you see when mitt was backing away from Ron Paul on the immagrint issue Lol. he didnt want to get any BLOW BACK!
MGiambone 4 years ago 3
Huckabee fact he is insane. Chuck Fact I'm just supporting him for the money I will get if he get elected, then I will film DELTA Force 20 the Iraq Showdown
axisdelasal 4 years ago 2
In your face Huckabeze
jpinkard 4 years ago
There is nothing false about this guy and ill tell you why. He NEVER smiles throughout this hole thing. Look at the other candidate. Always smiling for the camera. Ron is SERIOUS about what he is talking about
mvalldar 4 years ago 6
Yes good point!
RP4409 4 years ago
Vote Ron Paul and bring back the America that our Founding Fathers envisioned!
evilwhitey98 4 years ago 9
America is no longer what it was or as it appeared. VOTE RON PAUL
StartARev0luti0n 4 years ago 23
America is no longer what it was or as it appeared. VOTE RON
B0b0Th3H0b0 4 years ago
PAUL
B0b0Th3H0b0 4 years ago
America no longer was what is was or as it appeared to be. VOTE RON PAUL.
StartARev0luti0n 4 years ago 6
Ron Paul 08
TheThinWoman 4 years ago 7
plus.why the hell do we give money to fascist leaders in the middle east and all while our own country has an epidemic of poverty?! we give them billions and billions, I think the idiots who decided to do that should have their names and egos listed on a plaque for everyone to see what traitors they are! even complete idiots should know dont give money to your enemies!
thepoopfascist 4 years ago 6
He's the only one that gets so much applause, i love it.
Adirtybum 4 years ago 3
Ron Paul Rules
galcobair14 4 years ago 9
CONCORD — State officials say they will conduct a hand recount of Tuesday's Democratic and Republican presidential primaries at the request of two minor candidates.
Ohio Democrat Rep. Dennis Kucinich, who received less than 2 percent of the vote, and Republican Albert Howard of Michigan, who received about 44 votes statewide, are expected to pay a $2,000 fee to start the process, state officials said.
iTellYouNoLie 4 years ago 4
when Ron said ''we treat israel as a step child'' i started laughin my ass off... couldnt have said it any better.
joeblow59 4 years ago 9
Ron Paul has proposed doing away with the federal reserve and the income tax, bringing home the troops immediately, defending the borders and ending the war on drugs and guns...those are just a few of the solutions he has offered. VOTE for freedom!!! Vote for Dr. Ron Paul!!!
truebootsyes 4 years ago 5
He hasn't said how he intends to do all the things you've listed! I mean, him being a Republican and all (yeah right), how does he expect to get along with all the Dems. in Congress and get this done?
alphaursus 4 years ago
allphaursus - Why would him want to "get along" with the Dems who are crashing our economy, funding an unconstitutional war. We just lost our first class triple A status for borrowing money. What would that mean to you? Can YOU borrow money w/o collateral? Fed reserve prints money $ borrows from China.
go to ronpaul2008 for his platform. Republicrats are all alike- speak out of both sidea o/their mouth but VOTE THE SAME!
brainonnow 4 years ago
GIVE FACTS! Don't just tell me that the economy is crashing. Tell me where your idea of our economy crashing has come from. Also, tell me exactly why you call a war on terrorism, unconstitutional. As much education as you may think that you have had, is not enough to convince the majority, that you are smart! Take my advice. Don't sit home and drink on a Friday night and think you are correct. Just shut up and let the real protectors of this land protect us!
alphaursus 4 years ago
Congress has the authority by the Constitution to declare war, NOT THE PRESIDENT. CONGRESS NEVER DECLARED WAR. THEREFORE THE WAR IS UNCONSTITIONAL.
greatgatsb90210 4 years ago
OK then, that must mean that the last (how many?) wars we have been in were unconstitutional, right? Just tell me gats, did congress declare war during vietnam, desert storm, korea? The answer is NO! We haven't declared war in many years on our enemies. So don't give me one example, when there are several. You also forget that Congress gave the thumbs up to go into Iraq!
alphaursus 4 years ago
Are you aware that the US dollar has declined by over 60% against the Euro since 2000.
rossco355 4 years ago
Yeah????
So you declare that our economy has crashed?
Gloom and Doomers are all alike. This counrty is going to hell in a hand basket, you all figure. But you keep your asses right here instead of moving to a GREAT country.
alphaursus 4 years ago
I'm in Australia mate, also are you aware that the M3 money supply for your country is now at around 18%. M3 is a measure of the current level of inflation and this number has been rapidly increasing over recent years, when inflation is out of control the value of your hard earned US dollars diminishes, this is not good for the overall economy.
rossco355 4 years ago
Are you aware that we are fighting a war also? Since that is the case, then I have to be a little more optimistic than a lot of folks and say that I think our economy is quite strong considering what has happened "over recent years", to paraphrase you. I am not trying to make it seem as though there are not any problems with our economy. But I refuse to think that all is lost!
alphaursus 4 years ago
The war you are fighting is one of the main contributing factors as to why your economy is weakening. Through the excesses of government your nation is going bankrupt, how can you have a healthy economy when you have an increasingly weak dollar? Whats going to happen to peoples purchasing power when you have runaway inflation? What are you going to do when other countries you trade with demand more and more US dollars in exchange for goods?
rossco355 4 years ago 3
are you aware that we are bankrupting social security to finance this war? for what?? for profits of the upper 2% of the nation.. last time i checked my gas wasn't getting any cheaper.
perhaps 'all things considered', it's a wonder that we aren't worse off, true. but all is not well.
aslansalive 4 years ago 7
that was directed as a response to alphaursus post.
aslansalive 4 years ago
OK, so you pick the war on Terror to blame for Social security going broke! I can't even imagine how many excuses there have been for S/S going broke. Can you?Let me lay this out there for you. You and I may even agree on this one. When it comes to our government being in charge of private finances, they get an F- ! And just think, some want them in charge of our health insurance? Congress also put a stop to Bush's S/S reform! Remember?
alphaursus 4 years ago
alphaursus-go to dailypaul com for a real education. Articles,links,and views are shared with like minded people. This way you can do your reading and research with freedom loving,economically independent people. See Saxo Bank article via link. Expanded-extended war means Uncle Sam will TAKE you next! Draft measure ready to go - 18-40, men and women.
business24-7(dot)ae/cs/article_
show_mainh1_story(dot)aspx?HeadlineID=315
brainonnow 4 years ago
Well I hate to say it but I don't expect him to "get along" with dem or reps in congress since so many of them represent companies leaching off of gov contracts and depending on legislation to maintain monopolies of sorts but weve got to start turning the tide somewhere...and he is the only one offering to fix it where its broke, by limiting Our 2 biggest problems right now are the war and the economy, both caused by the fed not following the constitution.
truebootsyes 4 years ago 9
Ron and all the others on both parties talk about what is wrong but NO ONE has offered what their solution is.. NO ONE has a solution.
NO ONE IS WORTH IT!
WE ARE FUCKED!
twin2k6 4 years ago
Don't dispare; Ron Paul (Unlike the rest) understand what is REALLY wrong. So he knows (check out his site) what needs to change.
Everyone else is just using the subject of change to gain votes, with no real intention to do so.
DemeterMuse 4 years ago 5
twin2k6 - go to ronpaul2008 com to see what HE WILL DO! Come join the r3VOLution, one by one they are realizing Dr. Paul is the ONLY one who knows what is going on. The others laugh, run their mouth, and say nothing. RP accepts NO corp bribes or $ from lobbyists - "we the People" are the ones defending civil rights and freedom of speech!
brainonnow 4 years ago
oh yes he has, watch and listen more carefully
kaiserious 4 years ago
you can watch it at youtube at /watch?v=AvzsiESqVss
bubblebbb 4 years ago
when is the next ron paul fund raiser day?
Noobcs 4 years ago
Martin Luther King Day. He talked about it on CNN. Please donate.
bubblebbb 4 years ago 2
You tell em Ron !!!
Wake up people !!!! We need to take back our country from these corporate thugs that are raping America.
Watch the video here called The Truth Fiat Empire. Maybe it will help open your eyes to what's really going on.
aimeechrister 4 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I'd like to hear Ron Paul claim credit for what he has done. The others give long lists of their achievements and Dr. Paul is more ideological. His real world actions would tell his story best.
33115566 4 years ago
Ron Paul served in the millitary, never voted to raise taxes, votes in favor of the constitution everytime, voted against the war in Iraq, voted against the patriot, to much to list...I believe people like you enjoy being willfully ignorant...Do the country a favor and stay home on election day!
eastwood13 4 years ago 8
Our Founding Fathers would be damn proud to stand next to this man.
Ron Paul, the President for these United States of America, a Constitutional Republic!!!
WTP1776 4 years ago 14
Common sense.
flingthecow 4 years ago
Why do we have to fund them? Honestly why do we fund Israel? We don't fund Canada or Germany or France ... Israel is quite a wealthy nation, they have a growing technology sector, thanks to us their military is quite strong. It's time they start to be their own nation. They're more than capable of taking care of themselves. If there was a full scale invasion by another country then sure we could come to their aid. But I don't see the need for the continual flow of money.
hassleoffa 4 years ago 6
We give 3 times as much money to the arabs than to israel who we supposedly care about and are our main allies. Is it me or does this guy make sense or what? Damn I wish so many people didn't have their heads in the sand and actually listened to reality.
myrivarren 4 years ago 2
During all of the applause for Ron Paul I hear one female voice that is very loud cheering for him each time. Thank you whoever you are! I'm cheering like that in my living room.
taviacantarini 4 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
Vote for someone that's not bought and paid for.
Ron Paul 08!
abcinstaller 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
NEOCONZIONISTTHREAT[dot]BLOGSPOT[dot]COM
NOMOREWARFORISRAEL[dot]BLOGSPOT[dot]COM
NOMOREWARFORISRAEL 4 years ago
A man among boys.
RP 08 FTW
ProspectorSam 4 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Yeah he does say allot of things right but he's a liar about Free Trade and the promotion of the progress of sciences and the arts.
He's a conniving liar.
dustynbones 4 years ago
Explain why
MeInsulaEstParva 4 years ago 3
John McCain is so unprofessional, listen to him shooting his mouth off at the end of the clip.
CodeRed001 4 years ago 4
McCain is a brainwashed global communist
MeInsulaEstParva 4 years ago 7
this exactly why FIXed news tries to keep Paul out of the debates. He makes the others look like complete establishment monkeys. Go Ron!!!!
purechaos2000 4 years ago 4
click buzzz RATIONTAL THOUGHT WILL NOT BE TOLERATED buzzz whirrr click click
bigken61 4 years ago 3
ron paul soooo fucking right i used to hate ron paul but now i like him! bush and the globalist believes that they has the right to decide where israel borders should be,but hello globalist israel is a nation! and USA it is a nation! it is not part of mexico and canada,so lets respet every nation border and let's make mexico respect USA border
peter6dio 4 years ago 9
i meant respect :-)anyway sorry i am hispanic..oh and by the way! i am against amnesty too!
peter6dio 4 years ago 2
I'm loving those split screens. Huckabee looks like he had no idea what the world was really about until he started to LISTEN and LEARN from President Paul.
rayofminneapolis 4 years ago 8
Sorry, I accidentally gave you a "thumbs down" when I meant to click "thumbs UP."
Yeah, Huckabee is a moron. He thinks he can fix the economy by taxing the hell out of citizens, selling endless government bonds, and continuing the pointless Iraqi war. Unfortunately, Huckabee is not the only moron on stage and in the room.
Mechyuda 4 years ago
he is brilliant
spanishaustralian 4 years ago 2
Ron Paul kicks those moron's asses every time!!!
justicefx 4 years ago 4
Oh.. so logical! When will these other fuckers get it!
yeloveit 4 years ago 16
"Besides, we don't even have the money to do this."
hahaha that was a great line
<3 Ron Paul!!
36burrows 4 years ago 3
Poor Arab countries like Egypt gets all that aid. Saudis have investment in the US of about a $trillion dollars. They can help themselves very well, but of course, Egypt is being paid go be not threating to Israel, while Palestine is being bulldozed to dust.
Unfortunately, Paul has to keep try hard to avoid being called anti-semite..
rollingklouds 4 years ago 6
Ron Paul is the only one who talks about
it the way it is!
anamarie8 4 years ago 11
Good points.
joeystockdale 4 years ago 3
I dislike how there is footage cut out between each video. I wish i knew what was said.
dusteroo 4 years ago 5
I know I hope someone uploads the whole thing. Paul looks more aggressive here than in other debates.
EVIL1888 4 years ago 7
Which he needs to be.
gillybymarriage 4 years ago 5
agree.
EVIL1888 4 years ago 3
well when your a paul in fox noise infested waters....you better bring more than a hook line and sinker to show these sharks how its done......AMAZING DEBATE TONIGHT BY DR. PAUL
illusionofsafety07 4 years ago 5
Please support the next Ron Paul presidential campaign fundraising day!!!
Cantwetalk 4 years ago 20
Nice
Bassman5000t 4 years ago 4