Agreed for sure. Getz was so sugary and slick certainly not a monster innovator like Joe or Coltrane. I had heard that Getz was a bit much personality wise. Thanks for keeping the conversation civilized, it seems to be a bit of a rarity here on utube.
@guyfidelity I wonder if you’re equating the abiliity to play melodically with being “slick”? I'd recommend listening to some of the music Stan recorded with Kenny Barron, Laurindo Almeida, or with his own groups, which at times included Horace Silver, Chick Corea, Jimmy Raney, etc. He possessed gorgeous tone, unerring pitch, unique lyricism, a sophisticated harmonic concept, and impeccable phrasing.
Humans are complicated. Not every great artist has a congenial personality. So.
@guyfidelity pffft. Making Stan proud? Henderson blows Getz off the chart. Have you heard Henderson's album of Jobim tunes: Double Rainbow? Makes Getz look like an amateur. Peace.
@guyfidelity Who's Coltrane?....... Nah just messing with you. Respect though. Good comeback. :) Ironic how in personality Coltrane was far more peaceful and played agressively whereas Getz from all reports was a douche and played with such a sweet tone- just random facts. Peace.
Nothing's more beautiful to me than this. Bossa Nova always got to me and this is classic. I love Joe Henderson....all the guys. Thanks for the post, I need a vacation. :D
E gads! Who did (not do) the lighting? Was there a power failure or something? This incredible ensemble - playing in the dark. (Guess it was all about ambiance, Hey?)
The most interesting about Jobim is that he composed two songs for each melody in Garota da Ipanema, Dindi, Desafinado, Insensatez (How Insensitive) ... One in English and one in Portuguese. Except you know both languages, you'll miss one of them and half of the beauty of his poetry.
Simply amazing. Portuguese lyrics with Brazilian structure, English lyrics with American English structure. Respecting peculiarities.
"Só privilegiados tem ouvido igual ao seu, eu possuo apenas o que Deus me deu!"
I saw this on PBS when it was first on in 1994 and taped it...what luck!! The entire show is a great performance...this piece is fabulous....I love how the sax comes in!
I love it. Metheny comping the Bossa Nova in the classic style. And Joe Henderson - what a beautiful tone and touch he has. He was made for the Bossa Nova. Jobim is Bossa Nova. Two of my idols (Jobim and Metheny).
actually, although Tom never had a "colourful" voice, this song (called Offkey in englishs) is referring to the concept that bossa nova (brazilian jazz) was considered offkey by the 50's and 60's conventional brazillian society.
Pat plays Ovation 1763
shidatatomoyami 10 months ago
it's like walking on heaven
pillotrejos 11 months ago
Agreed for sure. Getz was so sugary and slick certainly not a monster innovator like Joe or Coltrane. I had heard that Getz was a bit much personality wise. Thanks for keeping the conversation civilized, it seems to be a bit of a rarity here on utube.
guyfidelity 1 year ago
Comment removed
RootsinBrooklyn 10 months ago
@guyfidelity I wonder if you’re equating the abiliity to play melodically with being “slick”? I'd recommend listening to some of the music Stan recorded with Kenny Barron, Laurindo Almeida, or with his own groups, which at times included Horace Silver, Chick Corea, Jimmy Raney, etc. He possessed gorgeous tone, unerring pitch, unique lyricism, a sophisticated harmonic concept, and impeccable phrasing.
Humans are complicated. Not every great artist has a congenial personality. So.
RootsinBrooklyn 9 months ago
Zero dislikes - damn straight. Man is joe great makin' Stan proud for sure. Beautiful tone indeed
guyfidelity 1 year ago
@guyfidelity pffft. Making Stan proud? Henderson blows Getz off the chart. Have you heard Henderson's album of Jobim tunes: Double Rainbow? Makes Getz look like an amateur. Peace.
SaXDuDe17 1 year ago
@SaXDuDe17 OK so you don't like Stan and your a sax player. Getz was no monster but to quote Coltrane..."We all wish we could play a sweet as Stan"
guyfidelity 1 year ago
@guyfidelity Who's Coltrane?....... Nah just messing with you. Respect though. Good comeback. :) Ironic how in personality Coltrane was far more peaceful and played agressively whereas Getz from all reports was a douche and played with such a sweet tone- just random facts. Peace.
SaXDuDe17 1 year ago
Nothing's more beautiful to me than this. Bossa Nova always got to me and this is classic. I love Joe Henderson....all the guys. Thanks for the post, I need a vacation. :D
9876543217303 1 year ago
OMG! Beautiful solo by Joe Henderson!
vapid1000 1 year ago
E gads! Who did (not do) the lighting? Was there a power failure or something? This incredible ensemble - playing in the dark. (Guess it was all about ambiance, Hey?)
RootsinBrooklyn 1 year ago
nice ! ですね.
maidoodesu 1 year ago
When was this recorded? Such beautiful music!
STrepp4 1 year ago
Joe has such elegance!
bluesont 1 year ago
The most interesting about Jobim is that he composed two songs for each melody in Garota da Ipanema, Dindi, Desafinado, Insensatez (How Insensitive) ... One in English and one in Portuguese. Except you know both languages, you'll miss one of them and half of the beauty of his poetry.
Simply amazing. Portuguese lyrics with Brazilian structure, English lyrics with American English structure. Respecting peculiarities.
"Só privilegiados tem ouvido igual ao seu, eu possuo apenas o que Deus me deu!"
pickybu 1 year ago
What beautiful son!
TSssFw 1 year ago
Unique! the sun shone a lot that day previously this unique show, an ultra special event, three masters together!
SynclavierMPDR 1 year ago
@SynclavierMPDR Can't agree more, Sync! So rare, indeed!!!
Magamaguitam 1 year ago
Outstanding!!!
ferchw 1 year ago
@ferchw PAT in tuxedo for Ripley, ain't dear Fer? ;) so elegant and belo, belo as he always is notwithstanding he wears, such fine a man & Artist!!!
Magamaguitam 1 year ago
So beautiful.
ajiteh 1 year ago
I chose to turn my deteriorating VHS copy of this program into a DVD over baby footage and home videos. This was the best PBS special ever made.
Amers115 1 year ago
Almost better than sex
teemingup 1 year ago
admirable discipline playing the sax, very cultured, very educated sax.
wtube07 2 years ago
I saw this on PBS when it was first on in 1994 and taped it...what luck!! The entire show is a great performance...this piece is fabulous....I love how the sax comes in!
satchmo35a 2 years ago
joeeeeeeeeeeeee!!!!!!!!!!!!!
wonderfulllllllll
i am crying
alexistexias 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
darkoanton5 2 years ago
Comment removed
darkoanton5 2 years ago
Wow!!! Pat Metheny in a tux. Wow!!!
I love it. Metheny comping the Bossa Nova in the classic style. And Joe Henderson - what a beautiful tone and touch he has. He was made for the Bossa Nova. Jobim is Bossa Nova. Two of my idols (Jobim and Metheny).
darkoanton5 2 years ago
Joe Henderson, Pat Metheny, Charlie Haden and Al Foster and Tom The Genius Jobim. It´s the Dream Team.
skandarcorrea 2 years ago 4
instant favorite
mistrynp 2 years ago
joe henderson has a beautiful tone
eddielu620 2 years ago 14
PAT IN A TUX!!!!!! THAT'S A FIRST!
rgrillidecastro 3 years ago 13
yeah!! omg
aviumterror 3 years ago
Al FOSTER is the BEST!
145321 3 years ago
actually, although Tom never had a "colourful" voice, this song (called Offkey in englishs) is referring to the concept that bossa nova (brazilian jazz) was considered offkey by the 50's and 60's conventional brazillian society.
gustavoloubet 3 years ago 2
That reference to 'perfect pitch' will be a sly dig at his own quavering vocal, will it? Nice touch if so. Must have been something to witness this.
fendweller 3 years ago 2